Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why are so many women putting up with ghastly husbands/partners?

318 replies

Dottymug · 04/03/2023 22:26

It's the 21st century. Women have so many more opportunities and choices than they had in the past. So why are so many women posting on here about being sworn at, insulted, betrayed and treated as slaves by men who they've no intention of leaving/chucking out? It's utterly depressing. Don't put up with that shit. Life is too short.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 05/03/2023 11:26

@ZoZoisresting

If you’re choosing to have children with a man you should at least be able to rely on his goodwill at that point (obviously it doesn’t always work out). The reality is even if you’re more of a girl boss you’re still relying totally on your husbands goodwill when it comes to your childrens security and safety. If you leave and will be well off because of your job, unless bad abuse is proven your husband will stake get child access and be part of your kids lives anyway.

All the more reason not to involve a man at all if you can afford not to.

TBH (and I know this is not going to be popular) I think the optimal environment for children to grow up in is a single parent household headed by a solvent and reliable woman.

In theory a nuclear family involving a woman and a good, reliable, solvent and involved man who both works hard and considers childcare as much his responsibility as the woman's should be better than this and when it works it probably is. In practice such families are vanishingly rare and you would be foolish to count on finding this.

You say you "should be able to rely on [a man's] goodwill". Of course you should. But that means relying on his goodwill to support you and play his part in the home and with childcare. How do you go about guaranteeing the man you met at prime childbearing age will remain like this for 40 years? You can't. And if you gamble on it you are gambling on yours and your children's financial autonomy.

Being sole breadwinner and primary carer is relentless but its almost always better than the alternative.

LexMitior · 05/03/2023 11:25

Fear, lack of money, lack of status.

That last one is mostly enforced by women. Mostly because there is a real myopia about difficult relationships which many women consider via their own experience. This comes across as "you find him difficult, that is you, sotto I do not". You see this all the time on Mumsnet. It's a narcissistic response but very common.

Also, despite a lot of campaigns about violence or domestic abuse, it's pretty obvious that women who do experience this are considered to be a problem, rather than the men who perpetrate it. The funding and efforts to combat these issues in our society are very small.

Stepping outside of this, well, you are on your own. Very tough to do. Notably abusive or unkind men rarely want to be on their own. They know how tough it is.

Hairmouse · 05/03/2023 11:25

@MarchMate yes I am aware I sound like a terrible friend but there are only so many times you can have the same conversation! I love my friends but it’s hard listening to intelligent kind women talk about their shit husbands again and again and not do anything about it. It’s made me hate their husbands as well. I am starting to resent it all.

MarchMate · 05/03/2023 11:24

@Penguinsaregreat even if a "woman is strong and financially well off" it is still very difficult to leave. I'm the breadwinner. I'm tough. I'm strong. I'm still staying.

Women who chose to stay are not weak.

Penguinsaregreat · 05/03/2023 11:22

I completely agree with the Peter who said many men don’t really want children. This 100%.
They will go along with it to obtain a partner who will pander to them and offer them sex and a clean house. They also see it as a bit of a status symbol but that’s it. I’m convinced that if a woman says I am not having children then at least 50% (very conservative estimate) of men would go along with that choice.
Then once children come along the balance of power shifts dramatically. Men are not really castigated if they leave children are they? Plenty of women continue to breed with men who have already proved that they are shitty fathers. I don’t feel any sympathy towards those women, the writing was clearly on the wall.
Completely different for women who have children with child free men, they don’t have anything to go on.
So, unless a woman is strong and financially well off, it is difficult to leave. A large proportion of fathers do not contribute either financially or emotionally once the relationship fails. The bar us set very low for NRP. Very, very low.

MarchMate · 05/03/2023 11:20

Yes I think it becomes an accepted narrative about rubbish husbands. Instagram is full of "funny" posts about men leaving stuff everywhere, not buying Xmas presents, not remembering their own mothers birthday and the wife sending a gift instead. It's become so normal it's become funny for women to all relate to each other on that basis..."oh my god you wouldn't believe what Steve did last week" etc @Hairmouse

But actually breaking it down is pretty awful. My husband might just be lying on the sofa every weekend which isn't anything too terrible on the surface but actually it's because he believes inherently somewhere it's my job to sort out his life for him. He doesn't mind looking pathetic. He just wants to be mothered. It's so unattractive and yet I'm still here because I am set to lose so so much if I leave. A huge chunk of my income, my equity and most importantly my kids. Its a pragmatic decision, not a fearful one.

So in the meantime we find solace and support from other women. It looks like we are all moaning martyrs to scared to go it alone but many of us are trying to make the best decision with the shitty situation we find ourselves in.

5128gap · 05/03/2023 11:19

ZoZoisresting · 05/03/2023 10:52

@5128gap

When it comes to serious violence perhaps. But as far as just being a shitty person, name calling, emotional abuse etc - it’s just as serious and far reaching with women as men and it just avoiding responsibility because it’s easier to lay it on men to suggest otherwise

I disagree. It's impossible to ignore the context in which such behaviours exist.
It may suit certain agendas to pretend there is no difference between being emotionally and verbally abused by someone who also has the ability to cause you injury and physically restrict your movements if they so wish, than by someone from whom you can easily overpower; but it's a falsehood.
Not to mention the social and economic contexts that make it far easier for men to exit such relationships.
I'm not saying they are no men in bad relationships, but to try to suggest this means its an equal problem for both sexes is just minimising the problem of male bad behaviour. Because its easier to lay the blame on women than suggest otherwise.

Retractable · 05/03/2023 11:12

You simply don’t know what someone will be like as a husband and father until he is one. The criteria for good boyfriend and even good child-free husband can be very different to what is required to effectively keep children alive.

Also, it’s simply the case that many women are pretty independent and don’t need anything but the fun easy stuff from a partner… until they’re pregnant/have a small child and suddenly vulnerable in ways they hadn’t anticipated. At that point lots of women learn many things about the man they thought they knew so well - sometimes many of them are more than just disappointing.

In a different context things didn’t seem to be ‘red flag but having a family (or even just pooling resources) changes that. It’s like shifting the coloured filter you view the world through - a child and shared responsibility free relationship can give you a cyan filter on the world. It’s sometimes impossible to perceive the red bits at all. And, as a woman, you don’t see the world through male socialisation so you simply don’t anticipate that they’re going to decide that it’s fair that you get no sleep at all ever and do everything.

Botw1 · 05/03/2023 11:06

@drpet49

Of course they did.

Not directly.

You've never seen a romantic film or TV show?

Teen magazines?

Books?

Come on. That message is everywhere

ChippyTeaYesPlease · 05/03/2023 11:04

Because the thought of looking over my shoulder all the time is terrifying, worrying that every little noise outside is him about to break in or put my windows in. The fear of being unable to relax in my new home is what puts me off leaving and keeps me trapped here. Also that the house needs so much doing thanks to him either damaging things (no doors on upstairs for example) or starting diy projects and not finishing (only had half a kitchen for the best part of a 18 months) mean that I wouldn't be able to sell for anything like what it's worth so I'm waiting for him to get those things sorted. I can't pay for them myself unfortunately.

So although it sounds pathetic, I am here for a bit longer yet. Being ignored or sworn at or whatever. I will get out though. I am making plans and thats incredibly liberating.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/03/2023 11:04

No idea, have never understood it.

Saschka · 05/03/2023 11:03

drpet49 · 05/03/2023 10:55

Eh? No one taught me or any women I know that.

Plenty of parents teach their girls that.

And actually I did have a teacher in school who told me not to apply for medicine but to apply for nursing “and then you can marry a doctor”. Like being a doctor’s wife was the zenith of female achievement. DM complained but that was the general attitude - girls should be pretty and marry well. This was early-90s Sussex village school. None of the mums worked.

ZoZoisresting · 05/03/2023 10:59

I also think controlling beahviour is often overlooked in women as not serious.

Isheabastard · 05/03/2023 10:58

There can be so many reasons as stated here. I’m much older and in my case I went from a very dominant mother to an increasingly dominant and controlling husband. The world was also a very different place 30/40 years ago and the roles for males and females was much more rigidly defined.

How old are you OP?

Im pleased to say my adult DD aged 25 has a very equal partnership with her DP. I sometimes worry that the mantra Women Can Have it All, really means Women Can Have it All to Do.

Sometimes it just comes down to some men are lazy, selfish arrogant fuckers.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 05/03/2023 10:58

Sometimes it is financial but I think for many women any man is better than no man. I'm not sure if it is a fear of loneliness or fear or social stigma, but being unhappy with a man is better than being unhappy without a man, which genuinely are the options they have.

ZoZoisresting · 05/03/2023 10:56

LlynTegid · 05/03/2023 10:14

Economics have been mentioned.

I'd add the law is inadequate and biased in favour of the non-resident parent when it comes to separation and divorce, and does not reward reasonable behaviour when it comes to access (or punish unreasonable behaviour).

I think also there is too much stigma on being single, be you a parent or not, and so this leads to many people entering or remaining in bad relationships.

@LlynTegid

The non resident parent is often forced out their own home and can’t see their own children much. Sometimes they may have done nothing at all to cause this and may be the wronged party in the marriage.

How on earth is the law biased in the non resident parents favour?

KingandIfan · 05/03/2023 10:55

Hairmouse · 05/03/2023 10:29

I think marriage and/ or having children is a challenging situation and one that most people aren’t prepared for. I was made to go on a marriage preparation course as I got married in a church. At the time I massively resented but it’s turned out to be useful. We were made to talk about all the boring details like attitudes to housework, money and disciplining children. Both DH are committed to family life and want it to work. It’s not perfect but it’s worth it. I think many men don’t actually want children or enjoy family life. They want to be looked after by women and have the status of a family man. Many women want children and are prepared to look past this. It ends up shit for women!

This is so true, especially "many men don't actually want or children or enjoy family life. They waant to be looked after by women and have the status of a family man. Many women want children and are prepared to look past this."

drpet49 · 05/03/2023 10:55

Botw1 · 04/03/2023 22:42

Oh and because we teach girls that bagging a man and having kids is the ultimate goal that must be achieved

And that they should be nice, people pleasing girls always

Eh? No one taught me or any women I know that.

WandaWonder · 05/03/2023 10:54

I do think we only hear one side of stories, the wife can say what they want about the husband for example

But can be omitting their part I nthe marriage

He could be the worse husband in the world, or something in between

But I have seen lots of examples of if the situation is true the wife comes across as controlling

ZoZoisresting · 05/03/2023 10:52

5128gap · 05/03/2023 08:10

Of course it's gender specific. There are centuries of history and a whole societal context that make the experience of being a woman entirely different from the experience of being a man. Switching genders on these type of questions adds nothing to the understanding of the question raised in the post, its simply an attempt to mask the problem behind a pretence that 'women are as bad. Male bad behaviour in relationships and wider society is an entirely different, more serious and far reaching issue.

@5128gap

When it comes to serious violence perhaps. But as far as just being a shitty person, name calling, emotional abuse etc - it’s just as serious and far reaching with women as men and it just avoiding responsibility because it’s easier to lay it on men to suggest otherwise

MissHoneysHappyEnding · 05/03/2023 10:50

@TrishM80 imagine if you said the same about rape? Or becoming a victim of a scam?
Why is domestic abuse somehow supposed to be so easy to spot? Or financial abuse? Or emotional abuse. I know many super smart women who have fallen victim to abuse in the context of intimate relationships. It's so easy to be manipulated or to lose track of what's normal. Not to mention societal pressure to procreate and have a family. Plus financial pressure. Plus women just generally being put under more pressure to please others and be reliable.
It's no use blaming individual women when everything is so against us being unable to leave troubled relationships and thrive afterwards.
Honestly a man cheating and running off with OW/OM is met with less judgement than a woman leaving the family home because she is unhappy. Because men are biological, primal beings right? And women are nurturers? The world very much has not moved on from this.
You should hear the judgment of single mums who
Go out
Date
Go on holiday without the kids
Get their nails done
Take annual leave when the kids are at school
Work part time or dont work

Spectre8 · 05/03/2023 10:49

On another thread, some women are saying well if you want to have more money have a partner and its your fault if your still single. Basically marry anyone and put up with shit and you can get that house

This is women telling other women this. No wonder we are in a mess about this

WhatsNewPussyCatty · 05/03/2023 10:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Mine certainly put on an excellent act. At first, everything was perfect between us - for months and months. He was the man of my dreams - my gift from heaven. I now know this was the 'love-bombing' period of our courtship. Then, the early red flags appeared. To me, they seemed to be minor disagreements which we (I thought) overcame easily with discussion and humour. I thought it was natural for a couple to have differing views from time to time, but as long as they were resolved it would continue to be fine between us.

These red flags didn't become proper concerns to me until it was too late, years down the line. After we'd gotten married (which was 2.5 years after we'd met). They got much worse once we had kids together (about 7 years after we married). The mask has truly slipped now.

Now, he's charming AF to everyone outside of our family. Self deprecating, kind, thoughtful, considerate, appreciative, etc. That's hard to swallow when he is unreasonable, argumentative, selfish, bullying oaf to me and, to a lesser extent, to our teenage kids, at home. Not always, but too often. Together, we 'manage' his tantrums. Not ideal, I know.

In the past he was often flirty (overly charming) with other women in front of me. This has stopped now (in front of me at least) but only on my repeated strong insistence.

I now know I'm married to a gaslighting narcissist and that this is typical of how they operate. My kids have the measure of him and his sort too.

Every day I try to plan how I will leave him and always draw a blank. I cannot make it work. And he WILL make sure any divorce I instigate will be as messy and painful as it can possibly get so my exit plan needs to be slick.

Ncgirlseriously · 05/03/2023 10:48

Oh wow now we’re busting out “nice guys finish last” rhetoric. 😂😂😂

SquirrelSoShiny · 05/03/2023 10:46

TrishM80 · 05/03/2023 10:40

Shush, you're not allowed mention that here!

Fact is, a lot of younger women are sexually attracted to arrogant, selfish twats (the "bad boy" to use that hackneyed term) and find the quiet, mild mannered, dependable chap in the corner "boring".

Then are oh so shocked when the arrogant selfish twat they were attracted to in their 20s turns out to be an arrogant selfish twat of a husband!

Imagine if the 'quiet dependable chap in the corner' turned out to be an abusive fuckhead, only smart enough to be covert about it until they had you trapped!

Ikr! Mind blown!

🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️