Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

3 day weekend - to think this what is needed to have a decent quality of life?

241 replies

Whatifthegrassisblue · 04/03/2023 02:43

Where does the time go? AIBU to think there is not enough time? By the time you catch up on chores, spend time with family, catch up with friends and try and have some time as a family as well ....it just doesn't happen. I was thinking about it ...1 day for chores and "life admin", leaves the other 52 days to split between time as a family, your extended family and friends. Let alone just wanting to have a day and chill and do nothing, or go on a holiday. I feel I am doing life wrong 😕 Does anyone else feel this way or AIBU?

OP posts:
DifferenceEngines · 06/03/2023 02:25

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 21:40

@Tiddler39 but that physically doesn't work in so many professions.

It's all very well saying "you'll just increase your productivity" but when you're restricted by things like the time it takes paint to dry, or how long it takes to mix cement and plaster, you can't just work quicker and get more done. It's not physically possible.

If DH has a house to plaster, he can't just work quicker and get more walls done in a day - as he still needs to stop and mix fresh plaster, and wait for things to dry. The painters and tilers who come in after him can't start their jobs until the plaster is dry - so dropping to a four day week would just mean jobs take even longer to complete.

You also can't change the construction industry to operating 24-7 either - as there are (understandably) limits on when you can make loud noises and operate heavy machinery, so it's not like they can work longer days to make up for it.

For outside work, you also need to take into consideration things like daylight hours and weather conditions - it's just not the same as working at a computer in an office.

It's very easy to say "all industries can work on a four day week" but the reality isn't quite as straightforward. I used construction as an example, but lots of industries are limited by how long processes take to complete - you can't just magically make them go faster because you're not working on Fridays anymore.

But there's nothing magic about a 5 day working week either. It's completely arbitrary, and was invented in an era when life and work was quote different.

We don't need to be more productive. Automation is increasing exponentially, and every year there are fewer jobs for people. The great upcoming challenge is finding stuff for people to do.

VeniVidiWeeWee · 06/03/2023 02:13

Great.

To start let's get civil servants and council workers doing 7 days per wèek.

It wouldn't involve anyone working more hours, just in a different pattern.

Whatifthegrassisblue · 06/03/2023 00:35

itsjustnotok · 05/03/2023 23:20

@Whatifthegrassisblue obviously a shorter week is amazing in theory but we all know that won’t work in lots of jobs. plus I’ve seen multiple threads about how shops etc should be open on Sundays because it’s inconvenient, so seriously who is staffing all these roles??

I don't think it would work everywhere, in fact perhaps we are the problem given we demand things to be open and quickly done in the first place. One can dream, the 3 day weekend is definitely the dream for me (although winning the lottery would be better!!). Who knows maybe it might be a thing in the future, 10 years ago everyone would've also scoffed at working from home ... we shall see

OP posts:
Judgyjudgy · 06/03/2023 00:21

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 23:37

@Judgyjudgy I still don't see how that works in reality.

You can only have a certain number of people on a job - so if instead of one person working five days, you decide to have two people working four, you're going have overlap and someone stood about with nothing to do.

Humans can't magically move faster than their bodies allow them to do. You also can't magically speed up machinery or change the weather to allow more work to be done in less time - it doesn't work like that.

I also very much doubt that anyone would want noisy building work operating 6-7 days a week from 7am-10pm disrupting their three day weekends Wink

This is literally what someone who specialises in this does, a resource planner. In construction, and other types of project management you have multiple constraints, noise restrictions, traffic, weather, people, specialist equipment, specialised skills etc; it's their job to figure it out. They're clever people, much more than me 😁🤷‍♀️ How else do you think giant skyscrapers, underground rail etc gets built. It's not the same 10 people, working 40 hours, 9-5, 5 days a week 🙃😉

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 23:37

@Judgyjudgy I still don't see how that works in reality.

You can only have a certain number of people on a job - so if instead of one person working five days, you decide to have two people working four, you're going have overlap and someone stood about with nothing to do.

Humans can't magically move faster than their bodies allow them to do. You also can't magically speed up machinery or change the weather to allow more work to be done in less time - it doesn't work like that.

I also very much doubt that anyone would want noisy building work operating 6-7 days a week from 7am-10pm disrupting their three day weekends Wink

itsjustnotok · 05/03/2023 23:20

@Whatifthegrassisblue obviously a shorter week is amazing in theory but we all know that won’t work in lots of jobs. plus I’ve seen multiple threads about how shops etc should be open on Sundays because it’s inconvenient, so seriously who is staffing all these roles??

Judgyjudgy · 05/03/2023 23:02

Judgyjudgy · 05/03/2023 22:44

Using some basic math, it can be done even in construction which I've worked in, as well as prkect management and resourcing. The organisation can still open 5 days, but people themselves could be rostered. In fact it could be more productive because you could open 6 days and have people on rotation. Anything can be done if you put your mind to it. The only restriction is if you work on your own, in which case less hours would mean more output and less money potentially unless you increased your prices. But then that's the downside of having your own business which of course allows you other flexibility.

Sorry typed too quick! You get the jist. It just requires some lateral thinking. Where there's a will, there's a way. The problem is there probably is not much will! 🙂

Judgyjudgy · 05/03/2023 22:44

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 21:40

@Tiddler39 but that physically doesn't work in so many professions.

It's all very well saying "you'll just increase your productivity" but when you're restricted by things like the time it takes paint to dry, or how long it takes to mix cement and plaster, you can't just work quicker and get more done. It's not physically possible.

If DH has a house to plaster, he can't just work quicker and get more walls done in a day - as he still needs to stop and mix fresh plaster, and wait for things to dry. The painters and tilers who come in after him can't start their jobs until the plaster is dry - so dropping to a four day week would just mean jobs take even longer to complete.

You also can't change the construction industry to operating 24-7 either - as there are (understandably) limits on when you can make loud noises and operate heavy machinery, so it's not like they can work longer days to make up for it.

For outside work, you also need to take into consideration things like daylight hours and weather conditions - it's just not the same as working at a computer in an office.

It's very easy to say "all industries can work on a four day week" but the reality isn't quite as straightforward. I used construction as an example, but lots of industries are limited by how long processes take to complete - you can't just magically make them go faster because you're not working on Fridays anymore.

Using some basic math, it can be done even in construction which I've worked in, as well as prkect management and resourcing. The organisation can still open 5 days, but people themselves could be rostered. In fact it could be more productive because you could open 6 days and have people on rotation. Anything can be done if you put your mind to it. The only restriction is if you work on your own, in which case less hours would mean more output and less money potentially unless you increased your prices. But then that's the downside of having your own business which of course allows you other flexibility.

Greenfairydust · 05/03/2023 21:48

Absolutely.

People working 5 days a week, often long hours and then trying to cram the weekly shop/cleaning/admin at the weekend and barely being able to squeeze in a bit of time for fun/relaxation is not a recipe for a happy life.

This only became the norm not because it the best, healthier way to live but because it suits large corporations and governments who prioritise profit/money/consumerism above anything else.

Basically you spend your life working so that a few people at the top can enjoy a privileged life.

I got out of this treadmill a few years ago once I started having health issues.

I now work 3 days a week and nothing in this world would make me work full time again. I would rather be cash-poor but time-rich because spending so much time in hospital made me realise how short life is and that I had living whatever time I had left.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 21:40

@Tiddler39 but that physically doesn't work in so many professions.

It's all very well saying "you'll just increase your productivity" but when you're restricted by things like the time it takes paint to dry, or how long it takes to mix cement and plaster, you can't just work quicker and get more done. It's not physically possible.

If DH has a house to plaster, he can't just work quicker and get more walls done in a day - as he still needs to stop and mix fresh plaster, and wait for things to dry. The painters and tilers who come in after him can't start their jobs until the plaster is dry - so dropping to a four day week would just mean jobs take even longer to complete.

You also can't change the construction industry to operating 24-7 either - as there are (understandably) limits on when you can make loud noises and operate heavy machinery, so it's not like they can work longer days to make up for it.

For outside work, you also need to take into consideration things like daylight hours and weather conditions - it's just not the same as working at a computer in an office.

It's very easy to say "all industries can work on a four day week" but the reality isn't quite as straightforward. I used construction as an example, but lots of industries are limited by how long processes take to complete - you can't just magically make them go faster because you're not working on Fridays anymore.

Tiddler39 · 05/03/2023 21:22

illiterato · 04/03/2023 07:21

The wouldn’t be and this is the problem. The 4 day week concept only really works/ applies well to office based type jobs vs “real time” jobs like trades, manufacturing, or things like teaching and nursing. Imagine the uproar of teachers say “yeah, we’re doing a 4 day week now so on a Friday you need to home school your kids”.

Well either they wouldn’t all work the same four days, so each teacher does four days but they split it so the kids are in school for five, OR we would just have a four-day school week. No home schooling required. Three-day weekend for everyone.

Tiddler39 · 05/03/2023 21:13

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 06:59

@DifferenceEngines I'm not so much talking about roles that require 24/7 cover.

I'm talking about things like dentists and GP practises. In many parts of the country, it's already impossible to find an appointment - dropping to a four day week is only going to make things harder.

Or (moving away from healthcare) roles like construction or building. Dropping a day a week will only make the jobs take longer - it won't increase productivity.

I think dropping to a four day week is a fantastic idea but I also think it's a luxury that most industries can't afford.

All the GPS in our surgery work part time already. Literally not one is full time. So it wouldn’t make anything any worse.

And actually, even in construction and other manual roles the four-day week could work. Many types of businesses took part in the trial and around 87% said that production went up.

Think about it — if you knew you had to get your work done in four days you could. You’d just become more productive.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 05/03/2023 20:18

I work a four day week since having kids and it’s a revelation.

I’m also equally productive or slightly more productive at work because I’m less shattered. So my employer is getting much better value for money from me, which is slightly annoying from my point of view.

Vodababy · 05/03/2023 20:14

I work Wednesday- Saturday (30 hours over 4 days) since third baby and I wish I had done it sooner!! I don’t earn much less since I pay less tax and I love it! Perfect balance. Home days fly by, as do work days. Every day is a happy day, not wishing I’m at the opposite place (home/work) because neither is too long 😊

Robin2008 · 05/03/2023 19:38

YANBU. I wish that weeks were 8 days long ... Don't mind working 5 days, but then with a longer, 3 day, weekend. Of course this is never going to happen but I have always thought that would be such a great solution !

evemillbank · 05/03/2023 08:53

I take Thursdays off. Never working more than two days in a row is game changing for me.

magicthree · 05/03/2023 08:36

follyfoot37 · 04/03/2023 07:55

Where did 'we' go wrong? During which years/decades/century did we have a work/life balance?
When we had to wash clothes by hand, beat carpets, prepare and cook all day?
When we sent kids to work aged 9?
When we were the property of our father/husband and could be left without a penny if your husband left?
When we couldn't vote/ earn our own money?
When we didn't have access to contraception/abortion?
So do tell where it all went wrong and then think on about your life opportunities and think how tired you might be if your home had just been destroyed by an earthquake, or if you live in a country where women are ignored/abused...

Well said! Honestly some of you don't realise how lucky you are. As for those working a 50 hour week, answering emails during your time off etc., surely that is down to you - no-one is forcing you to stay in these high pressure jobs.

champagneplanet · 05/03/2023 08:30

I've done a 4 day week with a Friday off since I went back after Mat Leave 5 years ago. I actually feel like i've had a break from work come Sunday evening, especially since she started nursery at 3.

I don't get paid for the Fridays but we got used to it. Id recommend it to anyone if it's doable.

missfliss · 05/03/2023 08:28

I'd love it -can't afford it on current wage though. 20% salary reduction for us ( compressed hours not possible).
I'm actually intrigued by someone's 9 day fortnight - might look into that

magicthree · 05/03/2023 08:27

illiterato · 04/03/2023 07:21

The wouldn’t be and this is the problem. The 4 day week concept only really works/ applies well to office based type jobs vs “real time” jobs like trades, manufacturing, or things like teaching and nursing. Imagine the uproar of teachers say “yeah, we’re doing a 4 day week now so on a Friday you need to home school your kids”.

This. It's funny how some people only apply this to their own work, and to hell with everyone else apparently. First everyone wants to work from home, now they want to work four day weeks - what's next, not working at all? Meanwhile, those who work five days, and not from home, just carry on as normal.

DavesSpareDeckChair · 05/03/2023 08:24

I'd love a 3 day weekend! 1 day for rest, 1 day for chores, 1 day for fun.

Highjinks01 · 05/03/2023 07:58

It is rubbish! I did over 50hrs at work last week. Yesterday I cleaned, shopped, cooked and ferried DD around. This morning I’ve been up since 6.30 stressing about all the work I need to do before work on Monday. I’m permanently exhausted- it is no life.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 05/03/2023 07:44

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts I'm a train driver. We do a 4 day week although more than 32 hours. Obviously different days off as it's a 24/7 industry and not always 3 days in a row.

Also Sundays are overtime and outside the working week. So if you work a Sunday, it becomes a 7 day week. Which drags.

mamnotmum · 05/03/2023 07:39

Yup switching the work balance feels better. Obviously it's a financial sacrifice though. I have a Monday off to do all the crappy stuff so I have my weekends free.

Sarah180818 · 05/03/2023 07:34

I work 5 days and was sick of giving up a day of my weekend to life admin and chores. Couldn't go part time so made other changes-do an online food shop, got a cleaner and do all the washing during the week in the evenings. No weekends are pretty much ours. Don't visit family much though as they live far away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread