Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you too attend a candlelight vigil tomorrow evening in Edinburgh, Bristol or London

235 replies

Sophforthe100 · 03/03/2023 19:54

.. for the 100 students every year who take their own lives every year.

The law needs to change so that Universities have a duty of care to their students.

Fine out more: www.forthe100.org.uk/vigil

I'm a very regular Mumsnetter who has name-changed to post this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BigGreen · 05/03/2023 17:40

Lots of university teaching is done by precarious workers that are paid a low rate per module. It's really hard to imagine how unis deliver these kinds of suggestions without a great deal of reform.

CMO · 05/03/2023 13:50

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 09:23

GPs, and all medical professionals, already have a duty of care to their patients.

Universities have a legal duty of care to their staff. They do not have a legal duty of care to their students.

We want this issues to be properly debated in parliament, that's the point of the petition.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/622847

OP, the petition is nowhere near the number of signatures it requires. That's probably because people don't agree with the premise that unis should be responsible for what you are describing. Employers also do't have a "duty of care" for employees. They have responsibilities under various peices of legislation but not a"duty of care"

SmotheringHeights · 05/03/2023 13:19

Disagree about making universities somehow liable and ‘a safe place’. Sadly, if a young person is minded to take their own life, nowhere will be a safe place and nothing will prevent them doing so.
Employer liability is entirely different to what is being discussed here.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 13:04

Or for someone employed to teach and research

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 12:46

A fail to act in a duty of care resulting in death would result in a charge of gross negligence manslaughter against either an organisation or individuals working in it. I’m really not sure that’s appropriate for a person employed to offer counselling sessions for mild to moderate MH issues and general student support. A person who isn’t qualified to prescribe medication, provide more complex counselling or diagnose anything. And I can’t see anyone wanting to work in such a job where that hangs over their head all the time. I think it’s grossly disproportionate.

anunlikelyseahorse · 05/03/2023 12:34

I was not really wanting to spell this out as I don't want to come across as crass and insensitive, but here are the issues with these point:

• If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.
The problem here is a potential man-slaughter charge. A student tells their tutor they feel suicidal. The tutor is unable to reach a parent (it would be totally inappropriate to leave a message on an answer phone) tutor then has other work to do and then is whizzing out of the door forgetting they haven't made contact with a parent. Student takes their own life and now we have a tutor who is potentially indirectly responsible, and could legally face a man-slaughter charge.
You would also need a signed document from the student saying it's okay to inform parents, otherwise the tutor could face disciplinary charges for breaking confidentiality, then the signed doc might be null and void because the student could argue they weren't compos mentis at the time, so now a tutor has to know the laws around capacity and would need to fill out a capacity assessment.
Then there is note keeping, where does the tutor record they've tried to contact the parent. Etc etc. as I previously mentioned it's not straightforward.

• if the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration. I can't answer for all universities, but having been a uni student a few times, being 'sent-down' only happens in extremis, but if someone is not engaging what are the uni meant to do, how else do they reach the student if they are not attending classes or answering emails / haven't requested a deferral etc? I'm fully aware that spiralling mental health means engaging with tutors / lectures / pastoral care even health care professionals can be nigh on impossible, it's a very tricky situation and there isn't an easy answer to this.

• If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.
If support services haven't managed to help resolve the issue, then it would be potentially unethical to keep offering a service that isn't working. I don't know if the university support services are run by actual qualified healthcare professionals, if so they should be able to refer on to NHS services. If they are more a support team without clinical training, then there are problems with record keeping and confidentiality.

Yes better funding is needed. Having out reach mental health teams visiting universities on a weekly basis could be a way forward. But you can't put the onus on lecturers/ tutors or pastoral care to support illnesses. I wouldn't expect a tutor to give me crutches for my broken leg, because it's not their remit.

Mental health is very complicated, it needs more research, it needs de-stigmatising, it needs a ton of money poured into. We all need much better understanding, but putting the onus on universities is not the answer. Blaming parent is abhorrent. This is an illness, it's no one's fault.

Fladdermus · 05/03/2023 12:20

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:21

Here are a few examples then - although I expect the Uni employees who keep being defensive on these points will have a response to them:

  1. If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.
  2. If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.
  3. If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.

Many Universities have excellent policies in place for safeguarding student mental health - but they are not legally required to follow the guidance.

They are adults. If they want their parents to be informed about their mental health problems then they should inform their parents themselves. They are at university not in childcare.

You seem to expect university to fill the void left by failures in NHS mental health services. It is not their responsibility. They are neither a student's parent nor their psychotherapist.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 12:19

I’m also very interested as to why this wouldn’t apply to under 21 non-students, or whether it would apply to mature students of say 35. We can’t have separate processes for non-students, their lives are just as valuable and if parents being informed is so beneficial shouldn’t their GPs have the power to do the same? In which case this all becomes a debate about medical confidentiality and Gillick competence rather than anything specific to universities?

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 12:13

By the way, I say all of this as someone who struggled badly with their MH at university and who accessed support both on and off campus. It wasn't my tutors job to speak to my parents for me, just as it wasn't my GP's job to talk to them for me.

My university was unable to offer me regular support so I went to see my GP and got help that way. That was my responsibility as an adult. I also spoke to my parents and told them I was struggling. Yes, it was hard and I'm not saying otherwise, but we can't place the full responsibility for a students' MH problems on a university. They can (and do) offer appropriate support but it's not their job to act as go-betweens.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 05/03/2023 12:10

If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.

I see the logic behind this, but students are adults - it's their responsibility to speak to their parents if they feel like they're struggling. It's not the job of a tutor/lecturer to spend time looking for their parents information and speak to them. I think it's a bit different if a student is under eighteen or has special needs/other disabilities/vulnerabilities that the university was aware of when they applied, though.

If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.

I can agree with this, but I suspect the e-mail being sent is an automated process that's triggered by a certain number of absences or a certain number of failing grades/courses. That's not to say it's okay, but I suspect it's not being done out of malice.

If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year

Universities support thousands and thousands of students each year - they don't necessarily have the facilities or staff available to offer regular appointments to all of them. If students need further support, they can be signposted to their local GP or some kind of therapy. The fact that those services are also underfunded and hard to come by is not the fault of the university and they shouldn't be expected to pick up the pieces.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 12:01

You keep repeating this without specifying what you think universities have to legally provide to staff in terms of "duty of care" that they don't have to provide to students. Do you think that if a member of staff committed suicide the university would be held responsible for not doing enough to prevent it?

Exactly.

orchid220 · 05/03/2023 11:14

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 09:23

GPs, and all medical professionals, already have a duty of care to their patients.

Universities have a legal duty of care to their staff. They do not have a legal duty of care to their students.

We want this issues to be properly debated in parliament, that's the point of the petition.

petition.parliament.uk/petitions/622847

You keep repeating this without specifying what you think universities have to legally provide to staff in terms of "duty of care" that they don't have to provide to students. Do you think that if a member of staff committed suicide the university would be held responsible for not doing enough to prevent it?

TrashyPanda · 05/03/2023 11:07

how does the proposed “duty of care” for universities work for students living at home?

wouldnt the parents for more in-depth knowledge of their own child?

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 10:56

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:40

Please don't blame parents for their children's suicide.

I'm sure there is not one parent who's child has suffered from any MH issues who has not already asked themselves if they were to blame or should not have done things different.

I dont blame parents at all, not sure where you are getting that from. Suicide is always the choice of the deceased.

But you're opening a can of worms as someone says above, if you expect the Uni to have a statutory duty to inform parents where consent is given, whose statutory duty does the follow up from that come from? The parents, the student, the uni?

What if the parents dont respond, what if they respond i the wrong way, what if the student changes their mind or denies they gave consent. Can someone sign a disclaimer, what if later someone says 'well they didnt have capacity due to their mental state to make any decisions like this'. Surely you can see this is a massive can of worms to involve a 3rd party into information sharing on a medical matter?

If the student wants their parents to know then they need to inform them. If they dont, then thats their choice.

Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 10:50

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:40

Please don't blame parents for their children's suicide.

I'm sure there is not one parent who's child has suffered from any MH issues who has not already asked themselves if they were to blame or should not have done things different.

I agree, but I don’t think blaming the university is any fairer either. When faced with a grieving parents it’s difficult to disagree without looking heartless, so it’s hard for them to defend themselves here. It’s always going to be a case of ‘we could have done more’ as that’s a standard reply by any organisation when faced with something like this, but it doesn’t mean they didn’t do an adequate job or what was reasonably expected of them.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 10:47

If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents

Who should do this? How is all this to be resourced in a system already stretched to the limits? How is that consent verified? I agree with a PP who said this could be best practice if it was clear that consent was given and given freely but it should not be an expectation or mandated.

If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.

I agree that the email communication given to students is shocking and often legalistic but I don't think this is a matter for legislation.

If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.

WHO PAYS FOR ALL THIS? Have you any idea what the waiting lists are like? There are often waits of several months for an appointment. What about all those students waiting in the queue who might be suicidal? The queue is there because of inadequate external support.

Focusing on shoring up NHS support is the real way to go. Not relying on the university to be a mental health provider!

My thinking on this is the same like "why don't they temporarily withdraw".
Because parents are "oh so proud darling" or "you must go to uni we all did" and they don't want to disappoint them by not managing.

Yep. I see a lot of this!

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 10:46

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:40

Please don't blame parents for their children's suicide.

I'm sure there is not one parent who's child has suffered from any MH issues who has not already asked themselves if they were to blame or should not have done things different.

I don't blame parents for their children's suicide.
Simply pointing out that maybe the issues are bit more complex than just uni and individuals like tutors getting the blame.

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:40

Please don't blame parents for their children's suicide.

I'm sure there is not one parent who's child has suffered from any MH issues who has not already asked themselves if they were to blame or should not have done things different.

OP posts:
IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 10:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:36

There have been failings in GP care as well as Unis. No one is saying they don't have a responsibility too.

www.leighday.co.uk/news/news/2022-news/student-theo-brennan-hulme-was-failed-by-university-of-east-anglia-and-norwich-health-care-trust-say-parents/

OP posts:
Moonicorn · 05/03/2023 10:32

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:21

Here are a few examples then - although I expect the Uni employees who keep being defensive on these points will have a response to them:

  1. If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.
  2. If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.
  3. If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.

Many Universities have excellent policies in place for safeguarding student mental health - but they are not legally required to follow the guidance.

I can possibly get on board with 1 and 2 although I wouldn’t want them imposed as a statutory duty, more a ‘best practice’. I suppose the glaring question is if a student wants their parents to know they’re having a MH crisis, why don’t they tell their parents themselves? If the parents are expected to act having received this communication does the statutory responsibility then transfer to them? If not, why not? What if a deeply distressed student agrees for them to be contacted only to change their mind but it has been done? Would they sign a disclaimer? What would be disclosed, full notes or just ‘your child is mentally unwell’?

As for dismissing them I can see how putting it on ice would help but again, that’s not a statutory responsibility as such, more internal procedure that the university is entitled to dictate for itself. What if the student in question has behaved in a threatening manner towards fellow students due to their MH issues? Do they expel them or are they forced to keep them on because of their MH struggles? Does this apply to diagnosed conditions only, as with any other ‘extenuating circumstances’ type process?

As for 3, mental health issues are rarely ‘resolved’ within a matter of weeks or months so I think that’s wholly unrealistic. This is absolutely the point at which care should be through the GP, you still haven’t said why universities should or are equipped to deal with long running mental health problems.

My issue with making all this a legal obligation is that it is basically unenforceable and as PP said, transfers the NHS duty of care to an institution fundamentally not there to do it.

bellac11 · 05/03/2023 10:32

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:21

Here are a few examples then - although I expect the Uni employees who keep being defensive on these points will have a response to them:

  1. If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.
  2. If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.
  3. If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.

Many Universities have excellent policies in place for safeguarding student mental health - but they are not legally required to follow the guidance.

Its the students reponsiblity to inform parents, consent or not. I dont agree that universities should be involved in that.

I would imagine that Universities dismiss students with a lot of consideration, moreso if they know the student has been ill. Presumably the student is signed off sick by their GP if they are not able to continue? If not, why not?

I dont agree with the 3rd point either. The student should be signposted to their GP or other support systems which are available. There may be universities who can offer ongoinng support but there will be others who simply dont have this available.

IHaveaSetOfVeryParticularSkills · 05/03/2023 10:31

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:21

Here are a few examples then - although I expect the Uni employees who keep being defensive on these points will have a response to them:

  1. If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.
  2. If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.
  3. If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.

Many Universities have excellent policies in place for safeguarding student mental health - but they are not legally required to follow the guidance.

I am not uni lecturer, was a student who actually used the services.

Few points

  1. Yes, possible failure, however, the student if suicidal should be supported by more trained medical professionals via NHS and local MH unit who then should be contacting parents if the student wishes to. This is though an individual failure not whole industry failure. Uni wellbeing services are not, and should not be acting as MH crisis unit.
  2. Again, individual failure, but yes, process should be better. Can't see how you legislate for this though...
  3. No. They should be signposted to GP to get support. Unies should, in my opinion, deal with some basic stress and signpost rest back to NHS. Since you keep comparing it to employers, this would be exactly the same. See point 1

Frankly, very frankly, it just feels like people are looking to point fingers. When suicide happens, it often leaves more questions than answers. It's understandable to know why. But this is not the correct way.

Now I ask again. Why is only uni responsible and not the GP the girl visited.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 05/03/2023 10:25

Here are a few examples then - although I expect the Uni employees who keep being defensive on these points will have a response to them:

FFS. We are not being 'defensive'. We are pointing out obvious flaws in the idea from the perspective of being inside the system - in other words we have expert knowledge about something we are invested in and which will affect us.

Sophforthe100 · 05/03/2023 10:21

Here are a few examples then - although I expect the Uni employees who keep being defensive on these points will have a response to them:

  1. If a student has given consent for the parents to be informed about their mental health problems and they know the student is suicidal, inform the parents.
  2. If the University is aware a student is having a severe mental health crisis then do not continue with the process of dismissing them from the University - by email - without consideration.
  3. If a student has visited support services with a mental health issue that has not been resolved, do not tell them they cannot have a follow up appointment with Uni support services until the next academic year.

Many Universities have excellent policies in place for safeguarding student mental health - but they are not legally required to follow the guidance.

OP posts: