Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school competitions leave some children very sad?

116 replies

Orangeis · 03/03/2023 13:32

We had an Eisteddfod on Wednesday (it's like a Welsh talent competition) and both dc got a prize so this post isn't sour grapes.

But both my dc have told me some children were sad as they didn't have any entries or some of their entries were a bit rubbish.
The dc are too young to do the entries alone, it's craft, photography etc that's to be done at home.

I wonder why the school can't do some class based entries as well to give the dc without parental input a chance. I know these things are a PITA sometimes, people work, some parents just can't engage for various reasons so it's not that I'm bashing them either.

Do your school try hard to be inclusive of everyone, or is this quite standard? I'm just feeling a bit sorry for some of the kids involved.

OP posts:
Annoyingwurringnoise · 03/03/2023 14:13

Oh come on, we had an Easter egg competition at primary school and it was always the teachers pet kids who had parental help that one. I was always a bit miffed that I never won, but you know, I’ve got over it. Christ on a bike, it’s no wonder kids have no resilience nowadays.

I agree that school competitions shouldn’t rely on parental input, but even when they don’t, some kids who are just crap at craft or story writing or whatever will never win those competitions. That’s life. What good would it do to teach kids they can win, even when they’re crap at something. What would be the point of working to get better at something if the people who are crap at it get the same rewards? Completely bonkers race to the bottom.

ladykale · 03/03/2023 14:11

Nimbostratus100 · 03/03/2023 13:43

not every event is for every child

but there should be something for everyone over the years

Agree but projects when parents go the whole thing are a bit pointless!

Swiftbushome · 03/03/2023 14:10

UWhatNow · Today 14:02

Losing and feeling sad doesn’t build resilience in many children. It builds in avoidance and low self esteem. Losing and wanting to beat people (or do better) next time can motivate a few children but at what cost?

Completely agree with this. It seems a very backward and old fashioned way of teaching kids to me.

Especially in events where its immediately obvious to everyone who came last. Like sports day, or if there's a spelling test where everyone's scores get stuck on the wall. Adults don't have to deal with this. Why should kids?
I have no issue with extra curricular events that are competitive. They can be great in inspiring the kids who choose to attend. But at least nobody is being forced to get laughed at when they come last every time.

Snoreboar · 03/03/2023 14:09

It was standard at our primary - kids always got prizes for their parent's work - I drew the line when ds was put in detention for not making enough effort at his art entry. Had to have a wee chat with the teacher on that one - just to let them know that - often parents do all the work, which should have been evident and Ds is not artistic or creative and getting detention for being crap at art wasn't exactly going to help him be better at it. The art teachers at secondary made a massive difference though to how he felt and he produced some quite amazing pieces.

UWhatNow · 03/03/2023 14:02

Losing and feeling sad doesn’t build resilience in many children. It builds in avoidance and low self esteem. Losing and wanting to beat people (or do better) next time can motivate a few children but at what cost?

Schools should mirror the sort of societies we want the future generations to build. Ones of inclusivity and people being celebrated for their unique talents. The thinking around managing competitive events still has a long way to go in British schools imo.

Untitledsquatboulder · 03/03/2023 13:59

Doing whole class projects or only allowing entries made in class is just another form of unfair. It discriminates against children who work more slowly, or who don't express themselves best in paper/card/crayons. It leaves no room to show what they do out of the classroom and that can be really important for children who are not traditionally "school shaped" or who don't necessarily shine out at school.

Swiftbushome · 03/03/2023 13:59

I hate the argument that kids should learn how to lose. Of course they should but you'll still find plenty of cocky kids who win at sports day and times tables and whose parents do all their art projects for them so they win at those too. Why do only the "loser" kids have to learn how to cope with disappointment? You'll find it often is the same kids who never end up winning anything school related, have a massive confidence knock, while the same kids who win everything sometimes turn into the school bully.
(I wouldn't ever call a kid a loser by the way before anyone digs me out - I used the word for effect here)

icypompoms · 03/03/2023 13:59

In our school all entries are completed in class. Surely your school does recitation and handwriting and singing and choir? That's all school based stuff.

Do you mean that some kids didn't do a homework based entry? If so the must still have had chance to paint a daffodil, write out the first verse of the anthem and do a dreaded acrostic poem based on CYMRU?

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 03/03/2023 13:56

What is the point of an Eisteddfod if "everyone wins"!? It's a competition. Some will win, some will lose. Some will be thrilled, some will be disappointed. It's life 🤷🏻‍♀️

In saying that, my secondary school Eisteddfod had competitions that you could only enter through classwork. E.g the poetry competition entries were written in class time and the poetry recital competition was also class-based (you learned and recited the poem in class and the teacher chose the best from their class and you were whittled down from there).

If the school has enough categories there should really be something to appeal to each child (writing, art, music, dance, poetry) and ideally they would be light on necessary resources but even then there would be disappointed children. Inclusive doesn't mean everyone wins.

Orangeis · 03/03/2023 13:54

I totally agree that every child shouldn't win every event, they all have strengths and challenges.
It's just this particular event that was parent led, most dc of 6 or 7 wouldn't have a camera, or be able to source their own craft stuff, or even know what the competition brief was.
I wonder if they were sat there thinking "Why didn't my parents bother to help me to enter this competition?"

OP posts:
TrainTucker · 03/03/2023 13:50

Depends on the judge
my son won the Easter egg for 2 hard boiled brown eggs with felt tip face and bunny ears and noses he cut and stick on which put in a shoe box cage with a carrot

he was up against multiple parent done offerings including wood structures

noblegiraffe · 03/03/2023 13:50

The idea that children should never be disappointed when they are younger stores up problems for the future though - always allowing a kid to win games, for example, leads to very poor losers.

Professional parent-made stuff should be disqualified though.

floratess · 03/03/2023 13:47

Yes, I agree there should be some competition- sports day could have a mixture of team/independent events etc. However it seems to start so young and is often the same children being left out of winning. My children's school is very competitive. They had a cross country event the other day and even reception children took part and were given a token with their number on at the end. The little girl who got last place was crying and it just seemed a bit cruel at that age. The school says it builds resilience.

Nimbostratus100 · 03/03/2023 13:43

not every event is for every child

but there should be something for everyone over the years

quietnightmare · 03/03/2023 13:40

Yes any entries should only be done by the children and in class

As for those who are sad, they will get over it and need to learn that you win some and you loose some and maybe their talents lie elsewhere.

It annoys me on sports day when EVERYONE gets a medal takes the shine away from the children who excel at sports and maybe that's all they are 'good' at yet don't get recognised.

MatildaTheCat · 03/03/2023 13:37

Yes, I agree. When mine were at school they would have prizes for eg model making, best costume or Easter hat. Some kids brought in virtually professional standard offerings while some were lame ( ours) and some non existent.

Doing whole class projects or at least projects where all the children have the same resources would be fairer. That said I think competitions do build resilience and confidence so do have a place in schools.

Swipe left for the next trending thread