Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is bats**t crazy? Don’t know what to do

334 replies

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 09:28

My DS is 14 and in year 9, his girlfriend from school is 13 and in year 8, they were born in the same year (2009) and there is 7 months age gap between them. She is also FAR more mature than my son, because she’s a girl!

apparently if now you go out with someone in the year below you are a none and pe*o and every other foul name under the son.

my lad is getting the most vile abuse at school but I don’t even know what to do because it’s everyone, in every year group and it’s constant, being shouted at in corridors, voice messages to his phone saying he’s weird and should be locked up, people approaching him at school and saying what he is doing is wrong.

I checked with other kids in other schools and it’s true there too?!?!? When the hell did this happen? When I was at school girls went out with boys in the year above!

Ive spoken to my lad about what he wants to do because he can’t stand the bullying, he’s gone from being really popular to a total pariah in 3 months.

OP posts:
Mariposa26 · 05/03/2023 10:49

I think the younger generation have become very acutely aware of age gaps even with older adults! Maybe because of the media? There was a trend on TikTok recently which showed parents with their birth years along with their children, and I noticed regularly that the comments would be from disgusted teenagers when an older couple were even 5 years apart in their 40s! It’s become a “thing”.

DrDinosaur · 05/03/2023 10:49

It is definitely batshit.
Talk to the school, but also ensures he knows there is NOTHING inappropriate about this relationship, and anyone who thinks there is is illogical and ridiculous.

Cocobutt · 05/03/2023 10:47

This would not have been ok in my school when I was younger or the schools that I’ve worked at as an adult.

The majority of students are different between year groups.

We actually had a year 7 dating a year 11 and her parents rightly so called the police.
There was only 3 years between them and she was way more mature than him (SEN) but it was still unacceptable.

In this situation they are much closer in age and it sounds like there is a good pier balance and they’re both similar emotionally but I get why others would find it odd.

A year 7 going out with a year 6 would be the same.

However, there is absolutely no need for the bullying and unfortunately a lot of students will just join in.

You need to speak to the school and tell them how bad it is.

It is awful when you’re being bullied by a few people but the entire school must feel absolutely horrible.
Its also going to make his friends abandon him as they’ll start to get bullied to or be persuaded that it’s not ok.

Talk to the head and head of year.
Tell them that it needs to stop.
I would personally ask them to talk about it during tutor time whilst he’s not there and they need to tell them that any mention of it is going to be punished.

Once the school is taking it seriously then HE needs to make sure he is reporting everything!
He needs to also save messages and write small things down that happen so he has the proof.

It may also be worth them pretending to have separated just to stop people being offended and finding reasons to bully them.

WishingIWasOnHoliday · 05/03/2023 10:47

Funnily enough I was talking about this to my year 9 DD the other day, as one of the girls in her year is going out with a Y10 boy. I don‘t think they[re subjected to the abuse your DS is, but my DD did say she thought it was "weird". I tried to explain that there could be a 1 day age difference between a Y9 and 10, or potentially a 364 day age difference between two Y9s, and although she understood what I was saying, "people" at school have decided it‘s weird, therefore that is what goes. I would say though, no one is calling the boy a paedo or nonce, I think "weird" is as bad as it gets, so it really does sound like it depends on where you are.

But unfortunately, teenagers don‘t like to be a lone voice. It‘s much easier for them to go along with the majority, even if deep down it makes no sense. Also, their sense of reasoning isn‘t always very attuned, which is why they often get on their high horses about things and see things in black and white.

I don‘t know what the solution is, other than talking to the school, or even moving schools, not that he should have to.

Sisisimone · 05/03/2023 10:46

PaigeMatthews · 05/03/2023 10:32

I would not be happy at all about my yr 8 dd ‘dating‘ a year 9 boy. It doesnt matter how much the age difference is when they are out of the school system, in the school system he is a year ahead.

you just cannot justify age gaps in school in the same way you would the world beyond that. Even one week end of august to the beginning of september still means they older is a year ahead, not a week older.

sixth formers dating 15 year olds is a problem due to the age of consent. If it is a sexual relationship it is a problem.

Neither would I. My dd is year 8, only 12 yo and all of her friends just seem still very childlike. There's a big difference in social maturity between the year groups at that age. It's nowhere near comparable to an 18 and 21 year old dating

Benjispruce4 · 05/03/2023 10:43

There’s nothing weird about this op. It’s just kids knowing or thinking they know so much more about inappropriate relationships, which this is not.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 10:42

PaigeMatthews · 05/03/2023 10:36

small age gaps are not as significant here as the life stages, which create the gaps and power imbalances. A 15 year old at school is at a different life stage to a 16/17 yr old at college. An 18 year old living at home attending 6th form is at a completely different life stage to a 21 year old close to finishing uni or working full time.

You seem very black and white in your thinking.

DS is not in the position of power, the other way round, GF has 2 older siblings, DS is an only child quiet and sheltered, she has tried drinking, he will not, she has tried a vape, he has not.

Being a year ahead in the education system does not mean being a year ahead in life experiences, maturity, or anything else.

you seem to be supportive of the nonce view which is baffling to me

OP posts:
BellePeppa · 05/03/2023 10:40

PaigeMatthews · 05/03/2023 10:36

small age gaps are not as significant here as the life stages, which create the gaps and power imbalances. A 15 year old at school is at a different life stage to a 16/17 yr old at college. An 18 year old living at home attending 6th form is at a completely different life stage to a 21 year old close to finishing uni or working full time.

I was going out with a 21 yr old when I was 18 there wasn’t anything weird about it all.

Benjispruce4 · 05/03/2023 10:40

Teens can be so vile. This is awful for him but just a joke that everyone is in on to them. Agree that school need to get on this very quickly.

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 05/03/2023 10:38

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 10:28

Yes this seems to be the thinking, but again the month difference is the same between DS and his GF and his best mate and HIS GF, but the birthdays fall so that best mate and gf are in the same year.

if you met my DS and his GF you would think she was older than him.

I suppose that kids see it as a bit off overall, and it becomes a "rule of the playground", with no room for edge cases.

When I was a kid you were only allowed to carry your backpack with one strap over you shoulder. Made no sense, but by god you'd be bullied for months if you wore it the way the manufacturer's intended even once.

I actually think kids today are far nicer than we were as kids. My daughter's in a fairly "rough" school, but even so the kids seem far more accepting of each others differences. However they're also taught far more about safeguarding and age appropriate relationships than we were, so maybe that's why this is still such a huge thing between them.

PaigeMatthews · 05/03/2023 10:36

BellePeppa · 05/03/2023 10:31

It is weird. Even my very bright very sensible late teen thinks someone of 21 going out with an 18 year old is creepy and unacceptable! What with this and the gender stuff our young people are getting their brains so scrambled they can’t think straight (or for themselves).

small age gaps are not as significant here as the life stages, which create the gaps and power imbalances. A 15 year old at school is at a different life stage to a 16/17 yr old at college. An 18 year old living at home attending 6th form is at a completely different life stage to a 21 year old close to finishing uni or working full time.

KTheGrey · 05/03/2023 10:35

Wow those kids' heads are going to spin when they have to do Romeo and Juliet as it seems all GCSE students must.

It is a thing, but it is ridiculous. If it's happening online is it not a police matter?

It is worth approaching the school because this is bullying and permitting it is part of school culture, so they need to address it. Conversations that happen anyway in schools are usually better acknowledged and contributed to by adults.

Youwhatnowbiggles · 05/03/2023 10:35

Hi @Puddingypops ,Sorry your dd is going through this. Just to let you know it’s the same at my dcs school too. My yr9 dd’s poor bf (yr10) was subject to the same accusations. They have very little interaction at school now except at the clubs they do that cross over yr groups and see each other in the holidays/weekends instead. They won’t go into the town where they’re at school though for fear of being seen together. She’s 14, he’s 15 - it’s utterly ridiculous!!!

EwwSprouts · 05/03/2023 10:35

Agree speak to school as it is clearly bullying.

I would also not be having a 13 year old girl upstairs in his bedroom door open or not, however much you trust both of them.

PaigeMatthews · 05/03/2023 10:32

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 10:08

Was it noncey though? Or are you saying it was considered, obviously wrongly, noncey by the year group?

I mean noncey is an adult human being sexually attracted to children isn’t it? Not a 16 year old dating a 15 year old!

apologies if I sound touchy about it, it’s just making me feel so angry the whole thing and helpless, it’s such a stupid stupid attitude

I would not be happy at all about my yr 8 dd ‘dating‘ a year 9 boy. It doesnt matter how much the age difference is when they are out of the school system, in the school system he is a year ahead.

you just cannot justify age gaps in school in the same way you would the world beyond that. Even one week end of august to the beginning of september still means they older is a year ahead, not a week older.

sixth formers dating 15 year olds is a problem due to the age of consent. If it is a sexual relationship it is a problem.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 05/03/2023 10:32

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

BellePeppa · 05/03/2023 10:31

RandomMess · 05/03/2023 09:49

I agree it's a widespread thing.

My DDs all think going out with a boy 2 years older than them in their late teens is "wrong" then my youngest wonders why her boyfriends are so bloody immature Confused

It is weird. Even my very bright very sensible late teen thinks someone of 21 going out with an 18 year old is creepy and unacceptable! What with this and the gender stuff our young people are getting their brains so scrambled they can’t think straight (or for themselves).

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 10:28

fdgdfgdfgdfg · 05/03/2023 10:24

It has ever been thus. Going out with a girl a year younger was a huge no no when I was in school 25 years ago. They'd get called exactly the same terms back then. It's just another way to bully them.

Weirdly, didn't seem to happen the other way round, if the girl was a year older than the boy.

Just asked DD15 about this. She says it does feel creepy to her. The year 9s seem so much younger and less mature than her year, and that the girls are always so aware of older boys and men leering at them. She also pointed out a year is a much bigger chunk of your life at that age. She did say that she wouldn't give anyone grief about it though (but who'd say otherwise would when talking to their Dad)

Yes this seems to be the thinking, but again the month difference is the same between DS and his GF and his best mate and HIS GF, but the birthdays fall so that best mate and gf are in the same year.

if you met my DS and his GF you would think she was older than him.

OP posts:
fdgdfgdfgdfg · 05/03/2023 10:24

It has ever been thus. Going out with a girl a year younger was a huge no no when I was in school 25 years ago. They'd get called exactly the same terms back then. It's just another way to bully them.

Weirdly, didn't seem to happen the other way round, if the girl was a year older than the boy.

Just asked DD15 about this. She says it does feel creepy to her. The year 9s seem so much younger and less mature than her year, and that the girls are always so aware of older boys and men leering at them. She also pointed out a year is a much bigger chunk of your life at that age. She did say that she wouldn't give anyone grief about it though (but who'd say otherwise would when talking to their Dad)

GoodChat · 05/03/2023 10:22

I have started subtly mentioning it in detail to parents of his friends and asking them to speak to their kids about trying to shut it down around them if they hear it but it’s so widespread it seems an impossible task to turn back time and make things as they were

To be fair if his friends start standing up for him other people will back off. It's only easy to bully someone who stands alone. It's not easy to bully someone who has lots of people to defend him.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 10:20

I would love to go to the school but what he wants is for things to be as they were where the kids outside his immediate friend circle liked him, we’re friendly, fist bumped him walking last etc.

even if school address the bullying that’s not going to happen.

I said to him surely that ship has sailed and if he ends things with her then he will still be a nonce etc? He thinks not that it will die down so he is faced with giving into the pressure like @dancinfeet or somehow powering through.

I have started subtly mentioning it in detail to parents of his friends and asking them to speak to their kids about trying to shut it down around them if they hear it but it’s so widespread it seems an impossible task to turn back time and make things as they were

OP posts:
dancinfeet · 05/03/2023 10:16

Ugh your poor son. I had a load of grief from people at college when I was 1st year sixth form (yr 12) and my boyfriend was yr 11 still at school. I have a summer birthday and his was right at the beginning of september, so a matter of weeks between our birthdays. Fool that I was back then, I gave in to the peer pressure and finished with him- he was a lovely lad, but he just wasn’t accepted by my new college friends because of him still being at school. Daft thing was, dating other people in year above at college was seen as fine.

GoodChat · 05/03/2023 10:14

@Puddingypops yeah kids don't think rationally like adults, that's the problem.

I would speak to the school and ask them to handle it delicately considering he's already a victim of bullying. A whole school assembly wouldn't be an appropriate action.

SettlingForAnotherMuffin · 05/03/2023 10:12

BMW6 · 05/03/2023 09:34

I'd approach the school as your son is being bullied for stupid reasons. The kids need to be educated on this en masse.

yes this. This is just bullying and outrageous.

Puddingypops · 05/03/2023 10:12

IWineAndDontDine · 05/03/2023 10:11

Totally normal at my school age wise... honestly kids find a reason to bully, if it wasnt this, it would be something else I think. Someone has taken a disliking to him and the mob mentality has taken over

No it’s not that. He didn’t ask her out for ages because he knew it would land him in this situation. It’s a taboo these days.

he just didn’t realise how it would make him feel when it’s finally got around the whole school and beyond

OP posts: