Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you too attend a candlelight vigil tomorrow evening in Edinburgh, Bristol or London

235 replies

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 19:54

.. for the 100 students every year who take their own lives every year.

The law needs to change so that Universities have a duty of care to their students.

Fine out more: www.forthe100.org.uk/vigil

I'm a very regular Mumsnetter who has name-changed to post this.

OP posts:
IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 08:41

Can I ask why the GP is not held responsible as the uni is?

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 08:36

I have every sympathy for those who work in Universities, the vast majority do a brilliant job, and I don't doubt that you are all under enormous pressure Spartacus.

But it is the processes and systems that need to be improved. Edinburgh Uni's own assessment in one tragic case:

"The university’s four-month review found that staff and systems were under-resourced and struggling to cope with an increase in overall student numbers, in particular numbers suffering from and disclosing mental health issues. It raised concerns that Ulvestad had no face-to-face contact with her personal tutor in her final academic year, describing it as “highly irregular”.

"It concluded: “There were opportunities both to respond more holistically to the information Romy actively disclosed about her mental health and wellbeing, and to monitor Romy’s ongoing situation more effectively, therefore allowing her to be identified as a student who was struggling and required additional support.”

www.theguardian.com/education/2021/mar/16/edinburgh-university-admits-failings-after-student-kills-herself-internal-review-support-mental-health

OP posts:
IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 08:33

How can we possibly make judgements about students who we rarely see?

You can't. We had suicide in a family. Family members spoke to him few hours before. People knew he wa "bit down" and helped him book a session with therapist.

While I agree that not notifying family when student wanted to was failure of the services, they are often overstretched too.

Agree with pps. This is just pushing blame from lack of NHS support onto uni who should not have these levels of responsibility. They do not usually have actual psychiatrists, of course.
When I spoke with our counselling they asked straight away if I was suicidal and if yes, they eill need to move me to appropriate service with NHS.

It's not overal uni failure, it's few specific service failures with notifications. And I am in doubt if that services are fully equipped anyway with the number of people they see and with them not being trained and qualified (officially) for this

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 08:20

How would they would have worked out if I was suicidal?

We would not. And it is not fair to put this burden on us and especially with legal consequences.

We are not trained for this, it is not our job and we are chronically overworked as is. How can we possibly make judgements about students who we rarely see?

When I get emails from students who are suicidal, in one case literally describing the view from the bridge the night before, we of course notify who we can and where possible checks are made.

No one cares about the effect on us by the way.

But I get a couple of hundred emails a week about different things and don't always answer them immediately. Often, I catch up on the weekend. Would I be at risk of legal consequences if I missed an email or did not respond until too late?

It's just unworkable.

Aphrathestorm - I'd second that.

Aphrathestorm · 05/03/2023 07:46

What I'd be more willing to sign is a requirement that police checks are carried out on students before they are admitted to halls of residence.

I know of at least one case where a uni allowed a known sex offender to live in halls.

UdoU · 05/03/2023 07:03

I don’t think my university professors or tutor knew anything about me. I only saw each one for up to 3 hours a week.

How would they would have worked out if I was suicidal?

JenniferBarkley · 05/03/2023 06:31

I absolutely agree that mental health services are a shambles, but a campaign to fix that should be focusing on the NHS and the government, not universities.

Universities are educational establishments, not healthcare. Our role is to help students who are struggling to complete their programme through adjustments like flexibility with deadlines, smaller exam settings etc - not to treat their mental ill health. If a student is unwell enough that those adjustments aren't enough then they should be taking a leave of absence until their health has sufficiently recovered.

anunlikelyseahorse · 05/03/2023 00:40

Op I'm sorry if you have had first hand experience of a loved one taking their own life.
I'm not sure if I've got this right, but when you refer to a 'duty of care' do you mean that if a student has said they are okay with their parents being informed of a mental health crisis, and the student then informs pastoral care or a lecturer that they are struggling, you would expect pastoral care or the lecturer to get in contact with the parent, so the parent can then get involved? On the face of it that would make sense and seems such a simple thing to implement; the problem is, something so seemingly simple is potentially far more complex.
But I whole heartedly agree we need to raise awareness, de stigmatised, and fund many more mental health services (the fact the government would save a vast amount of money if they put money into this area doesn't seem to compute with the powers that be...but that's for another thread).

bumblenbean · 04/03/2023 19:28

It’s tricky to know what this would look like in practice.

I had really bad anxiety and ocd throughout my 20s which started shortly before I started uni (almost 20 years ago!). I really struggled in halls. The porter was really nice and he’d do his best to check in on people he knew were struggling but there was only so much he could do. I saw the uni health service and they were reasonably helpful suggesting medication and referring for counselling. I can’t imagine what else the uni could have done - there’s no way the lecturers would have even known people were in a crisis unless the student disclosed this. Personal tutor maybe - but given a number of students struggle it must be hard for them to know who is at active risk of harm.

sadly a girl killed herself in my old halls (in fact my corridor) when I was in second year. The porter found her. That really effected me as it felt a bit ‘there but for the grace of god’. It turned out the porter had found several students who had died by suicide over the years. It must’ve been pretty traumatic and I wonder if he felt in some way responsible - but he wasn’t a psychiatrist and realistically what else could he have done?

It’s a very difficult topic but I can’t say I ever felt the uni should have been responsible for my mental health. If I told a lecturer I was suicidal I think the most i’d expect is for them to refer me to the uni health centre. However I don’t know what my parents would have felt had I killed myself when at uni- perhaps they would have felt the uni didn’t do enough. I imagine there’s a drive to find someone to ‘blame’ because the situation is so horrific.

Moonicorn · 04/03/2023 19:25

So is it just a case of informing parents if the student gives the green light to do so? Would changing the rules around medical confidentiality also apply to non-student under 21s? Or mature students? I don’t see that only applying it to under 21s who are at university is very fair?

Nimbostratus100 · 04/03/2023 19:06

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 22:31

I hope so, because ate the moment students at the University of Edinburgh are only allowed one visit to student mental health support per academic year.

Or you could put it this way

Edinburgh university provides every single one of its 50 000 students with free access to a mental health professional once every single year

In other words, a huge, voluntary, expensive investment in mental health

which if they have any sense, they will now ricind, as as rather than being seen as a generous act of support, they are being vilified for not doing more, and people think they should be blamed for student suicides

It is the typical response - do anything at all to help anyone, and you lay yourself open to the totally unreasonable demands to do far more, and a shedload of blame and possible legal action

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 04/03/2023 19:05

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 18:57

More rudeness, defensiveness and aggressive language from multiple posters who honestly seem to think students should all fuck off and die.

Are you all academics? Or are some of you “school of life, kids these days don’t know they are born”?

Can you please point out where the aggressiveness and rudeness was? Of course someone will get defensive.

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 19:03

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 18:57

More rudeness, defensiveness and aggressive language from multiple posters who honestly seem to think students should all fuck off and die.

Are you all academics? Or are some of you “school of life, kids these days don’t know they are born”?

You are the aggressive one. Nobody thinks students should fuck off and die.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/03/2023 19:01

Such hype... Literally nobody thinks students should just fuck off and die

yes, very offensive. No one has said that or thinks that.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 04/03/2023 18:59

It's not appropriate for universities to be in a position where they're communicating with parents. Students are adults who are responsible for themselves and for getting themselves help and support if they need

Yes, there are privacy concerns here too. If parents want to be more interventionist that’s their call. Having said that, in many cases where I hear about students’ emotional distress the parents play a big role in causing this.

Nimbostratus100 · 04/03/2023 18:59

This is the "duty of care" that universities owe employees, and students

check that all electrical equipment is maintained safely

provide PPE in labs when required

Use a properly trained gas fitter

etc etc etc etc

Beyond that, what is required between employer and employee - but students are not employees

Again, if I go for a hair cut, I should expect the saloon owner has maintained the electrical equipment safely, supplies PPE for any strong chemicals that need it, has used a properly registered gas fitter, etc

I can tell the hairdresser anything I want about my mental state, it isn't her business, it isn't her problem and it isn't her duty to respond

Just imagine the red tape nightmare if hairdressers had to assess the mental health of every customer, and respond in some way

Hair salons would be shut by administration overload within a few days

That would also happen to universities

I think universities have to some extent started providing more support services in recent decades, but this is voluntary, and in this current climate, with pressures like this put on them, they are far more likely to cut back and shut services, because rather than being something the offer for the possible benefit of some students, it is going to be something they are held accountable to, to a totally impossible level, which could cause them so much trouble

The logical thing to do in those circumstances would be to withdraw all support services and keep them closed

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 18:59

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 18:57

More rudeness, defensiveness and aggressive language from multiple posters who honestly seem to think students should all fuck off and die.

Are you all academics? Or are some of you “school of life, kids these days don’t know they are born”?

Such hype... Literally nobody thinks students should just fuck off and die.

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 18:57

More rudeness, defensiveness and aggressive language from multiple posters who honestly seem to think students should all fuck off and die.

Are you all academics? Or are some of you “school of life, kids these days don’t know they are born”?

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 18:54

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 18:48

Workplaces don't have to work with the recommendations of a doctor unless the recommendations are about “reasonable adjustments” if someone is disabled. Universities have to do that too.

Yes you're correct, I was being a bit optimistic there!

Nimbostratus100 · 04/03/2023 18:51

BigFeelingsMoment · 04/03/2023 17:24

The kind of things that “duty of care” refers to in an employment context include

  • Healthy working environment
  • Good practice with Rotas eg not allowing people to work 72 hours without a break
  • Access to occupational health, work-related counselling
  • Reasonable adjustments to role, environment etc
  • Organising welfare checks if someone is unexpectedly absent
  • Kindness and pastoral support if someone isn’t “acting themself” at work

A pp is right that it isn’t right that universities have more legal responsibility for their employees than their students.

what planet are you on where employers offer welfare checks on someone who is absent, or respond kindly if someone "isn't themselves" at work!

as to 72 hours without a break, that only applies on the premises, not off.

orchid220 · 04/03/2023 18:48

bellac11 · 04/03/2023 18:17

Sorry also they dont have to supply OH but obviously would work with the employee to implement recommendations by their own doctor if necessary

Workplaces don't have to work with the recommendations of a doctor unless the recommendations are about “reasonable adjustments” if someone is disabled. Universities have to do that too.

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 18:35

Complete silence from op on the "what exactly do you want from them" front.

Fladdermus · 04/03/2023 18:30

According to the relevant professional body they already have a legal duty of reasonable care for regular students and a duty of enhanced care for vulnerable students. What other legal duties of care do you think they should have?

univwww.amosshe.org.uk/resources/Documents/AMOSSHE_Duty_of_Care_2001.pdf

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 04/03/2023 18:26

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:21

that doesn't seem to be OPs position, she has mentioned several times about universities contacting parents and wanting them to act as parents to the student

I have not said that. I have explicitly stated that the petition is NOT calling for unis to be in loco parentis.

Some posters have inferred this, but what I said was that there were some situations where students had given consent for unis to contact their parents with mental health concerns, and they had not done this. And the students had gone on to take their own lives, when the parents felt that they might have been able to prevent it had they been told what the uni knew.

But you're just repeating yourself without actually saying what it is you want them to do.

It's not appropriate for universities to be in a position where they're communicating with parents. Students are adults who are responsible for themselves and for getting themselves help and support if they need.

It's not the job of the university to get involved and act as the middle-man anymore than it's an employers' job to contact someone's spouse if they're concerned about their MH.

ReadersD1gest · 04/03/2023 18:22

Sophforthe100 · 04/03/2023 18:21

that doesn't seem to be OPs position, she has mentioned several times about universities contacting parents and wanting them to act as parents to the student

I have not said that. I have explicitly stated that the petition is NOT calling for unis to be in loco parentis.

Some posters have inferred this, but what I said was that there were some situations where students had given consent for unis to contact their parents with mental health concerns, and they had not done this. And the students had gone on to take their own lives, when the parents felt that they might have been able to prevent it had they been told what the uni knew.

Again; what additional responsibilities do you want them to take on?