Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was it my fault she died?

236 replies

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:26

I really love my mum. However I did not grow up with her, I grew up with my grandparents (saw my mum every week) and we did not have a conventional mother daughter relationship as a result. There was pain and hurt there when I was a young adult at times, although we had loads of fun together too.

She preferred to have firm boundaries around me, I think. I was always welcome for visits but her house wasn't my home. I am ashamed of this because it's childish and pathetic but I craved being 100% fully wanted by her and felt such deep shame that she didn't want me living with her. My siblings lived with her and it's like a blank space in my mind that can't work out why I was not "worth it" on the same level as they were.

I know this is just nonsense obviously as an adult and don't believe that has anything to do with my worth - but sometimes it still hits me over the head and I just feel so ashamed and distressed. It embarrasses me.

We developed a great relationship later on. However, by this time I had grown up and learned how to enjoy the relationship for all the good things it was, and let go of the rest.

But a big part of this was never, ever arguing with my mum or pressing my opinion on her - I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first. I reckon I was guilty of that for years as was demanding, always needing support. I am 100% aware that I was a shit person in that respect.

When she got sick she was very appreciative of my support which I was glad to do, but I was always too afraid to argue with her and push her. She was very keen to explore all options which we did together and did a virtual appointment with a very good doctor, but I didn't push her to move to a bigger hospital.

Maybe if I had REALLY pushed her, she would have gone and even if she had stopped talking to me, she might still be alive?

The other thing is maybe I should have been pushier about going to her town and actually going with her to appointments but again I was afraid. There was nowhere for me to stay and due to my own disability I can't drive.

But really - I prioritised my own disability and my own health. Having no access to my own doctors and things I need to manage my own health makes my own disability worse so I just put myself first. Again, if I had navigated things in a better way, would she possibly still be alive?

Am I just a shit daughter?

OP posts:
LilyPark · 03/03/2023 22:16

"But a big part of this was never, ever arguing with my mum or pressing my opinion on her - I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first. I reckon I was guilty of that for years as was demanding, always needing support. I am 100% aware that I was a shit person in that respect."

Op, I hope this does not come off as disrespectful to your mother and I obviously am just going on what you have said here, but It might be useful to look at narcissistic personality disorder and see if anything resonates with you there about your mum and how that might have affected your self esteem.

Mummyof287 · 03/03/2023 22:16

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:26

I really love my mum. However I did not grow up with her, I grew up with my grandparents (saw my mum every week) and we did not have a conventional mother daughter relationship as a result. There was pain and hurt there when I was a young adult at times, although we had loads of fun together too.

She preferred to have firm boundaries around me, I think. I was always welcome for visits but her house wasn't my home. I am ashamed of this because it's childish and pathetic but I craved being 100% fully wanted by her and felt such deep shame that she didn't want me living with her. My siblings lived with her and it's like a blank space in my mind that can't work out why I was not "worth it" on the same level as they were.

I know this is just nonsense obviously as an adult and don't believe that has anything to do with my worth - but sometimes it still hits me over the head and I just feel so ashamed and distressed. It embarrasses me.

We developed a great relationship later on. However, by this time I had grown up and learned how to enjoy the relationship for all the good things it was, and let go of the rest.

But a big part of this was never, ever arguing with my mum or pressing my opinion on her - I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first. I reckon I was guilty of that for years as was demanding, always needing support. I am 100% aware that I was a shit person in that respect.

When she got sick she was very appreciative of my support which I was glad to do, but I was always too afraid to argue with her and push her. She was very keen to explore all options which we did together and did a virtual appointment with a very good doctor, but I didn't push her to move to a bigger hospital.

Maybe if I had REALLY pushed her, she would have gone and even if she had stopped talking to me, she might still be alive?

The other thing is maybe I should have been pushier about going to her town and actually going with her to appointments but again I was afraid. There was nowhere for me to stay and due to my own disability I can't drive.

But really - I prioritised my own disability and my own health. Having no access to my own doctors and things I need to manage my own health makes my own disability worse so I just put myself first. Again, if I had navigated things in a better way, would she possibly still be alive?

Am I just a shit daughter?

Of course you're not a shit daughter, why shouldn't you put yourself first? She never put you first when you needed her to!

And you are not childish, pathetic, talking nonsense....don't downplay what she did to you and the way she rejected you.That is an incredibly emotionally damaging and cruel way to treat a child.Do you know why your siblings were allowed to be with her and you weren't?

It sounds like you are still carrying alot of guilt and have low self worth if you are blaming yourself so much and dismissing the difficult feelings you are more than entitled to have.

I'm so sorry you went through what you did, my heart goes out to 'little you' 😔❤️

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 22:14

I hope this doesn't sound too bizarre but a part of you may even (totally unconciously) have wanted to inflict pain on her in retaliation for the intense pain she caused you, and this may be why you are feeling guilty now, as if your feelings may have somehow caused your mother's death.

I have questioned myself almost obsessively over this, trying to search out in case I unconsciously acted from a place of revenge or badness or some other horrific motivation, and I honestly don't think so.

But I suppose if it was unconscious I wouldn't know so I would say that wouldn't I? Hence, the uncertainty about something being lacking in me.

I genuinely believe I was trying to operate really carefully in a way that wouldn't alienate my mum. The bit that makes me wonder if it's my fault is more that I was too hesitant in fear of provoking that alienation. So I prioritised my need to not be cut off from her.

Whereas, if I'd pushed ahead maybe I could have convinced her, even if she was fucking angry at me and never spoke to me again...

But, as many people on this thread have said, they were her choices to make. It wasn't really my responsibility to push and push and push. I do know that in a way, it's just hard.

OP posts:
TongueTwistr · 03/03/2023 22:13

@howcaniknow When you say 'I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first.' I would suspect that you have been the victim of a narcissistic parent.

From painful, personal experience, I'm sure that rather than disappointing her in any way, you performed exactly the role that she wanted of you. Controlling parents often manipulate others to the grave and beyond.

By all means grieve for her, but I don't think that you have anything to feel guilty for. Be kind to yourself.

ThereIbledit · 03/03/2023 22:13

I have so many things I want to say to you about all of this but mainly I just want to wrap you up in a big hug.

It is 100% normal to have conflicting feelings about your mum when you've had the childhood and life that you have had. Really, totally completely normal. All of your feelings are valid and are allowed. That is healthy. Even the ones that those of us looking in from the outside can see are based on beliefs that we think are untrue, and terribly unkind against yourself. You weren't a shit daughter to your mum. I don't think that you were a demanding child - but you are allowed to feel all of these feelings and to process it all properly. That is normal, that is healthy.

On the subject of her medical treatment before her death: It sounds like she made healthcare choices for herself. We are all allowed to do that, even including choices that by accident or by informed choice lead to a shorter life than other choices may have led to. It sounds like you did things brilliantly - worked through the options with her, helped her to make a choice and tried to guide her without taking over. Those are wonderfully loving actions. It would have been worse to have forced her to go to a hospital that she didn't want to go to, and there is no guarantee that the outcome would have been better; it may have been worse. Quality of life is not measured by quantity.

I'm glad you have said you will get some therapy, I think there's a lot for you to unpack and that having a supportive therapist to do that with will really help you. I'm glad it's helping to talk it through on here, too. xxx

Gemls3123 · 03/03/2023 22:07

It is easy to blame yourself. You are stronger than that. Look after yourself foremost. If you don’t look after yourself you can’t be expected to be able to help others.

LilyPark · 03/03/2023 22:05

OP you experienced a deeply and profoundly painful rejection by your mother that cannot be underestimated. And it is compounded by the fact that it doesn't seem clear why you were sent away whilst your siblings were not As well as feeling a great amount of love for your mother, it would be extremely natural for a part of you to feel intense anger, even hatred, towards her as well but feel too guilty about those emotions to be conciously aware of them. I hope this doesn't sound too bizarre but a part of you may even (totally unconciously) have wanted to inflict pain on her in retaliation for the intense pain she caused you, and this may be why you are feeling guilty now, as if your feelings may have somehow caused your mother's death. YOU ARE NOT TO BLAME. As others have said I hope you can find a good therapist to help you work through these feelings and can use this event as a catalyst for your own healing. Please don't ever downplay what happened to you as a child. YOU ARE A GOOD AND WORTHWHILE HUMAN BEING WHO DESERVES LOVE.

Letstaketotheskies · 03/03/2023 22:03

OP it sounds like both your mum and your grandma loved you lots and wanted the best for you and that it wasn’t always easy for either of them to know what the best thing to do was for a baby born to such a young mum who also needed to finish her education and get established in life. But both of them were trying hard, in their own ways, to help you grow and learn and have a happy, safe, secure childhood. And from the sounds of things they mostly succeeded? Some things, like how your father behaved, were beyond their control, and it was inevitable that they didn’t always agree perfectly on every issue that cropped up. But, without invalidating the complicated feelings you understandably have around how you were raised, do you feel that both your mum and grandma loved you and wanted you to be happy and successful in life? Because that’s something to hold on to.

frankenburgers · 03/03/2023 21:59

user1471453601 · 03/03/2023 19:46

Sorry, opening poster. I voted yanbu. Not at all because you were a shit daughter. Quite the opposite. Under the circumstances, you were a far more reasonable daughter than I'm afraid I'd be. So I voted on your overall behaviour, which seems exemplary to me.

this is what I did too

Echobelly · 03/03/2023 21:58

I think there's a lot to unpick here and you'd probably benefit from talking therapy because of the way this has affected how you feel about yourself and is likely to colour your relationships with other people too.

ELCismyspiritnana · 03/03/2023 21:46

You are certainly not a shit daughter Op, you were forced to have a relationship within the boundaries your mum set for you, and I think you were extremely gracious and forgiving to accept this and forge a relationship with her within those boundaries.

My heart hurts for little you being rejected in that way when your siblings weren't, and can only say that, as a mother and a daughter, this was in no way down to anything you were or did, and solely down to issues your mum had.

I sincerely hope your grandparents gave you a loving upbringing and that you can come to terms with the relationship you had with your mum. I cone from a complicated family and can say that in my experience, motherly love is neither unconditional nor a foregone conclusion, but it is never, ever to do with the child. Children have no blame, and you must have made your Grandparents so very happy to have taken you in and loved you instead.
Please be kind to yourself op, and if you can afford it perhaps seek some counselling to cine to terms with your upbringing.

LongLostTeacher · 03/03/2023 21:46

You did not let your mum down. I would be so proud and grateful to any child of mine who could stand with my in the face of a difficult illness. That is a hard thing to do.

I hope you seek therapy, OP, you deserve to make peace with all aspects of your relationship with your mother, at all your ages and stages.

IJustHadToLookHavingReadTheBook · 03/03/2023 21:29

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:57

I think it feels like - I loved her, but in the end I let her down and didn't put her first. So in retrospect it makes sense, that she always knew on some level, that there was something lacking in me, so that was why I wasn't "worth it" and although she loved me she didn't put me first.

Wow. Is that the truth of it all?

Oh @howcaniknow this is so, so sad. This isn't the truth of it at all. Please seek some therapy in order to unpick how your guilt over your mothers death/your relationship is all tied up in having to think about your whole relationship all wrong in order to cope with it. My heart goes out to you.

PriOn1 · 03/03/2023 21:28

I didn't push her to move to a bigger hospital.

Maybe if I had REALLY pushed her, she would have gone and even if she had stopped talking to me, she might still be alive?

My grandmother had a comfortable death in a small local hospital.

My grandfather had an awful death, where they were still doing seemingly random interventions including enemas and other uncomfortable things when I could see he was dying.

The hospital that treated my grandfather so poorly also treated a friend’s mother. She had much closer contact than I did and she said her mum’s treatment was utterly chaotic and that several teams were involved and none of them could sign off on something if it might affect something one of the other teams was dealing with. My friend had relevant experience as well, so understood only too well what she was seeing.

You don’t say what was wrong with your mum, but I wanted to challenge the idea that it’s inevitable that treatment in a big hospital necessarily leads to a better outcome.

There are always “what ifs” when anyone dies, but it sounds like this is more about your lack of closure than that you did anything that made things worse. And it sounds like you loved her very much, in spite of the difficult circumstances. I wonder whether this is especially difficult for you as there is now no chance to “fix” the past, while it might have seemed possible (even if that wasn’t realistic) when she was still with you?

Anyway, look after yourself. You really haven’t done anything wrong and I hope you can come to see that and find some peace.

AdoraBell · 03/03/2023 21:25

No OP, you are not a shit daughter.

I hope you can have some therapy. My DH was left with his grandmother because she said “oh, he’s so lovely” and his mother said “if you think he’s lovely you can have him” and then walked away. He’s never recovered.

OuiLaLa · 03/03/2023 21:20

OP my dad died when I was in my early thirties after a long battle with dementia. It is so natural to question your decisions around a parental death and, in time, you will come to allow a space to accept that you can never know the answer and that is ok and unavoidable. I held a lot of sadness and (white hot) anger for about a year until it passed. I’m sure therapy would have helped me but honestly I no longer carry it with me. You did nothing wrong. Your mother
would have wanted her wishes taken into account and in doing that you honoured her, as an adult able to make her own decisions. Sometimes this is the hardest part to live with.

so the other issues with your mother aside, your questions around her death are natural and nothing to be ashamed of.

On the questions around the relationship with your mother - lots of pp have honed in on this. Clearly it was very complex and, in time, you may come to see it from different perspectives. My understanding of my parents has changed throughout life. You can accept that they did good and bad things and that you loved them even though they may have treated you poorly at times.

my comfort for your loss xx

123bumblebee · 03/03/2023 21:20

No, you are not to blame at all. Your mum was an adult who was responsible for her own health. I wonder if you took on the "adult role" in the relationship, and it sounds like from a very early age had to grow up prematurely and take on so much on little shoulders.
I wonder if speaking to someone would help. I think there is a lot to unpick here and to help to lift that heavy burden you have been carrying.

letthemalldoone · 03/03/2023 21:19

I actually think you're much more loved than you give yourself credit for,
@howcaniknow.

Your mum loved you enough to carry on her pregnancy in difficult circumstances. Your grandparents were amazingly supportive when I imagine some of their peers would have behaved very differently.

Your mum must have thought she was doing her best by your to leave you with your grandparents, and your grandma obviously didn't want to let you go to live with your mum because she loved you, and wanted to support your education. That must have been tough for your mum too.

FWIW I think they made mistakes, but they came from a place of love. Your mum probably carried a weight of guilt, and your father was just a waste of space who took no responsibility.

I understand how it must have all felt as rejection - apart from your so-called father - I'm not sure that was what it was meant to be? I think if you could learn to focus on the positives of your relationship with your mum, on the good times, it would help you to come to terms with your loss?

Everyone here is just speculating. My heart does go out to you though. Please, please don't ever think you have any responsibility for your mum's passing - you so don't. You must be a lovely, forgiving person to have built up the relationship you did with your mum. Definitely therapy is the way to go, to make sense of the whole situation.

Are you close to any of your siblings? I hope you have support from then. Very best wishes xx

Climbles · 03/03/2023 21:17

Your relationship with your mother was clearly complicated. She was just a child when she had you so I can empathise with why she felt it was best for you to be brought up by your grandmother. However, it sounds like since then she may have had opportunities to make it up to you and unfortunately didn’t do that.
I couldn’t possibly say whether decisions that were made were right or wrong for the situation, but I can categorically tell you that it was not your fault that you didn’t live with your Mum or that she died. You need to treat yourself with some of the kindness and forgiveness that you have shown your mother. She was lucky to have you.

SwishSwishBisch · 03/03/2023 21:17

OP it sounds like your mum had a difficult time when you were born and ended up in a situation that wasn’t one she would have chosen for herself, or you. The fact you maintained a strong family bond despite this is important however I cannot stress enough that YOU were the innocent party in all of it.
Whether of her own design or not, your mother bears the responsibility for how your relationship was shaped, along with your grandparents. You did not in any way shape or form let your mother down. I hope you can find a great therapist who can help you unpack all of this and see that you are not lacking, or undeserving or any of the negative words you’ve used about yourself.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 03/03/2023 21:15

These thoughts are a normal part of grieving; you have done nothing wrong and it's your mind torturing you, because of the grief. Losing a parent when you had a complicated relationship is very difficult: you grieve for the parent you wish you had, as well as the one you really had.

If you can access it, counselling can really help.

Crunchingleaf · 03/03/2023 21:10

I agree with a PP that the boundaries she put up were most likely to protect herself from her own feelings about the situation. I don’t know what she felt about the situation, it sounds like she tried to make the best decision for you however it’s still likely she felt guilty or even shame about the decision. These are powerful feelings. Feelings that most people will do anything not to confront.
Now even though as an adult you can easily see the predicament she was in, why she made that choice and had loving grandparents etc you still are affected by your childhood. As a child you didn’t understand why you didn’t live with her and it naturally shaped so much about you, your personality and relationships as an adult.
You are definitely not a shit daughter. It sounds like talking to someone about your grief and your childhood.

ArabellaScott · 03/03/2023 21:07

OP, my dear, I'm so sorry. I'm sorry for your loss, and I'm sorry for the relationship you wanted with your mother and didn't have. Flowers

It's not your fault, it's not your mother's fault. 'fault' isn't really the thing, here. What is here is hurt, and love, and grief and grieving.

Grieving is a verb. Take your time. Be extra gentle with yourself. Yes, find a good, trusted therapist or friend to talk about with it. Maybe writing a journal would help?

Sending you all my best.

Ofcourseshecan · 03/03/2023 21:05

OP, I wasn’t sure whether to vote yabu or yanbu — yabu to blame yourself, but yanbu to mind your own health while caring for DM.

You have been a very kind and forgiving daughter. You’ve tried to suppress your sadness, but your mother’s behaviour hurt you a lot and you’d be superhuman if you could just ignore it.

You sound like a lovely person, OP. I hope you can work through your sadness and enjoy the rest of your life. xx

SirWalterElliot · 03/03/2023 21:00

I couldn't work out which way to vote (I said yanbu but now I think that's wrong?) Anyway I absolutely think it's not your fault. You've had to deal with a very difficult parental relationship and I think it's amazing that you were able to care for your mum when she was ill.

Swipe left for the next trending thread