Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

4 day working week … for schools.

212 replies

AutumnIsHere21 · 04/03/2023 14:42

Inspired by another thread discussing the merits of a three day weekend and following on from the results of a study which concluded that a four day working week (for full time pay) had numerous benefits for employers and employees.

I just wondered how people would feel if schools followed suit and were only open Monday-Thursday.

Full disclosure: I’m a teacher so - obviously - would be very much in favour! 😆

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LlynTegid · 11/02/2024 10:49

@MumClaireof2 it's not just schooling that is designed around the presumption of two parents under the same roof with one a SAHP (or working from home). Utility 'appointments' (or time windows in reality), parcel deliveries are other examples.

Four day weeks at school would not work, especially for younger children, imagine them at 430pm on Thursday.

Sherrystrull · 11/02/2024 10:45

I think people forget that teachers are people with their own families and lives as well.

Whitestick · 11/02/2024 10:28

So @MumClaireof2 ive just realised that you expect teachers to have an "admin day" on a Friday - when they have already extended the hours of the school day Mon to Thurs? So they just get to work a lot more under your system? Look I can see you are finding the whole thing of childcare around school a bit shit, and it is, I've had over 10 years of it so I do sympathise - but the answer lies in better wrap around care for those who need it or more flexible workplaces, not longer school days that are not being done for any educational reason.

Parker231 · 11/02/2024 08:50

We’ve never done drop off and collecting as working hours and school hours aren’t the same and when you add in a commute, breakfast and after school clubs are necessary. Same as needing holiday clubs.
Employers aren’t going to change working hours to fit in with parents.

MumClaireof2 · 11/02/2024 07:42

Whitestick · 11/02/2024 00:56

If the children are at school 9-5, and someone works 9-5, wouldn't they still need childcare? School would need to be 8.30 to 5.30 - and then there's need to be special childcare for teachers' children that was open 8-6....

Not really if one parent does drop off and one does pick up. Obviously for people without that luxury a shorter working day may be necessary.

MumClaireof2 · 11/02/2024 07:38

Georgeandzippyzoo · 11/02/2024 00:19

I assume this has been posted because people are happy to consider it for THEIR jobs, so how would they feel if it was extended to others , including teachers?
Obviously many jobs couldn't just do 9-5, 4 days a week, and shifts etc would have to be implemented.

Posted out of sheer frustration as a mummy experiencing school life for the first time and facing the reality that the system doesn’t work for people who need/want/have a career and have kids in public school. Also the reality of wanting to pick your kids up from school but not being able to as you have to be at work and feeling so guilty sending the to a mediocre after school club as you have no other choice.
The hours in school were design for one parent working not 2. Shifts would work too but the reality is most people post pandemic flexi working from home have the luxury of being able to pick up their kids and still work but businesses requiring physically having their staff face the reality of not being able to have them a huge amount of hours or face having staff who are stressed due to the challenges of payments for out of school care. This way parents get a little relief, kids have more structured time in education with hopefully some more innovative physical activity to break up their day and taking away an unproductive 3 hours in school on a Friday. Doing this also allows time for teacher to focus on marking and lesson prep on a Friday which could be from home. Allowing saving on all factors of running the building to take place on a Friday too. Just a suggestion and a dream but wouldn’t have a clue how to get it off the ground. Just looking to see if others feel the same🤗

Whitestick · 11/02/2024 00:56

If the children are at school 9-5, and someone works 9-5, wouldn't they still need childcare? School would need to be 8.30 to 5.30 - and then there's need to be special childcare for teachers' children that was open 8-6....

Georgeandzippyzoo · 11/02/2024 00:19

I assume this has been posted because people are happy to consider it for THEIR jobs, so how would they feel if it was extended to others , including teachers?
Obviously many jobs couldn't just do 9-5, 4 days a week, and shifts etc would have to be implemented.

MumClaireof2 · 11/02/2024 00:02

Whitestick · 10/02/2024 23:42

What would the people running the Friday club do for the other four working days?

They would get easier, better jobs. Trying to find staff for these hours is really hard I’m sure. And I’m sure other businesses world pick up these clubs if needed. Such as football clubs, council run kids clubs, sporting halls etc.

Whitestick · 10/02/2024 23:42

What would the people running the Friday club do for the other four working days?

MumClaireof2 · 10/02/2024 23:28

Parker231 · 10/02/2024 22:53

Can’t see it working with parents having to spend more money on childcare for a full day on Friday as well as still paying for breakfast and after school clubs Mon - Thurs.

It gives the hours needed for a school week. Also if one parent does drop off and one does pick up it works really well. I don’t have a full day Friday of school so currently deal with this so I guess in other areas this may be different but a lot of Scotland is 9-12.30 on a Friday already.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 10/02/2024 23:02

A lot of private primary schools do a half day once a week

Parker231 · 10/02/2024 22:53

Can’t see it working with parents having to spend more money on childcare for a full day on Friday as well as still paying for breakfast and after school clubs Mon - Thurs.

MumClaireof2 · 10/02/2024 22:46

Parker231 · 10/02/2024 22:20

So if Friday is a non school day, where do children go on a Friday? A full day in childcare?

Yes of course if needed. This would be much more available as clubs would thrive on offering this full day instead of trying to find staff to work 1 hour am and 2.45 hours pm in after school clubs.
In our family we currently cover the Friday anyway as my kid goes to school in Edinburgh, they are in 8.45-12.15 which is so pointless. So I am off Friday one week and my husband is off the next Friday but we can work weekend days. A lot of the parents at our school do flexi working from home in a Friday and so they do this around the kids. It’s much easier to manage and much like the schedule we worked to when the kids were both in private nursery.
it is what private school work to as well but they offer this 5 days a week.

MumClaireof2 · 10/02/2024 22:38

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 22:23

Yes its a good idea.
Teachers have the most holidays out of all professions but their hols are not hols but working/preparing hols

I thought a teachers job was holidays galore until I met an ex-teacher

Yes of course if needed. This would be much more available as clubs would thrive on offering this full day instead of trying to find staff to work 1 hour am and 2.45 hours pm in after school clubs.
In our family we currently cover the Friday anyway as my kid goes to school in Edinburgh, they are in 8.45-12.15 which is so pointless. So I am off Friday one week and my husband is off the next Friday but we can work weekend days. A lot of the parents at our school do flexi working from home in a Friday and so they do this around the kids. It’s much easier to manage and much like the schedule we worked to when the kids were both in private nursery.
it is what private school work to as well but they offer this 5 days a week.

MumClaireof2 · 10/02/2024 22:36

.

FUPAgirl · 10/02/2024 22:35

I think secondary school kids could be in 4 days and do some work at home on the 5th day - allowing the teachers paid time to mark and plan. It's completely unacceptable that they are expected to do this in their own time.

I'm not a teacher so haven't a clue - but surely rather than worrying about teaching hours matching the curriculum- the curriculum needs to be designed to fit the teaching hours?

DistinguishedSocialCommenator · 10/02/2024 22:23

Yes its a good idea.
Teachers have the most holidays out of all professions but their hols are not hols but working/preparing hols

I thought a teachers job was holidays galore until I met an ex-teacher

Parker231 · 10/02/2024 22:20

MumClaireof2 · 10/02/2024 21:54

Hi,
I have been thinking a lot about this lately. My son just started school last year and honestly I’m just feeling like the system isn’t fair for working parents, kids or teachers.
Both myself and my husband work full time management jobs and need to to live but also have no flexibility with working hours as we are in each of our premises. We have had to commit to the fact we will spend on average £7000 per year on childcare when our daughter goes to school too (We are more at the moment with her in nursery!) We also have to deal with them going to after school club or miraculously finding a childminder which isn’t something we have managed at the moment as no one wants these hours of after school care.
Ideally I would like to propose a school week of Monday-Thursday 9-5 or 8.30-4.30 and a Friday off. Seems a no brainer to be honest. I am just not sure how teachers hours work etc but surely an admin day on a Friday would be great! This would save the schools on payroll. Electric, food, toilet roll etc to name but a few things. Thus would also allow the working parent to feel less guilty, more relaxed and productive in their jobs and the kids would find it great instead of being passed from pillar to post. Also the added benefit of how much money the working parent would save is phenomenal.
I really want to start a petition on this but I’m not sure where to start.
There are some comments that this is too long a day for children but my kids went from being at private nursery 4 days a week 9-5 having the best time to school on a much shorter day. They never felt this day was too long and I’m sure schools are innovative enough to incorporate out door play or physical skills into the day to have fun with this.
It just seems the school system is still designed for 1 working parent but with mortgages and life as expensive as it is now this cannot be the cases in a huge majority of families.
please do let me know if anyone feels the same, or not 🤗

So if Friday is a non school day, where do children go on a Friday? A full day in childcare?

MumClaireof2 · 10/02/2024 21:54

Hi,
I have been thinking a lot about this lately. My son just started school last year and honestly I’m just feeling like the system isn’t fair for working parents, kids or teachers.
Both myself and my husband work full time management jobs and need to to live but also have no flexibility with working hours as we are in each of our premises. We have had to commit to the fact we will spend on average £7000 per year on childcare when our daughter goes to school too (We are more at the moment with her in nursery!) We also have to deal with them going to after school club or miraculously finding a childminder which isn’t something we have managed at the moment as no one wants these hours of after school care.
Ideally I would like to propose a school week of Monday-Thursday 9-5 or 8.30-4.30 and a Friday off. Seems a no brainer to be honest. I am just not sure how teachers hours work etc but surely an admin day on a Friday would be great! This would save the schools on payroll. Electric, food, toilet roll etc to name but a few things. Thus would also allow the working parent to feel less guilty, more relaxed and productive in their jobs and the kids would find it great instead of being passed from pillar to post. Also the added benefit of how much money the working parent would save is phenomenal.
I really want to start a petition on this but I’m not sure where to start.
There are some comments that this is too long a day for children but my kids went from being at private nursery 4 days a week 9-5 having the best time to school on a much shorter day. They never felt this day was too long and I’m sure schools are innovative enough to incorporate out door play or physical skills into the day to have fun with this.
It just seems the school system is still designed for 1 working parent but with mortgages and life as expensive as it is now this cannot be the cases in a huge majority of families.
please do let me know if anyone feels the same, or not 🤗

BridetoBee · 05/03/2023 11:15

@Chocchops72 these are already less than the hours I work and my children have to go to nursery for those hours. I’d happily teach for those hours but I wouldn’t then do the additional hours needed. Someone on TV said yesterday teachers are working 9-4 at most. My school starts at 8.35 and runs till 3.30, in reality I do 7.30-4.30 every day so I’d much rather teach and be paid for those contact hours.

Botw1 · 05/03/2023 11:08

@AutumnIsHere21

Given that lots of teachers say they work 14 hour days 7 days a week and still can't keep up with the work, how on earth would you be able to take a day off?

AutumnIsHere21 · 05/03/2023 10:58

@Fluffyowl00 Definitely not a conservative researcher. Just a teacher who was curious about others’ opinions.

@MrsMikeDrop I didn’t say I thought schools should only be open four days. I was merely interested in what others thought about the idea. I teach English at a secondary school and (with my teacher head on) echo many of the concerns others have voiced re. curriculum content.

However, I’m also a normal human being and not one of these superhero teachers who is happy to put the needs of everyone else’s children above my own so I’d quite like to work only four days for full pay! I fully appreciate this is as likely as pigs flying but would I be a bit miffed if other sectors implemented the recommendations of the study but the education system didn’t? Yes I would! 😆Professionally, I can see a number of issues; personally, I can see only benefits!

OP posts:
Botw1 · 05/03/2023 10:19

@MarshaBradyo

Yeah, I agree.

I don't really get people who struggle with full time work. (disability aside)

Although I definitely think we need to move away from the Mon to Fri 9-5 model.

Longer days or more flexibility should be introduced

DashboardConfessional · 05/03/2023 10:01

Chocchops72 · 05/03/2023 09:41

In France there is a 'whole industry of term time school-age childcare' and it is very much funded by the taxpayer. In primary (up to age 11) the school day can be extended to run from 07h30 to 18h00. The morning, lunchtime and after-school 'garderies' are run in-school but not by teachers, so the teachers basically leave at the end of the school day and the garderie staff take over. That's not to say this is great for really young children, but it's there.

Outside of school, for parents that prefer their kids to be picked up and brought home, there is an army of nounous (nannys) and childminders all of whom are validated by and subsidised by the state.

Once children are 11-12 and in middle / lower secondary, it's pretty much assumed that they are capable of getting themselves to and from school and able to be home alone after school. So childcare needs fall away after primary.

Generally, unless you want your child to have a specific private nursery or nanny arrangement, childcare costs are not an issue in France, though the logistics can be and tbh not all parents want to be away from their kids all day, every day. But the provision of state-funded childcare is utterly normal here, and seen as an issue of equality: it enables both parents to participate equally in the workforce if that's what they want to do (we all know that the vast bulk of unpaid childcare falls to mothers, not fathers).

Your post reads a bit like I was saying that the lack of the above is a reason why 4 days can't happen (although extended funded childcare wouldn't under the Tories in a million years). I'm just pointing out that termtime childcare in school hours, so not after school or breakfast club, doesn't exist at the moment.

And yes, I agree there's nobody to do it, as a PP said. I said "create" because the existing preschool childminder network wouldn't cope.