Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if Civil Service are really enforcing the hybrid work policy to the letter?

219 replies

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 10:48

I hope some CIvil Service employees can help me here. I about to leave a job for a position in the civil service. My current job is 90% remote and I love the work and my team but it's s big US corporation and the holiday and time off is quite restricted compared to the civil service which I think offers s better work life balance, flexitime more annual leave etc

The civil service Job ad says their policy is 2 days in office and 3 days work from home. Problem is I live 55 miles from office and nearby parking is £25-£30 a day and there's no civil service discount becasue there's so much demand for it that there's a waiting list. I did not know that when I accepted Job and now this adds £50-60 per week to my commute bill., as well as about £40 per week on fuel.

Are there any CS employees out there who can advise me how much flexibility there is in individual departments on the hybrid policy. Do they take in to account individual Circs such as how far away people live and the likely cost to them of parking etc or is it a rigid rule set for all regardless of circs?

Am quite worried about this and am thinking of now reversing my resignation in my current job. I really really wanted this cs job and if they can allow me to work a bit less in office then I don't mind a bit of extra expense but can't justify £200-£240 per month just for parking and the same amount again for fuel.

OP posts:
CheesyBeanos · 04/03/2023 13:23

In my office we're supposed to be in a minimum of two days a week and it isn't currently monitored.

Some of my colleagues will do anything they can to get out of coming into the office, which is harming their reputation with some seniors due to some of the ways they go about achieving this.

And some of my colleagues would prefer to be in the office all the time (and are), due to working much more effectively this way - for a variety of reasons.

The resentment and divide between these groups is growing, and generally speaking, the output and standards of a lot of our wider team's work has decreased massively since hybrid working. Not everyone can see or is prepared to acknowledge this but it has soured the working environment.

I appreciate that won't be the situation throughout CS departments/teams, but it is in mine, in my specific location.

Out of interest OP, does the office you will be employed to work in attract any locational allowances/retention payments? That also makes a difference to how much flexibility you might have.

Idratherbepaddleboarding · 04/03/2023 13:19

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

BleepBipBoop · 04/03/2023 13:18

lieselotte · 04/03/2023 11:33

Blimey, that does sound strict. What if he was working on the Monday and on leave Tues to Fri - would they expect him to be in the office on the Monday?

There’s plenty of jobs I’d like to apply for but they don’t work for my individual circumstances and so I don’t apply for them but the OP didn't know about the expensive parking until after she'd applied. Although I've got to say I wouldn't apply for a job 55 miles away regardless, that is just too far unless you really only have go in once a month or something.

As an aside, 3 days a week in the office is silly, because 3 days rail travel costs the same as a 5 day a week season ticket. If you work where people commute by train, it needs to be 2 days office/3 days remote. If people drive it's obviously different

The cost of a 3-day vs 5-day railcard is not remotely relevant to an employer when setting their days in the office. Also cost is far from the only reason some people like to WFH, and the train is usually not the only cost of going into the office. Plenty of us would rather pay for a 5-day railcard, if that’s what’s necessary, and come in for 3 days then pay for a 5-day railcard and come in 5 days. It doesn’t “need” to be anything.

KittyDee · 04/03/2023 13:06

It varies a lot, depending on dept. But if it says 2 days on the advert that is what is expected usually as minimum. For example my dept is 3 days, 2 days as per your advert is more typical.

However a couple if caveats and worth talking to your potential boss about

It does depend on what office you are based at. For example in my dept the smaller regional offices are less strict than the London office.

It also often possible to negotiate a home working contract but you may get a lower salary.

ItisSailingTime · 04/03/2023 13:06

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 04/03/2023 11:05

And yes they can fire you for not doing the 2 days per week in the office. It would be the same as any other requirement of the role that you are unable to meet. The civil service is really good at providing flexible working opportunities but I would really counsel you not to take a role which explicitly says 2 days per week if you know now you can’t do that

@Lilifer I have to agree with this. You would quickly be subject to disciplinary proceedings, and you definitely would not pass probabtion. It's the same as any other job requirement, and if you're unable to fill it, the job is unfortunately unsuitable for you, which it sounds as if this is.

To make it fair on everyone, there is little leniency where attendance requirements are set- even with health conditions and other extreme personal circumstances.

Many Civil Servants pay significantly higher living costs to be close to their offices and reduce commutes (often in city/town centres), so higher commute costs are unfortunately the trade off for those who live further afield.

Notaclu · 04/03/2023 13:05

Hi it depends on the department - some are enforcing with weekly tracker sheets etc; others are expecting much more than 2 days pew; others still (or some teams at least) are not following this policy at all it seems.

Anotheanon · 04/03/2023 13:00

I am in a department that promised hybrid working and then decided one Wednesday that there would be no home working from the following week. Everyone had to come straight back in.
I have a friend that works in a different area in the same department. She works from one of the hubs. None of the rest of her team do. So when she is in the office she is on her own in a room full of strangers doing a completely different job. She still has to go in three times each week. It makes no sense whatsoever.

Ted27 · 04/03/2023 12:58

@LookingOldTheseDays

My previous team was cameras on from day 1 working from home for all meetings.
No cameras is very hard work, people really should be over it by now.

AltheaVestr1t · 04/03/2023 12:56

It totally depends on the culture of the team you are in. As does the frequency of travel to other sites, often involving an overnight trip.

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 12:54

they never put cameras on

This is a pet hate of mine, for the same reasons as you. This is the first place I've worked where people think it's OK to routinely do meetings with cameras off.

I get it in a big conference call with dozens of attendees, but if it's a 3 person meeting, let's actually see each other!

Hollyhead · 04/03/2023 12:54

Have you looked at websites where you rent someone’s drive for parking? It’s not clear where you’re travelling to but generally it’s £10 per day in major cities - even London. Or is there a better rain service you could get on to nearby etc?

Ted27 · 04/03/2023 12:52

Just to.add another perspective.
I've worked in ALBs and a govt dept for over 30 years so I have a bit of experience!
In September I joined a well established team, located over 5 offices so even when in the office we are rarely in the same one.
I have found it incredibly difficult to 'break into' the team, they never put cameras on, I'm a bit deaf in one ear so do lip read a fair bit so am hindered in teams meetings, you don't get the body language or pick up on moods. After 5 months I'm very much an outsider.
I gave feedback to my line manager about the cameras, we had one meeting with them on, with everyone moaning about having to do their hair.
I'm at the end of my career and will be leaving in May.
I feel really sorry for the youngsters starting out trying to work in this environment

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 12:50

The only downside is that travel to London (e.g. for tribunals) from where I live involves a pre-6am train, which is brutal.

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 12:49

@LookingOldTheseDays ah yes that too!

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 12:47

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 12:46

@LookingOldTheseDays good thing about travel is it is expensed (and counts towards your office attendance) I think I've spent more time in our sister offices than I have my own for that reason 😂

And I'm not allowed to work on the train (due to the nature of what I do) so I get the flexitime credit while reading a book!

ItisSailingTime · 04/03/2023 12:47

@Lilifer I'm a Civil Servant in a central government dept and worked on writing our dept's hybrid working policy, as part of this work I know a lot about the approaches of other departments. I also have friends who work in different CS departments so I know a lot about this.

My dept is one of the most flexible and operates on a principle-based approach rather than needing to be in ×-many days per week (likely because we don't have a minister, so far less pressure). So apart from some specialist roles that require far more attendance, most go in to the office for certain meetings.

However, if your department has told you it's 2 days+ a week office attendance, this will highly likely be strictly enforced. Some departments even monitor IP addresses to make sure people are logged on in the office enough (I guess to prevent line managers from allowing people to secretly stay at home).

A close friend of mine suffers from anxiety and MH and during a particularly bad period about a year ago, his doctor gave him a fit note- not to sign him off work, but to work from home. The department rejected it flat out and he had to get signed off completey in order to avoid office attendance.

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 12:46

Also (assuming it is the SOLS within HMRC), it's worth noting that SOLS are one of the few directorates that aren't enforcing 3 days a week in the office, and are currently sticking to only 2. If/when they change those arrangements they'd likely be increasing it to be consistent with the rest of the department, not decreasing it.

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 12:46

@LookingOldTheseDays good thing about travel is it is expensed (and counts towards your office attendance) I think I've spent more time in our sister offices than I have my own for that reason 😂

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 12:45

@Hawse sounds similar to mine, every now and then it becomes the hot topic again and it's out in all the comms, then it dies off with no change.

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 12:44

The OP has said the job is in SOLS, which to my knowledge is a dept within HMRC (but there could also be SOLS depts elsewhere?). I work closely with some SOLS people, and they seem to be really interesting roles - but office time will be expected. Flexitime will be available up to grade 6, which is a massive perk.

If it is SOLS within HMRC, you'll also spend time at tribunals etc, so there will be a reasonable amount of travel expected. It's not excessive though.

Hawse · 04/03/2023 12:41

HMRC, DBT (formally DIT), and looking at you DFE... have always had a bit of a reputation on WFH. I could barely wfh 1 day a week precovid at HMRC when in my 3rd trimester. HMRC is now back to strictly enforcing their guidelines on flexi-work. Thankfully have moved on and my current core department has actually given up on the weekly monitoring email, and seems to have quietly given up trying to force us all back.

FlyerHere · 04/03/2023 12:41

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 11:21

The CS is also very subject to political pressure, in a way that private businesses aren't. If the government decides that it wants all Civil servants in the office 3 days a week, pressure will be applied to make that happe. This will be beyond your control, and beyond your manager's control.

So so true!

pennylanestrawberries · 04/03/2023 12:39

There are some government departments that do advertise 100% home working jobs, maybe withdraw from this one and apply for one of those instead.

I have a couple of friends working for HMRC and their office attendance is very strictly monitored but I’ve heard it varies a lot across departments.

Soontobe60 · 04/03/2023 12:37

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 12:26

I would he delighted if I could do that.

To other poster who said why would I apply etc if I didn't think I could do it, can I just say that if I have to do it then obviously I will, and if I find it becomes to difficult or costly due to fuel and parking then I shall reassess. I know from anecdotal experience and from reading on here that there is a huge amount of variation in the enforcing or not of 2/3 days in office and I'm just asking on here to get more answers. My boss to be has said to me that privately she does not insist on it just for the sake of it as she doesn't see the value in making someone spend 3 hours in a car just to be in the office but that she can vary that requirement based on individual circs and that is why so far I have decided to try the job and see how I get on.

Fair enough - but did you know that before you applied?

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 12:37

OP do you live in an area with other offices/departments? This could be a good foot in the door, see what you can manage in the meantime, but then transfer to a more flexible department if that is an option.