Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disagreeing with DP about safe sleeping

108 replies

bells2810 · 04/03/2023 00:49

DP and I have a 1 week old DD together, my DP also has two children from previous relationship. This is my first baby and I’ll admit I’m an anxious parent. We have a Moses basket in our bedroom for DD to sleep in, she sleeps in it absolutely fine through the day but at night struggles to settle. She often will only settle by lying on DP’s chest and she can sleep like this for hours. When she’s in her Moses basket she wakes up frequently and I think she misses the close contact.

DP has said he wants to sleep in bed with her on his chest and says he did it with his other children and they were fine. I am really against this because throughout my pregnancy I was always told my midwives and other healthcare staff (support workers, health visitors) to never fall asleep holding a baby as it isn’t safe. DP gets frustrated with me saying this as he did it with his other children but the thought of him doing it and something happening to DD gives me horrendous anxiety, he slept with her in the spare room the other night to give me a break and when he said he’d slept with her on his chest I had a breakdown and couldn’t stop crying.

I’ve been told by my midwife to not let DD sleep longer than 3 or 4 hours maximum, and to wake her to feed, which I have been doing and setting alarms just in case she/we sleep longer than that (not that it happens often!) DP also disagrees with this and said that DD will wake us when she’s hungry and we should just let her sleep.

I don’t know what to do. DP is an amazing father and he is wonderful with his kids and DD, but I really disagree with him on these two points and it’s causing a lot of tension. I think I’m also suffering from a bit of the baby blues and feel very sensitive and emotional, whenever we disagree about these things I’m ending up in floods of tears and just feel like I’m causing problems when he is doing what he thinks is best but I’m terrified of something bad happening, especially re the sleeping.

OP posts:
Maiyakat · 04/03/2023 09:09

Lullaby Trust guidelines on co-sleeping here, they are very clear that sleeping on a sofa with a baby increases the risk of SIDS by 50 times. www.lullabytrust.org.uk/safer-sleep-advice/co-sleeping/
Sleep deprivation is awful, I understand he wants to help but at the moment he's completely undermining you as a mum. If he still won't listen you could phone your midwifery team and ask them to talk through the risks with him.

Jeds55 · 04/03/2023 08:39

I hope you managed some sleep OP. I posted in the early hours (awake with a 15 month old).
Can you talk about it with him today when emotions aren't running so high- show him this thread if you have to. Stick to your guns - it's really not safe. Things will get better, the very early days are such a whirlwind with c section recovery thrown in, I can remember feeling so vulnerable.

Olios · 04/03/2023 08:28

Your DP should not be arguing with you right now he should be accommodating your requests even if he doesn't agree (you are right on safesleeping btw).

CornishTiger · 04/03/2023 08:27

And just because his older children were fine doesn’t mean this child will be.

CornishTiger · 04/03/2023 08:26

The safe sleeping argument is one worth having cos the consequences are horrendous if something happens.

Only breastfeeding mothers should co sleep. The research is all there. We have a next to me crib with my 3rd child. Game changer.

junebirthdaygirl · 04/03/2023 08:25

It's so annoying that he keeps saying this is how he did it before. Is he going to say this about everything and give you no chance to discover ways of doing things for yourself? He needs to fully cooperate with you after a section, being in pain, learning how to cope with a new baby. He is causing you distress and this is very unfair. Its not only about what is safe or unsafe. Its totally distressing for a new Mom to have to waste energy to get what she is comfortable with. If he wants to help he needs to actually help and not make things worse. His job is to do all the things you can't do because of having an actual operation. He should be just falling in with your wishes at this vulnerable time and not insisting on his own way. He doesn't even seem to care that a new mom in pain is upset. I actually don't like the sound of him and l co slept with all my babies. I would focus on him not listening to you, on increasing your distress not adding to it. There is a massive mother protective instinct at work in your body right now and if he doesn't know that he is a right that.
Otherwise l would go to my own mother!!

Mariposista · 04/03/2023 08:21

amp.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/26/italian-hospital-investigated-after-newborn-dies-under-sleeping-mother

get him to read this story. Babies die if accidentally squashed by a sleeping parent. Not withstanding a baby does not need the same heat in a bed as an adult. She is far safer in her own cot.
He is however right that she does jot need to be woken up to feed - she will tell you if she is hungry.
Deal with this firmly - get your midwife on side if necessary, without tears and hysterics. He needs to know it’s serious.

sillysmiles · 04/03/2023 08:01

Dissenting voice, but your DH isn't imo being evil, he's parenting as he knows how as he has done before.

What does need to happen though is a big conservation about parenting together this time.

If the baby needs to wake for feeding, can he not sit up with her and stay awake if she's on his chest? And break up the time in the basket until you get a side sleeper.

In a very against the MN flow- remember you are equal parents- his opinions matter too (though the safety one needs to be addressed). If this was a 3rd time mum and 1st time dad no one would question defaulting to her opinion.

Oojamaflipp · 04/03/2023 07:59

bonjello · 04/03/2023 07:47

Also as a step parent I think its important he realises him saying he did it for his other kids isn't going to go down to well. This is your first child. He needs to allow you to learn how to parent without constantly harking back to when he had his other kids. Yes at times it's handy but if he starts insisting this child must be treated exactly the same as his others that is where problems start to creep in.

I understood from the op that he's the baby's father, not a step parent. This is also his child and if course he should have a say.

However, I agree with pretty much everyone else, not safe to sleep on his chest, especially if he's sleeping too. Surely that goes without saying.

I wouldn't personally wake a sleeping baby to feed, unless they were regularly going long stretches without waking (as in more than 4 or 5 hours). Mine never did so it wasn't really an option! (Looking as you DS who never slept for more than 45 minutes...)

But I think communication is the key here. He's perhaps trying to help by taking baby, and believes he has more experience, but this is making you feel undermined and like you don't have a voice. You need to sit down when you're both calm and talk about it properly.

Onnabugeisha · 04/03/2023 07:55

EthicalNonMahogany · 04/03/2023 06:49

also @amylou8 I assume you're the mum who'd given birth? Once more for those at the back, it is not safe for someone to cosleep with a newborn unless they are the mother!!

This isn’t true that only the mother can safely cosleep with a baby. There is no science behind it at all. Dads can safely cosleep with babies.

That said sleeping on a parent’s chest, mum or dad, isn’t safe cosleeping unless the parent is awake. Sleeping on the sofa is also not safe at all.

You and your DH need to arrive at him caring for the baby in a safer manner.

bonjello · 04/03/2023 07:47

Also as a step parent I think its important he realises him saying he did it for his other kids isn't going to go down to well. This is your first child. He needs to allow you to learn how to parent without constantly harking back to when he had his other kids. Yes at times it's handy but if he starts insisting this child must be treated exactly the same as his others that is where problems start to creep in.

Jooliusreezer · 04/03/2023 07:44

On the chest and in bed, but especially in a sofa, is not particularly safe. Your partner got lucky before. It’s easy for it to go wrong.

Go and buy a next-to-me crib today and try her in that.

PurpleFlower1983 · 04/03/2023 07:43

Get a side sleeper rather than the Moses basket. We had a Sleepyhead too and it was great.

PurBal · 04/03/2023 07:36

I learnt pretty quickly that healthcare professionals have different opinions so you should do what’s right for you.
Safe sleep guidelines are guidelines not law. Would I let my baby sleep on my chest overnight? No. Would I co sleep safely? Yes (and one midwife suggested this in hospital despite being told a few hours earlier that DS should sleep in the plastic cot). But I would persevere with the Moses basket too.
Would I wake my sleeping baby if they’d slept longer than expect as a one off? No. Would I wake them if they were regularly going hours and hours between feeds? Yes.
Your partner may have had other children but they have never had THIS child. All children are different and you both need to learn to parent your daughter together.

Emptycrackedcup · 04/03/2023 07:27

gamerchick · 04/03/2023 07:13

You can co sleep safely but that's not safe. You need a different plan if she likes a body. Find the compromise rather than lock horns for your own stress levels. Just one adult in the bed type of thing.

Hes right about the feeding, you don't need to wake them up.

Wrong. A newborn should be woken every 3 hours to feed. The misinformation on this thread is seriously disturbing 😳

HungryandIknowit · 04/03/2023 07:25

You are right about the sleeping. He shouldn't be co-sleeping with the baby at all, especially with her on his chest. Falling asleep on the sofa with a baby is incredibly dangerous.

If you are breastfeeding you could co-sleep though. This may save your sanity. Look at the lullaby trust website.

I agree with him about not waking baby to feed unless she's not putting on weight or there are other concerns.

It sounds like his attitude - whilst trying to be helpful - is not actually very supportive. He doesn't know best because he's done it before and you haven't.

Sugargliderwombat · 04/03/2023 07:25

Your dp is a dickhead and should be supporting you not telling you what's going to be done.

I cosleep using the lullaby trust sleepcode but never ever should a baby sleep ON someone.

You're doing really well advocating for your baby, if your op has a good night sleep he should give you a break to catch up on sleep tomorrow x.

Nuevabegin · 04/03/2023 07:21

For the people saying it isn’t normal to wake a newborn to feed , if you are breastfeeding it definitely is and really important. In the first week the baby is so sleepy and lethargic they won’t always wake naturally to feed , if this happens they can become jaundiced and lethargic and then reluctant to feed or don’t have the energy to latch. It’s actually a big factor in bf failure as the more lethargic, less feeding the quicker the weight drop and so people end up supplementing with formula to catch up .
The HV is 100 percent right to tell them to set an alarm, it’s literally only at the start and then the baby will start waking loads themselves anyway.

Nuevabegin · 04/03/2023 07:15

@gamerchick if the newborn is v v new and you are breastfeeding then it’s normal to wake them . I did with all my three so they’d gain weight and not get into a cycle of not feeding enough and becoming lethargic. It’s usually only at the beginning for the first couple of weeks.

Nuevabegin · 04/03/2023 07:13

You are absolutely right that this isn’t safe op and just because he’s had dcs before doesn’t change this fact. The only person who could cosleep safely ( following all the safety steps) next to a newborn is their mother who is exclusively breastfeeding as it’s a fact that bf mothers wake more frequently due to letdown, bf babies also don’t sleep as deeply and will wake more when near their mother , breastfeeding regulates heart rate and breathing etc . A man who hasn’t given birth , obviously can’t bf shouldn’t never be falling asleep holding a newborn , it’s dangerous.

gamerchick · 04/03/2023 07:13

You can co sleep safely but that's not safe. You need a different plan if she likes a body. Find the compromise rather than lock horns for your own stress levels. Just one adult in the bed type of thing.

Hes right about the feeding, you don't need to wake them up.

WeWereInParis · 04/03/2023 07:11

You're right about him sleeping with her on his chest, this is dangerous.

Unless there were specific weight concerns, I wouldn't wake a baby to feed them.

Beginningless · 04/03/2023 07:09

StarsSand · 04/03/2023 07:01

Your DP is not an 'amazing father' if he doesn't know that his role one week in is to support the post partum mother and not carry on like a muppet.

This. It’s ok for you to be upset about him trying to ride roughshod over your wishes when you are so vulnerable. I can get that he’s parented before so he thinks he has expertise and probably feels undermined by you not listening to him. However there is evidence that this approach is not safe, and I say this as someone who is very pro bed sharing safely. Have you sent him info on this? Ask HV to speak to him? But mainly I think you need to spell out to him that your body and mind just went through one of the biggest events in your life and that his arguing with you is seriously not ok. He needs to help in the way you ask, not impose himself at this time. Later when you are more recovered you can discuss more equally but I think when you’ve just given birth you need looked after in your way, not his.

Heronwatcher · 04/03/2023 07:05

Sorry, I think it was this thing I used (used to be called a sleepyhead), it was really good- like a bed within your bed. There will be loads of threads on here if you Google I am sure.
www.johnlewis.com/dockatot-deluxe-pristine-white-baby-pod-0-8-months/p5225715?s_ppc=2dx92700069424642082_mixed_home_BAU&tmad=c&tmcampid=2&gbraid=0AAAAAD2el1xEVFFzrW6l0UeYZdbU_EAvh&gbraid=0AAAAAD2el1xEVFFzrW6l0UeYZdbU_EAvh&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIq-KtmNrB_QIVgfftCh2JdwShEAQYASABEgKiJfD_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

StarsSand · 04/03/2023 07:01

Your DP is not an 'amazing father' if he doesn't know that his role one week in is to support the post partum mother and not carry on like a muppet.

Swipe left for the next trending thread