Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you too attend a candlelight vigil tomorrow evening in Edinburgh, Bristol or London

235 replies

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 19:54

.. for the 100 students every year who take their own lives every year.

The law needs to change so that Universities have a duty of care to their students.

Fine out more: www.forthe100.org.uk/vigil

I'm a very regular Mumsnetter who has name-changed to post this.

OP posts:
bellac11 · 04/03/2023 14:33

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 14:27

@Sophforthe100 - most people have no idea what you are suggesting and don’t understand the concept of duty of care. To be honest the lack of interest in the welfare of others is indicative of the AIBU boards more generally, I’m sure in real life there’s a lot more interest in reasonable measures to prevent suicide.

Explain what your definition of all this is then. Give some comparable examples of an employer and a university student and what would be different for each of them, or failing that, what OP is actually arguing for?

I think this thread and the petition is a classic example of where bad laws are made out of the best intentions. People have a huge sympathy with what the OPs experience is, not least the experiences of those who have struggled with their MH and felt like ending their life is the only way away from those uncomfortable feelings. But it doesnt make great law to try to say that x, y and z should take responsiblity to prevent that.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 04/03/2023 14:33

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 14:27

@Sophforthe100 - most people have no idea what you are suggesting and don’t understand the concept of duty of care. To be honest the lack of interest in the welfare of others is indicative of the AIBU boards more generally, I’m sure in real life there’s a lot more interest in reasonable measures to prevent suicide.

On the contrary, it's the OP who doesn't appear to understand what duty of care means.

People DO care about preventing suicide - they're just saying that universities are not responsible for the mental health of their students. If someone is struggling, they need to speak to their doctor.

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 14:32

Notagardener · 04/03/2023 14:31

Well if they should be treated as any adult and parents not to be informed without their consent
I don't see why bother preventing any suicide. Up to the person killing themselves. Maybe we should make it clear easier for them.

DC starving herself but it's her choice, I should not interfere....

You're her parent, of course you should interfere. Random people at the bus stop? Probably not.

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 14:31

most people have no idea what you are suggesting and don’t understand the concept of duty of care
On the contrary, most people understand the concept perfectly, and understand when and in what circumstances it's applicable.
It's actually op who is full of flowery, meaningless phrases having no actual understanding of the logic behind them.

Notagardener · 04/03/2023 14:31

Well if they should be treated as any adult and parents not to be informed without their consent
I don't see why bother preventing any suicide. Up to the person killing themselves. Maybe we should make it clear easier for them.

DC starving herself but it's her choice, I should not interfere....

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 04/03/2023 14:30

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:13

The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law; that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act. In work, or in education, 18-21 year olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care.

Again, you don't seem to understand what duty of care actually means.

You're right that employers have a duty to protect someone "from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act" - but all that means is that they have to keep the workplace safe. That means risk assessments, making sure the stairs are safe, making sure stuff on shelves isn't going to fall on someone's head, making sure people get correct training when it comes to heavy lifting or working alone.

It doesn't mean that the employer is responsible for someone's mental state and that they're at fault if an employee harms themselves or has a breakdown.

Daisychained8 · 04/03/2023 14:30

The whole of the UK fails people when it comes to mental health issues. It would be a bit of a joke to make this all about universities not having sufficient mental health resources when the actual country doesn’t either.

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 14:27

@Sophforthe100 - most people have no idea what you are suggesting and don’t understand the concept of duty of care. To be honest the lack of interest in the welfare of others is indicative of the AIBU boards more generally, I’m sure in real life there’s a lot more interest in reasonable measures to prevent suicide.

CMO · 04/03/2023 14:26

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:05

Do you work at a University Spartacus?

If so, the University has a legal duty of care towards you, as an employee. However it does not have the same legal duty of care to its students.

Several poster have asked you to clarify what you mean. Employers do not have a duty to provide mental health services for employees. They do have a duty around health and safety but this also covers anyone who is on the premises too. They have a duty to make reasonable adjustments under disability legislation too. They don't have any duty to liasie with families of employees. I've had two children through university and one struggleed with his mental health but I don't agree that the university owed him anything other than to allow him to use his MH as mitigating circumstances.

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 14:26

Safer systems and practices are needed, supported by a statutory requirement to exercise reasonable care and skill when teaching students
That's just a complete word salad. What reasonable care and skills are not currently being exercised whilst teaching students?
It's quite ridiculous to campaign for something you can't even define.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 04/03/2023 14:25

Breezycheesetrees · 04/03/2023 14:04

Really surprised by the hard responses here. Many young people (yes, they're adults, but they're very young) are extremely vulnerable at university - they're away from home and their support networks, often facing situations and pressures they have no idea how to deal with, alone. Universities make plenty of money out of them, of course they should have a duty of care.

It's not harsh to say that universities are not in loco parentis, though.

If any adult is struggling with their mental health, they need to speak to their GP and get referrals to counselling or access to medication via the NHS - and that applies to students as much as it does to any other members of the population.

The relationship between a university and a student is a business one. Students are paying for an education and perhaps some career support - they're not paying to access mental health support.

I struggled with my MH at university and I went to see my GP. It never occurred to me that my university was responsible for looking after me as an adult.

GailBlancheViola · 04/03/2023 14:23

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 14:16

You've repeated this exact paragraph from before

What is it in practice you want to see happen? Describe the scenarios

You keep comparing to employers but employers wouldnt take on the responsibility you seem to want universities to take on

You're asking people to sign up to something but wont expand and explain what it is you actually want to see

@Sophforthe100 if you cannot explain exactly what you want then how do you expect people to support it? The question has been asked of you many times and you still have not explicitly said what you want that is different from what is currently on offer.

How can a debate be held if people do not know what they are debating for or against?

VeggieSalsa · 04/03/2023 14:22

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:13

The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law; that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act. In work, or in education, 18-21 year olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care.

But I don’t think these suicides are as a result of direct injury or failing to act by the university.

I read some of the stories, they are desperately tragic.

If I told my employer I was suicidal (and I don’t think they would be obliged to infer that if I hadn’t explicitly told them), then I would expect them to signpost me to services that can help - not actually deliver those services.

Their duty of care doesn’t require them to actively prevent me taking my own life. That’s not what is meant by “failing to act”.

Would you be happy with the university doing that? It sounds like they are mostly doing that already.

I think a statutory duty of care might mean that university’s reduce their MH services as they won’t want to over extend their duty of care and so they will do the bare minimum to comply, and may withdraw services which make them aware of students’ mental health issues as it would be better for them to have plausible deniability.

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 04/03/2023 14:21

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:13

The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law; that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act. In work, or in education, 18-21 year olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care.

You are misunderstanding that duty.

The forseeable harm by act or omission employers must reaosnably try to prevent is not what you think.

JarByTheDoor · 04/03/2023 14:19

I think what I'm really saying is that if you build a system where mental health services are so shit and resourceless that people are shunted off elsewhere at every opportunity, to services that were never originally set up to deal with severe mental illness or psychiatric emergencies, then even if those services try their best to respond, people will want things from them that they could never provide.

Mental health services like mine offload responsibility onto universities because they have counselling services, but however much universities might want to help, or try to respond by hiring psychiatric nurses to deal with emergencies and seriously mentally ill students, they're not a psychiatric service and don't have those responsibilities or powers.

And of course it means that students who aren't severely mentally ill but want counselling because they're stressed or homesick or feeling a bit low or struggling with their workload will have a hard time getting an appointment, because of all the appointments taken up by people like me.

The solution to all this is properly-funded, properly-staffed mental health services with multiple routes in. I'm fairly sure that if a community psychiatrist had a suicidal student with bipolar disorder in front of them, and there was spare capacity for that student to see a clinical psychologist for bipolar disorder-specific psychological treatment, without depriving someone else of treatment, that psychiatrist wouldn't tell the student that they should just go sign up with the university counselling service.

Properly funding and staffing mental health services wouldn't necessarily directly help those students who kill themselves without accessing any services or who don't have a diagnosable mental illness, but it would mean mentally ill people being given the correct treatment by the correct people, and universities being freed up to provide more support to those struggling with life stuff and emotional troubles.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/03/2023 14:17

I’m giggling to think that my university, in which bullying is rife and we are sinking under unreasonable workloads, gives a shiny shit about employee mental health. There some employee service that provides less than that which the students get. That’s it.

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 14:16

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:13

The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law; that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act. In work, or in education, 18-21 year olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care.

You've repeated this exact paragraph from before

What is it in practice you want to see happen? Describe the scenarios

You keep comparing to employers but employers wouldnt take on the responsibility you seem to want universities to take on

You're asking people to sign up to something but wont expand and explain what it is you actually want to see

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:13

The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law; that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act. In work, or in education, 18-21 year olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care.

OP posts:
YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/03/2023 14:10

Universities are hardly turning profits and teaching staff have ridiculous workloads. It’s not the job of universities to compensate for inadequate mental health services.

I regularly deal with (refer on) students who are self harming, write me emails in which they tell me of suicide attempts, and who surface after long absences with a litany of MH concerns that require dedicated and proper MH services. No one considers the effect on me and my colleagues. Many of us are not trained for this and nor should we be.

if young people are that vulnerable then they should not be miles from home in an environment that should be designed to test them … except it isn’t because everything is trigger warning Ed or cut from the curriculum in case it causes distress.

GCAcademic · 04/03/2023 14:10

What “reasonable care and skill” do you think lecturers are not providing?

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 04/03/2023 14:10

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:09

Safer systems and practices are needed, supported by a statutory requirement to exercise reasonable care and skill when teaching students and providing support services.

They already do that.

So what exactly does the campaign want.

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:09

Safer systems and practices are needed, supported by a statutory requirement to exercise reasonable care and skill when teaching students and providing support services.

OP posts:
IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 04/03/2023 14:09

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 14:07

You've been asked several times to explain what you mean by this duty of care, what is it you think the employee has that is different to what the student has and how that connects to students who need MH intervention?

Exactly this.

What exact care do people want?
This is honestly bit ridiculous with just repetition of "duty of care" towards adult students.

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 14:07

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:05

Do you work at a University Spartacus?

If so, the University has a legal duty of care towards you, as an employee. However it does not have the same legal duty of care to its students.

You've been asked several times to explain what you mean by this duty of care, what is it you think the employee has that is different to what the student has and how that connects to students who need MH intervention?

Breezycheesetrees · 04/03/2023 14:06

There's a weird and very nasty attitude to young adults on Mumsnet - once they're 18, stop supporting or helping them, charge them market rates for rent, fuck em, basically. Thankfully I don't meet many people in the real world who are so cold towards young people.