Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you report this? Potential benefit fraud

389 replies

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 09:35

I’m struggling with this one, on one hand I think just leave it as everyone is struggling to survive, on the other it just doesn’t sit right with me. And I’d it even benefit fraud? I don’t have much experience with benefits so not sure. I need your thoughts! here’s the situation.

A couple had a baby a few years ago. Almost straight afterwards they split up.she got a housing association property and universal credit, she doesn’t work. He lives at his mums, has a decently paid job and doesn’t claim UC. But ever since they’ve still appeared to kind of be together. He sleeps over a few times a week, they go on days out and holidays together and she talks about them as ‘we’ and ‘us’. She’s also talked about buying a house together in the future as he is able to save a decent amount.

OP posts:
Daffodilsandtuplips · 03/03/2023 11:44

I wouldn’t judge

tattygrl · 03/03/2023 11:44

Littlefaeries · 03/03/2023 11:14

Probably is benefit fraud but wouldn’t worry me.
Years ago I had a friend whose job it was to arrive early and watch men leave the homes of women claiming benefits.
I thought it was extreme then.
When the government takes tax evasion by the rich seriously then fair enough.
In the meantime the energy companies are screwing everyone with the backing of the Tories.

EXACTLY. When the rich are no longer able to wriggle through loopholes and outright break the law to avoid tax and hide money, maybe we can worry about everyday people eeking out a few extra quid from the system. Business accountants basically predicate their whole job and usefulness on finding ways for business owners to minimise their tax and pay as little as possible, and get as many grants and benefits as possible. Not always totally legitimately, I might add. They're praised for being savvy. Double standards, and at least benefits claimants put money back in the economy, they don't hoard it.

Poppopandmorepop · 03/03/2023 11:44

They are definitely playing the system. My mums neighbour Is doing the same. Like the number of single mothers at my work, working 16 hours a week but getting top ups and everything else. Which is fine. But most have cash in hand jobs making an extra 100 + a week on top of this. Driving new cars, nice holidays, lip fillers. Bitter yes.

Daffodilsandtuplips · 03/03/2023 11:44

I judge, she’s playing the system and good luck to her.
Compared to the corrupt dodgy dealings during Covid by our so called Government this is small beer.

LuluLehman · 03/03/2023 11:43

A final question? What would you get out of this? What pleasure would it give you to see this new mother be put through hell?

OP if you want to be a one-person vigilante why don't you go after more worthy and proven fraudsters? Channel your nosey-parker energy into calling out the rich and powerful who play the system and get away with it - even though they already have so much and can't possibly need more.

Trinity65 · 03/03/2023 11:43

callmeblondee · 03/03/2023 11:38

Bang on! I am a high rate tax payer and couldnt give one flying F about what people on benefits do or dont do. I do however feel very strongly about what companies do to avoid paying trillions in tax which is of course is the real issue here, not someone claiming a couple of quid extra. and the whole "oh but people with real issues could use the money" dont be so stupid, that is not how the benefit system works.

Totally

Moonicorn · 03/03/2023 11:43

IsItThough · 03/03/2023 11:41

She's a financially abused woman. And you think she and her child shouldn't have an income?

Sounds like she’s financially abusing the taxpayer tbh

Trinity65 · 03/03/2023 11:42

What is IT with people like YOU
Keep your nose the Hell out .

Why not report those who use TAX EVASION instead
No. Always the easy targets you busybody

Blossomtoes · 03/03/2023 11:42

Moonicorn · 03/03/2023 10:06

But our babies lose money when our taxes get leeched by people on the fiddle, do they not?

Nobody’s losing anything. The amount of benefit fraud - real fraud, not a situation like this - is dwarfed by the amount of unclaimed benefits.

IsItThough · 03/03/2023 11:41

Hunnytree · 03/03/2023 11:39

This. I also know someone who planned a baby (privately funded fertility treatment), the boyfriend/partner has his own home but stays at hers roughly 2/3 of the time. She constantly complains that he doesn't help with childcare at all, and gives her no money towards the child.

But he can easily afford to contribute as he is running his own home (he owns and so does she). But she won't ask him to pay a penny because he only agreed to the fertility treatment on the understanding that he doesn't pay anything towards the resulting child. She wants to stay in a relationship with him. So she receives UC instead.

Meanwhile my husband and I have had one free NHS round of IVF- which failed. We can't afford private fertility treatment like they could do will likely never have a child of our own, and if we are blessed, we'llbe working hard to provide for them. We can't afford to buy even one home between us as we're being crippled by private rents.

I've never reported her but yeah- i think it's quite understandable why it might be tough to see people playing the system like that. These people are taking away resources from the rest of society, from your own children.

She's a financially abused woman. And you think she and her child shouldn't have an income?

Hunnytree · 03/03/2023 11:39

Moonicorn · 03/03/2023 10:06

But our babies lose money when our taxes get leeched by people on the fiddle, do they not?

This. I also know someone who planned a baby (privately funded fertility treatment), the boyfriend/partner has his own home but stays at hers roughly 2/3 of the time. She constantly complains that he doesn't help with childcare at all, and gives her no money towards the child.

But he can easily afford to contribute as he is running his own home (he owns and so does she). But she won't ask him to pay a penny because he only agreed to the fertility treatment on the understanding that he doesn't pay anything towards the resulting child. She wants to stay in a relationship with him. So she receives UC instead.

Meanwhile my husband and I have had one free NHS round of IVF- which failed. We can't afford private fertility treatment like they could do will likely never have a child of our own, and if we are blessed, we'llbe working hard to provide for them. We can't afford to buy even one home between us as we're being crippled by private rents.

I've never reported her but yeah- i think it's quite understandable why it might be tough to see people playing the system like that. These people are taking away resources from the rest of society, from your own children.

callmeblondee · 03/03/2023 11:38

Flamingogirl08 · 03/03/2023 11:36

The absolute entitlement from some posters to dictate how people live their lives is insane!

So without any idea of this couples circumstances people have jumped straight to fraud. So if you claim benefits and you're in a relationship you must live with your partner otherwise you're a fraudster. You have no say on how you live your life because you're a scummy benefit claimer and you should live how I see fit. It is everybody's responsibility to spy on these people, they must know their place.

God I hope the girl hasn't got sky TV or a smart phone because then she's really in trouble.

And to address some previous posters just because I think the OP is a nosey fucker who should keep her nose out doesn't mean I am claiming benefits or playing the system.

Bang on! I am a high rate tax payer and couldnt give one flying F about what people on benefits do or dont do. I do however feel very strongly about what companies do to avoid paying trillions in tax which is of course is the real issue here, not someone claiming a couple of quid extra. and the whole "oh but people with real issues could use the money" dont be so stupid, that is not how the benefit system works.

callmeblondee · 03/03/2023 11:36

Idkrealorfake · 03/03/2023 11:22

"On an industrial scale"??

What hyperbole.

Unless you want to point me in the direction of the businesses specialising in helping people commit fraud?

Hmm like the accountants employed by corporations and billionaires to ensure they can game the system and avoid paying tax, netting them tens of millions EACH?

I guess it's much easier for you to punch down to those just below you, than to question the corrupt class you look up to, or perhaps aspire to join.

Exactly this, people reporting on each other for somethign they have no actual facts of, making people miserable, potentially causeing real harm, curtain twitching, punching down on a few people who may just get a few extra quid (and we are talking a small amount here), yet meanwhile go and buy their coffee from tax dodging coffee places, or buy their shit from amazon, ALL NON TAX PAYERS, but no, lets turn on each other and be little watch outs for the gov... I truly believe that these type of people have no life at all. cannot bear to see people living. It is deffo projection and its entirely sad.

Flamingogirl08 · 03/03/2023 11:36

The absolute entitlement from some posters to dictate how people live their lives is insane!

So without any idea of this couples circumstances people have jumped straight to fraud. So if you claim benefits and you're in a relationship you must live with your partner otherwise you're a fraudster. You have no say on how you live your life because you're a scummy benefit claimer and you should live how I see fit. It is everybody's responsibility to spy on these people, they must know their place.

God I hope the girl hasn't got sky TV or a smart phone because then she's really in trouble.

And to address some previous posters just because I think the OP is a nosey fucker who should keep her nose out doesn't mean I am claiming benefits or playing the system.

tattygrl · 03/03/2023 11:35

JFC get a life. Sorry, but this is ridiculous. Let the DWP worry about people on benefits, god knows they make it hard enough for any of us to get any. I'm not really sure what good you hope could come out of you sending this rather tawdry list of speculation to the DWP - her money stops? You save this government about 50p a year? Benefit fraud is a tiny, miniscule drop in the financial ocean in this country. It really isn't an issue.

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 11:33

IsItThough · 03/03/2023 11:29

Oh god do you believe in "the deserving poor"?

What is the deserving poor?

OP posts:
NicknameTaker · 03/03/2023 11:33

ladykale · 03/03/2023 10:38

@NicknameTaker *highly subsidised house

Same message!

I find it baffling people don't have an issue with others playing the system which means less resources for those who really need it!

So basically benefits bashing and misguided judgment and definitely a whole load of misinformation.

We all know men should pay towards their children. Some don’t.

Social housing is set up for those who are deemed to be in need, they aren’t handed out for free like a sample in a supermarket.
Most if not all people in social housing have likely gone through years of homelessness, staying in hostels, sofa surfing or living on the street and after all of that have finally been given a home.
Some live on benefits for the rest of their lives, some go to work and would likely pay monthly rent amounting upto the equivalent of a monthly mortgage.

I think the issue is there is nothing anyone can do about what you believe is fiddling the system. We do not know the in’s and out’s of everyone’s household.

Snoopinator · 03/03/2023 11:32

Mind your own business, nosey parker!!

callmeblondee · 03/03/2023 11:32

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 11:20

No. I do think it’s morally wrong though to play the system and would much rather the extra money go to carers of disabled dc, or are too unwell to work though

What a load of shit, dont be a fkng "hero" and just go about your day and get some kind of life. I just couldnt imagine being this much of a curtain twitching nosy saddo.

LuluLehman · 03/03/2023 11:31

Moonicorn · 03/03/2023 10:03

I always think posts like this are by people on the fiddle themselves.

Report her, if there’s nothing amiss then she won’t be in any trouble 🤷🏼‍♀️

But let’s not pretend benefit fraud is a ‘victimless’ crime or ‘not really stealing’.

No. The post is from fastidiously law-abiding people like me who try to mind their own business (even though I am by nature very nosy). The op has no idea what is really going on, if it is fraud or not.

I know of a case where someone (on the evidence of a toddlers' single innocent remark) accused her own brother of child abuse. She called the police and social services got involved. The remark was proved to be totally innocent as was the brother. However, the brother was so distraught about what he had been put through - as well as what his child had been put through - and the idea that he would remain stigmatised (because neighbours etc believe "there is no smoke without fire") that he tried to end his own life.

The OPs neighbour referring to the bloke as "we" and "us" may be referring to their role as parents, not necessarily as a couple.

If the op is so interested why doesn't she just ask them? No? Thought not.

Zone2NorthLondon · 03/03/2023 11:30

@Idkrealorfake
Industrial scale absolutely industrial amounts totalling £millions. It’s fact. A perfunctory google will attest to this

Philip Green,Michelle Mone, Starbucks,Amazon, eBay, Adobe, Google, Cisco, Facebook, Microsoft, and Apple all participate in tax avoidance

latter part of your post is incomprehensible gibberish, you appear to be casting aspersions? Given I’m not a tax avoidant millionaire I really don’t feel it’s applicable

Anyway as you were

callmeblondee · 03/03/2023 11:29

Does it directly impact you, no? What the hell is the world coming to when people just cant keep their noses out of others lives. Do you not have much going on yourself? Why so concerned about what other people do, its very very very odd. Get a life and be happy.

IsItThough · 03/03/2023 11:29

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 11:20

No. I do think it’s morally wrong though to play the system and would much rather the extra money go to carers of disabled dc, or are too unwell to work though

Oh god do you believe in "the deserving poor"?

Lotsofthingstoconsider · 03/03/2023 11:28

idontbutido · 03/03/2023 09:38

That's not benefit fraud though. You can have a boyfriend who sleeps there a few times a week and you go on holiday together and still have a single UC claim.

I'm sorry it's not as simple as that.
Or everyone would be doing it !!

Hi Overthebow this falls into an investigation type called LTAHW. (Living together as husband and wife.

Every year parliament legislates an amount of money due to individual situations. Carers, low income, unemployed and Lone Parent the basis for this claim by the sound of it)

The payment made via UC is decided by the individual circumstances of that particular claimant. These are the conditions of entitlement.

When looking at this sort of case we have to establish the situation. A number of factors are considered. Staying over x times a week (there is no allowable number of nights where it is ok.. or not ok it depends on the individual. )

For example. If the child/children have severe medical needs where the other parent requires nighttime assistance with care . There would be nothing to prevent the ex partner/spouse from staying 7 nights per week.

What is considered following such an allegation is ;
Household income. Does the lone parent have the same money coming in to her or his household as a lone parent without the relationship type described. ?

Another example.
Mother A has separated . Ex partner has left the house hold entirely and sees the children EOW . No contact and pays CMS which is declared to UC(CMS is exempt from UC calculation) All bills, food, costs fall to Mother A. So from the legislated amount ALL her bills are from this source.

Mother B has a different relationship. They have separated geographically but the ex partner still contributes to the household. He does pay CMS but the children don't stay. He also brings groceries over 2/3 times a week when he may or may not stay the night. At weekends they go out as a family. Father pays every time or at least contributes. He pays for Sky. He pays car insurance for a car in his ex partners name.

Mother B therefore has a financial advantage and is not actually a 'lone parent' She simply has a partner who lives elsewhere. This is benefit fraud.

How many times a week he stays over is actually very low down the list.

Another major factor is 'perception' . Would your neighbours consider you a couple. ? Do your kids ? Wider family.

On the face of it this seems a pretty clear cut case of benefit fraud where this couple have contrived a situation to gain money they are not entitled to.

It is EVERYONES responsibility to protect the public purse . I would report this on the National Benefit Fraud Hotline.. or on line anonymously.

IsItThough · 03/03/2023 11:27

You are allowed to have a partner/lover/significant other if you are on benefits you know, and choosing not to live together is a legitimate choice.