Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was it my fault she died?

236 replies

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:26

I really love my mum. However I did not grow up with her, I grew up with my grandparents (saw my mum every week) and we did not have a conventional mother daughter relationship as a result. There was pain and hurt there when I was a young adult at times, although we had loads of fun together too.

She preferred to have firm boundaries around me, I think. I was always welcome for visits but her house wasn't my home. I am ashamed of this because it's childish and pathetic but I craved being 100% fully wanted by her and felt such deep shame that she didn't want me living with her. My siblings lived with her and it's like a blank space in my mind that can't work out why I was not "worth it" on the same level as they were.

I know this is just nonsense obviously as an adult and don't believe that has anything to do with my worth - but sometimes it still hits me over the head and I just feel so ashamed and distressed. It embarrasses me.

We developed a great relationship later on. However, by this time I had grown up and learned how to enjoy the relationship for all the good things it was, and let go of the rest.

But a big part of this was never, ever arguing with my mum or pressing my opinion on her - I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first. I reckon I was guilty of that for years as was demanding, always needing support. I am 100% aware that I was a shit person in that respect.

When she got sick she was very appreciative of my support which I was glad to do, but I was always too afraid to argue with her and push her. She was very keen to explore all options which we did together and did a virtual appointment with a very good doctor, but I didn't push her to move to a bigger hospital.

Maybe if I had REALLY pushed her, she would have gone and even if she had stopped talking to me, she might still be alive?

The other thing is maybe I should have been pushier about going to her town and actually going with her to appointments but again I was afraid. There was nowhere for me to stay and due to my own disability I can't drive.

But really - I prioritised my own disability and my own health. Having no access to my own doctors and things I need to manage my own health makes my own disability worse so I just put myself first. Again, if I had navigated things in a better way, would she possibly still be alive?

Am I just a shit daughter?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Laisydaisy · 10/03/2023 09:45

Trust your instincts. You are very clear here when people misunderstand. You know how you feel and you know when the feedback you are getting ‘fits’ or when it makes you feel bad. It’s the same with a therapist: if the feedback isn’t helpful maybe you need someone different.
A good therapist will help you find a way to talk - that’s part of the job. You don’t have to worry about that.

Also - I think your mother’s difficulty was with her mother, your grandmother. Not with you. Her mother overrode her wishes, wouldn’t trust her to look after you even though she was proving she could, and refused when she asked. Your mother visited you very frequently and consistently even though she felt suffocated by your grandmother and must have had a complicated relationship with her.

keffie12 · 09/03/2023 22:47

howcaniknow · 09/03/2023 20:03

How do you talk to a therapist about some of these private feelings? It's ok to discuss here on an anonymous forum. But I can't see myself talking about this physical longing for my mum like I'm a small child!

It's embarrassing because I'm too old for this shit. Sure we had a complex relationship but surely I should not be feeling this? I've had literally years and am not stuck feeling like this on an everyday basis. I get that grief is the trigger but it's panicking me, I feel emotionally inadequate.

You're not alone with this. Hell, I'm a nana, with 4 adult children in their 30s. I'm still dealing with my sh*t from life/childhood and going back into therapy in April from yet another layer of therapy I need.

I said to my Dr the same recently, which was "FFS I've spent the last 20 years in and out of therapy cos of childhood stuff. I thought I would be done with this stuff by now. " After yet another trauma breakdown, so I get you.

You aren't going yo know how to deal with it until you try it.

I try and look at this stuff as if it were physical. If you had a broken leg, you wouldn't question the treatment. You would let them do it. That's one analogy. You won't know the therapist either.

It's your shout to either stay in where you are or try something new. I wish you well. I know it isn't easy.

One last thing: I found journaling daily very helpful. I got my thoughts out of my head on paper, which makes a lot of difference. I still use this technique regularly

Flowersintheattic57 · 09/03/2023 20:59

Talking therapy with the right person has this amazing effect of talking out loud and listening to yourself, it leads to understanding things in a different way. Good therapy is a great way of looking after yourself, a wonderful gift.
You did your best in a difficult situation; if you had pushed you might have alienated her, if you didn’t push she might not have had a treatment that might have helped. A no-win situation.
How about: if you had pushed she might have dug her heels in and seen less of you, or if you were supportive and let her make her own decisions she would feel you were with her no matter what she chose? You made the right choice. Everyone has their own path in dealing with illness.

MyopicBunny · 09/03/2023 20:17

howcaniknow · 09/03/2023 20:03

How do you talk to a therapist about some of these private feelings? It's ok to discuss here on an anonymous forum. But I can't see myself talking about this physical longing for my mum like I'm a small child!

It's embarrassing because I'm too old for this shit. Sure we had a complex relationship but surely I should not be feeling this? I've had literally years and am not stuck feeling like this on an everyday basis. I get that grief is the trigger but it's panicking me, I feel emotionally inadequate.

You need to find the right therapist for you, whom you feel is not judging anything you say. Their job is to get you to figure everything out, to give you support but never to judge you and you will feel that you trust them.

I had an absolutely wonderful therapist. The therapy was hard and I cried many tears but she helped me so much. Before I found her, I had other horrible therapists who I did not like. One told me there was no such thing as depression.

You need someone empathetic. Don't feel that you are too old - nobody ever is and most of us have scars from childhood.

howcaniknow · 09/03/2023 20:03

How do you talk to a therapist about some of these private feelings? It's ok to discuss here on an anonymous forum. But I can't see myself talking about this physical longing for my mum like I'm a small child!

It's embarrassing because I'm too old for this shit. Sure we had a complex relationship but surely I should not be feeling this? I've had literally years and am not stuck feeling like this on an everyday basis. I get that grief is the trigger but it's panicking me, I feel emotionally inadequate.

OP posts:
BringItOn2023 · 09/03/2023 19:04

Sorry that sounds so hard. I think your DM must have been good at compartmentalizing/ hiding her feelings. And deep sound, you must feel a level of rejection (even though you feel there were reasons you didn't live with your DM).

One very hard thing, I've found, is having a parent who you have mixed feelings about. It's hard for the brain to accept someone can contain both good and bad.

keffie12 · 09/03/2023 18:56

howcaniknow · 09/03/2023 18:46

Coming back to my thread as I'm a little worried something odd is happening to me.

You know when you're a small child, if you are away from home and you really, really miss your mother/ maternal person? In my experience it's a physical sensation as well as emotional, a sort of twisting in your stomach.

I used to get that feeling when separated from my grandmother, I don't ever really remember having this feeling for my mum as a child.

But I'm having it now for my mum, as a thirtysomething year old grown adult woman. It's a horrible sensation that I've quite literally not felt for years, not since I was a child. A deep physical anguish.

I'm not feeling it right now but just the memory of it is making me cry on and off. I feel like there is something wrong with me, like in this aspect my emotions have gone back in time or something.

You're grieving. It isn't odd. You're not just grieving for your mom and what you would have liked it to be. Losing someone brings up passed grief too. I suggest you contact CRUSE and have some counselling. It is free and you have nothing to lose. They are incredibly good. I have seen them. I didn't think they could help. They did. The link to the website is below.

www.cruse.org.uk/

howcaniknow · 09/03/2023 18:46

Coming back to my thread as I'm a little worried something odd is happening to me.

You know when you're a small child, if you are away from home and you really, really miss your mother/ maternal person? In my experience it's a physical sensation as well as emotional, a sort of twisting in your stomach.

I used to get that feeling when separated from my grandmother, I don't ever really remember having this feeling for my mum as a child.

But I'm having it now for my mum, as a thirtysomething year old grown adult woman. It's a horrible sensation that I've quite literally not felt for years, not since I was a child. A deep physical anguish.

I'm not feeling it right now but just the memory of it is making me cry on and off. I feel like there is something wrong with me, like in this aspect my emotions have gone back in time or something.

OP posts:
Donnaslayer · 05/03/2023 15:02

Hello its sounds like you are at the Bargaining stage of grief.
During grief, you may feel vulnerable and helpless. In those moments of intense emotions, it’s not uncommon to look for ways to regain control or to want to feel like you can affect the outcome of an event.

In the bargaining stage of grief, you may find yourself creating a lot of “what if” and “if only” statements.

Bargaining is a line of defense against the emotions of grief. It helps you postpone the sadness and confusion.

I hope the above info helps op. And I just want to tell you, you didnt deserve to be treated in the way you described by your mum. Im so sorry this happened to you.

Understanding grief is realizing that no ones experiences is the same. Its very personal, and you may feel something different every time. You may need several weeks, or Im afraid may be years long.

If you decide you need help coping, try talking about your feelings to a friend, family member, health professional or counsellor – you could also contact a support organisation such as Cruse Bereavement Care in the UK or call: 0808 808 1677

Jenasaurus · 05/03/2023 13:18

When I was younger I saw a counsellor as I couldn't move past something that was controlling my thoughts 24/7. One thing he said to me has stuck with me all these years on and it is that you cant change the past but you can change the future and present, learning to accept something as just having happened and allowing yourself to be free of guilt was liberating for me. I hope you can find some peace and acceptance too. Sometimes life is hard and can cause us to focus on what ifs instead of taking each day as a new chance to move on and make your current life more enjoyable x

Nettleweed · 05/03/2023 12:49

No, you’re definitely not a shit daughter.

What happened can’t be changed, and you can’t let ‘what ifs’ haunt you for the rest of your life.

I speak from experience with my own mother, as medical professionals persuaded me to put a ‘do not resuscitate’ on her records towards the end of her life, and I have often wondered if this was the right decision.

Fortunately, someone recently said to me “You can’t think like that”, and that would also be my advice to you.

Self care is also very important - if you had not been mindful of your own well-being, you may not have been capable of helping and supporting her to the extent that you did.

StopStartStop · 05/03/2023 12:15

Remember - your mother loved you and your grandmother loved you. That is real. You are clearly lovable and worthy of that love.

Very well put and undoubtedly true.

Laisydaisy · 05/03/2023 11:15

Lillygolightly · 04/03/2023 20:00

@howcaniknow

From reading your posts and what you’ve said about your mother, if I had to guess your mother’s feelings and intentions I would say the following.

Your mum clearly loved and wanted you, to keep the pregnancy at a young age and in less than ideal circumstances she obviously wanted you, but at 18 she probably still wanted a life for herself and a decent future for you. This culmination of age and circumstances meant that you were raised by your grandparents whilst she worked on herself and her future. Sadly by the time she thought and felt she was stable enough to parent you properly you were already very attached to your grandmother, settled in your home and doing well in school, your grandmother was also obviously very attached to you and had grown used to parenting you and didn’t want to let you go. Essentially they fought over you and your grandmother won, and likely because your mum was actually putting you first, didn’t want to traumatise you by taking you away from all you knew and loved. She clearly felt you should be with her hence her arguing with your grandmother over you, but ultimately she went against what she wanted and instead did what she must have thought was best for you at the time.

As for her moving away and keeping very strong boundaries, I would imagine she did this because it was too painful. She loved you and wanted you but essentially couldn’t have you. Her keeping that little bit of distance may have just been her protecting her own heart. Imagine having something you want so so much, so so close, but also just outside of your grasp. I would think this must have been incredibly emotional and painful for her. I am guessing she will have assumed that you were fulfilled with your relationship with your grandmother and that you were happy. She may never have suspected otherwise until much later when you were much older.

For you as a child having had that main parental relationship with your grandmother and not your mother I imagine like most children do, that it was your grandmother you wanted when you were sick, injured or upset. When you were tired and wanted to curl up on the sofa or in bed, you will have wanted to do that at your home that you shared with your grandmother. Whilst you won’t have been rejecting your mother, your mother will have experienced hurt at each of these instances. As a mother it hurts when your child doesn’t want you, but you did want her, she just didn’t know and I would guess she saw that as her penance for the choices she made however painful it maybe.

I could of course be completely wrong but from reading all that you have about your mother and what you have said, it sounds to me as though she did want you, and wanted you very much, but I also think that perhaps she loved you so much that she also let you go, because she thought it was what was best for you.

Sending you some very big hugs. From someone who had a difficult relationship with my mother and also felt rejected and then my mother died I do understand how unresolved these things can feel and how much it take take up space in your mind. Ultimately my advice would be now that your mum has passed is to choose the narrative that gives you the most peace and go with that. 💐

I completely agree with this.

Also - it is clear your grandmother considered education and stability as very important factors in your upbringing. So it may be that, when your mother was pregnant with you, your grandmother was very active in promoting your mother’s decision to go to uni and for you to stay with her so that she could give you a stable and loving home. At 18 your mother probably felt her mother knew best - and maybe she did. Certainly she would feel her mother was more experienced at looking after a baby than she would be at that age. And it sounds like she wasn’t going to get any help from your father who was not ready to be a parent.
Later, when your mother wanted you to live with her, your grandmother prevented it.
Despite all this your mother worked hard to build and maintain a strong relationship with you. You clearly mattered to her hugely and it sounds as if she was as attentive and committed to you as she could be given the situation. Regardless of any rows and tensions you also had lots of fun and time with her and your relationship lasted all her life. Which - if she hadn’t loved you - wouldn’t have been possible.
I imagine she was hugely touched by your support when she was sick.
Grief at death (and other losses) can cause us to search for how we could have prevented it.

It’s part of our desire for the death to have not occurred. We try to change it in retrospect - I think it is a kind of magical thinking- so that maybe it won’t be true. It’s not unusual - but it can be very difficult to move through - particularly when some aspects are complicated and especially if we love and miss the person. And the loss stirs up all the other losses and we bargain with them too.
You love your mother and you miss her deeply and this stage of the grief is especially hard for you. Good therapy would help you to process all the losses.
Remember - your mother loved you and your grandmother loved you. That is real. You are clearly lovable and worthy of that love.

pollymere · 05/03/2023 11:15

Don't be hard on yourself. She was a grown adult and it could even be that nothing would've changed the outcome.

Tulips1990 · 05/03/2023 10:42

Alot of people say that your mum wasn't your responsibility alone as you had siblings. It's important to realise that your parents are not your responsibility and you don't owe them anything whether you've had a good or bad upbringing. The majority of people do take care and help their parents in old age but this is usually done out of love, not obligation (and how it should be in an ideal world). Love and obligation are difference.

If you haven't had a good relationship with your parents because of their behaviour/choices, why would you commit to looking after them in old age especially if you have your own life and commitments. You get back what you put in. Without going into detail, my mother is not a good mother, and through therapy I have come to realise that I have no obligation to her. The weight this has lifted off my shoulders has completely transformed the quality of my life as I was struggling with my feelings about it i.e - feeling guilty all the bloody time. It takes time to change your mindset and your choices won't be popular with everyone but screw everyone. This is your life.

You're slightly different in that your mother has already past but the principle is the same - let go of the guilt. A therapist can help you with this.

LadyEloise1 · 05/03/2023 09:54

I misunderstood @howcaniknow when I posted a few days ago. Apologies. I hadn't realised the circumstances of your birth and early years. Your Mum was young and your grandparents looking after you was the best solution they ( including your Mum ) thought at the time.
I think you were loved. By them all.
Did you write that your grandmother, in hindsight, thought it might have been better for you and your Mum to have moved into a flat together after you were born.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing !

Noangelbuthavingfun · 05/03/2023 09:46

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:40

Please can people not say she failed as a mother or was shit. She wasn't shit, I loved her so much and I did feel loved. Just confused as to why I wasn't fully wanted.

My head is so tired of trying to understand.

Op I hope it's not too forward of me to ask..but is there any mental health or your disability the reason she felt she couldn't give you her full attention and therefore uour gran could ? Meaning in their minds almost her kids got the attention they needed? Thenbits not rejection its making sacrifices for everyone's benefit although hard. Fwif you didnt fail her ...your siblings had a responsibility too....

Comtesse · 05/03/2023 08:10

You poor love, none of this is your fault. It wasn’t your fault as a child. It’s not your fault as an adult. Her death will stir up lots and lots of feelings, that is to be expected Flowers

Ambersonlove · 05/03/2023 07:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

T1Dmama · 05/03/2023 01:41

And I totally get it…
Your mum was young, not settled, had university in front of her… It’s great she never just aborted you like many would’ve, instead choosing to allow her loving parents to raise you, and it sounds like you had n amazing relationship with your grandparents… it isn’t greedy to have that amazing relationship and still want your mother to prioritise you… we are all told our parents are the 2 people who should always put us first… it messes with you, knowing you’re loved but questioning ‘am I though - because she isn’t mum full time’… or why Can’t I be part of the ‘family’… I suspect your outburst in your twenties was a test (subconsciously) of whether she would stick around and still love you unconditionally if you were awful and told her a few home truths… she stuck around and you rebuilt your relationship to something special - so you have your answer… I think she loves you every bit as much as your siblings, but the relationship was different - not through your fault, or hers… but just because she hadn’t been there for the first teeth, first steps, nursed you through childhood illnesses or wiped your tears when you fell out with your first best friend or been there for your first breakup, first period etc…. She also probably felt a huge sense of guilt and shame when with you (not shame because of you) but because of how she’d left you to be raised by her parents… I suspect she felt huge guilt about it and maybe she kept firm boundaries because she felt unworthy of your love!…. Definitely not because you weren’t worthy of hers… I think guilt paralysed her ability to be ‘mum’ to you.
Maybe her inability to allow you to ‘care for her’ in her final days was also lead by guilt … maybe she felt that she hadn’t fully been there for you, so you shouldn’t have to be there for her… She wouldn’t have told you this because a parent shouldn’t push this feeling of their guilt into their child and she wouldn’t have wanted to put you in a position where you had to reassure and comfort her - she probably felt she didn’t deserve that from you… She knew how much you loved her, and she loved you too!! I’m glad you built happy memories and a good relationship in later years… Her passing is very sad, but you can’t force someone to except medical help, It’s not your fault xx
You all did your best with what you knew and had at the time, Please except that she loved you and did her best, even if her best wasn’t everything you desired, and you did your best, even if at times that was anger and resentment, it was what you had to work with at the time and you worked through it….. I hope you find peace with all this and I hope you have the support of your mums husband and your other siblings. Be kind to yourself OP ❤️

T1Dmama · 05/03/2023 00:49

Of course her death isn’t your fault.
It’s great you built a relationship with her as an adult, and sorry for your loss… but she wasn’t your responsibility alone, you have siblings, where were they during her time of illness? Sounds like they should’ve been pushing her to go to hospitals and supporting her, she chose not to have a full daughter/mother relationship with you… because of this you were the least likely to push her into getting any help needed… sounds like the others should’ve stepped up!

Atsocta · 05/03/2023 00:14

No your human with feelings, seems to me you’ve had a rough deal
and sound a lovely person, don’t beat yourself up
be happy x

Ponderingwindow · 04/03/2023 22:01

it isn’t really that we want to insult your mother, at least that is not what I read in most of these posts. It is that many of us have gotten to the point that we understand what having a flawed parent does to us in terms of people-pleasing and trying to take responsibility for others. Until that moment clicks for you, it seems like people are insulting your parent.

we really just want you to see what we can see because we have been there and are still there. I am almost 50 and I still have to remind myself every day that I am not responsible for my father.

keffie12 · 04/03/2023 21:46

howcaniknow · 03/03/2023 19:26

I really love my mum. However I did not grow up with her, I grew up with my grandparents (saw my mum every week) and we did not have a conventional mother daughter relationship as a result. There was pain and hurt there when I was a young adult at times, although we had loads of fun together too.

She preferred to have firm boundaries around me, I think. I was always welcome for visits but her house wasn't my home. I am ashamed of this because it's childish and pathetic but I craved being 100% fully wanted by her and felt such deep shame that she didn't want me living with her. My siblings lived with her and it's like a blank space in my mind that can't work out why I was not "worth it" on the same level as they were.

I know this is just nonsense obviously as an adult and don't believe that has anything to do with my worth - but sometimes it still hits me over the head and I just feel so ashamed and distressed. It embarrasses me.

We developed a great relationship later on. However, by this time I had grown up and learned how to enjoy the relationship for all the good things it was, and let go of the rest.

But a big part of this was never, ever arguing with my mum or pressing my opinion on her - I think she always felt I was too pushy and demanding and put my own wants and needs first. I reckon I was guilty of that for years as was demanding, always needing support. I am 100% aware that I was a shit person in that respect.

When she got sick she was very appreciative of my support which I was glad to do, but I was always too afraid to argue with her and push her. She was very keen to explore all options which we did together and did a virtual appointment with a very good doctor, but I didn't push her to move to a bigger hospital.

Maybe if I had REALLY pushed her, she would have gone and even if she had stopped talking to me, she might still be alive?

The other thing is maybe I should have been pushier about going to her town and actually going with her to appointments but again I was afraid. There was nowhere for me to stay and due to my own disability I can't drive.

But really - I prioritised my own disability and my own health. Having no access to my own doctors and things I need to manage my own health makes my own disability worse so I just put myself first. Again, if I had navigated things in a better way, would she possibly still be alive?

Am I just a shit daughter?

There is nothing about what you say that is nonsense. I'm from an extremely dysfunctional family of origin, so I get what you're saying. My heart goes out to you.

I suggest you seek out Family of Origin therapy. It was really useful for me to find peace

Also, a book called "Family Secrets: What you Don't know can hurt you" by John Bradshaw. This book was really helpful in my recovery

Tulips1990 · 04/03/2023 21:13

What an incredibly sad story and what a huge burden to carry on your shoulders. You must really try to stop this way of thinking. It is not your fault your mother died and you are not a bad daughter. My goodness, this must be so exhausting for you. You really should consider seeing a therapist. They will help you work through these complex emotions so you can begin to think more clearly and get on with living your life. I had to see a therapist due to my relationship with my mother and it helped me enormously. I think more clearly and rationally, and I realise that many many things weren't my fault. Your only obligations are to your immediate family and yourself. Everyone else can do one, so NEVER feel guilty about putting your own needs first. I hope everything works out for you. X

Swipe left for the next trending thread