Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did you know ABA is widely considered abuse?

163 replies

PennyRa · 03/03/2023 19:15

I may be trying to kite a derailment a little bit but I also feel like it deserves its own thread?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PennyRa · 06/03/2023 15:38

Hope54321 · 06/03/2023 12:58

What is your motive behind creating this thread? Did you make this thread to wind people up? It seems like you’re not interested in any discussion regarding ABA. Are you interested to find out what Aba actually is and what it actually involves?

To kite a derailment. Like I said in the OP

OP posts:
Hope54321 · 06/03/2023 12:58

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 23:11

Just because my child is severely autistic doesn't change the science

What is your motive behind creating this thread? Did you make this thread to wind people up? It seems like you’re not interested in any discussion regarding ABA. Are you interested to find out what Aba actually is and what it actually involves?

CMO · 05/03/2023 00:34

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 23:11

Just because my child is severely autistic doesn't change the science

You don;t know what ABA is and any further duscussion with you is futile.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 04/03/2023 23:27

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:50

C. People keep saying the same thing therefore the answer stays the same

Oh OK. I'll take it that you don't actually have the knowledge to back up what you are saying then. I had next to know knowledge of ABA prior to reading this thread, my ds has asd and adhd but thankfully he has never had need of any therapy and at 16 is doing fantastic and is really happy. After reading this thread though I think ABA absolutely has a place in enhancing the lives of some autistic people.

Fifi0102 · 04/03/2023 23:25

Some of the strategies we use are tailored communication methods , play therapy medication and PBS which is a form of ABA. All together we have had great success of moving people out of hospitals , huge reduction in physical restraints, minimal usage of sedatives and integration back into the community. In an ideal world no one would need any therapy but we base the decisions on doing the least harm and improving quality of life.

Hercisback · 04/03/2023 23:19

Just because my child is severely autistic doesn't change the science

Science of what?

Cognitive science?

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 23:11

Just because my child is severely autistic doesn't change the science

OP posts:
Fifi0102 · 04/03/2023 22:58

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:49

This has already been settled up thread

You have only suggested play therapy , we do already use play therapy everyday mostly as engagement and distraction but on a 20 stone 6 foot 4 male who has urges to be sexually inappropriate and is highly physically aggressive. Play therapy doesn't wholly fix the safety concerns of these people eventually reintegrating into the community. I think you are looking from this from the lense of HFA in children and low support needs not people who are sectioned, or have committed crimes or do things like smearing , bang their heads , forced vomiting.

Another example of us HFA hijacking the care of autistic people.

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:50

C. People keep saying the same thing therefore the answer stays the same

OP posts:
CrotchetyCrocheting · 04/03/2023 22:49

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:42

All of that can happen through non abusive therapy

I'm really curious why you are just replying to a thread you started with the same one line over and over again? It gives the impression that A. You don't believe on what you are saying or B. You don't have any clue what you are talking about.

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:49

This has already been settled up thread

OP posts:
Fifi0102 · 04/03/2023 22:45

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:42

All of that can happen through non abusive therapy

How? Talk me through it ? What evidence based therapies work for severe ASD and dangerous behaviours of concern (many of which are illegal )

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:42

Fifi0102 · 04/03/2023 22:40

You are just being goady and I'm almost certain you have never worked in forensic services. ABA forms part of PBS plans and it changes lives without it some people would never be able to leave locked units for time in the community. With the strategies people end up moving on to fulfilling lives in the community and not in hospital !!!

All of that can happen through non abusive therapy

OP posts:
Fifi0102 · 04/03/2023 22:40

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:24

Any "benefits" or "progress" you can get through ABA you can get without abusive methods

You are just being goady and I'm almost certain you have never worked in forensic services. ABA forms part of PBS plans and it changes lives without it some people would never be able to leave locked units for time in the community. With the strategies people end up moving on to fulfilling lives in the community and not in hospital !!!

PennyRa · 04/03/2023 22:24

Any "benefits" or "progress" you can get through ABA you can get without abusive methods

OP posts:
turbonerd · 04/03/2023 11:02

Thehonestbadger · 04/03/2023 10:46

I have an ASD young child and my view of ABA is controversial. I don’t share it but given this is anonymous here goes…

In my personal experience it’s usually those with ‘high functioning’ or at least ‘basic functioning’ ASD children who are really judgmental and condemning of it. They can’t possibly understand why anyone would want to stamp out those ‘unique qualities’ like a bit of stimming or social difficulties. All whilst their kids go to normal schools, communicate and function with a few challenges but generally managing.
These parents are so venomously passionate about ABA being the devil and offer no empathy or understanding that actually those with low functioning children are living a totally different life to them. ASD is a broad spectrum and life with a high functioning child is in no way comparable to a low functioning one. That’s like saying someone with a limp is the same as someone in a wheelchair… it’s obviously not the same thing. They’re both mobility issues but they are not the same!

Those of us with kids who, if they stay like this, will never live independently, or have any sort of autonomy over their lives. Those of us who lie awake at night wondering what sort of crappy NHS care home our kids will be in once we aren’t here to look after them anymore… we are generally much less condemning of ABA. Frankly we would try anything to give our kids the chance at freedom and autonomy in their futures.

This. You say what I’m trying to say much better!

turbonerd · 04/03/2023 11:00

lborgia · 04/03/2023 10:41

It didn't matter how much you say it was done with the best of intentions... "I mean well" butters no parsnips - you need to listen to autistic adults.

They're not lying. They're not whinging because they didn't like their teacher. It's not helpful to say "that's not my experience of ABA" as a provider, because all we should be concerned with is the long term impact on the client.

Undoubtedly, you can make a case for some of it if you're trying everything to avoid dangerous behaviours, but it's like saying stomach bypass surgery is wonderful for all overweight, fat and morbidly obese people.

The surgeon may well say that. The doctors dealing with the outcomes of malnutrition, excess skin, and myriad long term side effects, may well think differently.

I know that's a weird analogy, but was just speaking to someone about it.

I was horrified to hear a Harvard psychiatric professor last year, diabetic describing autism as a disease. Not only is it offensive, it's not true. But here is this man who's every word is supposed to be golden because of his credentials.

Just because you think you know how to "fix" autism, doesn't mean you know what it's like to be in the receiving end.

I was willing to hear that it had changed dramatically from adult experiences of 10, 20 years ago, but from pps above, it sounds as if it's still based on fixing broken kids.

To my mind it really is not about fixing broken kids. My children are not broken.
They are lovely and beautiful and need extra help in maneuvering their surroundings and in looking after themselves.

For my DD this service was one of several I could choose. She tried other approaches, but they did not help her in her need to organise herself and in her strong wish to interact with other people.
Using this technique has given her lots of confidence - never once as a detrimental activity for her.
I was very involved with the nursery and later school, and the health specialists who travel around teaching the method.

There are behaviours that signal distress - then we must work on finding out what causes the distress rather than trying to «fix» the symptom. For example biting and hitting others, or banging their own head on hard surfaces. Even if that is stimming it is not sustainable or healthy long term - best practise is to identify the stressors and mitigate or avoid them.

I realise people do have bad experiences, but a blanket statement that ABA is abuse is very much wrong.
Rather, could we bring to the forefront ways that people with autism need to organise their days and interactions to avoid overstimulation?

I have to organise my days very carefully. I learned that the hard way, not knowing that all my crashes and «depressions» were me not coping well with too much going on in my days. I spiralled downwards and ended in trouble.

aintnothinbutagstring · 04/03/2023 10:48

I think if ABA reduces the autistic person's vulnerability, helps to keep them and the people around them safe, helps them communicate their needs, facilitates the building of positive relationships - then it is not abuse. I can't imagine stimming (if it is a safe movement, not head banging) is on anyone's list of priorities to try and change. The thing is - as from the other thread - some of people supposedly speaking out for autistic people have no clue about severe autism and how it affects the individual and their families. You end with parents who do go down the ABA route being horribly judged. I mean the people going on about eye contact - lots of autistic people, severe or otherwise, have absolutely no issue with eye contact - I'm not sure why that is singled out as a thing. Just shows the lack of awareness.

Thehonestbadger · 04/03/2023 10:46

*mainstream schools

Thehonestbadger · 04/03/2023 10:46

I have an ASD young child and my view of ABA is controversial. I don’t share it but given this is anonymous here goes…

In my personal experience it’s usually those with ‘high functioning’ or at least ‘basic functioning’ ASD children who are really judgmental and condemning of it. They can’t possibly understand why anyone would want to stamp out those ‘unique qualities’ like a bit of stimming or social difficulties. All whilst their kids go to normal schools, communicate and function with a few challenges but generally managing.
These parents are so venomously passionate about ABA being the devil and offer no empathy or understanding that actually those with low functioning children are living a totally different life to them. ASD is a broad spectrum and life with a high functioning child is in no way comparable to a low functioning one. That’s like saying someone with a limp is the same as someone in a wheelchair… it’s obviously not the same thing. They’re both mobility issues but they are not the same!

Those of us with kids who, if they stay like this, will never live independently, or have any sort of autonomy over their lives. Those of us who lie awake at night wondering what sort of crappy NHS care home our kids will be in once we aren’t here to look after them anymore… we are generally much less condemning of ABA. Frankly we would try anything to give our kids the chance at freedom and autonomy in their futures.

turbonerd · 04/03/2023 10:44

Hostofgoldendaffodils · 04/03/2023 09:37

If my autistic siblings had received ABA, it's possible my childhood could have been just about bearable.

This is such an important factor. Having a sibling with autism is really challenging. If the nd sibling has aggressive behaviours and lashes out it is even worse.
💐 for you.

My high functioning children have had to sacrifice a lot for their sibling - activities, me coming to parent’s evenings and meetings, going ti the cinema/pizzarestaurant/cafe/just out as a family is a near impossibility.
They had to put themselves to bed from an early age, no time for reading or playing with me. It was hard and quite lonely for them.
They love their sibling, and now they are older teenagers have more understanding for the challenges we have had. But it has been a tough path for them.

The few family outings we have had, including holidays were made possible on a few, carefully planned occasions, much thanks to her ABA programme. And to patient parents (mine) and an extremely patient and understanding step father + step-siblings.

lborgia · 04/03/2023 10:41

It didn't matter how much you say it was done with the best of intentions... "I mean well" butters no parsnips - you need to listen to autistic adults.

They're not lying. They're not whinging because they didn't like their teacher. It's not helpful to say "that's not my experience of ABA" as a provider, because all we should be concerned with is the long term impact on the client.

Undoubtedly, you can make a case for some of it if you're trying everything to avoid dangerous behaviours, but it's like saying stomach bypass surgery is wonderful for all overweight, fat and morbidly obese people.

The surgeon may well say that. The doctors dealing with the outcomes of malnutrition, excess skin, and myriad long term side effects, may well think differently.

I know that's a weird analogy, but was just speaking to someone about it.

I was horrified to hear a Harvard psychiatric professor last year, diabetic describing autism as a disease. Not only is it offensive, it's not true. But here is this man who's every word is supposed to be golden because of his credentials.

Just because you think you know how to "fix" autism, doesn't mean you know what it's like to be in the receiving end.

I was willing to hear that it had changed dramatically from adult experiences of 10, 20 years ago, but from pps above, it sounds as if it's still based on fixing broken kids.

copperplated · 04/03/2023 10:36

I see that in the example I've chosen most NT children would stop taking clothes off, of their own accord at a certain point, so maybe this wasn't a good example.

copperplated · 04/03/2023 10:34

I'm not sure how this approach is so different to how all children learn? Is it more repetitive, so an intervention to change behaviour can take much longer? Would a NT child learn after say a couple of times, whereas someone with ASD would need much longer?
I 'm trying to understand how it differs to how any of us learn?
Take the example of taking clothes of in public. Many toddlers do this, or attempt to do this both NT and ND. What are some of the different types of intervention to prevent this happening and how would play therapy differ from ABA to get the required result, ie not taking clothes off?
Am i understanding correctly that some people are opposed to the method and not the result. So it's better to use a different method, rather than it's better to not try to modify some behaviours. Surely everyone can recognise that some behaviours need modifying, to enable fuller participation in society.

Timesawastin · 04/03/2023 10:01

percypercypercy · 04/03/2023 09:38

Well this is depressing as fuck

It is, although it depends if you suggest something else might have helped, or if you are suggesting NT children in a family should just suck it up when faced with dangerous and distressing behaviours from siblings.