Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you report this? Potential benefit fraud

389 replies

Overthebow · 03/03/2023 09:35

I’m struggling with this one, on one hand I think just leave it as everyone is struggling to survive, on the other it just doesn’t sit right with me. And I’d it even benefit fraud? I don’t have much experience with benefits so not sure. I need your thoughts! here’s the situation.

A couple had a baby a few years ago. Almost straight afterwards they split up.she got a housing association property and universal credit, she doesn’t work. He lives at his mums, has a decently paid job and doesn’t claim UC. But ever since they’ve still appeared to kind of be together. He sleeps over a few times a week, they go on days out and holidays together and she talks about them as ‘we’ and ‘us’. She’s also talked about buying a house together in the future as he is able to save a decent amount.

OP posts:
Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 23:27

As with many situations in life, the more you do for somebody, the higher their expectations and the lower the gratitude.

100 years ago a welfare state that gave you somewhere adequate to live, money for a basic lifestyle and free unlimited healthcare was nothing but a pipe dream. (I’ll wait for the ‘you want us to go back to Victorian times!’ responses from those hard of analytical thinking skills).

Now it isn’t enough, it’s actually seen as a ‘pittance’ and people claiming benefits honestly expect to be able to have takeaways, holidays, Netflix, nights out. They don’t see their entitlement to enjoyment as any less than the person slogging away to put the money in their account to start with, when it is 🤷🏼‍♀️

The fact is when claiming benefits puts you on almost the same, or the same, level of lifestyle as somebody who works full time and doesn’t claim, then benefits will be the more appealing option. It’s endearing how many users of this website truly believe everyone claiming benefits are worse off because they won’t get a mediocre pension and maybe a say in their nursing home in return for 50 years of graft. I mean, wake up.

blueskylie · 06/03/2023 23:08

-There is a difference between earned money, and money other people have earned that is taken from them to give to people who haven’t earned it.

But that's exactly what i'm talking about. Hearing about this tory peer who just got awarded £300k levelling up grant to fix the potholes on his private driveway - that's not what levelling up was intended for and it's some millionaire taking money off the taxpayer. He didn't earn that money.

And Rishi is PM. It did not damage his chances.

woodhill · 06/03/2023 21:40

Crikeyalmighty · 06/03/2023 21:20

@Moonicorn Thing is I'm actually social minded, I'm not a Tory - but I feel really peeved for the single mum teachers and nurses I see on here or couples on low incomes but both working who get next to no benefits , if any at all , as are just over- or have a mortgage etc. many if these get peppercorn maintainance too if any.

My own personal view is that unless you have children under 5 or a physical disability that stops you being able to work or a child with a disability that means you have higher caring responsibilities then maintanance should count towards income into the house and focus on getting back to chasing non resident parents who aren't paying up for their children and partners when able. There will be less 'playing the system' then I think and yes if they want to live separately for social reasons, then all fine and dandy but let's remove the financial incentive to do so - and at the moment I feel there is one.

Have to agree

It isn't right

JustKeepGoingThere · 06/03/2023 21:22

People are being dumb if they think they can tell whether or not the couple are committing benefit fraud or not. They look like they 'might' be and that's why they should be reported.

Crikeyalmighty · 06/03/2023 21:20

@Moonicorn Thing is I'm actually social minded, I'm not a Tory - but I feel really peeved for the single mum teachers and nurses I see on here or couples on low incomes but both working who get next to no benefits , if any at all , as are just over- or have a mortgage etc. many if these get peppercorn maintainance too if any.

My own personal view is that unless you have children under 5 or a physical disability that stops you being able to work or a child with a disability that means you have higher caring responsibilities then maintanance should count towards income into the house and focus on getting back to chasing non resident parents who aren't paying up for their children and partners when able. There will be less 'playing the system' then I think and yes if they want to live separately for social reasons, then all fine and dandy but let's remove the financial incentive to do so - and at the moment I feel there is one.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 21:10

LakieLady · 06/03/2023 20:44

Isn't it possible that either one or both of them don't actually want to live together?

I know couples, with children, who love each other and are in committed relationships, but value their independence and don't want to live together 24/7.

Should couples be forced to live together to save the taxpayer a bit of money?

They shouldn't be "forced" to live together but they shouldn't be rewarded for NOT living together, if they are otherwise operating as a couple/family unit.

JustKeepGoingThere · 06/03/2023 20:55

You can't tell if it's benefit fraud or not which is why you should report it and why I would report it. You can't know what the actual situation is though so it's pointless speculating. I'd just report them and forget about it.

Why should the state subsidise the family when there is a Dad/ boyfriend involved.

Fuck that. I'd rather money go towards people who are more in need.

LakieLady · 06/03/2023 20:44

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 16:16

Oh come off it she’s clearly gaming the system. Why should other people be happy to pay for it?

Isn't it possible that either one or both of them don't actually want to live together?

I know couples, with children, who love each other and are in committed relationships, but value their independence and don't want to live together 24/7.

Should couples be forced to live together to save the taxpayer a bit of money?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 20:41

Seymour5 · 06/03/2023 18:52

Couple, married or not, decide to have a child, or children. Realise it takes two moderate incomes to finance the family. One choice is that they live together in one property, both work, pool resources, and qualify for no means tested benefits. They get child benefit.

Identical sized family, similar earning power, they realise they don’t both have to work, especially if father (usually him) earns more, and has an ‘alternative’ address where he might keep a few things, gets his mail sent, and occasionally uses the spare room. His parents’ house for instance. Resident parent, particularly if the home is rented, gets quite a raft of benefits, including housing and council tax benefits and all the add ons like the recent COL payments. Big savings on child care costs and of course non resident parent’s contribution is not counted. The cohabiting couple whose income is assessed together, get none of these. Is that really how it should work?

Perhaps Universal Basic Income is the way forward.

Bingo!

Seymour5 · 06/03/2023 20:17

XenoBitch · 06/03/2023 19:15

I live alone and am on benefits. I am not sure what the problem with that is. It is not a crime to be single. Me house sharing would not cost the tax payer less.

Its more affordable, as most young, lowish earners know, to share accommodation. Of course, if a single person has all housing costs (social housing perhaps) covered by benefits, there’s no incentive to share. Without knowing reasons for living on benefits, it’s impossible to have an opinion on individual cases.

EnthENd · 06/03/2023 20:04

YABU, because the DWP have a reputation for shooting first and asking questions later.

Based on what you have said, it's not necessarily fraud. It's arguably "playing the system" - but at the same time it's a woman making sure she and her daughter have their own home and income.

Considering the rich play the system to the max, I can't get too worked up at a poor woman taking everything the law gives.

XenoBitch · 06/03/2023 19:15

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 16:39

OK, but then why should the rest of us, the taxpayers, fund those choices? I prefer to live alone too, but no one is subsidizing that.

I live alone and am on benefits. I am not sure what the problem with that is. It is not a crime to be single. Me house sharing would not cost the tax payer less.

Blossomtoes · 06/03/2023 18:57

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 17:18

Guess you could say the same for big corporations tax evading then 🤷🏼‍♀️ won’t be spent well, so let ‘em have at it?

It’s completely different. Corporate tax evasion costs billions that the Treasury will never see. Benefit fraud is money already collected and allocated.

Seymour5 · 06/03/2023 18:52

Couple, married or not, decide to have a child, or children. Realise it takes two moderate incomes to finance the family. One choice is that they live together in one property, both work, pool resources, and qualify for no means tested benefits. They get child benefit.

Identical sized family, similar earning power, they realise they don’t both have to work, especially if father (usually him) earns more, and has an ‘alternative’ address where he might keep a few things, gets his mail sent, and occasionally uses the spare room. His parents’ house for instance. Resident parent, particularly if the home is rented, gets quite a raft of benefits, including housing and council tax benefits and all the add ons like the recent COL payments. Big savings on child care costs and of course non resident parent’s contribution is not counted. The cohabiting couple whose income is assessed together, get none of these. Is that really how it should work?

Perhaps Universal Basic Income is the way forward.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 18:10

And don’t forget if you’re not happy to do it, you’re very very right wing - touching on Goebbels in fact.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 18:07

Crikeyalmighty · 06/03/2023 17:24

@LetThemEatTurnips it's not very encouraging though is it to working single parents or even working coupled up parents on 2 lower incomes when the person I know has£2300 coming in, £580 rent and doesn't do a tap of work - whereas the working ones are very little better off or just over the limit to get any help at all

Remember we’re supposed to be happy to fund her, being away from our own kids to do so 😂 piss take, isn’t it?

Crikeyalmighty · 06/03/2023 17:24

@LetThemEatTurnips it's not very encouraging though is it to working single parents or even working coupled up parents on 2 lower incomes when the person I know has£2300 coming in, £580 rent and doesn't do a tap of work - whereas the working ones are very little better off or just over the limit to get any help at all

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 17:18

Blossomtoes · 06/03/2023 16:56

Because the money wouldn’t be spent on new nurses, even if there were 25,000 people straining every sinew to start training.

Guess you could say the same for big corporations tax evading then 🤷🏼‍♀️ won’t be spent well, so let ‘em have at it?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 17:08

Hoplesscynic · 06/03/2023 17:01

So you are saying people shouldn't have a choice to live independently, but rush to move in (or move back with) a partner, just because they are on low income claiming benefits?

I shared flats and houses when I was on low income, until my earnings progressed such that I could afford my own place. And I made a point to NOT produce children that would hinder me from becoming financially solvent and able to support myself.

If someone has made the choice to procreate, then yes, they should do the usual things such as, oh, live with the person they chose to procreate with, or get other types of roommates, etc. Put in a little effort and put up with a little hardship, frankly. Not say "oh we are together / co-parenting/ whatever but don't want to LIVE together so taxpayers, please top me up!"

The money doesn't come from a magic pot, it comes from fellow citizens getting up and going to work every day. It should be applied for as a last resort, not a first resort. And one doesn't necessarily get to have everyone as one prefers, when someone else is paying the price.

And sorry, but if one is on the dole, one isn't living "independently."

Hoplesscynic · 06/03/2023 17:01

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 16:39

OK, but then why should the rest of us, the taxpayers, fund those choices? I prefer to live alone too, but no one is subsidizing that.

So you are saying people shouldn't have a choice to live independently, but rush to move in (or move back with) a partner, just because they are on low income claiming benefits?

Blossomtoes · 06/03/2023 16:56

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 16:22

Why does some people not claiming make others defrauding the system fine and acceptable?

Why wouldn’t you rather people stopped thieving and we paid for 2500 new nurses with the proceeds of the fraud?

Because the money wouldn’t be spent on new nurses, even if there were 25,000 people straining every sinew to start training.

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 16:51

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 16:43

Or god forbid if one of us productive net taxpayers saves up enough to buy a rental property and becomes the dreaded landlord!

Yep! Then you really are evil greedy scum!

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 16:51

MoreSleepPleasee · 06/03/2023 16:45

They don't have to pretend to split. You are allowed a relationship. They could be married even. I was with my ex 7 years and we never lived together (shocking hey). But op has said they don't live in the same house so they are doing nothing wrong.

Well clearly they have 🤷🏼‍♀️ we all know it’s dishonest. It doesn’t matter how you try to slice and dice it on here.

MoreSleepPleasee · 06/03/2023 16:45

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 16:36

😂 oh please. It’s patently obvious what’s happened, they worked out hon much better off they would be if she pretended to be a single mum so pretended to split. You can’t be this naive?

They don't have to pretend to split. You are allowed a relationship. They could be married even. I was with my ex 7 years and we never lived together (shocking hey). But op has said they don't live in the same house so they are doing nothing wrong.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 06/03/2023 16:43

Moonicorn · 06/03/2023 16:40

100%. Why is it okay only for benefits claimants to be selfish and look after number 1 at everyone else’s expense, yet somebody who actually works full time and pays tax does something - let’s say doesn’t declare a cash in hand job - and they’re suddenly a greedy fat cat desperate for everyone else to starve?

Or god forbid if one of us productive net taxpayers saves up enough to buy a rental property and becomes the dreaded landlord!