Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

AIBU to ask for alternatives to toxic old MN

420 replies

FannyBawz · 04/03/2023 16:38

I’ve been here 15 years and just find it all so nasty and toxic a lot of the time. The witty responses have gradually been replaced by snidey bitchiness much of the time, honestly it’s so depressing. People get jumped on all the time for asking for support.

Thats before we get to the way that womens rights are treated plus the whole sex forum fiasco.

and sorry I am fed up with having dildos waved at me every time I sign on.

Nobody seems to give a shit really at MNHQ and they have a like it or lump it mentality to valid concerns.

I know I don’t have to stay here and So does anybody have any recommendations for other forums? I see a new one called FemVox has been set up and it looks promising.

what else is out there?

OP posts:
ranktastic · 04/03/2023 20:14

TBH OP

I think I use MNs slightly different to a lot of people, I go look for people who have the same type of interests or hobbies.

Recently its been pokemon go, its then normally easier to set up our own community on something like discord or reddit.

You do get a smaller number of people, you might not click in which case you are free to leave, not post, you have lost nothing, but its a bit like when it was all fields.

I have had this happen a few times now, where a new community was set up because of an interest and then grew into a good group of friends

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 20:09

Sorry I don’t mean to say it’s all bad…it isn’t otherwise I wouldn’t post here. It’s varied, interesting and often intelligent too. I’ve learned a lot of new things and had my thinking changed from being on mumsnet.

It’s just…it’s just…aaahhh. Maybe I’m a bit rough or whatever but my life certainly hasn’t been as seamless as people on here claim theirs to be.
Not that I’d ever discuss it…I’d only be torn to shreds.

pointythings · 04/03/2023 19:57

I'uve been on MN for 13 years now and I'm not seeing this sink of toxicity. Yes, there are some shitty posters on here - has always been the case. Yes, some of the topics are too robust and could do with being reined in a bit - but not all of them.

If a thread looks hideous, I don't engage. Meanwhile I've had a lot of interesting debates and different points of view, the long running Brexit threads are a source of in depth political analysis that is absolutely lacking in the mainstream media and although Relationships does get it wrong at times, it is also a support of support for women who would otherwise have none.

If you are unhappy on MN by all means leave; other forums are available. But don't generalise that it's all toxic and bad, because that is not true.

SaturdayGiraffe · 04/03/2023 19:51

Screwfix Forum

Thisisthewaywe · 04/03/2023 19:51

It is different, @ilovesooty , but not vastly so. And in any case, weren’t you one of the posters who was arguing quite strongly for pervy PMs from men to be ignored / reported to MN?

MeAndTequila · 04/03/2023 19:47

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 19:39

Netmums is less snobby, competitive and judgemental. You’re actually allowed to be a human on there. You’re allowed to drop the ball, make a mistake, weather a crap decision or get things wrong without a parade of smart arses who have never made wrong move in their lives kicking you while you’re already down and telling you it serves you right.

I suppose it depends what the ‘wrong move’ is. I’ve definitely judged some people’s decisions and make no apology for it. Moving your new partner in with your kids after 3 months or getting a puppy when you work full time and now it’s eating your furniture sk you need to rehome it, I think people should expect to be told they’re a dickhead. 😂

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 19:39

Netmums is less snobby, competitive and judgemental. You’re actually allowed to be a human on there. You’re allowed to drop the ball, make a mistake, weather a crap decision or get things wrong without a parade of smart arses who have never made wrong move in their lives kicking you while you’re already down and telling you it serves you right.

FannyBawz · 04/03/2023 19:37

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 19:25

Netmums is much castigated on here but actually they’re more down to earth and realistic as rule, than the arrogant unfriendly mumsnetters who have never put a foot wrong in their entire perfect lives.

Isn’t it partly because you can’t name change there? So more accountability. In fact you used to have to use your real name as well I think- mine is unusual in this country so that massively put me off

OP posts:
SuperSange · 04/03/2023 19:37

Tattle can be harsh on influencers and people who behave poorly in the public eye, but there's more support on the various off topic threads than Ive seen on here in a long time. It's more like here used to be.

MeAndTequila · 04/03/2023 19:31

LucyLeave · 04/03/2023 19:30

I do agree that Netmums is more real than MN.

In what way? Genuine question. I used to use it when my kids were very young but haven’t looked at it in years. I may have to venture over there. 😬

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 19:31

If I were to epitomise Mumsnet it would be in the phrase, “And you had children with this man, why?”

Could there be a more disdainful, unhelpful, sanctimonious, self-congratulatory response to another woman’s pain than that?
Just belt up you evil fucking creature.

LucyLeave · 04/03/2023 19:30

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 19:25

Netmums is much castigated on here but actually they’re more down to earth and realistic as rule, than the arrogant unfriendly mumsnetters who have never put a foot wrong in their entire perfect lives.

I do agree that Netmums is more real than MN.

pictoosh · 04/03/2023 19:25

Netmums is much castigated on here but actually they’re more down to earth and realistic as rule, than the arrogant unfriendly mumsnetters who have never put a foot wrong in their entire perfect lives.

OhMaria2 · 04/03/2023 19:24

This place is bitchier than flipping 4chan!

MeAndTequila · 04/03/2023 19:23

I’ve been on and off mumsnet for 12 ish years. It does get repetitive but that’s bound to happen. I am starting to get annoyed with how mumsnet deal with certain topics or rather they don’t deal with them.

I think as you get older, you get more disillusioned with people in general though so no surprise that’s happening online too. You wise up to the bullshit and realise a lot of people are toxic, they always were, you get better at recognising the behaviours and less willing to let it go.

Femvox seems good. I haven’t looked at netmums for years. I don’t really like tattle or reddit but have a little look to see what they’re saying about mumsnet. If I think I’ve spotted a troll post that others here seem to be buying into, it’s often being discussed on reddit or tattle.

ilovesooty · 04/03/2023 19:23

Thisisthewaywe · 04/03/2023 18:53

It’s the way it is done, @ilovesooty , and you are no fool. You know full well having a ‘conversation’ with another poster about another poster would be extremely spiteful and snide if done in RL.

Had you said ‘I think you’re actively trying to recruit MNetters’ that would be different. I can’t honestly say I care either way, a different website was made over in the Staffroom based around the old TES forums that was linked to on here. I don’t see this as different tbh.

I think it is a bit different. The alternative to TES was created when the TES comminity site was pulled without warning, not as a site promoted as a direct alternative to here, being advertised on here, which is happening. People have even received unsolicited PMs through Mumsnet inviting them to join, so I think that's indicative of a recruitment campaign going on and using Mumsnet as a vehicle for it.

FannyBawz · 04/03/2023 19:14

BadNomad · 04/03/2023 18:06

Eh? Nothing I said was nasty. People have been advertising that site on other threads.

You and others have literally said that’s what this thread is about. And this sort of nasty nitpicking shite is exactly why it’s toxic. Jesus Christ.

OP posts:
Pixiedust1234 · 04/03/2023 19:12

I've just come from a thread where the op is asking for support but its really hard reading some of the nasty posts. Sometimes this place isn't very nice😟

Ragwort · 04/03/2023 18:59

Maybe my age but I am gravitating towards Gransnet these days!

I agree with a PP, I've also been here over 20 years and the topics get very repetitive... TTC, nor wanting ILs at the birth, unhelpful DHs, SAHM vs WOHM, can't make friends, how much to spend on Christmas presents, children not invited to a wedding ....... etc etc etc. It's a real delight when the occasional original discussion starts up. Smile.

lurchermummy · 04/03/2023 18:59

I honestly don't find it toxic. Mostly interesting and helpful in my experience anyway. I just ignore the occasional bitchy comment.

808Kate1 · 04/03/2023 18:58

Itsnotallblackandwhite · 04/03/2023 18:14

It's okay for observers to do that, but if the OP is stressed and upset its harder for them to ignore sniping and aggressive Qs. It would be very difficult not to take it personally.

Yes this is the thing, these wee nasty fuckers get an absolute thrill jumping onto threads where the OP is at the end of her tether and clearly on the absolute edge. It's hard not to call them out on it, mostly for the sake of the OP who just needs a bit of a supportive shoulder but instead is met with ridicule and spite.

I don't agree with PP's that it's menopausal women either - the worst examples I've seen are women with a young kid(s) under 5 - apparent life experts who are one sanctimonious bawhair away from perfection.

Thisisthewaywe · 04/03/2023 18:53

It’s the way it is done, @ilovesooty , and you are no fool. You know full well having a ‘conversation’ with another poster about another poster would be extremely spiteful and snide if done in RL.

Had you said ‘I think you’re actively trying to recruit MNetters’ that would be different. I can’t honestly say I care either way, a different website was made over in the Staffroom based around the old TES forums that was linked to on here. I don’t see this as different tbh.

Tigertigertigertiger · 04/03/2023 18:49

Reddit

Ihavedogs · 04/03/2023 18:49

StarDolphins · 04/03/2023 18:06

There are 2 groups of Mumsnet users imo…

  1. lovely, helpful ones, normal ones, witty ones, don’t get too offended ones.

  2. The ones that think they’re far superior, are menopausal, don’t get jokes, have to be warned ‘it’s lighthearted’, unhappy in their lives ones.

Gosh…was that really necessary 🤷‍♀️

IMustDoMoreExercise · 04/03/2023 18:47

Itsnotallblackandwhite · 04/03/2023 18:14

It's okay for observers to do that, but if the OP is stressed and upset its harder for them to ignore sniping and aggressive Qs. It would be very difficult not to take it personally.

That's fair enough. I was meaning when you are just reading the thread rather than starting it.

I have never had to start a thread where I was feeling vulnerable, but I can imagine it must be difficult to ignore the idiots.

The problem is that when the OPs react, then it makes it worse. If they were able to ignore them then the trolls wouldn't get any traction.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.