Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - She shouldn't have said this at the funeral?

94 replies

CalmReserve · 03/03/2023 16:57

Dave and Jane are happily married with 2 children. Dave works with Sarah.
Jane has cancer and passes away.
Dave quits work for a while to look after the kids.
Over the years Dave has several relationships, nothing lasting. 15 years later he reconnects with Sarah who gets divorced to marry Dave.
A few years later Dave dies in an accident.

At Dave's funeral Sarah has the officiant read out a eulogy she has written about their relationship. Part of which states they used to flirt all the time when they worked together, basically hinting they had a thing at the time when Dave was married to Jane.

AIBU to think this was totally inappropriate and disrespectful to Dave and Jane's kids and Jane's family- some of whom were at the funeral? Even if it was true, I just feel it doesn't need to be said at the funeral! There's a time and place. It's not like Dave and Jane even got divorced! They might have still been happily married had she not died.

Or am I overreacting and making a big deal out of nothing and she's entitled to say what she wants at her husbands funeral (and sod anyone else's feelings!)

OP posts:
ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 18:33

Hawkins003 · 03/03/2023 18:28

It's a valid question, besides it takes two to tango, at the funeral yes disrespectful.
But in the context as just friends how is flirting perceived as good bonding or wrong full.stop ?

It’s irrelevant to this thread. And you are being very inappropriate.

Awful.

Hawkins003 · 03/03/2023 18:28

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 18:25

🙄 Theres always one.

It's a valid question, besides it takes two to tango, at the funeral yes disrespectful.
But in the context as just friends how is flirting perceived as good bonding or wrong full.stop ?

Moxysright · 03/03/2023 18:28

I’d be fuming and most likely say something to her. In poor taste like others have said!

ALotLikeYou · 03/03/2023 18:25

Hawkins003 · 03/03/2023 18:14

Is flirting but being faithful good or bad ?

As for the funeral, does seem odd.

🙄 Theres always one.

BirdsAndBoats · 03/03/2023 18:21

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/03/2023 18:04

It’s very disrespectful to his children.

I don’t buy into this thing where it’s ok just to say anything you want because you’re the chief mourner. His children have lost both of their parents and may now have that niggling.

I actually know a family that fell out and a father and son haven’t spoken for many years because of something said at the funeral of the man’s second wife. His son’s mother is still alive, but a comment was made about how the second she came into his life he knew his second wife was the woman for him. He was married to his first wife for a further three years and the son felt it utterly disrespectful to his mother.

I don’t believe there is such thing as a chief mourner and I think that comment is a bit unfair. No one who is defending the widow has suggested such a thing. I believe that children who grieve a parent grieve just as deeply and painfully as the spouse who is left behind. It’s not a suffering contest. Everyone involved is hurting. Though they may be hurting in different ways.

I did defend the widow in my previous comment but I did not excuse what she said if that makes sense. People don’t think rationally in these situations.

People sometimes isolate themselves and burn bridges with pain. It’s not rational. We cannot expect people to be thinking logically when they are in the pits of despair. If the widow is doing this I don’t blame anyone for distancing themselves from her but I do hope they leave a rope behind for her to grasp onto once she’s out on the other side of the darkness.

shellyleppard · 03/03/2023 18:19

Theres a time and a place for those sorts of words....and his funeral was definitely not one imo. Feel for his children

PinotPony · 03/03/2023 18:17

@MaryJean87 A bit harsh based on one comment from a woman who's grief of losing her husband of the last 15 years, is fresh and new.

Sarah wasn't married to him for 15 years, only a "few". His first marriage to Jane was 15 years...

Hawkins003 · 03/03/2023 18:14

Is flirting but being faithful good or bad ?

As for the funeral, does seem odd.

Justmeandthedog1 · 03/03/2023 18:09

You don’t feel 100% rational in grief but you only get one chance to get a funeral right. I think this was a very unfair thing to say—- there were other ways to convey their happiness and live for each other that wouldn’t have upset others.

ReneBumsWombats · 03/03/2023 18:07

Yes, that is inappropriate and disrespectful to Jane's memory and family. Even if it's true, it didn't need to be said.

I've seen people use eulogies to take pot shots before.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 03/03/2023 18:04

It’s very disrespectful to his children.

I don’t buy into this thing where it’s ok just to say anything you want because you’re the chief mourner. His children have lost both of their parents and may now have that niggling.

I actually know a family that fell out and a father and son haven’t spoken for many years because of something said at the funeral of the man’s second wife. His son’s mother is still alive, but a comment was made about how the second she came into his life he knew his second wife was the woman for him. He was married to his first wife for a further three years and the son felt it utterly disrespectful to his mother.

Americano75 · 03/03/2023 18:00

Good grief, that is jaw dropping. Did his children not have any input to the eulogy?

BirdsAndBoats · 03/03/2023 17:58

NoSquirrels · 03/03/2023 17:10

I don’t think this is a thing you can settle with a vote. Grief is not rational and writing eulogies isn’t everyone’s forte. I wouldn’t like it if I were Dave’s child, and I would internally raise an eyebrow if I heard it in an eulogy (depending on how it was phrased) but everyone deserves some grace when they’re grieving.

I agree with this comment. It was in poor taste but I don’t think a grieving widow typically has their head screwed on right when they’re writing a eulogy. I know I wouldn’t. I don’t really get the feeling that it was written in spite or to be cruel but I guess I would have to know her personally to judge. Probably just clumsy with her words.

I hope that OP can offer her some breathing room. She’s going through enough as it is.

I’m one of those people who is bad with words. I do not envy her position. We live in a culture where our words are dissected and autopsied for problems to the point that it’s hard to even communicate verbally and honestly anymore she now everyone is diagnosed with social anxiety because of it. I hate that we treat each other this way especially during such difficult times in our lives.

Perhaps it’s best to just let it go.

Zanatdy · 03/03/2023 17:54

Very poor taste. Maybe she wasn’t thinking straight

Chikapu · 03/03/2023 17:51

She possibly wasn't thinking straight after, you know, just losing her husband. Grief is selfish and overwhelming and she can probably only look at their relationship through her own lens right now.

letthemalldoone · 03/03/2023 17:50

lieselotte · 03/03/2023 17:25

I agree.

When my uncle died, he was buried with his first wife who had died many years before. My cousin said he'd be buried with "my mum, as is right and proper".

My uncle's second wife, to whom he was actually married significantly longer than to his first wife, was at the funeral. I really hoped she didn't hear the comment but my mum thought she had.

Best to move on and remember the person, and ignore the silly comments made by the living!

My grandpa's first wife died tragically young. After a few years, he married a friend of hers. So, when grandpa died, he went in with Wife 1, and when granny died, she went in there too!!

That was a horrible thing for 'Sarah' to say though. How would you know if it was even true so many years later?

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 03/03/2023 17:47

CalmReserve · 03/03/2023 17:36

Thank you. My jaw dropped when it was read out. But I was just double checking because I'd have assumed she'd have run it all past someone first and would have thought someone might have pointed out it was not on to say that.
She literally used the word 'flirting'. They used to flirt with each other all the time when they worked together.

It is unfortunate that she didn't seek any advice on her eulogy. But there's a reason you hear the phrase "crazy with grief" used so often. If you feel able, just try to give her the benefit of the doubt, she very likely wasn't thinking about how her words might hurt other people.

I've found that most eulogies are written with rose colored glasses firmly in place. My late father's eulogy was so over the top that I whispered to my sister "who are they taking about again?".

Try to let it go if you can.

Womblemumma · 03/03/2023 17:40

Very poor taste . No consideration for his kids with Jane .

TomatoSandwiches · 03/03/2023 17:39

Disrespectful and unnecessary, reeks of insecurity within the marriage, I'd focus my condolences on the children instead tbh.

Justputitdown · 03/03/2023 17:39

Sarah is very insecure. Not nice and not even necessarily true!

MaryJean87 · 03/03/2023 17:38

SunShineAllMine · 03/03/2023 17:16

What a horrible woman, I am sorry for your loss.

A bit harsh based on one comment from a woman who's grief of losing her husband of the last 15 years, is fresh and new.

Fancylike · 03/03/2023 17:38

It’s in poor taste and she would have known what she’s doing too. It’s a final marking her territory pissing competition of one.

Not as serious but when my ex got married it was to a woman that was always hovering around our social group even before I broke up with him (because he wouldn’t commit with marriage…)
I attended only so I could supervise our child and to try and be civil. At the reception, her mum stands up and gives a speech about how they fell in love when they went to a concert together, they spent the entire weekend in bed, and were inseparable ever after. Those were concert tickets I gave him. He said he was taking his brother for the weekend as I was too pregnant to go. We were a couple for two years following that concert and apparently they were fucking the entire time.
Joke’s on them, she’s a shrill, unpleasant person, and he’s a broke, balding twat who is trying to cheat on Tinder using photos from 15 years ago.

CalmReserve · 03/03/2023 17:36

Thank you. My jaw dropped when it was read out. But I was just double checking because I'd have assumed she'd have run it all past someone first and would have thought someone might have pointed out it was not on to say that.
She literally used the word 'flirting'. They used to flirt with each other all the time when they worked together.

OP posts:
lieselotte · 03/03/2023 17:25

NoSquirrels · 03/03/2023 17:10

I don’t think this is a thing you can settle with a vote. Grief is not rational and writing eulogies isn’t everyone’s forte. I wouldn’t like it if I were Dave’s child, and I would internally raise an eyebrow if I heard it in an eulogy (depending on how it was phrased) but everyone deserves some grace when they’re grieving.

I agree.

When my uncle died, he was buried with his first wife who had died many years before. My cousin said he'd be buried with "my mum, as is right and proper".

My uncle's second wife, to whom he was actually married significantly longer than to his first wife, was at the funeral. I really hoped she didn't hear the comment but my mum thought she had.

Best to move on and remember the person, and ignore the silly comments made by the living!

JudgeRudy · 03/03/2023 17:25

I'd have to hear the eulogy myself to judge whether it implied more than friendship...if you're emotionally connected to Jane or their children this might be influencing your interpretation.
I think it's fine for her to say for example she had known Dave for a long time and always liked him with from when they first met due to his chirpy banter and uplifting chats. I don't think it's appreciate to say example I knew he was the one for me all those years ago and we shared a very special connection ....which we later took to the next level.

As the neutral niece who cared for my uncle towards the end of his life, l helped write the eulogy. I literally had to do word counts to check that each of his children received equal 'billing'. Did cherished out do adored? Does a poem chosen by one equal a piece if music chosen by another. Each person had their own take on it and one in particular thought it was very unfair. What do others think who were there? Are there neutral people you could ask.
Ultimately it's done. If this has caused a rift then it would be better to think about how everyone can heal. Grief alters our perception so whoever says what, bare that in mind. Remember also that Dave was loved by and loved you all.