Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bats**t crazy? Don’t know what to do

334 replies

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 09:28

My DS is 14 and in year 9, his girlfriend from school is 13 and in year 8, they were born in the same year (2009) and there is 7 months age gap between them. She is also FAR more mature than my son, because she’s a girl!

apparently if now you go out with someone in the year below you are a none and pe*o and every other foul name under the son.

my lad is getting the most vile abuse at school but I don’t even know what to do because it’s everyone, in every year group and it’s constant, being shouted at in corridors, voice messages to his phone saying he’s weird and should be locked up, people approaching him at school and saying what he is doing is wrong.

I checked with other kids in other schools and it’s true there too?!?!? When the hell did this happen? When I was at school girls went out with boys in the year above!

Ive spoken to my lad about what he wants to do because he can’t stand the bullying, he’s gone from being really popular to a total pariah in 3 months.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 16:47

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:40

You see that is surprising to me that year 7/8 was acceptable cross over.

a year 7 seems very young indeed having just left primary, but it depends on the ages

year 8s are going through puberty for the most part and year 7s not as much so that’s more pre pubescent and pubescent kids which to me is more questionable than year 8 and year 9

I was in a three-tier education system, so we had junior school, middle school and upper schools.

Middle schools (or prep schools in the private system) covered ages 9-13, so years 5-8 - so Y7/Y8 was a very normal crossover/friendship group.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:45

BadNomad · 05/03/2023 16:40

I'm actually quite glad to hear young people look down on age gap relationships these days. Hopefully that will stop a lot of young girls ending up with 40-year-old men.

(Obviously a 7 months difference isn't an age gap)

I agree, but when you look at the real world beyond grass roots is that actually happening? In the world of celebrity, footballers wives, influencers etc etc, and I’m sure in business and politics wherever you find powerful men you’ll find young girlfriends.

I totally agree as a feminist that it’s no bad thing to turn the tide on large age gaps as a rule, but this is being to an extreme and not where it’s needed.

and in an adult level not talking about kids here, it has to still be true that love is love? I know happily married people with ten year ages gaps with the woman older or man older…

OP posts:
Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:41

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 16:34

It was common when I was at school too, but only across certain year groups if that makes sense.

So, Y7/Y8, Y9/10/11 and Y11/sixth form crossovers were all considered acceptable and normal, but Y10/sixth form would have been considered inappropriate, as would Y8/Y9, and so forth.

I suppose different schools have different cultures and different ideas of what's acceptable and what isn't. Personally I don't really think it's a bad thing that people are no longer dating with big age-gaps while they're still at school - though that doesn't mean the insults are acceptable by any means.

Also I wouldn’t call 7 months a big age gap even at 13/14.

but your post is well thought out and none aggressive so I’m not arguing with you, just discussing

OP posts:
BadNomad · 05/03/2023 16:40

I'm actually quite glad to hear young people look down on age gap relationships these days. Hopefully that will stop a lot of young girls ending up with 40-year-old men.

(Obviously a 7 months difference isn't an age gap)

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:40

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 16:34

It was common when I was at school too, but only across certain year groups if that makes sense.

So, Y7/Y8, Y9/10/11 and Y11/sixth form crossovers were all considered acceptable and normal, but Y10/sixth form would have been considered inappropriate, as would Y8/Y9, and so forth.

I suppose different schools have different cultures and different ideas of what's acceptable and what isn't. Personally I don't really think it's a bad thing that people are no longer dating with big age-gaps while they're still at school - though that doesn't mean the insults are acceptable by any means.

You see that is surprising to me that year 7/8 was acceptable cross over.

a year 7 seems very young indeed having just left primary, but it depends on the ages

year 8s are going through puberty for the most part and year 7s not as much so that’s more pre pubescent and pubescent kids which to me is more questionable than year 8 and year 9

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 16:34

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 16:01

Thank you for explaining. I guess it’s just always been very normal here for students to date from other year groups. The only time I can think of one of my dc finding it awful was a sixth form, very definitely sexually actively boy dating a yr 9 girl. I think the school got involved in that one.

It was common when I was at school too, but only across certain year groups if that makes sense.

So, Y7/Y8, Y9/10/11 and Y11/sixth form crossovers were all considered acceptable and normal, but Y10/sixth form would have been considered inappropriate, as would Y8/Y9, and so forth.

I suppose different schools have different cultures and different ideas of what's acceptable and what isn't. Personally I don't really think it's a bad thing that people are no longer dating with big age-gaps while they're still at school - though that doesn't mean the insults are acceptable by any means.

Pubesofsoberness · 05/03/2023 16:29

They seem to think they are so tolerant yet here they all are bulling someone for a 7 month age gap

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:26

Pubesofsoberness · 05/03/2023 16:22

I find all that one of the most concerning things about being a parent these days

My 28 year old doesn't know anyone who's transitioned. The 20 year old was at school with one person who transitioned in year 7

I don't know about my year 7s year group but the primary school my 10 year old is at already has 2 children transitioning that I know of

The lead female role in the school musical this year is a trans
girl

OP posts:
Pubesofsoberness · 05/03/2023 16:22

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:09

Yeah I’m not anti trans (I am GC) but there are 5 boys FIVE from his primary year who now identify as female and wear girls uniform to school, and called by new names, that is completely fine and normal and no one would dare question it but date someone 7 months younger? NONCE PEADO CRIMINAL PREDATOR.

I find all that one of the most concerning things about being a parent these days

My 28 year old doesn't know anyone who's transitioned. The 20 year old was at school with one person who transitioned in year 7

I don't know about my year 7s year group but the primary school my 10 year old is at already has 2 children transitioning that I know of

Nancydrawn · 05/03/2023 16:16

Again, that's about identity, not activity.

AtomicBlondeRose · 05/03/2023 16:12

I’m not pro-Renton per se but that fact that they can forgive every single thing he does EXCEPT that is mind-boggling! Steal from your mates, watch someone beat a total stranger up and steal their stuff, basically kill a friend by giving them drugs - all fine and dandy.

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 16:12

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:09

Yeah I’m not anti trans (I am GC) but there are 5 boys FIVE from his primary year who now identify as female and wear girls uniform to school, and called by new names, that is completely fine and normal and no one would dare question it but date someone 7 months younger? NONCE PEADO CRIMINAL PREDATOR.

Cross posted. That makes it even stranger @Puddingypops .

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 16:10

It does make me wonder if all the sex Ed stuff they are being taught, the gender stuff, furries as pp mentions etc etc is actually doing a good job of putting them all off sex and relationships at their young age. Even 5 years ago it was quite normal in ds year for relationships at 13/14 but maybe that is changing?

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:09

Pubesofsoberness · 05/03/2023 16:05

It is odd, identify as a furry and wear a fake tail for a year. Totally acceptable

Go out with someone 7 months younger than you, totally unacceptable and weird

I wonder how many of them will cope when they become adults

Yeah I’m not anti trans (I am GC) but there are 5 boys FIVE from his primary year who now identify as female and wear girls uniform to school, and called by new names, that is completely fine and normal and no one would dare question it but date someone 7 months younger? NONCE PEADO CRIMINAL PREDATOR.

OP posts:
Nancydrawn · 05/03/2023 16:07

YukoandHiro · 05/03/2023 15:49

Yes this is a thing right into the mid twenties now. The new Puritanism. It's bloody weird. Kids self policing their own emerging sexuality. Totally the opposite of the embrace your sexuality thing around pride/trans that's also going on in schools. Quite perplexing.

It's not entirely perplexing. The free expression of sexuality you're talking about is often identity-based, not about activity.

These kids have grown up hearing important things about CSA, consent, and boundaries, as well as public stories about grooming and structural or institutional abuse. This makes them aware.

They've also grown up in a world in which a tiny tiny mistake (not, obviously, talking about the important things just listed) can be magnified and follow them around -- there is no escaping the digital world, no home-as-a-respite-from-school. This makes them afraid.

And they've grown up in a world where people are batshit crazy hysterical and have latched on to the very real problems outlined above as the ultimate insult, and do things like pizzagate and QAnon and all sorts of conspiracy-minded lunacy. Most kids don't believe this, but they're also very aware of the power of this particular insult. This (can) make them paranoid.

So I'm not surprised that, for both good reasons and bad, they're policing their sexual activity boundaries super strictly.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 16:07

AtomicBlondeRose · 05/03/2023 16:01

I agree about the new Puritanism and creeping infantilisation of young people.

I teach sixth formers. Now, when I, and my colleagues, were in sixth form we considered ourselves - and were largely treated as - young adults. It was something you aspired towards and longed for! We started to come and go as we pleased, stay out at night, get drunk (!), have relationships, and all the small, enjoyable rebellions that marked you out as a growing young person.

However, my sixth formers largely consider themselves children and expect to be treated as such. It doesn’t infuriate them as it would have done us - they like it! They like to be given strict rules, kept behind to do missed work (can you IMAGINE wanting to do this in sixth form? But my classes prefer me to timetable them in for extra sessions rather than just do the work at home on their own time!). They don’t want to finish y13 early and were miffed to find they’ll be done by June (“you just want to get rid of us” - er, yeah!). Most of them don’t want to go to university or leave home. They don’t date much - I only know one couple in all my classes which is very unusual. They don’t go out very much.

We study Trainspotting in Film Studies and for them, far and away the worst thing that Renton does - never mind lying, stealing from his parents, overdosing on heroin etc - is date Diane, who is still at school. Even though a) he’s meant to be someone who makes questionable decisions anyway so it’s not portrayed as admirable and b) she approaches him, is happy and fully consenting throughout, and holds most of the power in the relationship. They cannot get past the age gap. It’s completely black and white to them. The worst crime of all.

To be fair Renton is around 24 so as she’s about 14 even I’m with them on that one hahahaha

but it does illustrate the point, along with all the other terrible things he does and choices he makes, the age thing. I had no idea.

OP posts:
Pubesofsoberness · 05/03/2023 16:05

BellePeppa · 05/03/2023 10:31

It is weird. Even my very bright very sensible late teen thinks someone of 21 going out with an 18 year old is creepy and unacceptable! What with this and the gender stuff our young people are getting their brains so scrambled they can’t think straight (or for themselves).

It is odd, identify as a furry and wear a fake tail for a year. Totally acceptable

Go out with someone 7 months younger than you, totally unacceptable and weird

I wonder how many of them will cope when they become adults

AtomicBlondeRose · 05/03/2023 16:01

I agree about the new Puritanism and creeping infantilisation of young people.

I teach sixth formers. Now, when I, and my colleagues, were in sixth form we considered ourselves - and were largely treated as - young adults. It was something you aspired towards and longed for! We started to come and go as we pleased, stay out at night, get drunk (!), have relationships, and all the small, enjoyable rebellions that marked you out as a growing young person.

However, my sixth formers largely consider themselves children and expect to be treated as such. It doesn’t infuriate them as it would have done us - they like it! They like to be given strict rules, kept behind to do missed work (can you IMAGINE wanting to do this in sixth form? But my classes prefer me to timetable them in for extra sessions rather than just do the work at home on their own time!). They don’t want to finish y13 early and were miffed to find they’ll be done by June (“you just want to get rid of us” - er, yeah!). Most of them don’t want to go to university or leave home. They don’t date much - I only know one couple in all my classes which is very unusual. They don’t go out very much.

We study Trainspotting in Film Studies and for them, far and away the worst thing that Renton does - never mind lying, stealing from his parents, overdosing on heroin etc - is date Diane, who is still at school. Even though a) he’s meant to be someone who makes questionable decisions anyway so it’s not portrayed as admirable and b) she approaches him, is happy and fully consenting throughout, and holds most of the power in the relationship. They cannot get past the age gap. It’s completely black and white to them. The worst crime of all.

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 16:01

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 15:52

No, they're not in two different schools but I suspect it explains why they're reacting the way they are. In many parts of the country, middle schools are still a "thing" - so even if you don't attend one, you know people who do. Even in high school, Year 7/8 also often attend a different part of the school to Y9-Y11 which also highlights the differences between them - in our local school (for example) they have different assemblies, different lunch/breaks, even different finishing times.

I agree that (rationally) it doesn't make much sense when they're only seven months apart, but when I was growing up there really was a huge difference between middle school and high school - we all grew up a LOT in year 9 and the age gaps between the year groups became very obvious.

I'm not saying the way the DS has been treated is okay but I do see where the "ick" factor amongst other pupils is coming from.

Thank you for explaining. I guess it’s just always been very normal here for students to date from other year groups. The only time I can think of one of my dc finding it awful was a sixth form, very definitely sexually actively boy dating a yr 9 girl. I think the school got involved in that one.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 15:58

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 15:52

No, they're not in two different schools but I suspect it explains why they're reacting the way they are. In many parts of the country, middle schools are still a "thing" - so even if you don't attend one, you know people who do. Even in high school, Year 7/8 also often attend a different part of the school to Y9-Y11 which also highlights the differences between them - in our local school (for example) they have different assemblies, different lunch/breaks, even different finishing times.

I agree that (rationally) it doesn't make much sense when they're only seven months apart, but when I was growing up there really was a huge difference between middle school and high school - we all grew up a LOT in year 9 and the age gaps between the year groups became very obvious.

I'm not saying the way the DS has been treated is okay but I do see where the "ick" factor amongst other pupils is coming from.

There are no middle schools around here at all, and when I was at school lower site was 7,8 and 9 and upper site was 10 and 11

OP posts:
2bazookas · 05/03/2023 15:57

I'd take it up with the school. Neither your son or the girl should be facing such comments on the school premises.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 15:52

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 15:26

Thats me you’ve part quoted. But that’s not the case here is it? They’re both in high school and there’s a 7 month ( I think, not scrolling back to check) age difference. That’s nothing at all. And tbh if they were in middle and high but with that age difference I wouldn’t think anything of it. I would with a 2 year difference but not within a year.

No, they're not in two different schools but I suspect it explains why they're reacting the way they are. In many parts of the country, middle schools are still a "thing" - so even if you don't attend one, you know people who do. Even in high school, Year 7/8 also often attend a different part of the school to Y9-Y11 which also highlights the differences between them - in our local school (for example) they have different assemblies, different lunch/breaks, even different finishing times.

I agree that (rationally) it doesn't make much sense when they're only seven months apart, but when I was growing up there really was a huge difference between middle school and high school - we all grew up a LOT in year 9 and the age gaps between the year groups became very obvious.

I'm not saying the way the DS has been treated is okay but I do see where the "ick" factor amongst other pupils is coming from.

YukoandHiro · 05/03/2023 15:49

Yes this is a thing right into the mid twenties now. The new Puritanism. It's bloody weird. Kids self policing their own emerging sexuality. Totally the opposite of the embrace your sexuality thing around pride/trans that's also going on in schools. Quite perplexing.

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 15:47

Anyway back to the point. OP the bullying is unacceptable and the school need to deal with it.

Somanyquestionstoaskaboutthis · 05/03/2023 15:46

Willyoujustbequiet · 05/03/2023 15:42

It means different schools in many places of the country. The difference between a middle and high school is enormous.

But it doesn’t in this case. So that’s not applicable. It’s a 7 month age difference. What is the problem?