Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you too attend a candlelight vigil tomorrow evening in Edinburgh, Bristol or London

235 replies

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 19:54

.. for the 100 students every year who take their own lives every year.

The law needs to change so that Universities have a duty of care to their students.

Fine out more: www.forthe100.org.uk/vigil

I'm a very regular Mumsnetter who has name-changed to post this.

OP posts:
GailBlancheViola · 05/03/2023 10:15

It all feels very knee jerky, ‘someone else should have done more’ but not being able to say what or why.

I agree, the crux of it is this someone else should have done something and therefore there is this someone else who is made responsible and to blame.

JarByTheDoor · 05/03/2023 09:51

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:40

It’s a bit like saying I’m being failed by my dentist so I want Boots to take statutory liability for the care of my teeth because they sell toothpaste and their pharmacists can advise on minor matters such as mouth ulcers and denture care.

It makes no sense, would overburden a service not intended for that purpose and would actually result in poorer outcomes for the patients involved.

And as I mentioned above and have personal experience of, would (analagously) allow the dentist an excuse to refuse to provide necessary services that should be provided by those with dental expertise, because they know you have access to Boots.

GCAcademic · 05/03/2023 09:50

@Moonicorn Yes, I agree. No one on here is asking anything that wouldn’t naturally be raised in Parliament, by universities and in the press. These are reasonable questions to ask when legislation is being proposed, not people being mean.

JenniferBarkley · 05/03/2023 09:49

OP, can you give some concrete examples of what you want universities to do?

Because I'm betting that it will either be things they already do (like provide support services over and above the NHS services supposedly available to us all) or just not possible like breaking confidentiality.

University isn't school, if 150 out of 200 students turn up for a lecture that's actually very good, we don't go chasing the other 50. They've chosen not to come, that's their decision. We do actually get in touch with students who have bad engagement but if they don't respond or disclose whatever is going on, what can we do? If they do disclose something then we direct them to people who are actually trained to deal with that and then look after the academic side in terms of extensions etc.

What exactly is it that you want us to do differently?

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:46

@GCAcademic i think if you’re participating in a campaign that you expect to be debated in Parliament then enacted in universities across the country placing enormous responsibility on them, you should expect to be robustly challenged regardless of personal circumstances. You can have every sympathy for someone affected by suicide, but disagree with the aims of their campaign, and everyone has given OP a fair chance to explain but it seems she can’t. It all feels very knee jerky, ‘someone else should have done more’ but not being able to say what or why.

I’m also worried about how it would open university workers to prosecution which I feel would be deeply unfair. What about them?

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:40

It’s a bit like saying I’m being failed by my dentist so I want Boots to take statutory liability for the care of my teeth because they sell toothpaste and their pharmacists can advise on minor matters such as mouth ulcers and denture care.

It makes no sense, would overburden a service not intended for that purpose and would actually result in poorer outcomes for the patients involved.

GCAcademic · 05/03/2023 09:38

freckles20 · 05/03/2023 09:28

OP I'm sorry that there have been so many insensitive and deliberately obtuse posts on this thread.

Whilst I'm sure that this isn't a simple subject a little compassion and thought wouldn't go amiss.

Sometimes it seems people are hellbent on disagreeing in a thoughtless way rather than being constructive.

But the OP just keeps repeating the phrase ”duty of care” and refuses to explain what she means.

Perhaps you can explain if you think everyone else here is so hard of understanding? I am certainly not being deliberately obtuse, I genuinely don’t understand what the OP thinks I, as an academic, should be doing (and currently lack) to “teach with reasonable care and skill” and what the specific “duty of care” I receive as an employee is that a student doesn’t (particularly when staff counselling, for example, has been removed to focus on provision for students at my university).

I doubt that anyone on here feels anything other than sympathy for the OP if she has personal experience of this, but the answer is not to make bad laws to try to assuage anyone’s pain, especially when that risks making criminals out of people who are not health professionals.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 09:36

Universities have a legal duty of care to their staff. They do not have a legal duty of care to their students.

Around and around again we go.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:35

They shouldn’t be tough questions - these are exactly the things that would be discussed in parliamentary debate so you need answers to them for this to go anywhere.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:34

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 09:23

GPs, and all medical professionals, already have a duty of care to their patients.

Universities have a legal duty of care to their staff. They do not have a legal duty of care to their students.

We want this issues to be properly debated in parliament, that's the point of the petition.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/622847

You keep repeating this over and over, yet fail to say
a) why a non-medical institution should take statutory responsibility for the medical issues of their students
b) what that responsibility would actually involved beyond telling their parents
c) why you’re not instead campaigning to improve the system that is actually designed to treat MH issues, rather than their place of learning which is not?

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 09:34

This would unmuddy the water, make sure parents are 100% aware that this is not a place their offspring can go, that they need to go to the NHS

I totally agree.

I think it actually has the potential to lead to poorer outcomes by muddying the waters of patient confidentiality,

Many of the students I speak with have mental health issues that partly stem from their family life/parents. These include being pressured to do courses they do not want to do or to succeed academically when they are out of their depth. Sometimes parents don't respect the choice to go to university. Sometimes they don't accept their DC's sexuality or choices around religion. Sometimes parents are simply abusive or toxic in other ways.

These are not parents who should be informed of issues concerning their adult children unless very explicit and uncoerced consent is given.

But most of all it muddies the water concerning consent and confidentiality.

freckles20 · 05/03/2023 09:28

OP I'm sorry that there have been so many insensitive and deliberately obtuse posts on this thread.

Whilst I'm sure that this isn't a simple subject a little compassion and thought wouldn't go amiss.

Sometimes it seems people are hellbent on disagreeing in a thoughtless way rather than being constructive.

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 09:27

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 09:23

GPs, and all medical professionals, already have a duty of care to their patients.

Universities have a legal duty of care to their staff. They do not have a legal duty of care to their students.

We want this issues to be properly debated in parliament, that's the point of the petition.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/622847

So why is everyone going after unies and not the gps these students are visiting.
What is the rationale.

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 09:23

GPs, and all medical professionals, already have a duty of care to their patients.

Universities have a legal duty of care to their staff. They do not have a legal duty of care to their students.

We want this issues to be properly debated in parliament, that's the point of the petition.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/622847

OP posts:
GCAcademic · 05/03/2023 09:21

Nimbostratus100 · 05/03/2023 09:04

I think the answer is for universities to back out from all support offered, and withdraw all of this type of services.

This would unmuddy the water, make sure parents are 100% aware that this is not a place their offspring can go, that they need to go to the NHS

Universities can no longer be blamed if things go wrong

universities can concentrate their time, energy and resources on research and education

I agree with this.

As another PP has mentioned, the personal tutor system was never intended to support students with complex mental health needs. It was intended to provide the student with someone who has academic oversight of their progress over the course of the degree and who can offer advice on academic matters. Academics are not mental health professionals, and there is a high level of poor mental health within the profession itself.

Universities have put significant funds into student mental health support in the absence of a functioning NHS. That was a largely voluntary act (and pushed for by academics, amongst others). But if the logical progression of this is to make them legally liable for suicide, then they will understandably pull back from offering these services and re-draw and insist upon their boundaries as fundamentally research and teaching institutions.

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 09:17

bonjello · 05/03/2023 09:09

I guess coz GP surgeries are a bit crap at the moment. (Not their fault they need better funding).

But again yes maybe the answer should be improving the GP services.

I agree with you that making the university legally responsible seems a step too far.

It says in article she went to GP. It would be logocally assumption she kept going there or at least went more than once.

Why is the gp not accountable as uni? All are under pressures.

I agree with everyone, the best would be to campaign for better MH services with NHS. Random uni staff shouldn't be expected to deal with suicidal students or staff and be held accountable for the sad outcomes.

But signposting could be worked on. Again tho. Signposting to what since everything is under pressure

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 09:17

Nimbostratus100 · 05/03/2023 09:04

I think the answer is for universities to back out from all support offered, and withdraw all of this type of services.

This would unmuddy the water, make sure parents are 100% aware that this is not a place their offspring can go, that they need to go to the NHS

Universities can no longer be blamed if things go wrong

universities can concentrate their time, energy and resources on research and education

I totally agree with this. By doing a sort of drip here and there it does completely muddy the waters. The patheway for MH treatment in the UK is via the GP and MH teams. There shouldnt be any confusion about this

bonjello · 05/03/2023 09:09

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:07

Why not at the GP though?

I guess coz GP surgeries are a bit crap at the moment. (Not their fault they need better funding).

But again yes maybe the answer should be improving the GP services.

I agree with you that making the university legally responsible seems a step too far.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:07

bonjello · 05/03/2023 09:06

That's a good point.

Maybe the answer is more MH support in unis. I don't know how they'd go about that.

Why not at the GP though?

bonjello · 05/03/2023 09:06

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:05

In fact, sorry OP but the more I’ve thought about this, the less of a good idea it seems. And it’s actually a little worrying that you intend to impose this level of responsibility on universities and then what - have them prosecuted if a student sadly takes their own lives? I think it actually has the potential to lead to poorer outcomes by muddying the waters of patient confidentiality, taking on students with significant MH issues that they’re simply unable to cope with, and students relying on a much smaller and under equipped service than if they went to their GP. I actually think it has the potential to go badly wrong.

That's a good point.

Maybe the answer is more MH support in unis. I don't know how they'd go about that.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:05

In fact, sorry OP but the more I’ve thought about this, the less of a good idea it seems. And it’s actually a little worrying that you intend to impose this level of responsibility on universities and then what - have them prosecuted if a student sadly takes their own lives? I think it actually has the potential to lead to poorer outcomes by muddying the waters of patient confidentiality, taking on students with significant MH issues that they’re simply unable to cope with, and students relying on a much smaller and under equipped service than if they went to their GP. I actually think it has the potential to go badly wrong.

Nimbostratus100 · 05/03/2023 09:04

I think the answer is for universities to back out from all support offered, and withdraw all of this type of services.

This would unmuddy the water, make sure parents are 100% aware that this is not a place their offspring can go, that they need to go to the NHS

Universities can no longer be blamed if things go wrong

universities can concentrate their time, energy and resources on research and education

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 09:00

There were opportunities both to respond more holistically to the information Romy actively disclosed about her mental health and wellbeing, and to monitor Romy’s ongoing situation more effectively, therefore allowing her to be identified as a student who was struggling and required additional support.

Opportunities but not the resources, basically? You’d be better off campaigning for better NHS provision for MH in young people, with universities only expected to signpost (I think they do this anyway).

That way they’ll be following a proper treatment program, have access to medication, have continuity of care rather than shuttling between GP/uni, and access to MH professionals who deal with more significant MH issues.

Would campaigning for an improved NHS pathway not be a much better aim? And even for their GP to have permission to contact parents if needs be, given they hold all their medical notes anyway and have a much better understanding of medical confidentiality and when it would be appropriate?

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 08:57

The university’s four-month review found that staff and systems were under-resourced and struggling to cope with an increase in overall student numbers, in particular numbers suffering from and disclosing mental health issues.

So the answer is to impose more responsibility and statutory responsibility on them? Confused

If anything, another reason why using universities as mental health treatment facilities is a bad idea?

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 08:47

This was all very sad and I'm familiar with similar cases.

However, I don't agree that the buck stops with the university and I think that the personal tutor system is doing things it was initially never designed to do - including dealing with students with complex issues including mental health-related ones.

I'd like to see universities push back and demand proper services instead of taking on responsibilities and passing these on to staff, who are not trained and whose role it is to teach and not make mental health referrals.

With respect, the parents also admit they should have been more vigilant and aware.