Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bats**t crazy? Don’t know what to do

334 replies

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 09:28

My DS is 14 and in year 9, his girlfriend from school is 13 and in year 8, they were born in the same year (2009) and there is 7 months age gap between them. She is also FAR more mature than my son, because she’s a girl!

apparently if now you go out with someone in the year below you are a none and pe*o and every other foul name under the son.

my lad is getting the most vile abuse at school but I don’t even know what to do because it’s everyone, in every year group and it’s constant, being shouted at in corridors, voice messages to his phone saying he’s weird and should be locked up, people approaching him at school and saying what he is doing is wrong.

I checked with other kids in other schools and it’s true there too?!?!? When the hell did this happen? When I was at school girls went out with boys in the year above!

Ive spoken to my lad about what he wants to do because he can’t stand the bullying, he’s gone from being really popular to a total pariah in 3 months.

OP posts:
Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 14:09

PaigeMatthews · 05/03/2023 10:32

I would not be happy at all about my yr 8 dd ‘dating‘ a year 9 boy. It doesnt matter how much the age difference is when they are out of the school system, in the school system he is a year ahead.

you just cannot justify age gaps in school in the same way you would the world beyond that. Even one week end of august to the beginning of september still means they older is a year ahead, not a week older.

sixth formers dating 15 year olds is a problem due to the age of consent. If it is a sexual relationship it is a problem.

I’m confused by this Paige, can you explain what the difference is between school years that makes you feel like this? To me it’s no different to being in different forms with the same age difference?

Goosebarnacle · 05/03/2023 14:07

DD has had this. She's in sixth form and is a summer baby, so young in her year anyway. Someone she briefly dated was only 3mths younger and also in sixth form, but in the year below. She was called a paedo, school treated it as a joke, they actually split up as she was so upset by it. This was bloody sixth form too, you'd think by that age they'd have grown up a little.

GatoradeMeBitch · 05/03/2023 14:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 14:01

Thankyou to all the posters who have been very supportive it’s really helpful x

OP posts:
Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 13:55

This is mad. My dd was born at the end of August. Her boyfriend from yr 9- yr 12 had an early September birthday. They were in the same year but he was 11+ months older than her. So everyone is saying that is fine because they’re in the same year group, but that if they were in different year groups a much smaller age gap wouldn’t be acceptable? How on earth is that logical?

OP I think you need to take it up with the school. It is totally unacceptable behaviour from the other students. I wouldn’t go behind his back though, you’ll need to find a way of him agreeing to it. Would his dad get further if they are very close.

The posters saying it’s gross, that they shouldn’t have boy/girlfriends at that age and definitely not in different year groups - do you have teenagers or older? If not I’m guessing you’ll probably see things differently when you do, but if you have we just parent differently.

SlightlyJaded · 05/03/2023 13:51

This post has taken a lot of wild turns and tangents, but the bottom line (imo) is that this 'relationship' is completely normal and your DS is being bullied.

At our local schools (West/SW London) no thought is given to such a small age gap in either direction. DD (17) has a boyfriend of 18 at the moment. So is she a 'child' dating an 'adult'? There are 6 months between them....

OP - talk to the school and perhaps help your DS and his friend find some words of phrases that will help them deal with anything on the spot. Is she getting bulled too?

Takoneko · 05/03/2023 13:40

I don’t think there’s anything wrong with the age gap described in the OP, or with children that age dating. That is developmentally normal behaviour for two young people at a very similar developmental stage.

However, there is a huge issue with the underlying assumption that girls are inherently more “mature” than boys of the same age. It’s an attitude that has a hugely pernicious impact on safeguarding teenage girls. A year 8 girl who vapes and drinks alcohol is vulnerable. That sort of risk-taking behaviour and presenting as “older” or “more mature” puts young girls at increased risk and needs to be seen as a risk factor rather than a sign of maturity.

Boomboom22 · 05/03/2023 13:35

School year is more relevant than age as they have had appropriate teaching in pshe etc. Yr8 are not usually in relationships that would lead to a first kiss, apart from in poorer areas or more vulnerable areas. Different schools are vastly different. Many schools first relationships are yr11 and 12.

More middle class areas and posters in that world will be utterly shocked at how blasé pp are about a yr8 being in the bedroom of a 14yr old boy and the mum thinking it's fine to kiss and be in a relationship.

Remember some parents don't let their sixth formers out on their own let alone have bf. Some parents keep their kids home for uni or make them call them when they get home even if they live away.

I do think it's too young to label as a relationship and yr8 especially.

sealon82 · 05/03/2023 13:28

This happened to my son, snogged a girl in the year below. I found about it when he asked me if he'd broken the law. I was so upset. He's 20 now so was a while ago.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 13:24

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:15

How about in this scenario?

say your daughter is in year 8 middle school, but for the last 2 years she has gone regularly with you to a very wholesome out of school activity, quite a professional one that requires hours and hours of dedication and practice. There she meets a boy who you also meet, and meet his parents, they are both 12 you spend a load of time with the boy, and his parents simply because you all have to stick around during the activity.

when they are both 13 they are selected to partner in a high profile event, lots of reversal together and over the 3 month rehearsal time become very close friends she tells you she wants to ask him out. He won’t ask her because even though he likes her he’s scared of being bullied at school because of how it’s viewed. So she asks him out.

do you still think it’s totally wrong?

People can ask out whoever they want to ask out. That doesn't mean other people have to agree with it or find it appropriate.

Like PP - where I grew up, Year 8 and Year 9 students went to different types of school and it would have been seen to be totally inappropriate for them to date, even if they were only a few weeks/months apart age-wise.

That of course doesn't mean your son is a bad person who is doing something morally wrong, but I can see why other children find it uncomfortable.

CeliaNorth · 05/03/2023 13:24

What about summer-born children whose school entry was deferred? Where do they fit in under these 'rules'?

Obviously can't date anyone in their year, because they're older than everyone else. But cross-year dating isn't 'allowed', so can't date anyone in the year above, either, even though they're probably older than some of them.

What if a deferred Yr8 dates a Yr9 who is six weeks younger? Which one is the 'paedo'?

piedbeauty · 05/03/2023 13:21

My Year 11 ds thinks the same, though I have tried to educate him about it. Teens can be so judgemental.

Your poor ds. I'd talk to the school.

SleepingRedSnowBootsAndThePea · 05/03/2023 13:21

I didn’t say screaming voicemails, I said voice notes and I heard them mainly from girls in his year and year 8 saying “I’m sorry we don’t care that you’re 13 and she’s 13 it’s weird and you’re a nonce you should be in prison”

Totally unacceptable. All of these messages need to be sent to the Head Teacher and they need to be suspended, and only allowed back to school when they apologise and on a final warning that any such further comments will mean being expelled.

Teateaandmoretea · 05/03/2023 13:20

I wouldn’t be cool with a year 8 going round to a year 9 boyfriends house.

But this is ridiculous, the words ‘paedo’ and ‘nonce’ are completely over used and unhelpfully.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:18

Zwicky · 05/03/2023 13:12

Im now more concerned by the amount of people talking about the maturity levels of a 13 year old girl as a way of justifying age gaps. That is something you need to think right through.

Totally agree with this. Girls are seen as more mature because behaviour that wouldn’t be tolerated in a girl in nursery is indulged in men long into adulthood. The other reason is of course, it lets men off the hook for noncey behaviour. Men can shag kids if they are suitable “mature”. Look how mature those kids in Rotherham were painted as. A y8 girl hanging out with older pupils, drinking and vaping, going into boyfriends bedroom etc sounds vulnerable, not mature.

And I said she had tried those things, she’s not vulnerable, why are you painting my son to be a predator? Gid help young men and
boys these days, truly god help them, when a respectful and kind boy like my son is being painted as a villain by adult women.

OP posts:
Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:16

Zwicky · 05/03/2023 13:12

Im now more concerned by the amount of people talking about the maturity levels of a 13 year old girl as a way of justifying age gaps. That is something you need to think right through.

Totally agree with this. Girls are seen as more mature because behaviour that wouldn’t be tolerated in a girl in nursery is indulged in men long into adulthood. The other reason is of course, it lets men off the hook for noncey behaviour. Men can shag kids if they are suitable “mature”. Look how mature those kids in Rotherham were painted as. A y8 girl hanging out with older pupils, drinking and vaping, going into boyfriends bedroom etc sounds vulnerable, not mature.

Oh my GOD. Why is the word mature now about sexual maturity?

mature is about being more sensible

OP posts:
Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:15

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2023 13:08

Where I am yr 8 is middle school and yr 9 high school so massive difference.

Imo kids of that age shouldn't be having boyfriends/girlfriends.

How about in this scenario?

say your daughter is in year 8 middle school, but for the last 2 years she has gone regularly with you to a very wholesome out of school activity, quite a professional one that requires hours and hours of dedication and practice. There she meets a boy who you also meet, and meet his parents, they are both 12 you spend a load of time with the boy, and his parents simply because you all have to stick around during the activity.

when they are both 13 they are selected to partner in a high profile event, lots of reversal together and over the 3 month rehearsal time become very close friends she tells you she wants to ask him out. He won’t ask her because even though he likes her he’s scared of being bullied at school because of how it’s viewed. So she asks him out.

do you still think it’s totally wrong?

OP posts:
Zwicky · 05/03/2023 13:12

Im now more concerned by the amount of people talking about the maturity levels of a 13 year old girl as a way of justifying age gaps. That is something you need to think right through.

Totally agree with this. Girls are seen as more mature because behaviour that wouldn’t be tolerated in a girl in nursery is indulged in men long into adulthood. The other reason is of course, it lets men off the hook for noncey behaviour. Men can shag kids if they are suitable “mature”. Look how mature those kids in Rotherham were painted as. A y8 girl hanging out with older pupils, drinking and vaping, going into boyfriends bedroom etc sounds vulnerable, not mature.

monsterradeliciosa · 05/03/2023 13:12

That’s crazy
I would ask to sit down with the head

I would ask them to educate the children about defamation and the seriousness of accusations like that

not sure what else but off that’s normal note schools sound horrible and I’ll give educate again come secondary

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2023 13:08

Where I am yr 8 is middle school and yr 9 high school so massive difference.

Imo kids of that age shouldn't be having boyfriends/girlfriends.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:07

Whiteroomjoy · 05/03/2023 13:06

Ok, wrong post🤦‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️🙄
god knows how that happened 🤣🤦‍♀️🤣🤣

I know hahahaha it was so long too! Poor you lol

OP posts:
Whiteroomjoy · 05/03/2023 13:06

Ok, wrong post🤦‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️🙄
god knows how that happened 🤣🤦‍♀️🤣🤣

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:06

OldFan · 05/03/2023 13:04

It is not on and should stop.

But also @Puddingypops if it encourages him and other boys not to date younger (even if only the year below) girls at this age, then that's no bad thing.

Ok if 7 months younger is too young, what do you think the acceptable amount of months is? Is 5 months ok? Or 1?

OP posts:
OldFan · 05/03/2023 13:04

It is not on and should stop.

But also @Puddingypops if it encourages him and other boys not to date younger (even if only the year below) girls at this age, then that's no bad thing.

Whiteroomjoy · 05/03/2023 13:02

Ok, op…there are a number of issue going on with your tennants and I think you need to address them directly with them

I’d ask to have a meeting with them. First of all say how much you’ve appreciated them as tenants and that by and large you are very happy with how they are using the property and their responsibilities towards the house.
There are now a few issues that have been building up and causing potential problems and “damage” to the property that you need to discuss with them.

  1. You will be requiring a new tenancy agreement to be signed that contains clauses about the garden maintenance and dog . - have this to hand and give them copies at end of conversation saying they obviously need to read and then come back with any queries in 2 weeks time (for instance) and the new tenancy will be needed to be signed before (say) next months rent due.
  2. the new garden clause will reinstate as it was before, that you “let go” and now know is giving issues in terms of amount of work that will be needed to get it back to state it was at start of tenancy (you need to have good evidence of what state was at that time). Right now, you are having to maintain garden yourself at your cost for a gardener which was never the original agreement and you rather naively thought it would be ok to remove the clause and they’d step up of their own volition. As they haven’t which is fair given you remov3d the clause) you now need them to Either do it themselves, pay for gardener themselves or pay you increased rent for the cost of your gardener. Point out that the garden was in original tennacy and is standard (despite what people are saying here) that tennants are responsible for garden maintenance- specify what maintenance is exactly: . Mowing, weeding, cutting back. Their choice as to how they want to approach but doing nothing but allowing it to over grow is not an option . If they say they’ll take it on then go outside with them and show them- ideally have a written clause in contract or ano piece of paper to state what is expected (within reason ) that they need to do. They cannot be expected to do heavy labour, pruning (they might not be gardeners and therefore could do more damage), but sweeping, mowing to a length of maximum of 4 inches at all times, edging, and weeding is entirely reasonably. But, it is also reasonable you pay for gardener to get it back to condition you want firs, that they then go on to maintain , given you dropped the clause.
  3. the new dog clause will be put in to stipulate how the house must be managed wrt to dog. This includes that dog waste MUST never be left in house or garden. That is a health issue and can be reported as bad neighbour issues to environmental health so is utterly unacceptable. All dog waste must be removed to appropriate dog waste bin immediately. It must not be put unwrapped into your domestic bins (council will not replace dirty bins for next tennant even if health hazard). There must be no waste left in the house at any time. Any damage to the house OR garden by the dog is not considered “normal wear and tear” and they need to pay for replacements/repairs themselves. (E.g if dog pees on carpet they must pay for cleaning and if you’re not satisfied they pay for replacement, similarly scratches to doors, if dog damages lawn over time for. Digging, scrapping and weeding then they’ll need to cover cost of reseeding and repair, etc) . This needs to be spelled out in tenancy agreement and they must sign it if they keep dog and tenancy . You will require an increased deposit to be paid for the dog being there to cover any waste removal at end of tenancy, carpet cleaning and repair of any dog damage in the house or garden. This is entirely fair. I know tennants who have to pay extra rent each month now for a pet fgs. I don’t believe that is fair, but do believe an additional deposit is fair and entirely sensible. It will need to be substantial if damage is done to lawn, house etc that they don’t repair properly.
  4. You held off against rent increases in line with government requests during pandemic. You will be increasing rent over next 3 years to bring it in line with interest rate and market rental values. This year the rent will increase by 5%, at the maximum the government suggest as responsible landlord. This is in addition to an additional increase for the gardener if they choose not to take that on themselves. There will then be further increases over next year and beyond

i do suspect though, that they will try to move - may not be immediately, but they’re probably staying becuase of lower rent. They’d be idiots not too. But the fact they’re happy for garden to be overgrown, dog shit left outside, doesn’t make me think they’re people who actually take much pride in where they live and “it’s just a house “ to them. That’s not an issue, entirely fair for rental, but I suspect they have far less loyalty to you than you to them. Their loyalty is probably down to what they pay and convenience of being close to where they need to be.

Your relationship, if they stay, won’t be where it was. You will be giving up some trust towards them to stipulate these things- which isn’t nice for you and certainly not for them. Trust is reciprocal , so they will trust you less and deem you more money grabbing. However, I really think if they’d done a good job on garden, were being super careful with dog, you’d be looking to minimise rental increases anyway to keep them as tenants form heaven.

Swipe left for the next trending thread