Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school competitions leave some children very sad?

116 replies

Orangeis · 03/03/2023 13:32

We had an Eisteddfod on Wednesday (it's like a Welsh talent competition) and both dc got a prize so this post isn't sour grapes.

But both my dc have told me some children were sad as they didn't have any entries or some of their entries were a bit rubbish.
The dc are too young to do the entries alone, it's craft, photography etc that's to be done at home.

I wonder why the school can't do some class based entries as well to give the dc without parental input a chance. I know these things are a PITA sometimes, people work, some parents just can't engage for various reasons so it's not that I'm bashing them either.

Do your school try hard to be inclusive of everyone, or is this quite standard? I'm just feeling a bit sorry for some of the kids involved.

OP posts:
GloomyDarkness · 03/03/2023 15:45

I wonder why the school can't do some class based entries as well to give the dc without parental input a chance.

DC school did start doing this - perhaps mention it - they did suffer from a lack of parental engagement so maybe felt they had little choice.

Though DS did win easter bonnet parade in his previous English primary - mainly as it looked the best of ones that looked like parents hadn't helped - though he'd had some help - we tended to start them off give them material and let them get on with it. Did that with DD1 same school with a summer project teacher said it looked awful and hid it at back all the rest were clearly all parent creations- it really upset DD1 to point next year she refused to do the project.

Generally though there been enough competitions in enough areas that prizes were share out and no child won everything - which TBH is probably harder than it looks to achieve.

DianasTeacup · 03/03/2023 15:34

I think it's fine for kids not to win in a fair competition, its a lesson in life.

I think competitions should be for school based activities though. There is absolutely no fairness if parents are getting involved and helping or completing activities/crafts and those sort of competitions shouldn't be allowed. Entries should be disqualified if there has been input from anyone other than the child.

MargaretThursday · 03/03/2023 15:23

I think competitions are fine, and I'm speaking as a non-artistic, non-sporty person who has similar children. But I think there should be plenty of them so losing becomes less of a big thing because there's always another one to enter.

I do agree with child done, not parent done. However what about the child who does something really well and then doesn't win because they think the parent did it?
I've seen that happening.

When I was at primary school we had a new teacher join who did loads of competitions. We even had one to design a motif for the school-I've just checked and they still use it, which I'm finding stupidly exciting. No, I didn't design it, nor was it one of my friends.
She'd do 1-2 a term, and there would be normally a prize per year and an overall, or 2 overall (so 8 or 9 prizes in total). The prizes weren't massive, and I don't recall the same people winning them either-by accident or design I don't know. They were often quite different, so maybe they naturally had different winners. But I don't recall there being upset from anyone over not winning. I'm not sure I can even remember snide remarks.

CremeEggsForBreakfast · 03/03/2023 15:22

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/03/2023 14:59

I agree with this. It’s so easy to say “oh it builds resilience”. No it doesn’t. That’s a lazy cop out response. People who’ve been treated with respect as children are far more resilient adults.

It doesn't have to be humiliating and disrespectful to come last, though, does it? Being last is not bullying FFS.

I'm shit at swimming but I remember the time my team did not have anyone for the 25m race at the school swimming gala so I volunteered. I knew I was going to come last but we got a housepoint or something just for participating. I did indeed come last by quite some margin and I still vividly remember everyone cheering as I reached the end. It was such a buzz.
I did similar in secondary school for the 300m, again knowing I was going to come last by a long way and once again feeling elated that I'd completed the race and everyone cheered and celebrated with me.

THAT is what treating people with respect looks like. It looks like celebrating their achievement (even if it's last place) and actively teaching the child that their effort is significant and more important than their ranking.

I mean, yes. Those experiences also mean I do not now participate in competitive sport because I know it's not a talent I possess but how do you know how good you are if you don't compare yourself to another? And why does realising "this is not my strongest skill" have to be a bad thing?

Thinkbiglittleone · 03/03/2023 15:19

I do think it's healthy for kids to learn that on life they won't always win and that missing out or loosing is just part of life. It does build resilience.
However I do think that there should be activities across the year that are gives all the kids a chance to exhibit their talents, be it sport, creativity etc.

Our DS school do token star of the week etc, it's a given each child will win it throughout the year, makes it a tad pointless to me (and our DS once he has twigged) but they do it so no one is left out,

KnickerlessParsons · 03/03/2023 15:16

Everyone is good at something - be that writing poetry, mathematics, swimming, foreign languages, running fast, looking after sick people, knitting, gardening, carrying heavy stuff, singing, whatever...

I'm all for competition, but schools ought to make sure that there are enough diverse competitions so that all pupils have an equal chance of doing well in at least one of them.

There's obviously always one child who is good at everything, and who is also a child of a teacher the most popular child (these will be the children who are always chosen to be Mary and Joseph), but there's not much we can do about that.

Deanandthellhounds · 03/03/2023 15:13

I will say though, i buy way too much craft stuff for my kids now, and have enough pens to colour in my whole street!

Deanandthellhounds · 03/03/2023 15:13

Orangeis · 03/03/2023 13:54

I totally agree that every child shouldn't win every event, they all have strengths and challenges.
It's just this particular event that was parent led, most dc of 6 or 7 wouldn't have a camera, or be able to source their own craft stuff, or even know what the competition brief was.
I wonder if they were sat there thinking "Why didn't my parents bother to help me to enter this competition?"

My parents never helped with things like this, we didn't have resources at home like glue and pens or even paper.
The teacher let me take scrap paper home but it was just a fact of life, people like me don't win competitions and people like little Tom and Jane who had perfect parents did win.

I remember feeling quite jaded on a dress up day where Jane came in with a tailor made outfit her mum had spent loads of time and money on. The teachers were all gushing Over it but didn't care about my tshirt with multiple badges on that I scoured the old birthday cards to have a 'spotty tshirt' I think It was probably pudsey day.

But you know, when it came to secondary school and I had to do loads of projects, and homework and sort out stuff like that, it made me really resourceful. I mean, I found all of our old virtual cards and took the badges to make spots, that's pretty resourceful. And I entered egg competitions and stuff with my measly offerings but it was my work. I knew I couldn't compete with Jane and Tom's parents but I wasn't competing against them. I was competing against Jane and I caught up pretty fast by year seven while she was still being babied in year 11.

I don't think my parents did anything wrong, by the way. I used to go to the local library for my homework even in year 3 when I was what? Seven? and I used to be able to find encyclopedias and other non fiction books and make really good (for a seven year old) attempts.
I even made a book out of paper but I couldn't stick it together so i ripped a hair bobble open and used the elastic to tie the pages together. You just get on, don't you?

Vates · 03/03/2023 15:04

My Dad was really good with creative projects at home. Memorable homemade costumes (I was dressed as a rocket for Brownies one year and my Sister as Guy Fawkes with homemade hat and beard!). Easter masks, tudor house replicas, hedgehog art with actual 3D spikes, lots of crazy crap! Some we won, other's we didn't. My Dad worked full time in a factory manufacturing something to do with metal, we always knew what swarf was, stuck in his shoes. (Mum was a care assistant, long winded way of saying that we weren't rich). He was just genuinely creative and willing to give the time to do it.

In Secondary school I became generally frustrated and annoyed (as did my friends and others kids in class) that the student of the year awards were always the same people, year in, year out. It made us not want to go the extra mile and try to improve because those students always won so what was the point?

floratess · 03/03/2023 15:00

I didn't. I could see the girl's mum from across the field so I didn't want to step on her toes but you're right, maybe I should have. We always have to give feedback forms at the end of the year and apparently the head reads every single one so it might be worth doing so on that.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/03/2023 14:59

ZeldaB · 03/03/2023 14:55

It’s been shown over and over again that bullying and humiliating does not build resilience, it just causes depression. I hope you asked to speak to the head about why the school is deliberately humiliating a four year old.

I agree with this. It’s so easy to say “oh it builds resilience”. No it doesn’t. That’s a lazy cop out response. People who’ve been treated with respect as children are far more resilient adults.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/03/2023 14:58

I do think they have to have an eye to giving every child a chance to feel like they’ve shone at some point. Something genuine, not a small obvious pity offering.

So even if the kid is just good at, say, helping the teacher water the plants, that’s a thing. They get the helpful award, or the environment award or something.

Equally I don’t think things like sports which some kids will never ever be good at should be so disproportionately cried up compared to everything else - where the football team gets praised well above anything the academic kids, or kind kids, or creative kids do. Or the plain hard working kids. It’s not a good preparation for life, as in life it’s possible to find your niche for most people.

ZeldaB · 03/03/2023 14:55

floratess · 03/03/2023 13:47

Yes, I agree there should be some competition- sports day could have a mixture of team/independent events etc. However it seems to start so young and is often the same children being left out of winning. My children's school is very competitive. They had a cross country event the other day and even reception children took part and were given a token with their number on at the end. The little girl who got last place was crying and it just seemed a bit cruel at that age. The school says it builds resilience.

It’s been shown over and over again that bullying and humiliating does not build resilience, it just causes depression. I hope you asked to speak to the head about why the school is deliberately humiliating a four year old.

NotMyDayJob · 03/03/2023 14:53

I actually complained to school last year because I didn't agree with how the children were told who had won the easter bonnet contest (winning bonnet's hung on the classroom door) and then the parents weren't told who had won so we weren't able to prepare ourselves to deal with disappointed DC. I didn't think that was an appropriate way for 4/5 year olds to find out they'd not won a competition. The local vicar chooses the winner, and I laughed out loud when the head teacher told me he tries really hard to choose one that obviously hadn't been made by the parents.

Fair play to little Bob (not real name) but there was no way on God's green earth his parents hadn't made that hat.

Sugargliderwombat · 03/03/2023 14:51

UWhatNow · 03/03/2023 14:02

Losing and feeling sad doesn’t build resilience in many children. It builds in avoidance and low self esteem. Losing and wanting to beat people (or do better) next time can motivate a few children but at what cost?

Schools should mirror the sort of societies we want the future generations to build. Ones of inclusivity and people being celebrated for their unique talents. The thinking around managing competitive events still has a long way to go in British schools imo.

Er, how can you celebrate some people's unique talents without leaving people out 🤔. Schools just can't win 😅🤣

DoneForToday · 03/03/2023 14:41

Iam4eels · 03/03/2023 14:38

Completely agree with this.

The school where I work focuses heavily on nurturing children and one of our core values in that everyone brings something of value to our community. Across school we try to have various opportunities for everyone to shine so that it's not always the same kids.

And yes, on sports day everyone gets something. The children are in mixed age and ability teams and complete in teams. The winning team gets the school trophy and an extra playtime that Friday then everyone who takes part gets a participation prize of a pencil or a little bag of sweets or a plastic medal on a ribbon, whatever the PTA has put together.

There's also been quite a few research studies that shows that extrinsic motivation for kids (eg winning prizes, rewards or even praise) makes kids perform worse in the long term and also makes kids less likely to actually enjoy the activity and persevere with it when it requires more effort.

BelindaBears · 03/03/2023 14:39

I agree competitive things should be done in class to give an equal chance. Fine to learn winning and losing and how to deal with disappointment, but “my mam made a better Easter bonnet than your dad so I won a prize” doesn’t have much of a message. I appreciate class time is already very busy as it is though so teachers probably can’t win.

Iam4eels · 03/03/2023 14:38

UWhatNow · 03/03/2023 14:02

Losing and feeling sad doesn’t build resilience in many children. It builds in avoidance and low self esteem. Losing and wanting to beat people (or do better) next time can motivate a few children but at what cost?

Schools should mirror the sort of societies we want the future generations to build. Ones of inclusivity and people being celebrated for their unique talents. The thinking around managing competitive events still has a long way to go in British schools imo.

Completely agree with this.

The school where I work focuses heavily on nurturing children and one of our core values in that everyone brings something of value to our community. Across school we try to have various opportunities for everyone to shine so that it's not always the same kids.

And yes, on sports day everyone gets something. The children are in mixed age and ability teams and complete in teams. The winning team gets the school trophy and an extra playtime that Friday then everyone who takes part gets a participation prize of a pencil or a little bag of sweets or a plastic medal on a ribbon, whatever the PTA has put together.

DoneForToday · 03/03/2023 14:36

Swiftbushome · 03/03/2023 14:10

UWhatNow · Today 14:02

Losing and feeling sad doesn’t build resilience in many children. It builds in avoidance and low self esteem. Losing and wanting to beat people (or do better) next time can motivate a few children but at what cost?

Completely agree with this. It seems a very backward and old fashioned way of teaching kids to me.

Especially in events where its immediately obvious to everyone who came last. Like sports day, or if there's a spelling test where everyone's scores get stuck on the wall. Adults don't have to deal with this. Why should kids?
I have no issue with extra curricular events that are competitive. They can be great in inspiring the kids who choose to attend. But at least nobody is being forced to get laughed at when they come last every time.

Yeah I agree with this. As I said above, my DD is born end of August and is tiny even for her age. She always comes last. However, I think, it's fair enough because at least she can see that the other kids were faster and in front of her.

She is really good at drawing and crafts and very imaginative and puts a crazy amount of effort into the arts competitions but never gets prizes there either because they are so subjective. I wish they didn't have competitions for these as it's difficult to explain what she could do better or why she never wins.

I know some kids have to be the losers in competitions and it is just something to get used to but when out of 12 kids (small independent school) you never win anything and don't even know why then I do think that can affect your self esteem.

RafaellaOrDella · 03/03/2023 14:35

Competition is fine and healthy, parent-produced craft projects are not.

DoneForToday · 03/03/2023 14:28

I could be mistaken but in DD's school it's always the same kids winning everything. I don't mind the sports ones as at least with those there are objective criteria but I really wonder about the subjective ones like arts and crafts and the ones that kids do at home. I always insist that DD does them mostly herself as what's the point otherwise and often I cannot see how the winning entry was in any way better than or sometimes even as good as DDs though I am biased of course.
Dd's classmate's parent is a teacher in the school. They are very sporty so win most of the sports competitions anyway but they also always get prizes in all the arts competitions and the end of year "best student in the class" (or something like that. I've got no idea what the criteria is for that but I think it's to award effort) and major roles in the school plays. Parents I know in other years say the same about teachers kids being favoured. It's a private school and many teachers have kids studying there so maybe that is why there is so much nepotism. I don't know. I try to tell myself that I'm just imagining it as I do like the teachers a lot but it's getting a bit too obvious.

DD being end of August born is very unlikely to win anything for a few years. I wouldn't mind at all but it really gets to her sometimes.

I wish they'd just get rid of all the competitions. I don't think it prepares for real life at all. In real life you need to be good enough to do your job or achieve your goals or whatever else it is you have to do. It's rarely just about being better than someone else (except maybe when it comes to getting a job). I'd rather teach children Intrinsic motivation and how to give something their best even when there are no prizes to be won and no accolades.

redskylight · 03/03/2023 14:23

When DD was 3 she won the Easter bonnet competition by wearing an empty box with some sweet wrappers and stickers stuck to it. most of the children were sporting bonnets that could only have been made by an artistic prodigy of a 3 year old.

I do think that these sorts of competitions should be won by entries that are genuinely created by children. And, not required for children to do something that might be beyond them.

Logburnerperils · 03/03/2023 14:20

It is called life. You win some and you lose some.

caringcarer · 03/03/2023 14:18

I think competition is good for children to build their resilience. Don't necessarily think reception and Year 1 but probably Year 2 onwards. My Foster son excels at sports. It's all he's good at though. He went to a school where he was not given many opportunities to shine. In sports lessons for ex as mple rounder match class got split into 2 with him and all children who could not hit ball or catch on one team and more able but not exceptional children in other team. After a while he stopped bothering and did not try. Teachers spoke to me about it is at Parents Evening. He was with me. They said as he grows older and in real life he can't just not try. He replied in real life I play in a team where all players are very good. He plays county level at cricket. Swims for large town and has won many Aquathlons including county series for his county. At school they would not even let him bowl overarm in cricket despite only using a tennis ball. He said in Sport at school there was nothing for him. Non competitive Sports days with no individual running races and when team events Teachers always made him in team with least abled pupils. In first year of secondary he was picked for cross country against other schools and he won. After that year his school did not attend inter school competitions. Yet in other subjects children are set according to ability and no one bats an eyelid. In last year of primary child who won Sports award given it because used to help teacher tidy up equipment during break. That was stated at Prize Giving. At the time he had just won 2 Aquathlons in last month and been selected to play for county at cricket, which school knew about. My Foster son was furious. He won 2 awards that meant so little to him he threw them in the bin on the way out of school. He won 100 percent attendance award and Class Form award for helping other children. He said child who won Sports award was really rubbish at Sport yet according to school programme they were attainment awards not effort ones. He's at college now studying Sport and loving playing with others on his course who are all good at Sport.

Snoreboar · 03/03/2023 14:14

UWhatNow · 03/03/2023 14:02

Losing and feeling sad doesn’t build resilience in many children. It builds in avoidance and low self esteem. Losing and wanting to beat people (or do better) next time can motivate a few children but at what cost?

Schools should mirror the sort of societies we want the future generations to build. Ones of inclusivity and people being celebrated for their unique talents. The thinking around managing competitive events still has a long way to go in British schools imo.

If it's parents doing the art - like it is where we live -for the kids whose parents do not have the time, resources and inclination it just highlights how different their lives are - it doesn't make them more resilient...if that was the case the poorest kids in the country would be the most resilient - they use this to rise up - don't see it happening in great numbers - or do we need to neglect them a bit more?