Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you too attend a candlelight vigil tomorrow evening in Edinburgh, Bristol or London

235 replies

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 19:54

.. for the 100 students every year who take their own lives every year.

The law needs to change so that Universities have a duty of care to their students.

Fine out more: www.forthe100.org.uk/vigil

I'm a very regular Mumsnetter who has name-changed to post this.

OP posts:
Hintofreality · 04/03/2023 11:16

And what about their family’s duty or care, you don’t just pack your kid off to a Uni and expect someone to take over all responsibility for them.

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 11:14

Wow. Some victim blaming going on here. It's our fault as parents if our children have mental health problems because we've "infantilised" them and encouraged them to become "introspective"?

Fortunately nowadays there is much better recognition and understanding of mental health than there was when I was a young adult, and there is some help and therapy available - instead of being told to pull your socks up and get on with things (as I once was by a GP).

We are asking for a debate in parliament to find a better way forward for students - for some of whom have been failed by the current system. That is all.

OP posts:
DrDinosaur · 04/03/2023 10:25

OP I’m sorry if you have personal experience of this. Any death from suicide is a tragedy.

But I don’t think making universities responsible is the answer. 18 year olds are adults. Their frontal lobes may not be fully developed, and they sometimes make poor choices, but they need to be taking responsibility for themselves and learning to be independent.

There does seem to be increasing infantilisation of teens and young adults.
When I was 16 I moved alone to London in the summer holidays and found myself a job and a place to stay. When I was 18 I travelled across Europe and got a job - my only contact with my parents was a fortnightly airmail letter. I’d have been outraged, when I came back to study, if my university had been reporting to my parents on my mental health.

Improving NHS mental health services for everyone would be a better focus for your campaign.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 04/03/2023 10:15

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 22:28

Employers have a legal duty of care to their staff.

Prisons have a legal duty of care to prisoners.

Universities should have a legal duty of care to their students.

In an employment scenario the duty of care does not include contacting parents or family members.

If an employee disclosed to me that they were suicidal I would engage with HR, we would encourage the employee to utilise Occupational Health, GP or Employee Assistance programmes, we would have discussions about how we can help in the work environment to support with work activities. If they didn't attend work and were uncontactable we may contact the police if we had cause to believe a welfare check is needed. We would not contact the staff members parents though if the staff member is over 18 years old as that would be a breach of privacy.

University Duty of Care is similar, they should signpost to services, offer support within the context of what they have control over like assignment deadlines and lecture attendance but they are not parents or carers to the students.

Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 10:01

Yes hard work is good for you! It baffles me how ‘exhausted’ everyone is these days as well. I’m now doing a degree in my early 30s, paid for by employer - started as an admin assistant and worked up. I’m doing it alongside my full time job, a 3 year old DD and a dog. It’s been tough, but 🤷🏼‍♀️ However I cannot see how only being a student with no caring responsibilities doesn’t give you ample time to study and work.

It’s very much a middle class parent issue if I may say that. I expect my kids to ‘be teens’ when they’re teens - I expect them to go get drunk at parties (hopefully not much earlier than 16!), I expect to find a vape in their bag (hopefully not a bag of weed), I expect that they’ll find the opposite (or same, who knows) sex more interesting than school for a little while. I expect them to be ‘immature’ and want to have a laugh as they go around figuring the world out and learning a few lessons.

Today’s teens look so miserable, dripping about in black clothes and stressing over climate change/inequality/politics. It’s like we’re trying to force them into the emotional strait jacket of an older adult while simultaneously confiscating the responsibilities and freedom that an adult has. Recipe for disaster IMO.

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 09:52

Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 09:42

I think some of this feeds back into the extended childhood culture we have . Mid- late teenagers are much more immature than those even 20 years ago. They are emotional/ social children in an adults world. We need to talk about ways to make them more resilient.

I was a teen in the early 00s and looking back I was a fully blown adult when I left home at 18 (not for uni), minus the financial experience. I cooked all my own meals, did my laundry, had been taking myself everywhere on public transport since I was 12, organised my own accommodation and new job.

I’m fascinated and appalled when I read threads on here about how much parents now interfere in and control their older teens’ lives - ‘should I allow them to go to this party at 17?’ ‘How do I choose a uni for them?’ ‘16 year old has a friend I disapprove of because they smoke’.

They’re encouraged to introspect almost constantly, every minor upset treated as a ‘trauma’ with parents afraid to even raise their voices in case it’s seen as ‘abusive’.

A lot of posters talk about resilience but don’t actually want to do anything to help it along, they seem to think it’s something that magically appears.

Completely agree with this. Sounds like you had a similar trajectory to me.

I really really object and always have, to the requirement for parents to be financially supporting their adult children at university in way that is not expected (quite rightly) for adult children who are living independently at the same ages. It encourages this view that because someone is at university they're incapable of working and supporting themselves on top of any loan they take out. I financed myself through 2 degrees (the second of which I was a mature student and had very poor MH, suicidal but was under the GP who was fantastic I have to say) and was working and saving from 13 in various weekend/evening jobs.

Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 09:42

I think some of this feeds back into the extended childhood culture we have . Mid- late teenagers are much more immature than those even 20 years ago. They are emotional/ social children in an adults world. We need to talk about ways to make them more resilient.

I was a teen in the early 00s and looking back I was a fully blown adult when I left home at 18 (not for uni), minus the financial experience. I cooked all my own meals, did my laundry, had been taking myself everywhere on public transport since I was 12, organised my own accommodation and new job.

I’m fascinated and appalled when I read threads on here about how much parents now interfere in and control their older teens’ lives - ‘should I allow them to go to this party at 17?’ ‘How do I choose a uni for them?’ ‘16 year old has a friend I disapprove of because they smoke’.

They’re encouraged to introspect almost constantly, every minor upset treated as a ‘trauma’ with parents afraid to even raise their voices in case it’s seen as ‘abusive’.

A lot of posters talk about resilience but don’t actually want to do anything to help it along, they seem to think it’s something that magically appears.

Aphrathestorm · 04/03/2023 09:34

Anyone I know who had mental health problems (I mean suicidal) at Uni never even thought to go to the uni for support.

They had GPs just like everyone else and got crappy NHS non service like everyone else.

It is a problem though that some students can't get GOs near unis as they are 'full'.

But I heard a woman who lost her DD talking about this on women's hour last week and I do have sympathy.

I don't think unis should break confidentiality without consent though.

I think some of this feeds back into the extended childhood culture we have . Mid- late teenagers are much more immature than those even 20 years ago. They are emotional/ social children in an adults world. We need to talk about ways to make them more resilient.

You see it all over MN the culture of mollycoddling and helicopter parenting that's the norm now.

It goes right back to infancy with no overnight babysitting, others not allowed to visit/ hold a newborn, kids not walking alone to school til secondary, being driven everywhere, teens who've never taken a bus/train alone, pre teens who can't go into a shop and pay, late teens who can't make a formal phone call or know how much bills are.

No wonder they can't cope when thrown into the maelstrom of uni.

Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 09:25

Nimbostratus100 · 03/03/2023 23:35

it is not the universities role to check up on students, any more than it is the busdrivers role, the shop assistant's role, the hairdressers role...

You are totally misunderstanding the role of a university - it is primarily a research organisation, partially funding itself by getting its researchers to give lectures

I think maybe the issue is that the role of schools has become so distorted and unreasonable, that parents who have got used to demanding ridiculous things from schools think they can demand the same from universities

It simply isnt feasible to try and dump this sort of duty on universities, they don't have the personal, the resources, the time, the money, or even the requirement to take responsibility for adults who come to their lecturers

sorry

I agree with this. Sorry OP, there’s clearly a personal angle here which you haven’t gone into so I understand the replies will be hard for you to read.

But if the university should have a statutory ‘duty of care’ over the students, why shouldn’t their own parents? Should parents be prosecuted because in hindsight they ‘didn’t do enough’ to protect and support their adult child? If they’re not yet ready to be regarded as autonomous adults, then their parents should still be viewed as their legal guardian shouldn’t they?

I can’t help but think that when deaths happen now, grieving families look to place the blame somewhere because it makes the grieving process more ‘productive’ and the ensuing campaigning gives them something to focus on.

But from a non-emotionally-invested standpoint, making universities/workplaces etc responsible for the suicide of their members is illogical and deeply unfair. The only time there should be one is if they are dramatically failed by mental health services.

JuneOsborne · 04/03/2023 09:18

Ok, but how?

A student can be seen by dozens of employees of the university. Few, if any have any kind of contact details for students families. Or even their term time address. Or phone number.

Some students never attend their classes. They're written to, eventually. How do you keep an eye on somebody who isn't there?

Lots of university accommodation isn't owned by the university itself. So if something happens there, what does the university do?

I don't disagree with you in principle, but I can't get my head around how it would work. What do you do about mature students? Or international students? Who should be responsible at the university because it's impossible to say 'the university'.

TrashyPanda · 04/03/2023 09:14

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 08:42

I wonder how many people on here saying "students are adults" have parented an 18 year old?

I have.

a child with MH issues, who has attempted suicide.

and I think that all people matter. The suicide rate is significantly higher among non-students. Why not hold a vigil for all those who have been so desperate they have taken their own lives?

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 09:07

Bellac that is why we want a debate in parliament to discuss all the issues properly. I agree there are a lot of nuances, it is not about apportioning blame but - hopefully - passing carefully considered legislation which will result in better outcomes and decision-making for everyone's benefit. And save lives.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 04/03/2023 08:50

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 08:45

I am involved in this campaign for personal reasons. Please read the experiences of some of the parents on the website to get a better understanding of the issues we are highlighting.
www.forthe100.org.uk

But you're not answering the question, what in practical terms would you like to see happening and how is that comparable with an employers 'duty of care'

Im sorry if you have had a loss of this kind, its unimaginable but I do feel focusing on universities in a blame manner is a red herring and a misuse of the focus and energies which need to be put into challengin and campaigning for the NHS services to be vastly improved.

Yes I have parented an 18 year old and Ive also been one. The cut off for adulthood has to be a line somewhere, I had left home long before I was 18 and I dont believe in infantilisation of young adults, I think its hugely damaging to them and society.

Morph22010 · 04/03/2023 08:48

bonjello · 03/03/2023 20:10

Gosh that's bad

They can still go to the gp though like non students

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 08:45

I am involved in this campaign for personal reasons. Please read the experiences of some of the parents on the website to get a better understanding of the issues we are highlighting.
www.forthe100.org.uk

OP posts:
Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 08:42

I wonder how many people on here saying "students are adults" have parented an 18 year old?

OP posts:
bellac11 · 04/03/2023 08:42

I think like others are saying you're misunderstanding what a duty of care entails

What in practical terms are you talking about then in relation to suicide?

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 08:39

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 08:01

Are you saying that if my employer knew I was suicidal they would inform my family without my consent?

No-one is saying that. The campaign ask is this: “The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law, that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury or by failing to act.

“In work, or in education, 18- to 21-year-olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care. This is not just about suicide prevention; everybody will benefit from improved decision-making within the sector.”

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 04/03/2023 08:09

Why should unis speak to parents? They are adults and surely it is a privacy issue?

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 08:01

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 22:32

Companies do have a legal duty of care for their employees.

Are you saying that if my employer knew I was suicidal they would inform my family without my consent?

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 08:00

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 22:29

There are examples of Universities who did not contact the parents when they knew a student was suicidal.

How can they if the adult doesnt consent. In the same way any organisation cannot disclose personal information to someone where there isnt consent, whether that be Sainsburys or the library, wherever someone is working.

I would like to think that any agency or organisation would contact the NHS/crisis team/patients GP to share the information, that does need to happen.

Nimbostratus100 · 03/03/2023 23:35

it is not the universities role to check up on students, any more than it is the busdrivers role, the shop assistant's role, the hairdressers role...

You are totally misunderstanding the role of a university - it is primarily a research organisation, partially funding itself by getting its researchers to give lectures

I think maybe the issue is that the role of schools has become so distorted and unreasonable, that parents who have got used to demanding ridiculous things from schools think they can demand the same from universities

It simply isnt feasible to try and dump this sort of duty on universities, they don't have the personal, the resources, the time, the money, or even the requirement to take responsibility for adults who come to their lecturers

sorry

PersonaNonGarter · 03/03/2023 23:26

I don’t think this was a good topic for AIBU.

OP, you are going to find the replies hard.

I actually do think universities have a duty of care to their students in respect of mental health, particularly around exams. However, the relationship is between the university and the student. The university is not responsible for contacting third parties although there should be a mechanism for doing that in serious circumstances.

Daisymay2 · 03/03/2023 23:15

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

thebear1 · 03/03/2023 23:01

No, University's should support students wherever possible but they can't prevent all suicides. Sometimes a student dies and no one, not even their family knew the student was unwell. Sometimes University trys to get someone into NHS residential care but the NHS say they don't meet the threshold. I've even seen students with preexisting severe mental health issues encouraged to study, despite not being well enough. The issues are hugely complex but making University legally responsible isn't the answer.