Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was it my fault she died?

236 replies

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:26

I really love my mum. However I did not grow up with her, I grew up with my grandparents (saw my mum every week) and we did not have a conventional mother daughter relationship as a result. There was pain and hurt there when I was a young adult at times, although we had loads of fun together too.

She preferred to have firm boundaries around me, I think. I was always welcome for visits but her house wasn't my home. I am ashamed of this because it's childish and pathetic but I craved being 100% fully wanted by her and felt such deep shame that she didn't want me living with her. My siblings lived with her and it's like a blank space in my mind that can't work out why I was not "worth it" on the same level as they were.

I know this is just nonsense obviously as an adult and don't believe that has anything to do with my worth - but sometimes it still hits me over the head and I just feel so ashamed and distressed. It embarrasses me.

We developed a great relationship later on. However, by this time I had grown up and learned how to enjoy the relationship for all the good things it was, and let go of the rest.

But a big part of this was never, ever arguing with my mum or pressing my opinion on her - I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first. I reckon I was guilty of that for years as was demanding, always needing support. I am 100% aware that I was a shit person in that respect.

When she got sick she was very appreciative of my support which I was glad to do, but I was always too afraid to argue with her and push her. She was very keen to explore all options which we did together and did a virtual appointment with a very good doctor, but I didn't push her to move to a bigger hospital.

Maybe if I had REALLY pushed her, she would have gone and even if she had stopped talking to me, she might still be alive?

The other thing is maybe I should have been pushier about going to her town and actually going with her to appointments but again I was afraid. There was nowhere for me to stay and due to my own disability I can't drive.

But really - I prioritised my own disability and my own health. Having no access to my own doctors and things I need to manage my own health makes my own disability worse so I just put myself first. Again, if I had navigated things in a better way, would she possibly still be alive?

Am I just a shit daughter?

OP posts:
YetMoreNewBeginnings · 04/03/2023 18:23

I really really urge you to get good therapy for this.

I was brought up from 7 by my grandparents. Different reasons to you, my parents were neglectful and abusive, but something that I was told when I was in therapy probably is similar.

When your parent dies and they weren’t a standard/traditional/“normal” parent you can end up grieving twice over.

You lose the person they were and everything that that brings with it.

However, you also lose the person that little girl inside you still wishes they could be/could have been. The parent that one day they suddenly wanted to be, or could be. The one that it felt like everyone else had.

You’re also navigating the difficulty of placing your relationship with her. You were mother and daughter, but also not. You were brought up by her parents, but you weren’t her sibling.

it’s not easy. And there is likely a lot to unpick. And lots it will likely fall into “was I good enough?”

Raddar · 04/03/2023 18:22

I don't know why she wasn't a mother to you but not being with your mother through your childhood is the fault of your mother. Definitely you have nothing to blame yourself for. Your mother appeared to be a mother only by giving birth to you. An absent mother is not a real mother. Again if it was your mother's choice to disengage with a child then that adult was and is at fault

ImagineImagine · 04/03/2023 18:21

Absolutely not your fault, and of course you had to prioritise your own needs. Her rejection of you was also not your fault and all her. I’m glad you had grandparents willing to step in and hopefully made you happy. Perhaps you should talk this all through with a counsellor, then maybe you’ll be able to move forward with your life knowing you did nothing wrong, and deserved more from her.

Angelil · 04/03/2023 18:14

I voted YANBU just because you were not being unreasonable to put yourself first.

YABU (but for totally understandable reasons!) to think you could have prevented her passing. I am sorry for your loss xx

ThistleTits · 04/03/2023 18:09

@howcaniknow Perhaps you living with your grandparents was the best thing for you as a baby. Your mum may have been unable to cope with a baby for numerous reasons. Later, when she was more able it felt unfair to move you from your settled home. It doesn't mean you weren't loved or wanted, you obviously were. Your upbringing was different from your siblings, although you spent time with everyone.
My parents were very young when they had me, practically children themselves. I know they loved me but I dreamed of living with my grandparents. Mostly for stability.
You were not a bad daughter, nor was your mother a bad parent. Simply different in ability and approach. You know you done all you could. I doubt your mum would have wanted you to neglect yourself.
💐

Pupinski · 04/03/2023 17:55

NellietheElephantpackedhertrunks · 03/03/2023 19:31

Absolutely not, but she sure was a shit mother. Not sure I would even mourn her loss if I were you, let alone feel guilty for her decisions!

Unhelpful

Mistletoewench · 04/03/2023 14:25

StopStartStop · 04/03/2023 14:10

I read the thread last night but couldn't reply. So, I'm late. But here goes...

OP, you are not to blame, at all, ever for the death of your mother. You knew her, you reacted to the situation the way you had learned to react, from your relationship with her. Her death wasn't down to you, the responsibility for how and when she died did not and does not lie with you.

Similarly, you are not responsible for the failings in the relationship between you. I lived with my daughter all through, but still got it wrong. People are who they are, damaged, challenged, different from each other and can't always be the mothers their children need them to be.

Back in the day, sometimes if a very young woman (or a woman with problems, eg drink, drugs, poor mental health) got pregnant, her parents would take on the child as their own. If the young woman later found a husband and started a family, the first child stayed with the grandparents. That's how it was often done in my (white, working class, UK) culture, and how it seems to have happened in your case, though as you refer to 'our culture' you and I are probably from different backgrounds. It wasn't unusual, outrageous or uncaring or a rejection, though it did sometimes lead to family arguments when young mothers weren't happy with the way grandparents were doing things, or the other way around.

Do get therapy. Loads of it. Eventually, it works. Mine took over ten years.

Here is some woo stuff in case you are into that. It came to mind when I was reading your thread last night and is the main reason I'm posting...

All around the world there are older women. Crones, hags, grandmothers, wise-women, witches, non-witches, nuns, all sorts of women. We've seen a lot, done a lot, endured and survived a lot. Our energy is strong. Nothing shocks us. We have much love to give, without entanglements, without past or future, without explanations or justifications. Tap into the love and strength of grandmothers, it's everywhere, all around you. They can hold you in their love and strength until you have healed enough, however long that takes.

Love this ❤️❤️ wise words

StopStartStop · 04/03/2023 14:10

I read the thread last night but couldn't reply. So, I'm late. But here goes...

OP, you are not to blame, at all, ever for the death of your mother. You knew her, you reacted to the situation the way you had learned to react, from your relationship with her. Her death wasn't down to you, the responsibility for how and when she died did not and does not lie with you.

Similarly, you are not responsible for the failings in the relationship between you. I lived with my daughter all through, but still got it wrong. People are who they are, damaged, challenged, different from each other and can't always be the mothers their children need them to be.

Back in the day, sometimes if a very young woman (or a woman with problems, eg drink, drugs, poor mental health) got pregnant, her parents would take on the child as their own. If the young woman later found a husband and started a family, the first child stayed with the grandparents. That's how it was often done in my (white, working class, UK) culture, and how it seems to have happened in your case, though as you refer to 'our culture' you and I are probably from different backgrounds. It wasn't unusual, outrageous or uncaring or a rejection, though it did sometimes lead to family arguments when young mothers weren't happy with the way grandparents were doing things, or the other way around.

Do get therapy. Loads of it. Eventually, it works. Mine took over ten years.

Here is some woo stuff in case you are into that. It came to mind when I was reading your thread last night and is the main reason I'm posting...

All around the world there are older women. Crones, hags, grandmothers, wise-women, witches, non-witches, nuns, all sorts of women. We've seen a lot, done a lot, endured and survived a lot. Our energy is strong. Nothing shocks us. We have much love to give, without entanglements, without past or future, without explanations or justifications. Tap into the love and strength of grandmothers, it's everywhere, all around you. They can hold you in their love and strength until you have healed enough, however long that takes.

LilyPark · 04/03/2023 13:59

OP, please forgive me if I am totally off the mark with this stuff. Obviously you know much better what was going on and I am not a therapist! I really hope you can find one who can help support you in the way you deserve.

LilyPark · 04/03/2023 13:44

I just used the phrase "properly nurturing relationship with you" and realised it might sound too dismissive. It sounds like she was capable of showing you a lot of love but that at some level you have experienced it as conditional on you behaving a certain way. It's always been a 'half-way house' for you.

LilyPark · 04/03/2023 13:39

"You know, I'm beginning to wonder if her determinedly not having any mental health issues, was actually a defence against confronting some painful stuff?"

Yes, this. It sound like she coped with what must have been extremely difficult emotions for her through denial. The problem of course with that is that the feelings don't just disappear, they have to go somewhere, and it sounds like a lot has been projected on to you. That is what I meant about you being 'the scapegoat' i.e. the one who has to pick up the feelings and emotions in a family or in a relationshp where the other cannot or does not want to own those feelings themselves. I imagine she will have felt a lot of shame that she had a child out of wedlock (if that was frowned on by the culture in your family which it seems to have been) and also rejection by your father. She also effectively had to separate from you which must have been extremely painful for her. She may, despite aslo feeling love and gratitude towards her parents, have had all sorts of feelings of envy and possibly hatred towards her parents who presumably influenced her decision for you to live with them. If those intensely painful and conflicting feelings were not acknowledged or processed by her she may have found it difficult to have a properly nurturing relationship with you, which seems to have been what has occurred.

MyopicBunny · 04/03/2023 12:58

GeorgesMarvelousCalpol · 04/03/2023 12:30

This is s really sad thread to read. All your defence of your mother and taking all this blame is just heartbreaking 💔
I think you need more than a grief counsellor, but not sure what best to recommend. Take care of yourself, none of this is your fault - not her dying, and definitely not her leaving you with your GP as a baby.

I agree. What is very important to understand is that when you have a toxic parent who was abusive towards you, and you keep defending their actions, you may ultimately use your own children as a dumping ground for your unresolved issues.

I say this, because I've been on the receiving end of it from my own mother. Who is intensely critical of me, when it should be her abusive mother whom she directs her anger at. Instead, she makes endless excuses for her mother and tells me that I am the one who made her unhappy.

For myself, I've had extensive counselling so that I can minimise the possibility that I project any of this onto my own children.

GettingStuffed · 04/03/2023 12:40

I voted YANBU but that's because I believe that it's not unreasonable to feel like that. I lost my mum when I was in my late 20's. I'm still feeling guilty that I didn't push her into asking for chemotherapy. They were due to start the day she was diagnosed with a malignant brain tumour.

So YANBU for feeling like this. YABU for believing it is true.

GeorgesMarvelousCalpol · 04/03/2023 12:30

This is s really sad thread to read. All your defence of your mother and taking all this blame is just heartbreaking 💔
I think you need more than a grief counsellor, but not sure what best to recommend. Take care of yourself, none of this is your fault - not her dying, and definitely not her leaving you with your GP as a baby.

DavesSpareDeckChair · 04/03/2023 10:52

category12 · 04/03/2023 08:17

I wasn't a scapegoat, no. I was brought up having it drummed into me that I was clever (lol) and very talented at several things, so wasn't told I was stupid or worthless or anything like that.

No, but you were taught you were too much and that you weren't allowed to feel your feelings. Being valued for achievements is no substitute for just feeling loved and wanted.

None of this was your fault.

I agree, it is possible to feel that your achievements were valued or only certain attributes of yourself were valued yet at the same time feel YOU were not valued.

slowquickstep · 04/03/2023 08:38

I think your Mum was very very lucky to have such a wonderful Daughter that didn't turn her back on her. Many in your position would not have lifted a finger to help your Mum but you did and that shows you are a wonderful person. Your Mother made her choices, she obviously liked everything her own way. Remember the good times you had with her and forget the rest. Please enjoy the life you deserve Flowers

JMSA · 04/03/2023 08:23

You are so NOT being unreasonable! You're not a shit daughter, but I'd argue that her parenting skills were shocking. No parent should make their child feel like this. No wonder you're still trying to work through those feelings years later Flowers
I think if your mum had no other children and chose to live alone - with you living with your grandparents - I could just about get my head around it. But that wasn't the case.

category12 · 04/03/2023 08:17

I wasn't a scapegoat, no. I was brought up having it drummed into me that I was clever (lol) and very talented at several things, so wasn't told I was stupid or worthless or anything like that.

No, but you were taught you were too much and that you weren't allowed to feel your feelings. Being valued for achievements is no substitute for just feeling loved and wanted.

None of this was your fault.

Billydaffodil · 04/03/2023 08:11

Just another thought, maybe you prioritised your needs over hers (rightly in my eyes) because she taught you so well that that's what you do. She always put her needs above yours. Don't live with me, don't question my opinion etc.

Plainascanbe123 · 04/03/2023 08:03

I think you're being way too hard on yourself. You were not brought up in ideal circumstances. It is natural to want answers as to 'why', but out of respect for your mum you didn't want to push the issue. Growing up likely you lashed out due to feeling hurt, confused and abandoned, and you did the best you could as a daughter to love your mother despite the pain caused to you, which was completely out of your control when you were not part of the close family environment. At times you had to put your own health and needs first, and this is making you feel guilty because your mother for reasons she didn't explain to you put her needs first when she allowed you to be raised by your grandparents. If I had no answers for it I would feel confused too in your situation. You mentioned that you also have other siblings, so they could have stepped in to help your mother as well. They grew up with her. You did what you could. Try not to feel guilty. When you consider the experiences you've had to deal with you have proved yourself to be very strong indeed. I think you should go for counselling to unravel all these emotions you are going through. You are also still grieving as well. Try not to be hard on yourself, you're only human.

Billydaffodil · 04/03/2023 07:41

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:57

I think it feels like - I loved her, but in the end I let her down and didn't put her first. So in retrospect it makes sense, that she always knew on some level, that there was something lacking in me, so that was why I wasn't "worth it" and although she loved me she didn't put me first.

Wow. Is that the truth of it all?

I think you have an unusual view of how a parent- child relationship usually operates, of course that's not your fault, just due to your experience.

Most parent - child relationships revolve almost completely around what the child needs and wants, often at great expense of the parent (in my experience).
I wonder if you think you 'let her down' because you thought it was your responsibility to put her needs first. That is really not the case, almost all parents would rather suffer themselves in order for their child to have what they need.

You did not 'let her down' in putting your own needs first (though it doesn't really sound like you did that.) That is exactly what children should do.

If she 'knew' there was something lacking in you, but that 'lack' was your ability to put her needs above your own, then it sounds like that was not a fair expectation on her part.

Did your siblings always put her needs above their own?

MrsRickAstley · 04/03/2023 07:22

No she was an adult capable of making her own decisions. She didn't get them right. That's on her.

Detach yourself - your self worth is not dependent on her actions anymore.

GG1986 · 04/03/2023 07:12

I hit the wrong button sorry
You are not a shit daughter and it wasn't your fault she died x

montysma1 · 04/03/2023 07:01

You prioritized your own needs. Just as your mother clearly prioritized hers over yours. You owe her nothing and have nothing to be guilty about.

Jooliusreezer · 04/03/2023 06:14

Your ‘mother’ has done a real number on you. None of this is your fault.