Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you report this? Potential benefit fraud

389 replies

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 09:35

I’m struggling with this one, on one hand I think just leave it as everyone is struggling to survive, on the other it just doesn’t sit right with me. And I’d it even benefit fraud? I don’t have much experience with benefits so not sure. I need your thoughts! here’s the situation.

A couple had a baby a few years ago. Almost straight afterwards they split up.she got a housing association property and universal credit, she doesn’t work. He lives at his mums, has a decently paid job and doesn’t claim UC. But ever since they’ve still appeared to kind of be together. He sleeps over a few times a week, they go on days out and holidays together and she talks about them as ‘we’ and ‘us’. She’s also talked about buying a house together in the future as he is able to save a decent amount.

OP posts:
MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 06/03/2023 15:56

CMS isn't taken into account because too many men don't bother paying it. The government decided its easier to ignore it than to actually make the men pay.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 15:50

CMS payments should absolutely be taken into account for the sake of UC. I don’t understand why it isn’t.

Crikeyalmighty · 06/03/2023 15:42

I mentioned before about a woman I know. She has a nice HA flat in what is predominantly a private development and is a single parent to two primary aged kids.. she doesn't work and gets around£1580 in UC of which her rent is around £580 - on top of this she gets around £750 maintanance a month (2 different fathers) - she was I admit right to the point and said it was pointless working as in an average job she would be no better off at all . I must admit I was a bit gobsmacked that her maintanance doesn't affect UC at all- the point I am making is that the way benefits are currently set up is that they are almost encouraging people who aren't highly paid to not be in a couple set up or encouraging women who are lucky enough to get decent maintanance to actually work- particularly if they rent. People aren't stupid, especially if things are tight and it's hard to get social housing- they will make choices that benefit themselves first and foremost and can be seen as 'playing the system' . Personally I don't see why maintanance isn't in the figures when it comes to benefits. Maybe it would actually encourage authorities to actually get tough with lying or feckless fathers.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 15:30

Leave them to it at least they are going to better themselves

a) what makes you think they’re going to ‘better themselves’ with the money?
b) if they were Joe Bloggs stealing from the public purse via another method for a house deposit, such as fraudulent travel expenses as a minor civil servant, would you be fine with that?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 15:13

I want there to be a generous benefit system for people who really need it. Those with profound disabilities mainly. Not for people who decide work isn’t for them because they’re depressed or have a bad back and therefore they’re entitled to live off the rest of us 🤷🏼‍♀️

This. There should be ample benefits for victims of significant, involuntary misfortune. Not to bail people out of everyday issues and the predictable results of their own poor choices.

stinkfaceison · 06/03/2023 14:52

Plus there are people committing benefit fraud who you would not think would be doing it and doing it in plain sight . Friends mum many years ago was claiming left right and centre while running a small antiques business on the side for cash . Lived in a lovely leafy wealthy part of town.

stinkfaceison · 06/03/2023 14:46

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 09:35

I’m struggling with this one, on one hand I think just leave it as everyone is struggling to survive, on the other it just doesn’t sit right with me. And I’d it even benefit fraud? I don’t have much experience with benefits so not sure. I need your thoughts! here’s the situation.

A couple had a baby a few years ago. Almost straight afterwards they split up.she got a housing association property and universal credit, she doesn’t work. He lives at his mums, has a decently paid job and doesn’t claim UC. But ever since they’ve still appeared to kind of be together. He sleeps over a few times a week, they go on days out and holidays together and she talks about them as ‘we’ and ‘us’. She’s also talked about buying a house together in the future as he is able to save a decent amount.

This was going on 40 years ago . Leave them to it at least they are going to better themselves. Once they buy house they won't be so reliant on the state . They are trying to better themselves.

pointythings · 06/03/2023 14:45

@Moonicorn and you and yours aren't monstering benefit claimants? So much pejorative language on this thread, and so little empathy.

I don't claim benefits, but I know people who do. It's far from life of Reilly.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 14:35

pointythings · 06/03/2023 14:33

for all the benefit bashers on here

You won't read it, or if you do you won't give a flying fuck because you don't have a conscience or any human decency, but here it is anyway.

This country is so full of shitty hateful people.

Oh grow up. Critiquing or discussing benefits is actually legal, and what’s more, we should do it. I can’t think of any other area of public spending that posters on here are attacked for discussing. This ‘shut the conversation down by monstering people who disagree’ it just boring, and will have the reverse effect.

pointythings · 06/03/2023 14:33

for all the benefit bashers on here

You won't read it, or if you do you won't give a flying fuck because you don't have a conscience or any human decency, but here it is anyway.

This country is so full of shitty hateful people.

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 06/03/2023 14:32

Throwncrumbs · 06/03/2023 14:26

That’s because the days of popping out 6,7, or even 8 kids and getting benefits for them have changed, unless of course you work the minimum hours which allows you the maximum benefit which lets you get away with the 2 child limit!

No it doesn't.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 14:27

Throwncrumbs · 06/03/2023 14:26

That’s because the days of popping out 6,7, or even 8 kids and getting benefits for them have changed, unless of course you work the minimum hours which allows you the maximum benefit which lets you get away with the 2 child limit!

That’s what worries me about Labour getting in. I just cannot forget the days of the early 2000s when feckless parents with 5 kids were absolutely raking it in because there were no caps.

Throwncrumbs · 06/03/2023 14:26

Fifi0102 · 06/03/2023 01:19

Having loads of kids is becoming a thing of the past. There's a 2 child limit for UC and child benefit pays £12 a week for subsequent children. £12 pays for fuckall. The most kids I've seen benefit claimants have is 3.

That’s because the days of popping out 6,7, or even 8 kids and getting benefits for them have changed, unless of course you work the minimum hours which allows you the maximum benefit which lets you get away with the 2 child limit!

Overthebow · 06/03/2023 14:24

When Rishi puts his money in a tax haven to avoid paying his fair share of tax it's prudent.

Nope didn't like that either.

OP posts:
Throwncrumbs · 06/03/2023 14:22

Wish I had done this, stayed in rented place claiming benefits and getting rent paid, while my boyfriend in his well paid job saved for us to have holidays abroad every year. I could have prob had a lovely car as well, while all you mugs out there working and paying tax were paying for my lifestyle choice…

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 14:20

When Rishi puts his money in a tax haven to avoid paying his fair share of tax it's prudent. When someone on benefits does anything to maximise their income, even within the law, it's irresponsible and scrounging.

Of course it wasn’t, it killed his chances of being PM at the time. There was a lot of talk about it and none of it good. He’s PM now so 🤷🏼‍♀️ maybe it didn’t last long, but nobody went ‘ooooh that’s prudent’.

There is a difference between earned money, and money other people have earned that is taken from them to give to people who haven’t earned it.

Mumsnet posters seems to have a really, really hard time wrapping their head around that.

If somebody has paid £500,000 in tax they’re less likely to get worked up over them ‘hiding’ another 100k than somebody who contributes nothing and whose entire lifestyle is funded by others.

I want there to be a generous benefit system for people who really need it. Those with profound disabilities mainly. Not for people who decide work isn’t for them because they’re depressed or have a bad back and therefore they’re entitled to live off the rest of us 🤷🏼‍♀️

blueskylie · 06/03/2023 14:14

blueskylie · 06/03/2023 14:05

Poor people who game the system and produce offspring they can't afford. I haven't noticed anyone criticizing hardworking, ambitious, prudent poor people who understand the value of self discipline (and contraception.)

Maybe those qualities are why they aren't permanently poor & dependent.

Are you talking about Boris Johnson?

I find this argument repugnant and also illustrates my point. Anyone on benefits is lazy, imprudent, not hard working, promiscuous. Poor because of character flaws. Those of us who are hard working and prudent are not poor. It's a way of thinking that demonises the poor and of course is promoted by all the very wealthy lazy, promiscuous and imprudent people in government with actual huge character flaws.

When Rishi puts his money in a tax haven to avoid paying his fair share of tax it's prudent. When someone on benefits does anything to maximise their income, even within the law, it's irresponsible and scrounging.

blueskylie · 06/03/2023 14:05

Poor people who game the system and produce offspring they can't afford. I haven't noticed anyone criticizing hardworking, ambitious, prudent poor people who understand the value of self discipline (and contraception.)

Maybe those qualities are why they aren't permanently poor & dependent.

Are you talking about Boris Johnson?

Mrsjayy · 06/03/2023 12:02

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 00:12

But in the OP's scenario the man is the father of the baby. They need to support their own family, not mooch off fellow citizens.

Well we don't know if they are "mooching "or even together because the Op doesn't know anything about their situation !

LuluLehman · 06/03/2023 06:20

JazbayGrapes · 05/03/2023 20:26

Are you saying that you play the system too?

Playing the system isn't fraud. The system is rigged. People get financially punished if they try to better themselves.

If you read my post and the quote you will see that I am having a laugh with the quotee who has accused all who support the accused of playing the system ourselves.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 01:33

@Fifi0102

There is no global shortage of humans.

And birthing more into shitty, thoughtless, dependent situations is not a societal benefit.

ConcordeOoter · 06/03/2023 01:28

Don't create problems for other people ffs, and unless you have seen some actual proof a fraud exists don't accuse people of it or gossip about it as if it does based on assumptions.

Fifi0102 · 06/03/2023 01:25

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 01:24

Two children is two too many if one can't provide decently for them.

Better to focus on ones own education & employment, not one's sex life, till one can be a contributing member of society. THEN procreate.

Birth rate is declining and we have an aging population.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 01:24

Two children is two too many if one can't provide decently for them.

Better to focus on ones own education & employment, not one's sex life, till one can be a contributing member of society. THEN procreate.

Fifi0102 · 06/03/2023 01:19

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 01:00

But why should the rest of is support these shiftless people who are in no position to (honorably, anyway) continually produce additional offspring, when they can't even support themselves adequately? It boggles the mind.

Having loads of kids is becoming a thing of the past. There's a 2 child limit for UC and child benefit pays £12 a week for subsequent children. £12 pays for fuckall. The most kids I've seen benefit claimants have is 3.