Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if Civil Service are really enforcing the hybrid work policy to the letter?

219 replies

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 10:48

I hope some CIvil Service employees can help me here. I about to leave a job for a position in the civil service. My current job is 90% remote and I love the work and my team but it's s big US corporation and the holiday and time off is quite restricted compared to the civil service which I think offers s better work life balance, flexitime more annual leave etc

The civil service Job ad says their policy is 2 days in office and 3 days work from home. Problem is I live 55 miles from office and nearby parking is £25-£30 a day and there's no civil service discount becasue there's so much demand for it that there's a waiting list. I did not know that when I accepted Job and now this adds £50-60 per week to my commute bill., as well as about £40 per week on fuel.

Are there any CS employees out there who can advise me how much flexibility there is in individual departments on the hybrid policy. Do they take in to account individual Circs such as how far away people live and the likely cost to them of parking etc or is it a rigid rule set for all regardless of circs?

Am quite worried about this and am thinking of now reversing my resignation in my current job. I really really wanted this cs job and if they can allow me to work a bit less in office then I don't mind a bit of extra expense but can't justify £200-£240 per month just for parking and the same amount again for fuel.

OP posts:
Cosmos123 · 04/03/2023 16:20

They will refer to the contract so it worth bearing this mind.

Consider the cost of 2 days in the office all the time and see 8f this works for you.

We have had individuals apply for positions and live 300 miles away. The individuals have remote working contracts.

It is all based on what is in the contract.

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 16:20

@LookingOldTheseDays yes but it sounds like she's going to go back and have a franker conversation this time to explicitly confirm or rule out if one day a week is plausible. It would be silly to throw away a good opportunity without clarifying fully first.

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 16:16

The OP has already had this conversation with the manager though...

she said they can be a bit flexible say for eg in winter because I would have so far to travel etc so that is positive but I suppose I am hoping that long term once I am out of probation and settled in the job I would have more flexibility myself to have less days in some weeks if needed

Her manager has essentially said that in unusual circumstances (bad winter weather) there is some flexibility, but the OP is hoping that means she can do fewer days on a regular basis if she wants.

The OP can have the conversation again, but I think she already has her answer.

Also, if I'm right and it is HMRC, it will definitely be enforced. The pay and contract reform package was a big area of debate/dispute within the organisation, and they are going to a fair bit of effort to ensure the outcomes are applied consistently. That's good when it comes to being able to work flexitime etc., but the office days are part of the trade-off.

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 16:09

@ItisSailingTime absolutely, it is informal so you have to take a risk, it hasn't backfired for me thus far but my expectations are managed. In terms of how they are perceived, that is between the manager and the employee, so long as the conversation has been had prior to them starting, you can't really fault the new employee for their working arrangements if it was discussed prior to their first day, but the OP is intending on speaking to the manager again so it is moot, she's not trying to get in and then stomp her feet.

LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 16:05

However I wouldn't be flexible with someone knew the office location prior to accepting the role, its not fair on the rest of the team who most likely will be will also be paying commuting costs 2 days a week.

This is the crux of it. In the private sector it is fully expected that different employees will have different pay and benefits packages depending on how keen the company is to retain them or how good they are at negotiating. In the public sector this isn't the case and making exceptions for one person isn’t generally considered acceptable.

The home workers in my team fall into 2 categories. They either have health issues (disability, CEV), or they previously worked at an office a long way away, and that office has closed down (so it was a choice between redundancy or offering them home working). New employees who apply for a job at the current location are all treated the same on the basis that they knew the location and T&Cs when they applied .

ItisSailingTime · 04/03/2023 16:00

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 14:15

@Nowfeeltheneedtopost equally I'm worried the OP will take all the other posts literally and walk away from the job without discussing with the manager first, being a senior civil servant doesn't mean you know more than anyone else here, I'm not denying it's not a risk because any flexibility is likely to be informal and not guaranteed, but honestly I do not recognise most of the posts here, I've worked across 3 organisations and have not been subjected to the strictness described here. It might be moot if OP is HMRC which does seem to be one of the stricter organisations, but honestly there are areas operating in the CS very flexibly. I know people living hundreds of miles from their pinned location, I line manage one!

I do agree with this, but as @Nowfeeltheneedtopost and I have highlighted, any verbal agreement with the immediate line manager would be very flimsy and very vulnerable to pressure from above.

And although the Civil Service is flexible, it's still an employer and there are other employees to consider. As PPs have pointed out, I can imagine it would be frowned upon if OP were to take a position, knowing the steer is 2 days per week and that this is unsuitable for her and expecting special measures. And that's putting it lightly.

Mississippi6 · 04/03/2023 15:59

fluffi · 04/03/2023 15:53

@Lilifer I'd be wary of relying too much on the flexibility and kindness of your potential future manager. If they get the word from "up high" to strictly enforce the 2 days a week in the office, then their hands will be tied.

Also what happens when you boss leaves or moves into a different role / gets promoted / leaves? A future boss may not be as flexible, especially if your reasons are commuting cost and distance from the office which was known when accepting the job.

As a manager, if my team had a 2 day a week in officee policy, I'd try to exercise flexibility if someone working in my team developed a medical condition that would benefit from more WFH or was temporarily dealing with a difficult unexpected situation at home or bad weather / transport strikes. However I wouldn't be flexible with someone knew the office location prior to accepting the role, its not fair on the rest of the team who most likely will be will also be paying commuting costs 2 days a week.

I think you need to find a cheaper and practical solution to getting to the office 2 days a week rather than relying on your current manager.

And as others have said already, the reequirement to work in the office is more likely to go up over time than reduce.

Exactly!! It’s constantly changing, we were required to come 1 day a week to the office, then soon after 2 days a week and now 3 days a week. It is more likely that the days required in the office will increase, not decrease. Also, I believe that the policy is that newcomers (under 12 months within the organisation) don’t get to request flex working.

fluffi · 04/03/2023 15:53

@Lilifer I'd be wary of relying too much on the flexibility and kindness of your potential future manager. If they get the word from "up high" to strictly enforce the 2 days a week in the office, then their hands will be tied.

Also what happens when you boss leaves or moves into a different role / gets promoted / leaves? A future boss may not be as flexible, especially if your reasons are commuting cost and distance from the office which was known when accepting the job.

As a manager, if my team had a 2 day a week in officee policy, I'd try to exercise flexibility if someone working in my team developed a medical condition that would benefit from more WFH or was temporarily dealing with a difficult unexpected situation at home or bad weather / transport strikes. However I wouldn't be flexible with someone knew the office location prior to accepting the role, its not fair on the rest of the team who most likely will be will also be paying commuting costs 2 days a week.

I think you need to find a cheaper and practical solution to getting to the office 2 days a week rather than relying on your current manager.

And as others have said already, the reequirement to work in the office is more likely to go up over time than reduce.

ItisSailingTime · 04/03/2023 15:50

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 04/03/2023 14:10

Thank you. I’m really worried the OP is only reading the posts which suggest there will be the flexibility she wants. I’m a senior civil servant and honestly know what I’m talking about here. I am also a great supporter of flexible working but it doesn’t mean everyone gets to do just what they want.

I'm totally on the same page as you @Nowfeeltheneedtopost. I'm only SEO but with the work I've done on our hybrid working policy I'm familiar with the approach of many different departments, and from my social network (lots of CSs across various departments) I can see how those approaches work in practice.

I'm also a huge advocate of flexible working and the benefits it brings, but the business still has to come first and it requires balance and consideration from everyone. If everyone was given special dispensation because they live far from the office, the policy would be pointless.

For our legal roles, even agreement for part time or condensed hours for new starters has to go to senior Area Business Managers, well above LMs hands. I would worry in OP's case that any verbal arrangement with the new LM could quickly go up in smoke at the click of a minister's fingers, or a change in manager.

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 15:32

@jmh740 that's awful, could they not try to redeploy him?

ChickenBurgers · 04/03/2023 15:32

My mum is HMRC, I’m Probation service.

probation requires 80% of your working week to be in the office. This seems to be better followed by some than others and how strict it is depends on your line manager. My line manager is a gem and whilst I do all 3 of my working days in the office the majority of the time through choice, if I needed to wfh for a week for family reasons for example she wouldn’t bat an eyelid. But if I did it regularly I would be pulled up on it rightly so.

My mum is an AO, if she can’t go in on one of her office days she has to swap for another day that week. Her team were very lax on this for a long time but have tightened up in recent months as some people took the piss.

Honestly though, the reasons you’ve given aren’t enough to justify going against their policy and I wouldn’t expect them to. You’ve chosen to take a job 55 miles away.

jmh740 · 04/03/2023 15:31

Unfortunately my oh has been pushed out of his Cs job they sent him to work from home at the start of the pandemic. They now want him back in the office full time his condition has deteriorated and his consultant said he should be working from home they said he has a customer facing role there's no other roles in the service he could wfh so has been forced to take medical retirement at 54 its been 8 months without pay while they sort out his pension payments and there doesn't seem to be end in sight they have not been flexible at all its a nightmare.

GreenAllOver · 04/03/2023 15:31

OP It may also be worth asking if it has to be that office. I know people working in offices outside the official hubs, but which are much closer to their homes and/or have free parking. It fits the letter of the agreement, in that they’re physically in the office, though I think some departments do require specific hub offices. But in a department with a lot of local offices, you may well find one closer to home.

Whether there’s any point, other than making the ‘office day stats’ look better, in working in a random office with no-one in your team is a whole other question…

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 15:27

Thank you Nowfeeltheneedtopost 🥰

OP posts:
Lilifer · 04/03/2023 15:26

sosickofthisshit · 04/03/2023 15:17

I'm CS, and we are supposed to be in the office 1 day a week, but it's not enforced or monitored. Looking at other replies though, it seems to vary wildly by department, with some being much more lax than others.

It really does seem quite varied!

OP posts:
Lilifer · 04/03/2023 15:26

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 15:09

Good luck OP, I hope it all works out!

Thank you 🙏 🥰

OP posts:
sosickofthisshit · 04/03/2023 15:17

I'm CS, and we are supposed to be in the office 1 day a week, but it's not enforced or monitored. Looking at other replies though, it seems to vary wildly by department, with some being much more lax than others.

kljk78 · 04/03/2023 15:09

Good luck OP, I hope it all works out!

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 04/03/2023 15:08

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 15:06

Some very useful info here, I'll definitely look into the parking in driveway thing and also see if I can get in to the car park then mins away from new workplace.

I'll contact new boss and have another discussion re expectations of this as from reading all these responses it's possible it's a lot stricter than I anticipated but will only know for sure once I have that chat.

Thanks all for responding 🙏

Best of luck OP

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 15:06

Some very useful info here, I'll definitely look into the parking in driveway thing and also see if I can get in to the car park then mins away from new workplace.

I'll contact new boss and have another discussion re expectations of this as from reading all these responses it's possible it's a lot stricter than I anticipated but will only know for sure once I have that chat.

Thanks all for responding 🙏

OP posts:
Lilifer · 04/03/2023 14:50

Yes I was confused by that too but asked at interview and they said it was two days a week in office.

OP posts:
LookingOldTheseDays · 04/03/2023 14:47

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 04/03/2023 14:42

im not sure if you have mis-typed but your quote from the job ad of “the opportunity to work from home 2 days per week” suggests 3 days per week in office? Your OP suggested an expectation of 2 days in the office. Either way, the best advice is obviously to discuss with the hiring manager.

That quote is from a press release by HMRC after they agreed contract changes with the Union (link to Google search below)

Most HMRC directorates are required to work 3 days a week in the office, but a couple of smaller directorates (including SOLS) only expect 2 days a week in the office. They are outliers within HMRC though.

www.google.com/search?q=%22Where+the+role+is+suitable%2C+employees+will+have+the+opportunity+%28though+not+a+contractual+entitlement%29+to+work+from+home+for+two+days+per+week%2C+or+more+where+the+business+agrees%22&client=ms-android-samsung-ss&ei=wFkDZLaHJtjtgAa0r6uoAg&oq=%22Where+the+role+is+suitable%2C+employees+will+have+the+opportunity+%28though+not+a+contractual+entitlement%29+to+work+from+home+for+two+days+per+week%2C+or+more+where+the+business+agrees%22&gs_lcp=ChNtb2JpbGUtZ3dzLXdpei1zZXJwEANKBAhBGABQ3AtY3AtgsxBoAHAAeACAAQCIAQCSAQCYAQCgAQHAAQE&sclient=mobile-gws-wiz-serp

mrsbyers · 04/03/2023 14:47

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 14:31

I won't make any decisions till speaking again with manager-to-be, she's very approachable and I'm sure she will clarify in what circs they can apply flexibility. I wouldn't pull out of job unless I really feel it's going to be too much.

To the other poster who criticised me for not "bothering" to research parking etc properly I worked in CS last year in a central office ten mins from the one I'm about to start in and that was a private owned car park which civil service employees had a substantial discount for so I presumed a similar arrangement here. I got that wrong. But it must be great to be as perfect as you are. 😊

enquire about parking at the office ten mins away ?

Nowfeeltheneedtopost · 04/03/2023 14:42

Lilifer · 04/03/2023 14:25

Ok it looks like I either need to have another convo with my manager-to-be and possibly consider withdrawing from this Job if the last few posts are anything to go by, and I do appreciate all the candid and informative responses to this.

The job advert stated "Where the role is suitable, employees will have the opportunity (though not a contractual entitlement) to work from home for two days per week, or more where the business agrees" this is why I thought there would be flexibility if the business/manager agrees it , that's what I took from that employment term.

im not sure if you have mis-typed but your quote from the job ad of “the opportunity to work from home 2 days per week” suggests 3 days per week in office? Your OP suggested an expectation of 2 days in the office. Either way, the best advice is obviously to discuss with the hiring manager.

Mississippi6 · 04/03/2023 14:40

It is strictly reinforced and we have to be 3 days a week in the office.

Swipe left for the next trending thread