Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"I'm proud of you"

218 replies

isntitapip · 03/03/2023 14:45

Can I ask you please what your thoughts are in that phrase? I'm trying to work out if my feeling are reasonable or I'm over-reacting.
How would you feel if a partner/friend said this to you after an achievement of yours?

I've said it to my kids. My Dad said it to me once. I'm ok in that situation.

A partner/bf situation it feels like an ownership comment. Am I making sense? Like they had something to do with the achievement. It just feels patronising. Is it me? I'd love other peoples' thoughts on this

OP posts:
Arniesleftleg · 03/03/2023 16:19

I think you're overthinking this. My mum is currently very poorly in hospital, she's come through open heart surgery and is fighting hard to get well, I told her I was so proud of her. My hubby is doing really well with his own business, I told him how proud I am of him. I tell my friends all the time, it's not patronising it's actually very encouraging in my opinion. I've had people say it to me and just take it for what it means, that someone is proud of me.

Sirius3030 · 03/03/2023 16:16

ferneytorro · 03/03/2023 15:21

I agree, it’s infantilising. Why are you proud of me ? I assume it’s because you thought I was shit/useless and wouldn’t be able to do it?

different when it’s a child. I’m immensely proud of my daughter.

I am incredibly proud of my two sons, and I tell them regularly. The fact that they are grown adults has not stopped me being proud, nor stopped me telling them.

jays · 03/03/2023 16:15

isntitapip · 03/03/2023 14:45

Can I ask you please what your thoughts are in that phrase? I'm trying to work out if my feeling are reasonable or I'm over-reacting.
How would you feel if a partner/friend said this to you after an achievement of yours?

I've said it to my kids. My Dad said it to me once. I'm ok in that situation.

A partner/bf situation it feels like an ownership comment. Am I making sense? Like they had something to do with the achievement. It just feels patronising. Is it me? I'd love other peoples' thoughts on this

I sort of get you OP after having read your net few posts. I initially thought you meant ownership of you and not your achievement and I get what you’re saying. It wouldn’t bother me, however, I made a point of saying to my ds when he was younger that I was really happy for him, it was a brilliant achievement and that HE must be so proud of himself. I didn’t say I, I said he because I never wanted him to feel like he was trying to make me proud or trying to please me ( it was an issue for me as a child) so yes, I actually get what you’re saying!

Climbles · 03/03/2023 16:15

I’m fiercely independent and would feel a bit patronised by someone saying they were proud of me. I’d much rather they said impressed or similar. However it’s not controlling or like they own you at all.

betchamel · 03/03/2023 16:15

isntitapip · 03/03/2023 14:45

Can I ask you please what your thoughts are in that phrase? I'm trying to work out if my feeling are reasonable or I'm over-reacting.
How would you feel if a partner/friend said this to you after an achievement of yours?

I've said it to my kids. My Dad said it to me once. I'm ok in that situation.

A partner/bf situation it feels like an ownership comment. Am I making sense? Like they had something to do with the achievement. It just feels patronising. Is it me? I'd love other peoples' thoughts on this

Completely agree OP. It's a very modern phenomenon. I always think it sounds patronising when used in anything other than what I regard as its traditional context.

It's ok to be "proud of" your own or your child's achievement.
It's ok to be "proud to" have contributed to an achievement.
It's ok to be "proud to" belong to a particular group or organisation.
But it's not ok to be "proud of" someone who is your equal when their achievement is their own.

It's particularly grating when used by celebrities. E.g. A celebrity saying they are "proud of" a fan who has done something brave or achieved something. They should really say they are "proud to" be asociated with them.

It's just bad/evolving grammar, but it's endemic and here to stay.

weirdoboelady · 03/03/2023 16:12

I agree - it sounds a bit patronising to me too. BUT I wouldn't take it that way. I would try to
a) translate it into "You have done so well that I am proud you are my partner" (which I'm sure is what DP meant) and
b) maybe try to explain to DP what I felt and train them into using my rephrased compliment 😙

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2023 16:10

Ultravox · 03/03/2023 16:01

I always think this is an odd phrase. It smacks of ownership and superiority to me.

I just usually say “you should be so proud of yourself” to people instead.

I just usually say “you should be so proud of yourself” to people instead.

I would definitely need to hear the tone and see someone’s face if they said this. I would read it as patronising otherwise especially with the word “so” in it.

JustAJokeLikeOnTopGear · 03/03/2023 16:09

I feel exactly the same. Like they are taking some of the credit because you couldn’t have done it without them.

lazycats · 03/03/2023 16:09

LemonLimeWater · 03/03/2023 16:08

I agree. Saying 'I am proud of you' makes the accomplishment about that person, not you.
'You should be so proud of yourself ' makes do much more sense.

"I'm proud of you" isn't a phrase I'd use, but I defy anyone to say "you should be proud of yourself" and not have it sound sarcastic.

listsandbudgets · 03/03/2023 16:09

I'm hugely proud of my DH. He's been through some awful experience over the last few years. I've supported him all I can but ultimately it's been him who's had to deal with the fallout and he's done it efficiently and with great dignity whilst doing everything he can to protect me and our DCs from any consequence.

Honestly I sometimes feel like yelling how proud I am of him from the roof tops.

LemonLimeWater · 03/03/2023 16:08

isntitapip · 03/03/2023 14:59

Kind of this, yes.
Although I'm surprised at how unreasonable I seem to be, I'm not surprised I have issues and yes to the people who asked if I'm looking for issues, I think I might be. That was what I was trying to unpack in my head.

I don't feel that way about "I love you", that's totally fine in my head. "I'm proud of you" feels different

I agree. Saying 'I am proud of you' makes the accomplishment about that person, not you.
'You should be so proud of yourself ' makes do much more sense.

Cocobutt · 03/03/2023 16:07

I told my mum I was proud of her and I can’t ever imagine my DD getting too old to tell her I’m proud of her.

I commented on a work photos a few days ago telling everyone how proud I am of them all.

If people have an issue with someone saying I’m proud of you, do you also have an issue with someone saying well done?

ferneytorro · 03/03/2023 16:06

Somanycats · 03/03/2023 15:37

Well by your own reckoning you actually think she is shit useless and not able to achieve stuff. It's the same phrase. It means the same for an adult or a child. The meaning I attribute it is well done/go you/ great job/you did it! But you have I different interpretation.o

No, is it’s said to ME by another adult.

i am proud of my daughter.

ItsaMetalBand · 03/03/2023 16:05

I kind of understand.
DM says it to me but mainly because she's usually very negative or dismissive of whatever it is that I'm doing but then when I succeed at it, she says she's proud of me in a surprised sort of way, like she didn't think I'd have it in me.

I'm used to it now but it does grate on me, to the point I sometimes am rather prickly if its said anywhere else however genuine it's meant. I have to keep reminding myself that DH or whoever is actually being proud of me in a nice way!

Boringcookingquestion · 03/03/2023 16:04

My partner often says he’s proud of me. I’m very proud of him too. I think I’d only find this weird/annoying if they were unsupportive whilst I was working towards something, then said they were proud after.

TedMullins · 03/03/2023 16:02

My partner often says he’s proud of me for my achievements and it’s never crossed my mind to find it anything other than complimentary. For me, it’s almost the same as him saying he’s impressed. It makes me feel good that he recognises my achievements. The only time I’d take it badly is if someone was doing a very sarcastic, passive aggressive “proud of you hun” type thing where they wanted it to be obvious they didn’t feel that way at all.

Ultravox · 03/03/2023 16:01

I always think this is an odd phrase. It smacks of ownership and superiority to me.

I just usually say “you should be so proud of yourself” to people instead.

Justalittlebitduckling · 03/03/2023 16:01

No, my DP and I would say that to each other for example if one of us got a promotion or an award at work.

creekingmillenial · 03/03/2023 16:00

My DH and I tell each other we are proud of each other. I don’t see it as ownership related.

fandangodango · 03/03/2023 15:59

My husband and his whole family say this phrase a lot. I found it weird and a bit cringe at first as it was never something my parents said to me (I knew they were proud of me, but they never expressed it in those terms). But it’s a totally normal thing. Just not something that not everybody says. I’m used to it now and am fine with it.

Hobbi · 03/03/2023 15:59

@blackpearwhitelilies

And he'd tried to teach me without success for 15 years. It wasn't until I booked lessons with a (maybe handsome) instructor that I managed it, so he couldn't have been vicariously claiming credit 😂.

WagnersFourthSymphony · 03/03/2023 15:58

Is it more to do with the actual words than the usual sense behind them which is that people are pleased for something you've achieved? So if someone said 'I'm really pleased for you' or 'I bet you're feeling proud of yourself' it wouldn't feel so weird?

But saying 'I'm proud of you' might feel condescending or even a tad proprietorial, like taking some of the credit or ownership of your achievement, if you take it too literally.

Maybe look on it more as them saying they are proud to feel associated with you?

There are lots of expressions we use casually which feel strange when you look at them too hard.

Galadriel90 · 03/03/2023 15:58

The one thing mumsnet has reliably taught me is there are always people (I say people, really I mean women) who will turn any compliment into a negative. See any thread about the expression 'you look well' for further evidence of this.

Zanatdy · 03/03/2023 15:55

My bf has said it a few times. No issue and I’ve never have thought it was an ownership thing, my friends will say it occasionally, as do I to them

Topseyt123 · 03/03/2023 15:54

You're being daft. It's a compliment. My DD told me she was proud of me a while back. She is 20. Was she trying to own me or control me? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 Should I have been suspicious of her motives? 🤣🤣