Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we shouldn’t leave kids unsupervised while in bed

261 replies

Namechange12908 · 04/03/2023 09:13

…early in the morning. At what age would you do this? DC are 7 and 4 and will happily watch TV/play after breakfast. Kids wake up quite early (6-7ish), and at a weekend DH an I take turns at lie in, the other gets up with the kids. If it’s DH's turn to get up he will usually happily come back to bed for an hour after making them breakfast. He says he will hear if they start fighting or they come find him if they need anything. I would love to do the same but I don’t feel comfortable leaving them unsupervised.IABU?

OP posts:
Dinkleberg · 05/03/2023 19:40

My DD is 4 and sometimes on weekends, if baby DS is still asleep, I will get her breakfast and then doze on the sofa whilst she potters around the living room.

Strawberrydelight78 · 05/03/2023 19:39

I think that's ok as long as they can be trusted not to leave the house or climb to up on the kitchen cupboards to get something. But your DH has sorted they're breakfast. Mine have special needs and siezures. So have never been able to leave them unsupervised.

Thisisthewaywe · 05/03/2023 19:35

Go on then, what’s the difference?

If it isn’t harmful to leave very young children unsupervised for hours, then why is it a problem if someone wants to get off their head? The kids are fine, and it’s good for their independence.

I have come across this a lot, often it isn’t drug addiction but depression or illness meaning the parent isn’t getting up and engaging with them, and children are getting themselves up and sorting themselves out. According to this thread, that’s really good parenting, isn’t it?

Atsocta · 05/03/2023 19:35

Don’t agree, the OP must have some concerns or wouldn’t have asked!
yes anyone can have an accident, and yes it’s fine until perhaps something happens, then they would have wished they had entrusted the little ones care to a 7 year old .. better safe than sorry comes to mind …

Jooliusreezer · 05/03/2023 19:33

but is there really a massive drastic difference in a heroin addict who leaves the kids unsupervised to get their own breakfast for two hours and one who is asleep

Ding ding, we have a winner. The most Mumsnet thing ever written goes to…

Vynalbob · 05/03/2023 19:31

Ours always amused themselves in their own room....never asked...no reason to. I would say depends on the kids, how childproof (gas appliances/big dog etc) & sibling dynamic.
Know people who do it with no problems but also have heard under 6s :trying to start the car: wandering to corner shop for sweets my favourite (old one) posting a jam sandwich in a video recorder.

Plaidparty · 05/03/2023 19:31

concertgoer · 05/03/2023 16:04

My children were left alone from probably 2&4. In as much as I’d get up and make their warm milk, change any nappies, plonk them with toys/tv/both and go back to bed for half an hour.
I knew they were in safe surroundings, could hear them and at that age I wouldn’t go back to sleep.

A 2year old left alone with a 4year old?

I wouldn’t leave a 4 year old alone but there is no way I’d leave a 2 year old alone at all.

Are people really doing this? The risks are insane.

Thisisthewaywe · 05/03/2023 19:24

It’s not so much about what’s going to happen, although accidents are a possibility.

But speaking very generally, I do think kids need supervision, even if that’s only keeping a cursory eye on them as they watch CBeebies.

I am definitely not talking about any parents here, but these parents do exist, where they aren’t available at all, they are in bed, depressed, or on drugs, or drunk, and after a while kids do give up and just get on with things themselves. And I know that will elicit defensive replies and probably mocking ones too, but is there really a massive drastic difference in a heroin addict who leaves the kids unsupervised to get their own breakfast for two hours and one who is asleep? It’s definitely the lower end, but it is a bit borderline. And IMO, four and seven is a bit too young.

Sarain · 05/03/2023 19:14

We've always done this once they were potty trained and nearly school age. I'd have no problem with a 4 and 7 year old having cereal and watching tv.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 19:13

Theelephantinthecastle · 05/03/2023 19:10

I just don't really get what the benefit of doing this in bed over the sofa is? The risks of them doing something silly or unsafe are clearly much higher.

If mine are up at 6, I often let them watch TV while I slump on the sofa with a coffee for a bit. I am not necessarily doing improving activities but they're not alone.

7 feels perfectly civilised to me, if you're in bed at 11pm you've had 8 hours, I don't particularly need more and am happy to crack on and play and don't find it miserable at all

I mean, I can think of several reasons I'd rather stay in bed, lol.

Beds are warmer and more comfortable, for starters. If you lay on the sofa, you're automatically going to have DC clambering on you, or pestering you for food/drink/to play, whereas if you occupy them with the TV and go elsewhere, you stand a chance of getting 10 minutes of peace and quiet.

I don't think dozing on the sofa is necessarily any safer than dozing in bed either - you still have your eyes closed/risk nodding off and you're not fully engaged or supervising either.

33goingon64 · 05/03/2023 19:10

DH and I only have sex on weekend mornings when the DC are downstairs. Can't remember what age that started but definitely before 4 and 7! What do you think is going to happen?

Theelephantinthecastle · 05/03/2023 19:10

buzzy06 · 05/03/2023 18:47

Yes, I remember the same thread. And the parents I know IRL do it for hours. Which makes sense in a way - I find it a bit peculiar to do it for 30 mins to an hour and not fully go back to sleep as a few people on this thread have said, at that point why not just get out of bed? I am not so desperate for 30 mins of dozing.

Need to time to adjust. I'm not being woken up at 7am on a weekend and immediately doing puzzles or doing potato art, I mean seriously? That's just miserable AF.

I wouldn't really go back to sleep (as I know it's only a matter of time before the DC comes back asking for something) but I lie in bed for a while and check the news, social media, Mumsnet, texts, emails whatever before I summon the energy to go next door.

I just don't really get what the benefit of doing this in bed over the sofa is? The risks of them doing something silly or unsafe are clearly much higher.

If mine are up at 6, I often let them watch TV while I slump on the sofa with a coffee for a bit. I am not necessarily doing improving activities but they're not alone.

7 feels perfectly civilised to me, if you're in bed at 11pm you've had 8 hours, I don't particularly need more and am happy to crack on and play and don't find it miserable at all

CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 05/03/2023 19:09

Our kids are 7 and very nearly 4….. just recently we’ve started letting them play together in the morning while we have a bit of a lie in.

we’re awake, having a coffee in bed while reading or watching the tv etc. can hear them playing and can hear if we need to intervene…. There’s usually a couple of arguments that need sorting.

it’s only very recently that we’ve done this as I didn’t trust them not to do something daft. DH is more anxious about it than I am.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 19:09

Atsocta · 05/03/2023 19:04

Depends how sensible the 7 year old is, would the little one be safe being supervised by the 7 year old etc, sure they should be safe, but kids are unpredictable, personally I would be hesitant. Just in case
mind I used to work as a casualty nurse and saw first hand just how kiddies do silly things …

I gave myself my worst injury aged 11 with my mum (a nurse) sat five metres away, watching me the entire time.

I suppose my point is, how far do you take constant supervision? Single/SAH parents will often have no choice but to leave their DC unattended for short periods while they cook, or shower, or pop to the toilet, or answer the door. I don't see why this is any different (in terms of safety, anyway).

Forgottenpeeves · 05/03/2023 19:06

I couldn't do it- mine are a similar age and the thought of them accidentally choking downstairs whilst I was asleep. Mine have a light breakfast snack like a muffin or fruit and watch iPads in bed whilst we doze (they snuggle with us). Then we get up and have a proper breakfast.

concertgoer · 05/03/2023 19:05

Not does … DID …. now both are highly capable teens ! & have never been injured watching tv on an early Saturday morning! 😂

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 19:05

Theelephantinthecastle · 05/03/2023 19:02

I was replying to @concertgoer who does this with their 2 year old

Ah, I didn't realise - my apologies.

Atsocta · 05/03/2023 19:04

Depends how sensible the 7 year old is, would the little one be safe being supervised by the 7 year old etc, sure they should be safe, but kids are unpredictable, personally I would be hesitant. Just in case
mind I used to work as a casualty nurse and saw first hand just how kiddies do silly things …

mamabear715 · 05/03/2023 19:04

My twins, when they were about 3 yrs old, were at their Dad's & got up on their own.. & found a tin of paint..
I had to try & keep a straight face when he phoned me & said he'd have to bring them back straight away as him & the Other Woman had to clean it all up.. they'd been through the entire house..
Nothing to do with OP's post really, I just remembered & thought I'd share the hilarity.. ;-)

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 19:04

Thisisthewaywe · 05/03/2023 18:37

See to me an hour is a long time. It’s age dependent, of course! I’m not claiming it is child abuse for a ten year old to be up for that time.

I honestly don’t want to sound precious and sniffy, but I do think a huge part of parenting is being there. I mean, there is no reason a child can’t eat dinner alone while their parents work or watch TV, but I think most of us would say it’s a pretty lonely and sad existence. I do see this as similar.

It certainly wasn't a "lonely and sad existence" for me growing up. I loved being trusted to go downstairs all by myself to watch TV in the mornings. I was allowed to make some cereal, have some juice and sit on the floor while I watched cartoons. My parents were always around and if I wanted I was always welcome to go upstairs and see them in bed.

IMO parents don't need to constantly "be there" from the minute their DC wake up to the minute they go to bed. I mean, even babies and toddlers are left unattended while their parents shower or get on with things in another room for short periods of time.

We're not talking about children left alone in a house with no supervision. The parents are probably barely ten metres away.

Theelephantinthecastle · 05/03/2023 19:02

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 18:57

But OP doesn't have a two year old - so whether you'd leave a 2yo alone or not is irrelevant to her post. Her children are 4 and 7, so considerably older and more likely to follow instructions. There's also nothing to say they wouldn't come and clamber over them if they got bored either.

I suspect most 4yo's would probably love being able to sit and watch TV with their big sibling and the 7yo's probably love being in charge without mum around too Grin

I was replying to @concertgoer who does this with their 2 year old

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 18:57

Theelephantinthecastle · 05/03/2023 18:40

See, if mine at 2 years old wanted to chat to me and clamber on me, they would just come and find me in bed. They wouldn't meekly stay in a different room. And if they were that docile, I would assume you could just tell them to stop it.

I can see where there's room for debate with a 4 year old, I don't think a 2 year old should be left alone for even half an hour

But OP doesn't have a two year old - so whether you'd leave a 2yo alone or not is irrelevant to her post. Her children are 4 and 7, so considerably older and more likely to follow instructions. There's also nothing to say they wouldn't come and clamber over them if they got bored either.

I suspect most 4yo's would probably love being able to sit and watch TV with their big sibling and the 7yo's probably love being in charge without mum around too Grin

Charmian1957 · 05/03/2023 18:52

I always stayed up with mine. Maybe cuppa on sofa & sort of snooze with one eye open.

buzzy06 · 05/03/2023 18:47

Yes, I remember the same thread. And the parents I know IRL do it for hours. Which makes sense in a way - I find it a bit peculiar to do it for 30 mins to an hour and not fully go back to sleep as a few people on this thread have said, at that point why not just get out of bed? I am not so desperate for 30 mins of dozing.

Need to time to adjust. I'm not being woken up at 7am on a weekend and immediately doing puzzles or doing potato art, I mean seriously? That's just miserable AF.

I wouldn't really go back to sleep (as I know it's only a matter of time before the DC comes back asking for something) but I lie in bed for a while and check the news, social media, Mumsnet, texts, emails whatever before I summon the energy to go next door.

Thisisthewaywe · 05/03/2023 18:43

@Theelephantinthecastle i have a handful of times. I’ve brought ds in bed with me and been so shattered I’ve gone back to sleep! I once had a strange moment where I thought I’d gone back to sleep for hours, and I couldn’t have as I fell asleep sometime when Chuggingtons started and then woke to Bing, but ds has gone and I thought he’d been fending for himself for ages. He was fine.

So I am not perfect and I do make mistakes but I just don’t see that a lot of the ‘stick some juice and a brioche and a remote in front of them’ as good. It may happen sometimes but it isn’t great.