Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you too attend a candlelight vigil tomorrow evening in Edinburgh, Bristol or London

235 replies

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 19:54

.. for the 100 students every year who take their own lives every year.

The law needs to change so that Universities have a duty of care to their students.

Fine out more: www.forthe100.org.uk/vigil

I'm a very regular Mumsnetter who has name-changed to post this.

OP posts:
Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:21

that doesn't seem to be OPs position, she has mentioned several times about universities contacting parents and wanting them to act as parents to the student

I have not said that. I have explicitly stated that the petition is NOT calling for unis to be in loco parentis.

Some posters have inferred this, but what I said was that there were some situations where students had given consent for unis to contact their parents with mental health concerns, and they had not done this. And the students had gone on to take their own lives, when the parents felt that they might have been able to prevent it had they been told what the uni knew.

OP posts:
Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 18:19

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:00

It's not about individual lecturers having responsibility, it's about the institutions taking more responsibility for their students. And the petition specifically states it is not about Unis being in loco parentis.
Here are interviews with some of the families involved today: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001jxb4/points-west-evening-news-04032023

But what does that actually mean, can you give 3 examples of things that would be implemented?

Nobody’s trying to be mean or unkind, and it goes against everyone’s instinct to not agree with something a grieving parent is saying.

But if you want people to sign a petition and put their name to something, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask for a bit of detail rather than just ‘duty of care’?

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 18:17

Sorry also they dont have to supply OH but obviously would work with the employee to implement recommendations by their own doctor if necessary

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 18:17

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:14

Universities already have lots of responsibility towards their students.

They do not have a statutory responsibility to their students however. But they do to their staff.

But you're still not saying what additional responsibilities you actually expect them to take on
Why are you avoiding this question?

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 18:16

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 18:05

While workplaces have provide safeworking environments, so do universities for students. Since when do workplaces legally have to provide access to occupational health or counselling services, welfare checks or pastoral support for those that aren't acting themselves?

Well there is an expectaion that employers are required to prevent emotional and physical ill health in relation to their business practices so that would be adhering to health and safety requirements and completing risk assessments etc

Im not aware that they are required to provide counselling etc, but even if they were, some universities do this. But that doesnt seem to be OPs position, she has mentioned several times about universities contacting parents and wanting them to act as parents to the student

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:14

Universities already have lots of responsibility towards their students.

They do not have a statutory responsibility to their students however. But they do to their staff.

OP posts:
coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 04/03/2023 18:10

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:00

It's not about individual lecturers having responsibility, it's about the institutions taking more responsibility for their students. And the petition specifically states it is not about Unis being in loco parentis.
Here are interviews with some of the families involved today: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001jxb4/points-west-evening-news-04032023

But you're still not saying what additional responsibilities you actually expect them to take on.

Universities already have lots of responsibility towards their students.

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 18:05

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 17:24

The kind of things that “duty of care” refers to in an employment context include

  • Healthy working environment
  • Good practice with Rotas eg not allowing people to work 72 hours without a break
  • Access to occupational health, work-related counselling
  • Reasonable adjustments to role, environment etc
  • Organising welfare checks if someone is unexpectedly absent
  • Kindness and pastoral support if someone isn’t “acting themself” at work

A pp is right that it isn’t right that universities have more legal responsibility for their employees than their students.

While workplaces have provide safeworking environments, so do universities for students. Since when do workplaces legally have to provide access to occupational health or counselling services, welfare checks or pastoral support for those that aren't acting themselves?

GCAcademic · 04/03/2023 18:04

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:00

It's not about individual lecturers having responsibility, it's about the institutions taking more responsibility for their students. And the petition specifically states it is not about Unis being in loco parentis.
Here are interviews with some of the families involved today: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001jxb4/points-west-evening-news-04032023

But you specifically mentioned teaching with “reasonable care and skill” as something which comes under that duty of care, which suggests you perceive a deficiency and responsibility on the part of lecturers, not just the university. What is lacking here, in your view, and what constitutes teaching with “reasonable care and skill”?

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:00

It's not about individual lecturers having responsibility, it's about the institutions taking more responsibility for their students. And the petition specifically states it is not about Unis being in loco parentis.
Here are interviews with some of the families involved today: www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001jxb4/points-west-evening-news-04032023

OP posts:
ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 17:54

I wonder how many parents would be happy with the idea of being prosecuted if their child committed suicide? In my experience, a significant number of students experiencing poor mental health have issues stemming from their home life. Why should lecturers have this responsibility but not parents?
It's truly baffling.

GCAcademic · 04/03/2023 17:50

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 17:31

Fascinating how worked up those posting in opposition to this are getting though. Perhaps the academics should consider why their working environments are so toxic.

We know why our working environments are toxic. It's because education has become thoroughly commodified with more and more unreasonable demands - and more and more hours added to our workload - every year. The latest, it seems, is that we are expected to be in loco parentis with a legal duty to prevent students from committing suicide when our workloads only allocate 40% of our hours to teaching and student support. I wonder how many parents would be happy with the idea of being prosecuted if their child committed suicide? In my experience, a significant number of students experiencing poor mental health have issues stemming from their home life. Why should lecturers have this responsibility but not parents?

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 04/03/2023 17:37

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 17:24

The kind of things that “duty of care” refers to in an employment context include

  • Healthy working environment
  • Good practice with Rotas eg not allowing people to work 72 hours without a break
  • Access to occupational health, work-related counselling
  • Reasonable adjustments to role, environment etc
  • Organising welfare checks if someone is unexpectedly absent
  • Kindness and pastoral support if someone isn’t “acting themself” at work

A pp is right that it isn’t right that universities have more legal responsibility for their employees than their students.

Bar the welfare checks my uni did provide all of that. From what my friends in other places said, their unies do too.
Unfortunately, it would not be reasonable to expect uni with thousands of students to check on everyone when they don't turn up. Because they often don't as I found out!

Re working breaks. I would consider students more like contractors or self employed if we would be comlaring it, so that doesn't apply.

Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 17:35

Notagardener · 04/03/2023 14:31

Well if they should be treated as any adult and parents not to be informed without their consent
I don't see why bother preventing any suicide. Up to the person killing themselves. Maybe we should make it clear easier for them.

DC starving herself but it's her choice, I should not interfere....

But you’ve just made our point, you’re her mother so you should take responsibility if anyone should. Why don’t parents have a statutory duty of care after their child is 18? Should they?

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 17:31

Fascinating how worked up those posting in opposition to this are getting though. Perhaps the academics should consider why their working environments are so toxic.

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 17:24

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 14:33

Explain what your definition of all this is then. Give some comparable examples of an employer and a university student and what would be different for each of them, or failing that, what OP is actually arguing for?

I think this thread and the petition is a classic example of where bad laws are made out of the best intentions. People have a huge sympathy with what the OPs experience is, not least the experiences of those who have struggled with their MH and felt like ending their life is the only way away from those uncomfortable feelings. But it doesnt make great law to try to say that x, y and z should take responsiblity to prevent that.

The kind of things that “duty of care” refers to in an employment context include

  • Healthy working environment
  • Good practice with Rotas eg not allowing people to work 72 hours without a break
  • Access to occupational health, work-related counselling
  • Reasonable adjustments to role, environment etc
  • Organising welfare checks if someone is unexpectedly absent
  • Kindness and pastoral support if someone isn’t “acting themself” at work

A pp is right that it isn’t right that universities have more legal responsibility for their employees than their students.

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 15:34

OP, I know you think universities provide "duty of care" for staff but not students but what do you think this "care" involves?

ThreeLocusts · 04/03/2023 15:28

OP I agree that more needs to be done for young people's mental health. All young people's not only students'.

I'm also formerly a lecturer at a British university who left b/o the poor working conditions. The sector has suffered badly from Tories' contempt for expertise and general starving of public services.

In the absence of extra resources, all that would result from making universities suable for student suicides would be more box-ticking, efforts to limit liability. Not really helpful.

GCAcademic · 04/03/2023 15:23

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/03/2023 14:17

I’m giggling to think that my university, in which bullying is rife and we are sinking under unreasonable workloads, gives a shiny shit about employee mental health. There some employee service that provides less than that which the students get. That’s it.

My university has removed access to counselling and to wellbeing services for staff in order to concentrate on supporting students. I line manage academic staff who are struggling to cope. The idea that our employer is providing something to them that students don’t get is rather back to front. But, nonetheless, the university is complying with the employer’s duty of care, it’s just that that duty of care does not mean what some people would like it to.

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 15:06

Notagardener · 04/03/2023 15:05

Sorry but as a parent of an 18y old I can not really interfere without my child's consent, which hasn't been given . I can not drag her to the eg GP, I can't talk to her GP etc.

But actually if I saw a random person on the bus trying to commit suicide I would interfer, or at least try

You're joking, right?

Notagardener · 04/03/2023 15:05

Sorry but as a parent of an 18y old I can not really interfere without my child's consent, which hasn't been given . I can not drag her to the eg GP, I can't talk to her GP etc.

But actually if I saw a random person on the bus trying to commit suicide I would interfer, or at least try

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 14:56

Can you define what "failing to act" would actually look like in practice @Sophforthe100 ?

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 14:53

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 14:13

The duty of care being called for is similar to that prevailing under employment law; that universities should have a statutory duty of care to protect their students from reasonably foreseeable harm, caused either by direct injury, or by failing to act. In work, or in education, 18-21 year olds are vulnerable enough to warrant this duty, and since providers are happy to take their fees, they should also take on this duty of care.

They do have a similar duty of care. For example, if a student came to harm while in a laboratory because the University hadn't taken reasonable safety precautions, the University would be responsible. They shouldn't be responsible for things that happen to students that aren't the result of university actions though, just as workplaces aren't responsible. Neither workplaces or universities have a legal obligation to provide mental health care services and neither should they. That is the nhs's job.

GCAcademic · 04/03/2023 14:38

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 14:27

@Sophforthe100 - most people have no idea what you are suggesting and don’t understand the concept of duty of care. To be honest the lack of interest in the welfare of others is indicative of the AIBU boards more generally, I’m sure in real life there’s a lot more interest in reasonable measures to prevent suicide.

The key word here is “reasonable”. Proper funding for mental health services that benefit everyone (including the many groups that have a higher suicide rate than university students) is something that most people can get on board with. What is not reasonable is the parent who was screaming down the phone at my colleague about our department’s apparently outdated system of having deadlines (even with a generous system of extensions) for assessed work which - she claimed - would drive her child to suicide. Making lecturers legally responsible for preventing an act of suicide as a response to a normal course expectation is not reasonable.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 04/03/2023 14:36

Notagardener · 04/03/2023 14:31

Well if they should be treated as any adult and parents not to be informed without their consent
I don't see why bother preventing any suicide. Up to the person killing themselves. Maybe we should make it clear easier for them.

DC starving herself but it's her choice, I should not interfere....

You can't compare a parent/child relationship to the relationship between a university and a student.