Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did you know ABA is widely considered abuse?

163 replies

PennyRa · 03/03/2023 19:15

I may be trying to kite a derailment a little bit but I also feel like it deserves its own thread?

OP posts:
PennyRa · 03/03/2023 20:35

Here's a link to one of the many research papers on ABA if you want to read

rdcu.be/c6PD0

OP posts:
cansu · 03/03/2023 20:34

I think that those who are high functioning may well have difficulty with a therapy that tries to tech skills that are perceived to be lacking. These individuals are a able to advocate for themselves and are able to declare themselves to be neurodiverse. My daughter is aged 18 but still requires 24 hour care. She will always need support. Being able to ask for what she needs and copy language and actions makes her life better.

Strawberrydelight78 · 03/03/2023 20:31

I have an autistic son and daughter. Some young American adults with Asperger's on autism Facebook groups I used to be on said the same. They felt like they are being made to be someone they are not. ABA isn't really a thing in the UK.

They also hate autism speaks and anything autism related with a jigsaw puzzle.

I did the earlybird early intervention programme with my son. Run by the national autistics society. It's less intense and they work with families in they're home and gave feedback each week to show progress etc.

bellac11 · 03/03/2023 20:31

cansu · 03/03/2023 20:27

Some people describe trying to help children with autism learning skills o denying autism. They talk about celebrating autism and point to documentaries like those by Chris Packham. They do not acknowledge that autism is a disability.

I agree and its highly disingenuous for some posters to talk about letting people be their true selves and be who they are etc when some of that is children and adults who self harm, attack others, behave in sexually inappropriate and harmful ways to themselves and others, present risk to themselves and others.

This isnt about people moving their hands around or having harmless repetitive habits or obesessions, its about dangerous and criminal behaviour that needs to be changed.

Somanycats · 03/03/2023 20:30

It absolutely does have it's place. A particular late teen male service user really likes to masturbate. Like a lot of teenage lads. He is just as happy to do it in public as in private. No boundaries on that score at all. He has been taken into police custody many times because of this. As yet he has not been prosecuted because ld practitioners ride to the rescue and sweet talk the police out of it. He will not get away with this for much longer. He has upset many members of the public. No one really cares that he has autism, certainly not the public or the police. He just needs to stop. Because the alternative of a prison sentence is much much worse for him. He won't like being 'made' to stop. But he must stop anyway. Yes it is making him suppress his inherent behaviours. But even so he must stop.

nilsmousehammer · 03/03/2023 20:30

It is interesting to read the experiences of autistic adults who were given ABA as children, and how they feel about it as an approach. Some did not find it a positive experience at all (to put it mildly), although they were aware that adults in their lives could be very happy with the results.

Tiggy321 · 03/03/2023 20:29

TrainTucker · 03/03/2023 20:21

Chris Packham has no relation to children undertaking ABA

In an old documentary, Chris Packham expressed his dislike of ABA and called it abusive!! Caused outrage in my ABA community.

cansu · 03/03/2023 20:27

Some people describe trying to help children with autism learning skills o denying autism. They talk about celebrating autism and point to documentaries like those by Chris Packham. They do not acknowledge that autism is a disability.

Cocobutt · 03/03/2023 20:22

Surely you can just look it up yourself?

I’ve tried but can’t find any evidence of abuse.

TrainTucker · 03/03/2023 20:21

Chris Packham has no relation to children undertaking ABA

Tiggy321 · 03/03/2023 20:20

cansu · 03/03/2023 20:19

Teaching a child to copy a simple action is not abuse. My daughter was completely in her own world. She learnt the difference between words using aba. It opened up her world. She is still of course autistic and lovely but she can ask for the things she needs and can write simple words. She can point to things and can understand simple language. Being severely autistic is a problem. I am fed up of hearing people talk about Chris Psckham and how being autistic is just being different. Not being able to function or communicate is a disability. Children need evidence based therapy to help them communicate and function in the world

THIS, with bells on !!

TrainTucker · 03/03/2023 20:20

ABA is very expensive to do well

Is that why LAs dont like it?

cansu · 03/03/2023 20:19

Teaching a child to copy a simple action is not abuse. My daughter was completely in her own world. She learnt the difference between words using aba. It opened up her world. She is still of course autistic and lovely but she can ask for the things she needs and can write simple words. She can point to things and can understand simple language. Being severely autistic is a problem. I am fed up of hearing people talk about Chris Psckham and how being autistic is just being different. Not being able to function or communicate is a disability. Children need evidence based therapy to help them communicate and function in the world

TrainTucker · 03/03/2023 20:19

Togoodtobeforgotten · 03/03/2023 20:02

Of course it is.

Why?

`please provide evidence of where you have seen it in practice

Ponoka7 · 03/03/2023 20:17

WellTidy · 03/03/2023 19:56

I feel that anyone posting on this thread who is against ABA is not going to change their mind as a result of this thread. And that anyone posting who is in favour of ABA having seen the positive impact on a (generally very lacking in basic skills prior to ABA) child isn’t going to change their mind either.

The irony is that anyone eloquent, intelligent and with the stamina to cope with this level of ‘debate’ is unlikely to be some who themselves would ever need ABA to help them develop essential skills.

There are always good and bad examples of all kinds of teaching. Abuse is a very strong and emotive word and should be very carefully used, imo.

"The irony is that anyone eloquent, intelligent and with the stamina to cope with this level of ‘debate’ is unlikely to be some who themselves would ever need ABA to help them develop essential skills."

Fuck me, where do I start with that one. Not as eloquent as I could be, but it's my autistic DD's favourite saying (especially when having to choose work passwords). We are both autistic and I used the gentler form of ABA during her childhood. She found friends in her first job, so forced herself to eat a wider range of food, make eye contact etc etc etc. So in a way carried it on. She is now living a life that amazes her teachers in her SEN school , our family and even me. I mask daily. I have to think about my tone, my body language and so much more. You can absolutely need ABA and be University material. It's a wonderful concept about society changing to suit those who are ND, but it won't happen in our lifetimes. So it then becomes about working towards getting the best life possible. In some areas it's dangerous to be different.

Optionschange · 03/03/2023 20:09

Yes Alot. I've read a bit from ABA survivors who explained how eye contact was painful yet they were trained to do it 😔.

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 20:07

Optionschange · 03/03/2023 19:55

Stimming (flapping, rocking etc) is often considered undesirable by NT people. But it's not unsafe and provides relief for the person.

This.

My friend is a psychologist and is now on a team that diagnoses autism. She has seen ABA being applied in a specialist school and found it highly distressing. It’s intensive treatment.

She saw children being encouraged to stop stimming. Children that did stop got a reward, those they didn’t, didn’t. Children who played with cars in the ‘wrong‘ way were encouraged strongly to play the ‘right’ way. She says many children were clearly very stressed and upset. They were also repeatedly told to make eye contact when they didn’t. I don’t think any of that is acceptable ‘treatment’. They were basically trained out of what came naturally to them and thsg relieved anxiety, for rewards.

TobeLeRone · 03/03/2023 20:07

Lenor · 03/03/2023 19:47

It’s interesting that people say that ABA is insistent upon autistic individuals masking and ‘acting neurotypical’. I don’t pertain to know a great deal about it, but my sister is an ABA therapist with a masters degree in ABA. She has always made it very clear that they only ‘work on’ behaviours that are unacceptable in general society. Not because they’re undesirable, I mean antisocial or violent things.

We work alongside eachother so often share information regarding specific individuals. She’s currently working with a boy who has sexually inappropriate tendencies, specifically towards younger children. Another child bangs his head against the wall so hard sometimes he’d knock himself unconscious. Her priority wasn’t making these children appear ‘normal’, it was keeping them safe and allowing them to integrate into society without causing harm.

This is along the lines of what I learnt about (starting a masters in autism - was several years ago now and my memory is flawed!).

There are many adult autistics who are able to speak very eloquently about their abuse via ABA, and understandably they will never accept it as anything but abusive, and many have ptsd from it.

Elements of ABA are commonly used in useful ways though, which don’t force a child to act NT, but rather work effectively to help reduce self harming behaviour, inappropriate behaviour (like stripping off in public or masturbating in public), which are usually positive for a child/teen to learn. Iirc it’s used in many special schools, but tends to not be called ABA any more (again, it’s been years and I can’t remember the specifics).

Like many other topics, this is an emotive one, people will tend to be polarised about it. It has been used in truly abusive ways, but like most things there’s a balance to be had, and it does have its uses.

Tiggy321 · 03/03/2023 20:07

I am an ABA Therapist and it is utter rubbish it's considered as abuse!! Maybe in the 1950/60's but now it CHANGES lives! It addresses change for social significant behaviour. I cannot stress how positively lives of kids I have worked with have improved- being able to go into the community without running away, hitting people, being toilet trained, being able to live safely at home .... the list is endless. I work with well respected BCBAs who are amazing and at NO point is there any abuse of any form. People do your research and stop spreading all these rumours!!!

Meandfour · 03/03/2023 20:05

Cocobutt · 03/03/2023 20:04

I don’t think we should be posting links to potential abuse.

Why not?

Surely if something is potentially abusive the word needs to be spread.

If there is evidence through links then they should be posted.

Surely you can just look it up yourself?

FloorWipes · 03/03/2023 20:05

The irony is that anyone eloquent, intelligent and with the stamina to cope with this level of ‘debate’ is unlikely to be some who themselves would ever need ABA to help them develop essential skills.

I have read lots of eloquent accounts from people who have been on the receiving end of ABA.

Cocobutt · 03/03/2023 20:04

I don’t think we should be posting links to potential abuse.

Why not?

Surely if something is potentially abusive the word needs to be spread.

If there is evidence through links then they should be posted.

Boomboom22 · 03/03/2023 20:03

It's not just positive reinforcement though surely as all schools and parents I am sure use praise, behaviour points, notice the good ignore the bad, buy you sweets of you are good at the park etc.

What makes it abusive? On the face of it being more able to cope I society is good. But is it causing emotional dysregulation and distress of masking? So many questions. Also not really sure what counts as aba.

BounceyB · 03/03/2023 20:03

romdowa · 03/03/2023 19:40

Yes it is very abusive. Its teaching autistic children to mask and act neurotypical. It's bribing them to suppress who they are.

I didn't see this going on. It didn't change his personality but it did make him better able to cope with the challenges of a mainstream setting. I've seen so many children with needs struggle due to not having friends or being able negotiate social situations.

The UK school system is rubbish for people with needs generally speaking. Most LSA's have minimal training and are just expected to know magically how to deal with it. Every time I'm at work I just end up thinking that there must be a better way - especially when I see a child unravelling due to overwhelm.

Togoodtobeforgotten · 03/03/2023 20:02

Of course it is.