Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bats**t crazy? Don’t know what to do

334 replies

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 09:28

My DS is 14 and in year 9, his girlfriend from school is 13 and in year 8, they were born in the same year (2009) and there is 7 months age gap between them. She is also FAR more mature than my son, because she’s a girl!

apparently if now you go out with someone in the year below you are a none and pe*o and every other foul name under the son.

my lad is getting the most vile abuse at school but I don’t even know what to do because it’s everyone, in every year group and it’s constant, being shouted at in corridors, voice messages to his phone saying he’s weird and should be locked up, people approaching him at school and saying what he is doing is wrong.

I checked with other kids in other schools and it’s true there too?!?!? When the hell did this happen? When I was at school girls went out with boys in the year above!

Ive spoken to my lad about what he wants to do because he can’t stand the bullying, he’s gone from being really popular to a total pariah in 3 months.

OP posts:
Stompythedinosaur · 05/03/2023 15:44

I don't think this is a universal thing across the country. The teens I work with dates other year groups.

I'd handle it like any other incident of bullying and expect the school to take action.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 15:44

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2023 15:42

It means different schools in many places of the country. The difference between a middle and high school is enormous.

What if both kids are homeschooled

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2023 15:42

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 14:09

I’m confused by this Paige, can you explain what the difference is between school years that makes you feel like this? To me it’s no different to being in different forms with the same age difference?

It means different schools in many places of the country. The difference between a middle and high school is enormous.

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2023 15:38

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 13:15

How about in this scenario?

say your daughter is in year 8 middle school, but for the last 2 years she has gone regularly with you to a very wholesome out of school activity, quite a professional one that requires hours and hours of dedication and practice. There she meets a boy who you also meet, and meet his parents, they are both 12 you spend a load of time with the boy, and his parents simply because you all have to stick around during the activity.

when they are both 13 they are selected to partner in a high profile event, lots of reversal together and over the 3 month rehearsal time become very close friends she tells you she wants to ask him out. He won’t ask her because even though he likes her he’s scared of being bullied at school because of how it’s viewed. So she asks him out.

do you still think it’s totally wrong?

Friendship yes, relationship at that age still wrong.

If they are spending time together with no sexual contact then essentially its a friendship thats all and that's fine.

But otherwise no never.

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 15:26

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 14:38

This is mad. My dd was born at the end of August. Her boyfriend from yr 9- yr 12 had an early September birthday. They were in the same year but he was 11+ months older than her. So everyone is saying that is fine because they’re in the same year group, but that if they were in different year groups a much smaller age gap wouldn’t be acceptable? How on earth is that logical?

As people have said, in many areas Year 8 students are still in middle school.

If your DD was a middle school student, would you really be happy with her going out with a boy from the local high school?

Thats me you’ve part quoted. But that’s not the case here is it? They’re both in high school and there’s a 7 month ( I think, not scrolling back to check) age difference. That’s nothing at all. And tbh if they were in middle and high but with that age difference I wouldn’t think anything of it. I would with a 2 year difference but not within a year.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 15:21

Absolutely, I agree, i remember being at school and knowing some kids were doing stuff at 14, in fact I remember my first boyfriend who I lost my virginity to was 18 and I was 16. When we broke up he started going out with a 14 year old from my school and that was totally outrageous looking back.

I do trust him you’re right but more than that I know him, I know his fears about breaking rules right from being a baby he has been a child who conform to the rules, for example a bouncy slide when he was 6, 2 goes down the slide for £1 after 2 goes the man who runs it and myself saying, there’s no one waiting go ahead and go on a third time, no way! It’s 2 goes for £1 it’s against the rules!

He’s not ND and I know that is fading somewhat but his absolute closest group of friends are all square (like he would be seen as) and not into anything like trying a vape or alcohol or anything like that when LOADS of other kids are well into it.

do I worry there might be some 2nd base stuff coming up? Yep I absolutely do worry about that, I live in a flat and I can see his room from where I sit so I can see them both if it’s just the 2 of them, not always when there’s the whole group but I’m hoping no petting will be happening when there’s a group of kids!

OP posts:
BadNomad · 05/03/2023 15:13

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 14:45

As it’s only been close to 3 months and most of the time they are in a large group of friends (mixed year 8 and year 9) I don’t think it’s progressed but of course I have spoken to him about what is appropriate for his age.

an acquaintance, (a year 9 boy who likes to try and show off to people) tried to get him to watch porn last month, he invites people back to his house and has the basement to himself and puts on porn but my son and his best mate didn’t know that part.

they left when this boy loaded up porn hub and my son came home and cried to me about it.

he knows he’s not old enough for a sexual relationship and I’ve also made sure he understands that for a boy he must never ever do anything even with consent because he could be accused of consent not being given.

I’ve explained the dangers of sexual relationships to him, to a girl and to their developing brains and approaching things like sex when he is older and equipped to deal with it.

i also check his phone whenever I want to, that’s the deal if I ask he hands it over. (I don’t do it all the time and a lot of the time I’ll ask and not look).

he decided to pursue the relationship because they like each other so much, he is extremely good looking and so is she, so obviously they fancied each other but the bigger thing is that they share and excel at a common interest, think along the lines of ballroom dancing, had recently been partnered in a huge event and spent lots and lots of time training together, they also continue to do this hobby together.

I still think you're being very naive. Telling him he is too young for sex won't mean anything when his body and brain is telling him he is. You're expecting a lot of sense and maturity from a young boy with hormones. It's clear you trust him, which is nice, but that's a huge risk. He's surrounded by other people his age maturing and going through stuff, and he's being exposed to it. It's a difficult age for him. His mum is telling him one thing, and all his friends are telling him something else. He obviously cares about what other people think, so it's natural then that he is going to give in to peer pressure on some of it. I think you need to remind yourself that other teens are not like your son.

BubziOwl · 05/03/2023 15:11

JazbayGrapes · 05/03/2023 14:42

Dear God, when did this all happen? I have only ever really known / experienced girls aiming to catch a boyfriend a year or two older! It always used to be the norm. We are creating a strange society if this is how children now view relationships growing up.

Back in "our day" it was the norm. Also the norm was covering up child abuse, and grown men taking advantage of teenage girls. Now the pendulum has swung.
In OP's case i suspect there must be some school drama involved, like other kids might be jealous and stirring up shit.

Yes, I agree.

There's clearly nothing wrong with OP's son 'dating' a girl who is 7 months younger than him. From what OP has said, it seems he's being bullied, and I hope you go to the school and can make some headway getting it sorted.

But I'm confused by all the other posters who seemed horrified by the idea that kids today are preferring to date people their own age.

If it's the alternative to the normalisation of girls being prayed on by older men and boys, is it really that bad? I'm struggling to see why people think society is going to the dogs because 15 year olds want to date fellow 15 year olds.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 15:10

NevieSticks · 05/03/2023 15:03

Your post is a bit confusing as you talk about him as if he is a little boy . You said he is "not old enough for a sexual relationship" so I don't even know why it had to be named as bf and gf esp when they have this common interest. TBH if he were my son at this age I wouldn't be encouraging him to have a "gf" at all but that's just me. I know there are mothers out there who delight in their sons having GFs - not saying that is you at all - and I wonder where their minds are!

He turned 14 a week ago, of course he’s not a little boy which is why I’m able to speak to him about sex and the dangers of these things in people too young to cope with the psychological impact and also consent and how a girl may consent but not mean it or withdraw it at the time or later.

do you mean about him crying? He is a very sensitive boy.

they wanted to be BF and GF, no I’m absolutely not one of those mums but I do know some lol.

I do think that at this age it’s natural to start exploring relationships but that there must be boundaries and keeping things at a friendship with hand holding maybe kissing etc but more importantly being special to someone and making someone feel special in your life and that seems to be what they enjoy about their young relationship.

I wouldn’t ever ban him from having a GF if he and a girl wanted to do that, we can only guide can’t we?

OP posts:
WiIson · 05/03/2023 15:10

That's weird. I was thinking about this recently as dd has a bf in the same year as her, which would not have been the norm when I was at school. Girls always went out with boys a year or two older, probably because of the maturity thing.

BellePeppa · 05/03/2023 15:03

Quveas · 05/03/2023 14:34

Dear God, when did this all happen? I have only ever really known / experienced girls aiming to catch a boyfriend a year or two older! It always used to be the norm. We are creating a strange society if this is how children now view relationships growing up.

It is very strange indeed. Are people only going to be happy when they have the same birthdate and year (let’s hope there’s not too many hours difference between them). Where did this oddity spring from? I’m glad my kids didn’t date at school and waited till college so we didn’t have to deal with this. My son was aghast when his cousin was twenty and dating a seventeen year old, I honestly did not (and do not) see a problem in that.

NevieSticks · 05/03/2023 15:03

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 14:45

As it’s only been close to 3 months and most of the time they are in a large group of friends (mixed year 8 and year 9) I don’t think it’s progressed but of course I have spoken to him about what is appropriate for his age.

an acquaintance, (a year 9 boy who likes to try and show off to people) tried to get him to watch porn last month, he invites people back to his house and has the basement to himself and puts on porn but my son and his best mate didn’t know that part.

they left when this boy loaded up porn hub and my son came home and cried to me about it.

he knows he’s not old enough for a sexual relationship and I’ve also made sure he understands that for a boy he must never ever do anything even with consent because he could be accused of consent not being given.

I’ve explained the dangers of sexual relationships to him, to a girl and to their developing brains and approaching things like sex when he is older and equipped to deal with it.

i also check his phone whenever I want to, that’s the deal if I ask he hands it over. (I don’t do it all the time and a lot of the time I’ll ask and not look).

he decided to pursue the relationship because they like each other so much, he is extremely good looking and so is she, so obviously they fancied each other but the bigger thing is that they share and excel at a common interest, think along the lines of ballroom dancing, had recently been partnered in a huge event and spent lots and lots of time training together, they also continue to do this hobby together.

Your post is a bit confusing as you talk about him as if he is a little boy . You said he is "not old enough for a sexual relationship" so I don't even know why it had to be named as bf and gf esp when they have this common interest. TBH if he were my son at this age I wouldn't be encouraging him to have a "gf" at all but that's just me. I know there are mothers out there who delight in their sons having GFs - not saying that is you at all - and I wonder where their minds are!

CremeEggThief · 05/03/2023 14:59

Er most teenagers and even younger kids nowadays incorrectly use nonce as a form of verbal abuse! It's the newer version of using gay as an insult.
In fact, I live near a park and there was a little fucker there the other day screaming and shouting and calling other kids fucking nonce, fucking paedo etc. and when I looked out the window to see who the hell was going on like that, he couldn't have been more than 9 or 10 himself and he was shouting this at kids younger than him when playing football!🙄

Of course it is not acceptable, but I am really surprised how many of you comenting don't appear to know this language is unfortunately normal in that age group!

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 14:54

user1492757084 · 05/03/2023 14:50

You do need to address this with school. If it is happening with everyone like you say ,how would kids know it was about him?
An authoritive teacher/person at school needs to call it out as bullying and unacceptable ASAP.
That said, your son and his girlfriend should try not to be too demonstative at school. It is unprofessional in an office and classroom. Being respectful and friendly at school won't be uncomfortable for their classmates. This is just my personal opinion. It allows space for other friends to still be close - it is healthiest for teenagers to have groups of friends.

Also it’s actually taken 3 months for it to get around the school, they were keeping it quiet, just holding hands etc out of school but word has got around now.

OP posts:
Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 14:53

user1492757084 · 05/03/2023 14:50

You do need to address this with school. If it is happening with everyone like you say ,how would kids know it was about him?
An authoritive teacher/person at school needs to call it out as bullying and unacceptable ASAP.
That said, your son and his girlfriend should try not to be too demonstative at school. It is unprofessional in an office and classroom. Being respectful and friendly at school won't be uncomfortable for their classmates. This is just my personal opinion. It allows space for other friends to still be close - it is healthiest for teenagers to have groups of friends.

Because he’s the only one going out with someone in the year below, that we are aware of, oh apart from it’s ok if you’re gay, same sex relationships are ok across year groups.

OP posts:
user1492757084 · 05/03/2023 14:50

You do need to address this with school. If it is happening with everyone like you say ,how would kids know it was about him?
An authoritive teacher/person at school needs to call it out as bullying and unacceptable ASAP.
That said, your son and his girlfriend should try not to be too demonstative at school. It is unprofessional in an office and classroom. Being respectful and friendly at school won't be uncomfortable for their classmates. This is just my personal opinion. It allows space for other friends to still be close - it is healthiest for teenagers to have groups of friends.

Fairislefandango · 05/03/2023 14:47

School year is more relevant than age as they have had appropriate teaching in pshe etc.

Seriously?! Kids' maturity is not based on what they have learned in PSHE! They don't wait until something's come up in PSHE and then decide to move onto the next developmental stage. PSHE is seenas boring, patronising and a waste if time by most students.

I've been a teacher for a looong time, and have taught plenty of year 8s who are more mature than many year 9s. I also have a dd with a late August birthday who is dating someone the year above her (though admittedly dd is 17).

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 14:45

BadNomad · 05/03/2023 14:35

I think you are being a bit naive about the sexual side of this. These aren't two pre-school kids playing at being mummy and daddy. These are two teenagers, with hormones, doing what human beings were made to do. They are biologically driven to bond and mate. So don't think just because you see them as little children still, that their bodies and brains agree. The girl is already doing things beyond what a child does (drinking and vaping). The difference between friendship and a relationship is intimacy. That's not to say they are having sex (yet), but this is not some little innocent platonic friendship.

As for the bullying, that's wrong, and I'm sad for your son. I doubt there is much the school can do about it. It sounds like your son knew people had this kind of attitude? Why did he decide to pursue a relationship with this girl?

As it’s only been close to 3 months and most of the time they are in a large group of friends (mixed year 8 and year 9) I don’t think it’s progressed but of course I have spoken to him about what is appropriate for his age.

an acquaintance, (a year 9 boy who likes to try and show off to people) tried to get him to watch porn last month, he invites people back to his house and has the basement to himself and puts on porn but my son and his best mate didn’t know that part.

they left when this boy loaded up porn hub and my son came home and cried to me about it.

he knows he’s not old enough for a sexual relationship and I’ve also made sure he understands that for a boy he must never ever do anything even with consent because he could be accused of consent not being given.

I’ve explained the dangers of sexual relationships to him, to a girl and to their developing brains and approaching things like sex when he is older and equipped to deal with it.

i also check his phone whenever I want to, that’s the deal if I ask he hands it over. (I don’t do it all the time and a lot of the time I’ll ask and not look).

he decided to pursue the relationship because they like each other so much, he is extremely good looking and so is she, so obviously they fancied each other but the bigger thing is that they share and excel at a common interest, think along the lines of ballroom dancing, had recently been partnered in a huge event and spent lots and lots of time training together, they also continue to do this hobby together.

OP posts:
AmeliaEarhart · 05/03/2023 14:43

I hate this casual throwing around if the words “pedo” and “nonce”. How distressing it must be for victims of actual CSA to have their trauma equated with a couple of young teenagers holding hands. It staggers me that the kids using these words in this situation actually think they have a moral high ground.

JazbayGrapes · 05/03/2023 14:42

Dear God, when did this all happen? I have only ever really known / experienced girls aiming to catch a boyfriend a year or two older! It always used to be the norm. We are creating a strange society if this is how children now view relationships growing up.

Back in "our day" it was the norm. Also the norm was covering up child abuse, and grown men taking advantage of teenage girls. Now the pendulum has swung.
In OP's case i suspect there must be some school drama involved, like other kids might be jealous and stirring up shit.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 14:38

This is mad. My dd was born at the end of August. Her boyfriend from yr 9- yr 12 had an early September birthday. They were in the same year but he was 11+ months older than her. So everyone is saying that is fine because they’re in the same year group, but that if they were in different year groups a much smaller age gap wouldn’t be acceptable? How on earth is that logical?

As people have said, in many areas Year 8 students are still in middle school.

If your DD was a middle school student, would you really be happy with her going out with a boy from the local high school?

BadNomad · 05/03/2023 14:35

I think you are being a bit naive about the sexual side of this. These aren't two pre-school kids playing at being mummy and daddy. These are two teenagers, with hormones, doing what human beings were made to do. They are biologically driven to bond and mate. So don't think just because you see them as little children still, that their bodies and brains agree. The girl is already doing things beyond what a child does (drinking and vaping). The difference between friendship and a relationship is intimacy. That's not to say they are having sex (yet), but this is not some little innocent platonic friendship.

As for the bullying, that's wrong, and I'm sad for your son. I doubt there is much the school can do about it. It sounds like your son knew people had this kind of attitude? Why did he decide to pursue a relationship with this girl?

Quveas · 05/03/2023 14:34

RandomMess · 05/03/2023 09:49

I agree it's a widespread thing.

My DDs all think going out with a boy 2 years older than them in their late teens is "wrong" then my youngest wonders why her boyfriends are so bloody immature Confused

Dear God, when did this all happen? I have only ever really known / experienced girls aiming to catch a boyfriend a year or two older! It always used to be the norm. We are creating a strange society if this is how children now view relationships growing up.

WonderingWanda · 05/03/2023 14:32

You need to go to the school. This is bullying. Teenagers will always say they don't want you to tell the school. He has two choices, put up with it or go and get it stopped.

PelicanWings · 05/03/2023 14:12

NEmama · 05/03/2023 09:42

I had a y11 boyfriend in y9. Nothing was said.
Tbf we were at it

Grim