Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did you know ABA is widely considered abuse?

163 replies

PennyRa · 03/03/2023 19:15

I may be trying to kite a derailment a little bit but I also feel like it deserves its own thread?

OP posts:
Timesawastin · 04/03/2023 09:58

Tiggy321 · 03/03/2023 20:54

Such as ? And science based??

Speech and language therapy, Makaton sign supported communication, PECS. All effective in various ways, all rigorously tested. That's just immediately off the top of my head as a parent.

percypercypercy · 04/03/2023 09:38

Hostofgoldendaffodils · 04/03/2023 09:37

If my autistic siblings had received ABA, it's possible my childhood could have been just about bearable.

Well this is depressing as fuck

Hostofgoldendaffodils · 04/03/2023 09:37

If my autistic siblings had received ABA, it's possible my childhood could have been just about bearable.

cansu · 04/03/2023 09:25

PennyRa
How many ABA programmes have you seen first hand in the last five years?

ABAwithlove · 04/03/2023 07:32

ABA is the science of behaviour, applied to socially significant behaviours. In my role this means applied to situations that would improve quality of life.

ABA...when delivered with love...is a play based therapy that aims at teaching skills to help a child to achieve skills that help them to be able to make THEIR voice heard, to explore THEIR interests, to interact with THEIR family with LOVE and less frustration and to be able to be integrated into THEIR community without worry of risk (e.g., to themselves or others).

Skills are broken down into small meaningful chunks and combined with positive reinforcement to help a child achieve. If children cannot achieve certain skills that would HELP THEM to have them then you work out 'why' this is happening and what developmentally appropriate skills are missing. You then work on this until you can help the child.

You can get BAD ABA like what has been stated in some of the posts. I have seen this (though I have seen far more ABA delivered with LOVE and passion). You can also get really SHIT special schools that leave kids to rock in corners or do the same shitty jigsaws day in and day out....doesnt mean all specialist schools are shit. You can get SLT that dismisses non verbal children of their caseloads and tells parents they will never learn to communicate. You can get OT's that don't help a child to learn to feed themselves with a spoon or dress themselves and write the kids off. Doesn't mean all OT is bad. You can get mainstream schools that don't engage kids with ASD or punish a child over and over again with an outdated system of behaviour support (when the poor sod has no emotional regulation skills). Does not mean all mainstream schools are bad.

My experience of ABA as an ABA consultant is one where it is delivered with LOVE. Where the children (and in the past adults) are empowered to learn skills that will help them to have a better quality of life and to be less vulnerable. The support system for parents of children with ASD is shocking. Most parents have to fight for support for their child and whatever route a parent takes it can be at times exhausting and lonely. To then be told that they have chosen 'abuse' is fundamentally WRONG. People should learn the FACTS before passing judgement on someone that is trying their upmost best by their child. I tend to avoid reading threads and comments like some of these posted, as I have dedicated my time, my energy and my love (at times to the expense of my own mental health helping burnt out parents navigating a brutal system)...However, I am confident that what I have dedicated my life to has been GOOD and with GOOD intentions. Intentions to help and not to 'normalise' (who likes normal anyway...I know I find normal boring).

Helping a young adult to learn replacement skills so that their extremely aggressive and dangerous behaviour is reduced. Resulting in no longer needing physical restraints and not being SECTIONED (I have been in a couple of units and tried to help create plans to get a couple of young people out of their and safely back into the community....NOT ABUSE

I helped a 5 year old who had been expelled from mainstream school for aggressive behaviour and outbursts. This took about a year to teach lots of developmental skills to help him. Lots of language difficulties (upper language), perspective taking and emotional regulation. He then went back into school with minimal support...NOT ABUSE

I have helped a small handful of children with Verbal Dyspraxia/DCD and ASD who were completely written off (but upon my assessment had the capability to do well). Parents told they would never learn to talk, never learn to ride a bike, never be able to access learning in a mainstream school. Those kids are doing all of those things now (mainstream on part time basis for lessons that are meaningful to those children, whilst they work on life skills, community skills, hobbies and language skills etc at other times). One boy was able to choose his own sound track to dance into his annual review to (and we all joined him in it)....NOT ABUSE

I am helping a little girl to develop her emotional regulation skills and upper language skills. She is often socially stigmatised, left out and is very susceptible to being bullied and is likely to be a vulnerable young adult if she is continued to be left with NO INTERVENTION. She is doing well and learning helpful skills to use when her emotions feel too big or uncomfortable for her. She is learning to take the perspective of her mother, so that she can understand how she might feel is she hurts her and she is doing so so well with a play based and positive approach to normalising all emotions but learning what behaviours are useful/not useful and the implications of engaging in these ....NOT ABUSE

For the most part, I walk into homes, schools, nurseries etc and I am greeted by children whom are very excited to see me. I was caught up in chatting to a child's teacher this week, before greeting them and they let me know this by approaching me and putting their arms up, pulling me down to their level, looking in my eyes and giving me the biggest hug and having a go at saying 'hi'.....I KNOW that what I have done and continue to do for these children is delivered with LOVE and the very best of intentions using methodologies that are play based, child centred and with positive reinforcement.

A blanket statement that all ABA is ABUSE is misleading and is dangerous. I am not sure if I will come back to the thread or not. I changed my name to post this incase it is helpful to any parents that feel stigmatised by their choice or any parents that are considering this for their child but I do not have the emotional or mental energy to get into any debates with person's who's opinions and perspectives can not be changed via respectful discussion.

lborgia · 04/03/2023 07:25

@BirdsAndBoats - well your answer typifies why I don't think it should be called a spectrum because so many people, including doctors, get it f'ing wrong.

It's not a spectrum with people on it. It's the spectrum of behaviours within one person.

Obviously not including physical and learning disabilities, but otherwise, there are of people who are on only "better" because they're good at covering up.

No one, seriously, no one would expect me to suffer from selective Miriam. But after a day at work, I need several hours of literally no input/ output at all. If I had to talk to someone, I'd end up in tears.

My son is somewhere in between. He needs hours of being mute, and then can happily engage for an hour or two before seizing up again.

The spectrum are within each person, for each trait. How good are they at socialising? How hypersensitive are they to loud noises, how good are they at reading facial expressions?

That's why it's so difficult.

My son and I would both absolutely be considered aspies, in terms of how we present, but what we have to do to present in that way is exhaustingly tough.

It's one of the hardest things for family to understand. If DS can be so chatty one minute, why is he mute the next? Why do we let him decide himself when he's going to leave the party?

I'm never going to make him behave the way others wish, because it hurts him, and he pays for it for days afterwards.

If he could walk a few steps before needing a wheelchair, most people would think it barbaric to take away the wheelchair and say "well you can obviously walk, so you don't need it". This is no different. You just can't necessarily see the impact immediately.

turbonerd · 04/03/2023 07:20

Also what @BirdsAndBoats says: it has to be useful for the recipient, and Asperger should have stayed a separate diagnosis.

I have 2 out of 3 on the spectrum. DS who is high functioning is going to uni next year. His needs are vastly different from DD.

turbonerd · 04/03/2023 07:15

Well, this bit goes some way to talk about that. It is s quote from the article:

The spectrum is so broad it doesn’t make much sense. Are we really going to put people with severe autism who cannot dress themselves in the same category as people with mild autism who work in Silicon Valley? It has also made this problem of not learning life skills worse – because even just slightly geeky kids are getting labelled as “on the spectrum”. Where this labelling can be useful is with relationships – it can help with misunderstandings.

BirdsAndBoats · 04/03/2023 00:39

Fifi0102 · 03/03/2023 21:31

We NEVER stop people stimming it's only very harmful behaviours we try to reduce so they can live alongside others and fully participate in the community.

Honestly I think it’s extremely problematic for this very reason that asbergers has been clumped together with much more severe forms of autism that require very different health needs.

ABA might not be abusive for more severe autism spectrum people who for example might say require diapers as an adult and are completely non verbal and can’t even function in society but might be abusive for someone who generally gets along in society and largely is just very socially awkward and may even be functional enough to get married and care for their own children later on. They have vastly different needs. Why do we insist on clumping them together and adding roman numerals? It makes for unclear, difficult and confusing discussions about their needs.

I find it unhelpful in my opinion. Who cares if it’s a spectrum. It can still be a spectrum and the different levels of need have clear and precise names that clearly define the levels of need.

Climbles · 03/03/2023 23:27

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 22:08

It’s interesting that ABA advocates talk about what is achieved. The issue is how it’s achieved and how the person feels.

The ABA that I’ve seen has not involved any distress or punishment, the children are not forced to take part. Sometimes withholding the reward can be frustrating for them. But it’s all positive rewards. Do you know how frustrating and distressing not being able to connect to those around you? Or not being able to express your basic needs?
However, I do think it needs to be done along side other approaches, such as intensive interaction otherwise the emphasis can be in ‘changing’ the autistic person rather than adapting the world.

ElfDragon · 03/03/2023 22:40

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 22:08

It’s interesting that ABA advocates talk about what is achieved. The issue is how it’s achieved and how the person feels.

Yes, I talk about what my dd has achieved via ABA. Because it is helped her on her way to everything she is today.

I can say that she is much happier now that she is able to communicate effectively; that she is much happier with a wider range of interests; that she positively skips into school each day (yep, a 19 year old skipping down the road, often singing with me too - I guess ABA hasn’t done a good job of making her hide those pesky behaviours, has it? Or getting her to mask her feelings. Maybe because that wasn’t ever the aim), and can talk positively about her experiences throughout her ABA placements, but still brings up the times she felt uncomfortable at pre-school (mainstream) and the placement (SN school, not ABA) before we won an ABA placement for her.

in fact, the only abusive practices I have come across were at the SN school prior to her ABA placement, where the head gleefully told me how they would make a child sit at a work station until they had completed the task set out - holding the child in place if necessary, and where the school made my dd wear ear defenders, which caused her huge distress, because she got upset at another child crying all the time. It was a crap school, with horrible practices, which I withdrew dd from as soon as I realised what was going on. Funnily enough, the staff there used to tell me how awful ABA was 🤔. However, I don’t think all non- ABA schools are abusive, or that they use the same tactics in the same way as that school. Maybe some people could also try to separate out the abusive practices and abusers from whatever setting they happen to operate in.

there hasn’t been a single part of dd’s ABA curriculum that hasn’t been taken in her best interests, with her at the centre of how it has been approached. I can’t say she has never been upset or frustrated, or any other emotion, just as any other parent cannot say that their child (ASD or NT) has never been upset or angry, or frustrated, etc. She is human, and subject to the same range of emotions as everyone else, and has had days where she is bored, some where she is pissed off, some where she is ridiculously happy and silly, and so on. but I can say that she has never been repeatedly subjected to behaviours and situations that will cause her distress in an ABA setting - the closest she came to that was in a (highly respected, as it happens) non-ABA SN school.

Fifi0102 · 03/03/2023 22:35

PennyRa · 03/03/2023 22:24

That can be achieved without abuse

It's not abusive , non harmful behaviours like stimming/ etc are never discouraged. Sexually inappropriate behaviour , physical violence , verbal etc because it effects the public and the person as they have their liberty restricted. A reduction in harmful behaviours is beneficial to both society and the person. We only use natural consequences we never punish , we use proactive and reactive strategies.

Name2456 · 03/03/2023 22:30

I had ABA as a child many years ago. I think it saved my life. My stims and other behaviours were violent - I suffered concussions and even broken bones.
If anything, I’d argue that it would have been abusive to withhold a treatment that could have improved/saved my life.

PennyRa · 03/03/2023 22:24

Fifi0102 · 03/03/2023 22:22

Would you rather not be allowed to go out because your behaviour is grossly inappropriate/ offensive/ illegal or with help , you can go out and do things you enjoy ?

That can be achieved without abuse

OP posts:
OneFrenchEgg · 03/03/2023 22:23

My question was where to find the bit about eloquent self diagnosis and this impacting services for those with severe ASD.

Fifi0102 · 03/03/2023 22:22

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 22:08

It’s interesting that ABA advocates talk about what is achieved. The issue is how it’s achieved and how the person feels.

Would you rather not be allowed to go out because your behaviour is grossly inappropriate/ offensive/ illegal or with help , you can go out and do things you enjoy ?

OneFrenchEgg · 03/03/2023 22:21

Do you even understand what Grandin is talking about when she talks about the most severe forms of autism?

what a weird question.

OneFrenchEgg · 03/03/2023 22:19

amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/oct/15/autistic-scholar-temple-grandin-the-education-system-is-screening-out-visual-thinkers

I can find this bit I don't think it's saying what you said, I'll keep looking.

turbonerd · 03/03/2023 22:18

@OneFrenchEgg
what a ridiculous article.
Do you even understand what Grandin is talking about when she talks about the most severe forms of autism?

Yes, everyone born is precious. But not everyone born (and their family) is receiving the support they need to survive - and that support is tenfold if you have a severely autistic child. You NEED a lot of support to survive physically, mentally, economically.
The child NEEDS a lot of support to live a life that is good and with dignity - all their life. There’s a lot of co-morbidities and sensitivities: digestive problems, lack of sleep, malnutrition, dental problems, hygiene related problems. There are mountains of washing, extremely limited social life, very reduced ability to work, parental illness due to exhaustion.

This Is what Temple Grandin is talking about.

percypercypercy · 03/03/2023 22:17

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Let's stick with the context of ABA therapy and autistic children. 'Plenty of' is irrelevant.

MrsRinaDecker · 03/03/2023 22:15

I have read that the science behind ABA is the same as the conversion therapies that were use on gay people, although obviously with different applications. I’ve also read autistic adults saying how traumatic they found it. So, maybe it’s not always abusive (I don’t know) but based on those things I’d certainly say it can be.

OneFrenchEgg · 03/03/2023 22:13

Thanks @turbonerd I've always avoided Grandin as I got sick of people asking if I'd heard of her and I didn't relate to her from what I'd seen. I'll try again.

turbonerd · 03/03/2023 22:09

@OneFrenchEgg
my answer was for you.

turbonerd · 03/03/2023 22:08

It was in The Guardian just last autumn. I’m sure you can Google it because my phone is crap at links.
I don’t know what HFA is.

She is practical, whereas a lot of «advocates» are away with the fucking faeries. One notable endravour from one of those «advocates» was that autistic children should only be cared for and taught by autistic adults. What a fucking nightmare. No consideration to how that would play out at all

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 22:08

It’s interesting that ABA advocates talk about what is achieved. The issue is how it’s achieved and how the person feels.