Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My brother's problems.

106 replies

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 12:30

I have one older brother. He is two years older than me. He hasn't been particularly nice to me . He has been nasty to me many times. He has had a lot of problems in his life. But so have I. I have had loads of problems. I have had a very hard life. I honestly don't care about him that much. I care about him in general but I have distanced myself from his problems as I need to look after myself.

My problem is my mother. Every time she rings me she talks about my brother's problems. It's always "your poor brother". At the moment one of the problems he has is that he is very overweight and he is upset that he can't get a girlfriend . He can't get a job. He has no friends . He never leaves his house etc I pointed out to her that no one is entitled to have a girlfriend.

Every time she rings me she tells me about 10 problems that my brother is going through. It makes me ill with stress. I've told her that I don't want to hear about his problems and that I have to look after myself. She will say "oh you tell me what I can talk about then".

She's done this to me since I was very young. I remember being away at college at 18, and I couldn't relax and enjoy college life as my mother would ring me every couple of days and talk about all my brothers problems. There was always some massive problem. And I was expected to listen about his problems before my own life.

I feel ill with the stress of it all. I was in a good mood today and then she rang me saying "your brother is so unhappy because of this this and this". And I instantly felt drained. I had planned to go to the swimming pool and after she rang me , I felt too drained of energy to get off the couche.

I feel like I am in a fucking prison. I am going to have to listen to the problems of someone for the rest of my life. I think he is spoilt selfish and has brought alot of his problems on himself. My mother babies him. hearing about his problems all my life totally drains my happiness and drains me of energy. If I tell her not to talk about it she'll say I'm telling her what she can and can't talk about. Shell say "well you tell me what I can talk about then". And nothing gets resolved. What to do? I'm 39 and I've been listening to my brother's problems for most of my fucking life.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fraaahnces · 05/03/2023 02:15

It’s not an Irish thing. I’m Aussie and my family was the same. My mum was furious to discover that you can’t leave adult human beings to your other child in your will - ie force them to take them under their care like she would like to have continued. My brother was 47 when she died and had never worked a day in his life. She had paid his rent and bills - and those of myriad girlfriends - to keep him out of her hair. Ummmm… Hard pass. Can barely afford to pay rent with mine and DH’s wages for our own three kids.

SisterAgatha · 04/03/2023 19:21

^ see how perfect this is 🤣 it’s worked even now, everyone has stopped talking. There is no response ✔️

SisterAgatha · 04/03/2023 16:33

My mum is the same.

no amount of talking to her, polite text messages, defining the problem, offering solutions, asking advice, therapy etc has worked.

what does work every single time without fail?

”oh sorry, I just have to go now mum, I need a poo”

She’ll stop talking and you just don’t call her back.

viques · 04/03/2023 16:31

get a timer , one that makes a noise. When she calls and if you feel like answering then set the timer according to how strong you are feeling that day. So you might think you can cope with two minutes, or five, or even ten on a good day. When the timer rings, you say “ got to go, speak soon” and hang up. The point being you are in control, it is your choice about how much time you give her.

Your brother makes choices about his life, but you are the person who makes choices about yours.

Barbecuebeans · 04/03/2023 16:27

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 14:06

Thanks for all the replies!

Yea I think it's best to either answer the phone less or if I do answer just listen and mildly agree , just grey rock and not really listen and say it is yes it is sad he he is like that.

Because I find if I get into an argument with her about it , it drains my energy more and makes me more upset.

Exactly, OP. It's the arguments and the investment in fixing your mum that's exhausting you.

It's not your job to sort out your brother or your mum.

TheGander · 04/03/2023 16:13

I feel for you. I had the same situation but it was my father. Our mum died when we were in our 20s. My brother has had mental illness since his teens and Dad was in denial . Every year, it was “ your brother must go back to university “ ( he dropped out after year 1) , your brother must get a job, your brother could be a teacher ( he has never held even a basic job down). Completely unrealistic and calling upon me to collude with this unrealistic attitude, at the same time not facing up to the extent of Bro’s mental illness. Then my dad got dementia ( they were living together), brother slid further into mental illness. I had to unpick that situation. It took me nearly two years of weekly counselling to build up my defences and feel I have the freedom and right to my own life, if not happiness. I am now resolved that I will help my brother where I can, but I will not be his carer or sacrifice what I want to do, which might include moving geographically further away from him.

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotOfMen · 04/03/2023 16:06

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 16:01

I'm just looking forward to life being over to be honest. It has just been a hard slog.

I was just talking to a woman here in Ireland and we were saying a lot of us go through the same problems in Ireland:

Abusive father's.
Overbearing mother's.
Sons being seen as more important than daughters .
No love.
A lot of abuse
Nothing to do.
Isolation.

Ireland is not a fun country to live in and never has been. I'm trying to get the strength to move somewhere else

That’s so sad
But I do get completely get most of your list.
so many cousins live in the back of beyond , down the bog as they say’. Have nothing going for them.

I always viewed it as lovely, but we just spent the 6weeks summer holiday and enjoyed the animals and fields etc.

My parents left to get a job and never went back.

I realised the comment about the church was silly. Irish churches don’t do socials as they’re always near the pub!!!

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 16:03

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotOfMen · 04/03/2023 16:01

OP
Mentioning you’re Irish didn’t surprise me.
Going to make a huge sweeping comment here and I dare say I will be completely trashed by MNs for it……
but here goes

We are Irish family ( plastics born in England)
All mothers in our family spoil their sons. It’s all about the boys. Drives me, us ( female cousins ) crazy.
So I’m not surprised you’re in Ireland.

In which case you need to have a strong word with your mum about this. I had to do it with mine, she just said ‘ oh well that’s how it’s always been, boys are more of a worry, “.

Think you’re mums attitude is seeped in potentially age old discriminatory attitudes

I totally agree with you. It's definitely a thing in Ireland. Sons are seen as more important than daughters. Daughters are seen as servants to look after the sons.
Men are seen as more important than women.

It all stems from the Catholic church which had a lot of power in Ireland up until very recently. The Catholic church taught that men were worth ten times more than women. The catholic church really taught that women were worth nothing.

OP posts:
Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 16:01

I'm just looking forward to life being over to be honest. It has just been a hard slog.

I was just talking to a woman here in Ireland and we were saying a lot of us go through the same problems in Ireland:

Abusive father's.
Overbearing mother's.
Sons being seen as more important than daughters .
No love.
A lot of abuse
Nothing to do.
Isolation.

Ireland is not a fun country to live in and never has been. I'm trying to get the strength to move somewhere else

OP posts:
AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotOfMen · 04/03/2023 16:01

OP
Mentioning you’re Irish didn’t surprise me.
Going to make a huge sweeping comment here and I dare say I will be completely trashed by MNs for it……
but here goes

We are Irish family ( plastics born in England)
All mothers in our family spoil their sons. It’s all about the boys. Drives me, us ( female cousins ) crazy.
So I’m not surprised you’re in Ireland.

In which case you need to have a strong word with your mum about this. I had to do it with mine, she just said ‘ oh well that’s how it’s always been, boys are more of a worry, “.

Think you’re mums attitude is seeped in potentially age old discriminatory attitudes

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 15:57

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotOfMen · 04/03/2023 15:54

Does the church have anything.
All small towns in Ireland lead to a church….😁

God no. The last place I'd want to be in is a Catholic church. They don't do social groups here anyway just mass. And maybe the occasional group of bringing elderly women away in religious pilgrimages. Not my cup of tea. I def wouldn't go into a Catholic church for fun

OP posts:
Tabitha1960 · 04/03/2023 15:55

Madamecastafiore · 04/03/2023 14:49

You need to tell her boundaries, say they're non negotiable and you'll put the phone down when she starts crossing those boundaries. Tell her that if the conversation ends then that's her doing. Tell her that your brother is an adult with every opportunity to change his life if he wishes but you're not willing to hear about his self inflicted problems.

Then you have to carry it through. She is then making the decision to forego your love and support.

^ This. Exactly this.

You must get tough, sorry x

AGovernmentOfLawsAndNotOfMen · 04/03/2023 15:54

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 15:35

Social groups to join? I live in a small town in Ireland. There is about one social group a month. There is no art groups. No book clubs. No walking clubs here. I always say you never know true isolation until you've lived in Ireland. I went to England once, and all the social things that people take for granted: book clubs walking groups, we just don't have them at all in rural Ireland. I'm looking to try to move out of Ireland this year.

Does the church have anything.
All small towns in Ireland lead to a church….😁

TheInterceptor · 04/03/2023 15:49

I went VLC last year with my mother (aged 75) for similar reasons. It's been absolutely liberating. I've spent enough of my life on her problems. Free yourself, OP.

LookItsMeAgain · 04/03/2023 15:47

I should add, if she phones you when you don't show up (and she sounds like she would) say:
"Well mum, you told me not to come, so for the sake of my mental well-being, I did just that. You can't keep shifting the goalposts. I'll be back in touch soon. Just no more talking about Brother", and then you get your Sunday back!

Rookie93 · 04/03/2023 15:41

You don't have to answer the phone just because it rings. Give yourself permission to not be available and call if & when you feel you want to speak. Agree its hard when someone you care about is so unaware of their impact on others. I have an older dsister (late 70's) who usually greets me with a complete history of her various medical issues regardless. Normally let her have 5 or 10mins to get it off her chest and either completely change the subject refusing to go back to that or say I've got to go as I was on my way out /just having supper/going out with the dog- when she rang and can't be late. Have realised that they won't change so I've learnt to change how I respond and deal with them. Not speaking for a week or two has helped create some mental distance for me and meant their calls have less impact. At least you would have some control.

LookItsMeAgain · 04/03/2023 15:41

Quitelikeit · 04/03/2023 13:06

Send her a text message

mum, please understand I am happy to hear from you and chat in the phone. However I do not want to talk about my brother every single time you call me. If you continue to call me and talk about him then I do not see the point in continuing our calls. I am not controlling what you can talk about besides this one topic as I find it draining.

thanks

The wording here is polite and gets your point across @Mooshamoo .

LookItsMeAgain · 04/03/2023 15:40

@Mooshamoo - this is in reply to your post at 12:36 -
If she's said that you're not to visit because she keeps telling you about your brother's woes, then don't go.
She's told you not to go, you certainly don't want or need to be her sounding board about your bother's woes, so there's your "Get out of jail free" card! Use it.
If you keep hanging up the phone and you don't go around, one thing is definitely going to happen - you will stop hearing about your brother. That's surely in the 'Win' column right?

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 15:35

Led9519 · 04/03/2023 15:18

I don’t even think the problem is your brother, so… you don’t like him. A lot of people don’t like their siblings. It’s your Mum moaning to you all the time about him!!
I like pp of just agreeing or saying “what do you think you can do to help then?“

I would try and reduce contact as much as possible if it’s stressing you out this much. Is there anything you can do in your day to day life to build more connections with other people? Any social groups to join, walking groups, book clubs, art clubs just to build your social circle a bit if all you feel you have is your Mum? (Not sure if this included friends or not?) but please don’t start moaning all the time to any new friends about your mum moaning about your brother 😂.

Social groups to join? I live in a small town in Ireland. There is about one social group a month. There is no art groups. No book clubs. No walking clubs here. I always say you never know true isolation until you've lived in Ireland. I went to England once, and all the social things that people take for granted: book clubs walking groups, we just don't have them at all in rural Ireland. I'm looking to try to move out of Ireland this year.

OP posts:
EqualFranknessWithYourLadyship · 04/03/2023 15:32

I’m sorry, my mum is like this too. Like you say, she’s the only mum we’ll get…..

your mum is desperate for comfort/reassurance and won’t realise the impact on you.
things that have helped me recently are:
1 only saying positive things (he’s lucky to have you to support him)
2 finding other ways to keep in touch. We exchange wordles each day and that keeps contact up when I can’t take the strain of calls.

all the best

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 15:32

I know . I've heard about him being unhapoy with his weight for about ten years. I don't care anymore. I might have cared for the first couple of months. Now I have learned to see that he is an adult that makes his own choices. And he is not my problem.

OP posts:
Led9519 · 04/03/2023 15:18

I don’t even think the problem is your brother, so… you don’t like him. A lot of people don’t like their siblings. It’s your Mum moaning to you all the time about him!!
I like pp of just agreeing or saying “what do you think you can do to help then?“

I would try and reduce contact as much as possible if it’s stressing you out this much. Is there anything you can do in your day to day life to build more connections with other people? Any social groups to join, walking groups, book clubs, art clubs just to build your social circle a bit if all you feel you have is your Mum? (Not sure if this included friends or not?) but please don’t start moaning all the time to any new friends about your mum moaning about your brother 😂.

InstagramBitchWife · 04/03/2023 15:01

Mooshamoo · 04/03/2023 13:54

I think what tipped me over the edge today was her complaint about him today was so ridiculous. She rang me and said "your poor brother is very unhappy , he told me he is sleeping alot during the afternoon".

My brother is not working. I am working a very stressful 40 hour week. To hear how tired my poor brother was, made me snap at my mother on tbe phone . I said " he is not working , I am working all week! I do not give a shit about how tired he is".

So I snapped at her. And then she said "if you're going to be like that , don't come". So I got blamed for it all again. Ahh.

What happens if you literally interject logically when she's droning on about him?

I'd be tempted to repeat that he needs to lose weight and get a job. Whether he chooses to do this or not is up to him but it has absolutely nothing to do with you. What the fuck does she expect you to do about it?

Boogismyname · 04/03/2023 15:01

Honestly I could have written this too OP. My older brother is exactly the same - spent his 20s and early 30s constantly bemoaning why he didn’t have a girlfriend and how it was all the fault of women. I do genuinely think there’s some incel influence that’s deeply unhealthy.
I agree. Some people do think they have entitlement for a relationship with a woman.

RL79 · 04/03/2023 15:01

YANBU it sounds to me that you should gradually reduce contact or when your asked what should she talk about find something to say you are interested in. Even just not answer some days no harm no foul.
I also think you should get some help for you to gain strength to help you. He will always be the favourite and it is clear she doesn’t want to help you. The only person you can rely on is you but your friends and other family should help