Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Year 10 Work Experience

68 replies

crisscross101 · 05/03/2023 08:40

AIBU or is this a total waste of time/unnecessary 2 weeks out of school?

DD is Y10, attends a selective state school that is always in top 10 of exam results league tables so will likely end up with 7-9s across the board at GCSE then off to a RG university. She wants to read law at the moment but that might change.

She had to do two weeks work experience in June. Her friends are spending a couple of weeks at mum's private practice or Dad's GP surgery, a couple who are 'less connected' are going back to their primaries for a couple of weeks despite no interest in teaching. No local solicitors are accepting WE round here due to hybrid working and the fact they are not in the office 60% of the time. DH is a manual worker and I work in a confidential environment meaning that DD couldn't come to work with me. So we're now on the beg for a work experience placement that has no bearing in any event to DD's career aspirations...

She's been looking for a Saturday job- to get proper work experience!- for over a year and no one takes kids in now until they're 16 (she's a summer baby so won't be 16 until after her GCSEs in Y11). (Other than a paper round which I've said no to on safety grounds).

This feels a completely waste of time that she'd be better off at school or on a school trip! I just feel so cross that nepotism starts before they've even left school Angry

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
amonsteronthehill · 05/03/2023 14:19

It's ridiculous and unnecessary.

The 'haves', as you say, get a free ride with their connections. One of my son's friends were all paid to do nothing by their family and extended family companies.

The 'have nots' struggle to find anything and most don't get much out of it by all accounts around here.

When we have students doing 'work experience' in the primary schools I've been in, you can literally watch them clock-watching until they can leave ... after doing pretty much nothing useful all day.

Wednesdayonline · 05/03/2023 13:48

I don't think the work experience will be that necessary for them to get into a law degree. I did my school work experience at a primary school and a library. I didn't know anyone with legal connections. Got good grades, got offers, studied law and now a solicitor. Work experience in a law firm will likely not be that helpful for them, its difficult to include someone young in day to day legal work. But you can probably contact local solicitors and ask if they can do work experience for even a day there if you want them to have it on their application, or just go sit in court and listen and put that on the application. They'll probably be able to bump into a barrister or solicitor after court that will take a few questions from them. Lots of different ways to get into law these days even if you don't have connections.

Choconut · 05/03/2023 13:47

I did WE at a university at that age it was brilliant! definitely made me want to go to uni.

buttercupboots · 05/03/2023 13:17

I'm a lawyer and did my Y10 work experience at my primary and with a local hospital's HR team. I also did various work experiences with law firms because I harassed them to be able to do it in school holidays.

I think it's a lot harder these days with remote working. Where I work, people used to just bring kids in with them for shadowing etc with little red tape but it would be a lot harder now with everyone being at home - they'd need their own teams access etc and even then it's just not the same.

Have you thought about other organisations like citizens advice, Acas, university legal clinics etc

If she's committed to showing her interest, she can attend the courts in her spare time, get involved in school activities ie debating etc. There's no excuse for having done absolutely nothing!

Barleysugar86 · 05/03/2023 12:58

I did my two weeks work experience at a legal office.

It was photocopying primarily. It's not like they taught us any law.

The only day that really taught me anything was the day they dumped us at the court alone to listen to small claims court cases, which although we could have done anyway I never knew was open to the public so that was quite fascinating.

Experience working anywhere with a parent sounds pretty lame for the others, half the fun was feeling grown up while we were there and who can do that going to work with mummy/daddy. Work experience doesn't mean anything for a CV or university, don't think I put mine anywhere.

Two weeks in a cafe or clothes shop or supermarket can be really fun. You get to see behind the scenes and give it a go being on the other side of the counter.

I think you're overthinking it tbh.

Btjdkfnn · 05/03/2023 12:49

Nepotism starts as soon as a kid is born OP. It is unavoidable. If mum or dad is skilled/experienced/working in a certain area, then this is often passed on. There isn't really much to be done about it. It's one of the most invisible forms of privilege. I know someone who did brilliantly in maths (both A levels, on to degree at Oxbridge) - that someone was on paper from an "average state school" and on paper the private school kids had a "better" start. Only - Mother had a fantastic maths degree and was an A level examiner. No head start or privilege there then Confused. Completely invisible.

However, I don't think you can complain too heavily when you have been able to access a school that is better than >99% of the schools in this country, whether they are private or state - especially as you don't even need to pay for it.

I would perhaps suggest a MOOC in law related stuff if your dd is unable to get something with a solicitor. Or online work experience with something like Springpod.

Bluevelvetsofa · 05/03/2023 12:39

It doesn’t have to relate to the potential career a student might have, although if it does, it can give them an insight into the career. It’s about learning new things, how to interact with others, how to think creatively, team work, telephone manner, working at something you might not want to do. All of which are useful tools for the future and can develop an understanding for the world of work.

I wonder if your daughter is as sure as you are of her future path. Is she the one aiming for these things? Be careful, things can change.

Bear in mind that w/e is not possible in certain situations because of insurance requirements.

Flamingogirl08 · 05/03/2023 12:33

It's a bit weird to be saying she will get these grades and will go to a RG University when she's only 14. Your hope is she will so these things. She might run off and join the circus for all you know

WhatWhereWhenHowWhy · 05/03/2023 12:19

I had a work experience in a tiny local bedding and curtain shop, while all my friends had Topshop/New Look/River Island. It felt like the ultimate waste of time and so embarrassing when my mates were talking about theirs. My parents made me go...
It was genuinely so useful and gave me so many life skills such as pattern cutting/sewing/using machinery etc...led to an A* in Textiles and just a general understanding of the world of work and being able to have those life skills such as repairing clothes.

Allywill · 05/03/2023 12:02

What about citizens advice or shadowing an usher in court if it’s legal stuff she’s interested?

ouch44 · 05/03/2023 11:58

Simplelobsterhat · 05/03/2023 09:20

Agreed, but I don't think many people are getting those experiences at 14. Most of the medicine shadowing schemes are for year 12 for example. So this year 10 work experience isn't the be all and end all. And actually many healthcare courses have said they really value the wider skills of customer service etc as well. In an ideal world it would be great to get a start on sometimes career related, but the softer skills are just as important.

Completely agree. My Year 10 child is going to work in a shop and Year 12 hopefully going to do something in engineering with a relative of a friend of his.
However, I have seen medicine related online schemes for Year 10 as I have a friend whose DD wants to do medicine. She’s going to work with someone who’s a carer though.

HotDogJumpingFrogHaveACookie · 05/03/2023 11:47

I think you're weirdly rigid about this.

If she gets work experience in a solicitors it'll be on reception or carrying out clerical tasks, it won't be dealing with anything actually legal related.

I interview young people and I'm always interested in hearing what they feel they got out of work experience, especially because many of them don't have experience of actual work to draw upon.

It isn't about learning how to do something specific to a career. It's about a change of environment, learning different expectations, moving outside of their comfort zone, learning how to communicate differently, use initiative etc. A great many kids do go on to pick up part time work on the back of their work experience too.

TheStarLady · 05/03/2023 11:39

My DS is in year 10 and there’s been no mention of work experience at all. I think it’s really disappointing and children need to learn to step out of comfort zone more than ever.

I actually had work experience in year 9 & 10. I went to a primary school first as I thought I wanted to be a teacher. By year 10 I had decided to do law and one of my friend’s dad owned a law firm so I went there.

I did do a law degree but actually work in finance now. I didn’t exactly ‘enjoy’ my placements but do think it was very valuable.

My DS wants to go into IT. However I’ve told him to get any job he can asap as it helps to build confidence and people skills.

Motherofacertainage · 05/03/2023 11:04

My children's school don't do work experience which I think is a huge missed opportunity. From kids I have taught work experience can teach them they definitely don't want to do something; it can inspire a passion for a certain profession; get them.a Saturday job or it can simply show them a different side of life they haven't yet experienced. For almost all of them (except perhaps the ones who work with mummy or daddy tbf ) it forces them out of their comfort zone and often builds their confidence of dealing with adults in the real world.

HereTodayHereTomorrow · 05/03/2023 10:50

The system for UCAS personal statements is changing. It really isn’t a big deal. Link

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/03/2023 10:50

crisscross101 · 05/03/2023 08:47

I disagree.

The inequity in a UCAS application of a child wanting to read law who has completed meaningful work experience with a private practice and a child who went and worked at the corner shop for free for two weeks is an obvious example.

Also, the idea work is you get something out of it. Two weeks free labour in a cafe because it's the only thing you could find isn't the reality of work.

It may be a possibility that at some point in her life your DD has to take a job that she doesn't particularly love or is not her preferred occupation/skillset.

It's not ideal but there are benefits to work experience.

latetothefisting · 05/03/2023 10:36

Agree with most of the other posters -year 10 work experience is more just to show "the world of work"rather than career relevant which would come more in year 12. Although obviously it might be of slight interest if they have been somewhere relevant uni admissions KNOW there is inequality between people whose parents/friends already work in the professions and those who don't and really won't base much of the decision on that.

Like others have said, there are other ways of getting legal specific experience (if that's what your dd wants to do) that will look as good or better seeing as she did it from her own initiative.

I went to superdrug for my year 10 work experience - I got absolutely loads of freebies at the end of it and an offer of a part time job so it was a win! The main thing I "learned" was that working 9-5 plus "commute" was bloody knackering!

ginforall · 05/03/2023 10:31

The school where I work have stopped doing it in year 10 as it was so difficult for students to get placements. We still do it in year 12 and even then there are a lot of rejections (particularly the last couple of years). Some students have done virtual work experience through springpod: www.springpod.com/virtual-work-experience which is obviously no where near as good but at least gave them something relevant to the field they wanted to work in.

AuditAngel · 05/03/2023 10:27

We won’t take year 10 for work experience due to insurance and the demands the schools place on us, some of our staff are DBS checked, but not all.

when DS wanted work experience I was filling in the forms for him to work at DH’s business (where he already worked weekends) but the paperwork demands were intrusive, and DH was only going to do it so DS had a placement. In the end we told the school it wasn’t possible and the school found him a placement in the local special needs school.

zingally · 05/03/2023 10:17

WE is deathly dull.
I spent my 2 weeks in a day nursery - which isn't a million miles off, as I'm now a primary school teacher. But I find nursery deathly dull!
My DH did his at Boots - he's now a social worker
My sister did hers in the office of a solicitors - she does computer systems for the police.
My best friend worked at an opticians, and she's now a pharmacist.

Tootsweets84 · 05/03/2023 09:57

I have a son in year 10 who wants to eventually work on a field where it's difficult to find work experience. The best advice I received was to contact local universities and ask to shadow a professor in the relevant department. It worked and hrs now looking forward to a really exciting placement. Might be worth a shot for your daughter

gingergiraffe · 05/03/2023 09:51

My son, only 15 years old when he did his yr 10 work experience, had no idea what he wanted to do after his GCSEs. He managed to get a placement with the local council with the electricians. He loved it. Later he applied for an apprenticeship with them and was accepted. He is still with them at 33 years old. He met lots of trainee electricians while on college courses who were very capable on the theory side of things but found it very difficult to get a practical placement to complete their training. Not relevant to your situation op but may be helpful to others.
I don’t know, but maybe the council would offer placements in other areas which could prove useful. Housing, for instance. Housing officers deal with clients and work with other organisations such as the police, social services, child protection and the courts in their day to day jobs. This could give some insight into how the law operates in regards to housing. I wonder if Social Services would offer work experience?

AliceS1994 · 05/03/2023 09:46

Year 10 work experience is not for swanning around as a mini lawyer as others have said it's a introduction to the world of work, it's about showing up on time, building confidence and lots of general soft skills. You'd be surprised how little admissions officers care about it tbh. Any summer job would demonstrate your daughter to be hardworking etc. she will gain little knowledge of law from a one week placement. She could learn this content in a summer school programme- lots of unis run this.

She will have a better chance to get experience in law settings once she's past 16. I would strongly recommend doing this. An admissions officer will be much more impressed with a 16-17 year old doing work experience in their summer holidays anyway than a 14 year old who sat around in Daddy's law firm making tea and scrolling on their phone. I would use this is a opportunity to help her get a proper paid job, which is in turn will help her get other opportunities in law-relates fields further than the line and help her get more out of those experiences.

I completely agree with you that the nepotism is very sad indeed!

MoreHairyThanScary · 05/03/2023 09:39

Back in the dark ages when I did work experience I manage to get into a local firm of solicitors ( I also wanted a career in law). That week made me question my choice ... I set up another WE in the holidays with the crown prosecution service which confirmed that law was not for me.

WE can be as useful in working out what you don't want to do.

Agree that 2 weeks is a long time, local schools only do 1 week, but they do provide access to opportunities locally for firms who have worked with students, My daughter wrote lots of emails and letters to get a place. She has also set up work experience with a local accountancy firm in her holidays ( only 2 days) but on the back of that had an interview for an apprenticeship and has a job offer.

I think you are quite short sighted and not seeing the bigger picture!

wonkylegs · 05/03/2023 09:39

@crisscross101
I think you are looking at this wrongly
Work experience is about the stuff that school doesn't teach you (which is a lot) and opens kids eyes up to aspects of life they haven't directly experienced before.
Yes some will find it easier than others to find something to do but all experiences have value including the difficulty of finding WE in the first place - it will be an eye opener as to what is to come (some people will have job opportunities that others won't upon qualification too)
Just because a WE placement may not be directly in what your kid is interested doesn't make it less value.
Cast the net wide - lots of businesses have applicable skills & experience which would add value to your childs journey in law - not just lawyers.
I always wanted to be an architect but as a child I did WE at a construction firm & a bank offices - I learnt a lot about what I did and didn't want to do in those experiences.

Our son is looking for WE placements atm too - it's hard and some places won't take them but there are still plenty out there if you look hard enough (and that are not 'just' in the hairdresser or corner shop)

Swipe left for the next trending thread