Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say something to inlaws or keep quiet?

233 replies

MakeMineATea · 05/03/2023 10:06

Dh's parents moved away last year to a different part of the country. When they told us they were going, they said they'd visit us once a month for a couple of days, help out with our young dc's, give us an evening out, etc. This happened once a month after they moved and not since. If they've come to see us, it's been a quick visit in a day.

We've had a really difficult couple of years and especially the last few months. Our eldest child has very challenging additional needs and our youngest is still a baby. Myself and dh have mental/physical health problems. Both work.

My parents are 10 years older than dh's parents. They haven't been in good health either and although they would help out, I don't want to put that on them. Dh's parents are in good health and younger. They're financially comfortable. We will visit them in the summer but it's not somewhere we can go to regularly in our circumstances. Dc's are also too young to stay there without us and I don't think it will be a particularly child friendly house either.

I feel like they are full of false promises. Like coming for a few days to help us once a month. FIL said he'd decorate our dc's bedroom about a year ago. We didn't ask, he offered and said he'd do it several times but nothing ever came of it. We didn't follow this up with him, just got a decorator in to do it. They also said they'd give us £1000 to put towards a family car. Again, we didn't ask, it was genuinely and sincerely offered (I thought). A few weeks after that, we got a car, inlaws knew about it and didn't offer the £1000 they offered. We didn't say anything.

Dh and I have been at breaking point recently. The pressure of everything has been huge. It's got so bad for me personally that I'm struggling with self harm as well as other complex mental health problems. Plus trying to hold down a job and be a mum. Them moving away has been extremely difficult as they did see us every one or two weeks before that and it was nice to have that family contact.

It would massively help us if the inlaws would just commit to coming down once a month as they said originally. The problem is, they're not great with being asked for things. It's always on their terms when they fancy seeing their gc. So we feel awkward about asking but then again, if they don't know how we feel and how things actually are, nothing will change. But what if they just don't care?! Should we just keep quiet and not rock the boat? Dh is very hurt and angry about their blow hot blow cold, inconsistent behaviour towards us but has never said anything. Do we open this can of worm or keep the lid on?

OP posts:
DancingDaughter50 · 05/03/2023 16:01

@@Pigletnotatwiglet.

Have I? How could you possibly know?

I'm traumatised by mine and don't think I will ever get over them!!

Infact I'm sure if I posted about mine now I would get the likes of you and ink pot slamming me down and telling me off for posting again.

Which is Maddness. This isn't your site, going through in law issues is a process.

We should be able to freely post as many times as we like without posters like you not helping.

Also referring back to how many times she's posted sounds demented. What the hell is it to you or any poster? Do you sit on here all day every day monitoring how many times people post.

Bottom line : this is supposed to be an anonymous forum that provides support in particular for parents. How can anyone use it if posters like you try and shame people for keeping on posting about an issue and bringing up past posts?? @mnhq

Dishwashersaurous · 05/03/2023 16:01

Your in laws are not going to do what you want them to do.

You've been given the same advice on multiple threads.

you need to stop obsessing over your inlaws and find alternative support.

You chose to have two children when you both have mental health problems. You now need to work out how to make your life work.

It's not your in laws responsibility to solve your problems.

And even it it were the THEY ARE NOT GOING TO.

You need to devote the mental energy you spend obsessing about your in laws to find alternative support

KatherineJaneway · 05/03/2023 15:59

I think they moved away and gave you platitudes so the move away was easy. You clearly need help and they do not wish to provide it but don't feel comfortable telling you that you had these kids and you now need to deal with them.

Pigletnotatwiglet · 05/03/2023 15:52

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

whumpthereitis · 05/03/2023 15:52

DancingDaughter50 · 05/03/2023 15:44

@Inkpotlover

And??

Problem in laws can cause families to split up. Arnt people allowed to post as many times as they need about problems they have?

How is it your business? Why mention this?
How is it helpful.

I've posted for over a decade about my pils because I've never known anything like it and each time I've posted on different issues and worked through the problems.

I don't think without the support I had here I would still be married to be honest.

Because it’s the same issue rehashed over and over again, sometimes in the form of a reverse. OP doesn’t want advice, she wants to see her Inlaws, who are already acting as carers, bashed because they’ve had the audacity to move away from what at this point is continued harassment. They purposely hid the fact they were moving because they knew how OP and her husband would react.

2bazookas · 05/03/2023 15:51

We could look into other childcare options but as our eldest child has adhd, autism and spd, his needs are such that this can make it hard

You said the PILS did come once to baby sit in sole charge while you went out , and haven't repeated it.

That strongly suggests that they perhaps found it too challenging, harder than they imagined ?

Inkpotlover · 05/03/2023 15:49

DancingDaughter50 · 05/03/2023 15:44

@Inkpotlover

And??

Problem in laws can cause families to split up. Arnt people allowed to post as many times as they need about problems they have?

How is it your business? Why mention this?
How is it helpful.

I've posted for over a decade about my pils because I've never known anything like it and each time I've posted on different issues and worked through the problems.

I don't think without the support I had here I would still be married to be honest.

I mentioned it because lots of posters have taken the time to reply and give advice over the many threads but the situation doesn't change because OP simply doesn't want to accept her PIL don't want to help them out. I think counselling would genuinely help her deal with everything that's going on and the pressures she's under, because instead she's deflecting into obsessing about what her PIL will and will not do. I'm not saying it to be hurtful, I'm saying it to help. I'm glad posting repeatedly helped you, but I suspect it was different in that you moved on from the situation a bit more each time, whereas OP is clearly just stuck.

What's that saying? The definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.

macbooks · 05/03/2023 15:44

greekyoggy · 05/03/2023 15:39

Sorry to hear you're struggling but you sound like a whiny sorrowful victim

The amount of posts i read where people are upset to not have family support and the kids have special needs and both parents have mental health problems

Lol well apparently it’s OP behind all those posts you’ve read

LittleOwl153 · 05/03/2023 15:44

MakeMineATea · 05/03/2023 11:38

I think it is easier said than done, finding childcare for a child with additional needs outside of an education setting. Ds is only 4 and has autism, adhd and spd. He needs familiarity. If we could find someone who understands him, that would be great but maybe not a straightforward task as some people have suggested.

This says to me that you

a) need to apply for DLA for your child if you haven't already.

b) need to seek respite through your local coh cil for your SEN child. This is hard fought I'm aware - but it will give you some consistency of support. It will take a while to get into place so the sooner you start... if you have any support eith your own me tal health you could ask them to help you get respite for the eldest child. Hopefully then you will be better able to cope with the younger one(s) and maybe find a standard babysitter for them.

Did you eldest child go to nursery? If the do/did ask there.. many nursery staff do some babysitting out of hours. That would be someone familiar with your DSs needs. (Then if the above cones off you can perhaps seek direct payments to keep them going - but I do think respite would suit you better if you can get it!)

Parenting SN children is rough OP - but I don't think your inlaws are the answer. They will just co tinue to let you and your kids down. Best bet is to ignore them. When your MiL visits next week if it's inconvenient for you just say so. Sorry that doesn't work for us.

DancingDaughter50 · 05/03/2023 15:44

@Inkpotlover

And??

Problem in laws can cause families to split up. Arnt people allowed to post as many times as they need about problems they have?

How is it your business? Why mention this?
How is it helpful.

I've posted for over a decade about my pils because I've never known anything like it and each time I've posted on different issues and worked through the problems.

I don't think without the support I had here I would still be married to be honest.

Spanglemum · 05/03/2023 15:43

I can't believe some of the replies on here to be honest. I have a child with ADHD and ASD and another one with ADHD. It's exhausting. You can't just get babysitters for kids like this.

I think there are 2 problems:

  1. Your in laws are flakey and make false promises. They are unable or unwilling to help. Maybe it's all too much, maybe they are selfish. There is not a great deal you can do about this though I can see why you're upset.
  1. You and your husband have mental and physical health problems and you need more support. Have you asked social services, NAS or your CPN for referrals? Are there any groups in your area for families with kids with ALN? Do you get DLA for your son?

I would focus on getting more support for your family. You are in a tough situation.

DancingDaughter50 · 05/03/2023 15:41

Many people feel like they have actually done good by offering.

It needs to come through that they have done nothing except talk.

Inkpotlover · 05/03/2023 15:40

I know venting helps and everyone piling on in support must make you feel better, but this is at least the sixth or seventh time you've posted about your PIL, MakeMineATea. Different user name but everything about your OP is instantly recognisable.

I say this kindly, but your anger towards them for daring to move to a new area in pursuit of the retirement life they always wanted is becoming so consuming that I really do think you should seek counselling.

greekyoggy · 05/03/2023 15:39

Sorry to hear you're struggling but you sound like a whiny sorrowful victim

The amount of posts i read where people are upset to not have family support and the kids have special needs and both parents have mental health problems

LunchBoxPolice · 05/03/2023 15:38

I thought I’d read several threads about this situation before.

op- they don’t want to help. Let it go.
We have two children and our eldest has SEN too. My parents are local but not in great health, and dh’s parents moved further away from us after dc 2 was born. They complain about not seeing us but only visit us once a year for 1 day. 😬
I’ve given up expecting any sort of support from them, it’s their choice to not be very involved.

SomersetONeil · 05/03/2023 15:31

Ah, OP, you’re a regular on here with this issue….

Sorry you’re struggling.

The fact that you can’t, or won’t, put them up in your place is very relevant, and I’m surprised it was omitted from your OP.

Of course it’s not going to be easy for them to come down to help 2-3 days a month, if they can’t even stay with you.

They’d be paying for a hotel, and then not even in the house to be hands-on helping for much of the time.

SpringIntoChaos · 05/03/2023 15:31

YABVU!

Yes, it sucks that they promised and then broke that promise, but they are NOT obliged to look after your children! That's your job, as parents. If you are struggling, change something to make things easier...you simply cannot carry on feeling like the grandparents owe you childcare! They absolutely do not.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 15:30

OP, you've posted about this loads of times and you get told the same thing every single time.

What's the point?

thedogsmum · 05/03/2023 15:29

I think you should follow up on their offers - so if they offer money towards a car your husband can ask them if they want to transfer the money right away or when you have the car, and follow up on it. Either they keep their promise or they stop making offers they don't intend to follow up on.

Harder with helping with your kids - they may not be interested enough or feel they couldn't manage, but best way to find out is to ask them outright to look after the kids for a specific event. It is reasonable to ask grandparents to babysit - they can say no, it's their choice, but I think it's very unkind of them not to help at all, particularly with a SEN child.

endoftheworldniteclub · 05/03/2023 15:28

Shinyandnew1 · 05/03/2023 15:26

Definitely. OP would be far better off writing fewer posts about how mean she thinks her in laws are from every angle, and using the time to research, find and pay for some actual childcare.

Not gonna happen!

LittlePinkPill · 05/03/2023 15:27

MakeMineATea · 05/03/2023 10:28

I was thinking about saying to them, even if they could come for 2/3 days every 2 months and we would pay for them to stay at a nearby hotel, does that sound unreasonable? We're not exactly financially comfortable to do that but we would appreciate them helping and would find the money. Unfortunately we don't have room for them to stay at ours.

But they don’t want to, or find it too difficult. Whatever the reason, use the money for a professional childcare rather than PIL. I get how hard it is, we never had PIL help, my DM helped occasionally, we also have a DC with ADHD/ASD and health issues. It’s shit but you can’t make people -even family-want to help.

Shinyandnew1 · 05/03/2023 15:26

endoftheworldniteclub · 05/03/2023 15:24

Op really can’t be well. This obsession with her PIL is not healthy. Something is not right here.

Definitely. OP would be far better off writing fewer posts about how mean she thinks her in laws are from every angle, and using the time to research, find and pay for some actual childcare.

endoftheworldniteclub · 05/03/2023 15:24

Pigletnotatwiglet · 05/03/2023 15:17

Fair play for finding them, it's just the same old same old, rehashed crap over and over again hoping to get people to agree. I smelled a rat as soon as I read it. I have read a so many versions before.

Op really can’t be well. This obsession with her PIL is not healthy. Something is not right here.

RiverSkater · 05/03/2023 15:20

Seems you only want help with the more difficult aspects of family life.

You should want to see them because you want to see them and forge strong bonds.

Frankly I'd not want the 'come down to see us and do some difficult childcare' . Who would? They aren't saints.

I'd suggest you ask to see them and plan a lovely day out somewhere with suggestions and ask them what they would like to do.

Make them feel welcome for them, not what they can do for you. You've got it all wrong.

tara66 · 05/03/2023 15:18

OP I don't think you said how far away your ILS are from you now - how many hours drive? You did say there was no room for them to spend the night - so how long is their drive to you? is it tiring after a day's baby sitting on same day?
Perhaps they offered help because you seemed to put pressure on them to offer it when ever you spoke to them - such as how you could not afford new car - so they offered money and you told (or clearly let them know) how very difficult etc your life is with your child, health etc so - at that moment they offered help to be honestly wanting to help in ''awkward'' spot as they could not offer any advice to you to improve your situation? But then - they found the offer of help too much? Also you do not seem to think they have any financial or health problems of their own but maybe they do.