Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have refused to get out of my car for the police in the middle of the night?

871 replies

AngeloMysterioso · 02/03/2023 17:05

Was driving home from work at just after 2 a.m last night when I was pulled over by a pair of male coppers in a squad car after I swerved in the road to avoid a pothole.

I stopped, lowered my window a crack and then turned the engine off and made sure all the doors were locked. They both got out of the car and came over, asked about where I was going, where I’d been etc etc and then asked about the swerve- I explained about the pothole, and that I didn’t consider the move to have been dangerous as there were no other vehicles or anywhere near me (they had been some distance in front of me at the time and on the other side of the road but there was absolutely no chance of a collision) and no pedestrians anywhere around.
Then they asked if I would get out of the car and take a breathalyser test. I refused- I said I’d happily drive to the police station (maybe a mile- mile and a half away) and take a breathalyser there, but that I didn’t feel safe getting out of my car and being alone with two massive blokes in the middle of the night with no other people around, and them being in a uniform didn’t change that for me.

They asked a few more questions about my work, if they needed to would anyone be able to verify that I’d been working, gave me a lecture about driving safely and in the end let me go home with no further action taken - but I’ve just had a phonecall from another police officer basically telling me off for not just doing as I was told.

Was I BU?

OP posts:
ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 04/03/2023 13:33

@Daysoffarethebest are you a man? I’m genuinely surprised that a woman would accuse another woman of ‘hysteria’ for not getting out in the situation OP described.
On her own, industrial estate, early hours of the morning.
Broad daylight, on a high street with people around I would have got out no probs. But I wouldn’t have got out either unless they forced me to.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 04/03/2023 12:41

I’m sorry my post was hard to follow for you. I find your thinking a bit muddled too. Equating a machete wielding person with a lone women in a car who has a perfectly reasonably explanation and is suggesting alternatives (albeit not workable ones, but it shows willing) to giving a test whilst maintaining her sense of safety is just daft. Obviously the police thought it a reasonable explanation too at the time as they allowed her on her way

My point about the machete- as I suspect you know very well - is that policing does not work if some groups are permitted to ignore the police’s instructions. (Although, as someone who has treated lots of both, I can assure you that you’re just as dead if you’re hit by a nice, middle-class drunk driver as you are if you’re macheted by a scrote).

This isn’t just because it would make the police’s job impossible, but because it is fundamental to a democratic society that everyone is subject to the law (yes, even you, Boris).

No one has questioned the police’s actions in regards to the OP, as an individual. But most of this thread has been posters arguing that lone women in general should be permitted to refuse police instructions.

Why lone women but not young black men? They are less at risk of sexual assault but at much higher risk of general assault. I bet there aren’t many MNetters arguing that the young men should be allowed to ignore police orders if they are afraid of the police.

OMG12 · 04/03/2023 12:08

ArabellaScott · 04/03/2023 09:53

Ah women have 'hysteria' for being wary of the police. Of course.

I think you’re the first person on this thread to use the word hysteria, probably more a reflection of your own thoughts????

OMG12 · 04/03/2023 11:32

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 09:48

I have reported the comment as I wasn’t sure either.

Thank you! Tbh it was clearly sinister in intention. So much for these people being all about supporting women to make them feel safe whilst simultaneously making threats, I’ve taken a screen shot.

Justforthissnippet · 04/03/2023 11:16

Not after an opinion, more if there is policy or a standard operating procedure on it.

If a compromise situation needed, could ask for keys first I guess.

When I have seen testing stops that do everyone driving past (normally around Xmas) it’s always been in car so obviously sometimes it’s deemed acceptable

Lockedinforwinter · 04/03/2023 11:12

Of course doing a breath test with someone sat in their car is a bad idea. It is likely to go very wrong when they fail the breath test, find themselves sat in the drivers seat with their keys and decide to make off. You then have a massive risk to that person and anyone they drive into, followed by headlines about incompetent police officers.

Justforthissnippet · 04/03/2023 11:04

Sorry, comply within the law, not without obviously. Crucial typo there.

Justforthissnippet · 04/03/2023 11:03

The same is true of drivers, yes even naice middle-class professional women. They drive drunk too. And, no, it is not possible for the police to tell reliably who is intoxicated by talking to them. I want drunk drivers off the roads

I’m sorry my post was hard to follow for you. I find your thinking a bit muddled too. Equating a machete wielding person with a lone women in a car who has a perfectly reasonably explanation and is suggesting alternatives (albeit not workable ones, but it shows willing) to giving a test whilst maintaining her sense of safety is just daft. Obviously the police thought it a reasonable explanation too at the time as they allowed her on her way.

People must comply without the law. Here, police need a reasonable suspicion that the driver is over the limit to demand a breath test. Now, what ‘reasonable’ equates to would need to be put to the test, but arguably there was no longer a reasonable case once the conversation had finished.

Bigger picture, my point that police need to be kept accountable and challenged when they are not doing things correctly stands (externally and from within). There are many cases that have shown this, and have led to change.

I know it wasn’t you that said it, but unless there is evidence that doing a breath test whilst someone’s perfectly calm in a car is not considered good practice, that seems a reasonable compromise to me.

bluetongue · 04/03/2023 10:45

Maybe I’m old fashioned but I still think of Police as someone who will (usually) look out for my best interests and that their orders should be obeyed apart from in extenuating circumstances.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 10:41

SpyouttheLand · 03/03/2023 08:34

Thisis all part of the problem! How is that OK? They might be cheap, but they're not his and that's stealing from taxpayers. Yet he appears to have no qualms at all about doing it publically.

Where are the standards? I wouldn't take so much as an envelope from work and if it was found I was doing it regularly, I'd be disciplined.

How much more cost to the tax payer than a few chap breathalysers is the police and court time if they are over the limit and caught. Not to mention the heartbreak caused to victims of drunk drivers and their families ? And why are you assuming he stole them ? Seems like good PR for the police to try and keep alcohol related death off the road by any means possible.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 04/03/2023 10:26

The police don’t need anymore headlines about women being scared of them, and if they’d have arrested me, then refused to let me rest at the station, I would have fought any charges all the way to the highest court AND made a song and dance about it to the media.
are women right to be wary of being alone with police officers at night in remote areas? Yes, they are - and not even the most right wing of judges or courts would disagree that she probably did feel unsafe.

ChunkaMunkaBoomBoom · 04/03/2023 10:24

‘She was on the brink of refusing to leave the car for a breathalyser when they decided no further action. Had they not been able to verify from talking to her that she was sober, they would have insisted on the breathalyser and had she continued to refuse, she would have been arrested - her own actions would have put her in a more risky situation than if she had complied. Refusing a breath test carries a potential prison sentence’

sorry, but that’s balls .

  1. she can take the test while sitting in her car
  2. they would have taken her to the station where she would have taken the test.

The police need our consent to police us and abusing their powers by arresting her for not getting out of a car to do the test then refusing to let her do one at the station is a clear abuse of those powers.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 10:19

lieselotte · 03/03/2023 11:45

Follow her and pull her over somewhere well lit. Like a station, a pub, a petrol station, a supermarket car park.

It's not hard.

And risk an accident if she is drunk ?

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 10:13

WedonttalkaboutMaureen · 03/03/2023 12:31

@Rosscameasdoody she didn't refuse to do a breath test. She said she wasn't getting out of her car. Different.

If they weren’t in a situation which allowed the breath test to be administered inside the car then, yes, she was refusing.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 10:10

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 20:45

There's an obvious difference between me asking someone for help and them asking me. A lost child should ask an adult for help. If an adult approaches a child for no reason, alarm bells go.off.

A policeman in America just won a bravery award for shooting to death an unarmed man doing the school run. I don't know why you are holding them up as an example.

Whether you ask them or they ask you, the trust issue is the same. They will be alone with you in the early hours when they respond. How is that any different. And I’m not holding up US police as any example, except for similar issues leading to defunding and chaos. Which is where we’re headed if we all start refusing to comply.

Daysoffarethebest · 04/03/2023 10:04

ArabellaScott · 04/03/2023 09:53

Ah women have 'hysteria' for being wary of the police. Of course.

So predictable.
Nobody is saying women have hysteria.
I said in some of these posts and quoted exactly what was meant, which I stand by.
I totally understand the fear but it should be proportionate, after all everybody knows you shouldn’t hold prejudice against every individual in a certain group based on the actions of some of that group, but that concept has been helpfully forgotten here.

ArabellaScott · 04/03/2023 09:53

Ah women have 'hysteria' for being wary of the police. Of course.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 09:48

OMG12 · 03/03/2023 14:37

And what is that supposed to mean?

I have reported the comment as I wasn’t sure either.

Rosscameasdoody · 04/03/2023 09:45

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 20:41

What crime had the OP committed to result in a prison sentence? You don't just get a prison sentence because you've annoyed a policeman. There's a court process to go through

She was on the brink of refusing to leave the car for a breathalyser when they decided no further action. Had they not been able to verify from talking to her that she was sober, they would have insisted on the breathalyser and had she continued to refuse, she would have been arrested - her own actions would have put her in a more risky situation than if she had complied. Refusing a breath test carries a potential prison sentence

Daysoffarethebest · 04/03/2023 08:44

With the level of hysteria in some of these posts, I’m surprised anybody leaves the house for fear some kind of catastrophe could happen.
“Highly highly dangerous”to get out of a car when stopped by two police officers who gave no creepy vibes and were admittedly polite-get a grip man!

Emotionalsupportviper · 04/03/2023 08:27

OMG12 · 03/03/2023 14:22

And you think it’s only one step from calling someone a rapist to being one🤦‍♀️. I actually despair!

So do I - but not for the same reasons, I imagine.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 04/03/2023 06:51

Justforthissnippet · 04/03/2023 00:28

explaining why it isn't realistic for you to remain in your car to perform a breathalyser test (some regional forces might do this from time to time, but its far from best practice and I suspect it only happens in cases where the officers involved are pretty much certain you aren't under the influence in any case)

What are you basing the statement that doing it in cars isn’t best practice on?

Also, if officers need reasonable reason to suspect drinking to administer a breath test, having spoken to the OP one could argue that they no longer had that anyway.

Yes, the risk is higher in this scenario that she would have been arrested for not agreeing to get out the car, than attacked if she did. But I do think this is less obvious in legal terms than some people are suggesting. In these cases, I think it’s problematic to say that people should comply because it’s easier as a general principle. Because often, it is challenge that highlights bad practice by the police, or where things can be improved.

That's a very muddled response, and a very naive one.

Most people whom the police have to apprehend are not naice MNetters who have unexpectedly had to swerve round a pot-hole. No police force can operate if the people whom they are lawfully stopping or arresting can decide whether or not to comply.

We had to call the police to our A&E dept this week, to detain someone who was waving a machete. I'm not that keen for a machete-waver to be allowed to decide not to comply, so that he can "highlight bad practice or where things can be improved".

The same is true of drivers, yes even naice middle-class professional women. They drive drunk too. And, no, it is not possible for the police to tell reliably who is intoxicated by talking to them. I want drunk drivers off the roads.

I totally get why women are fearful - I am myself. But the answer cannot be that lone women (or any other group who justifiably fear the police - e.g. young black men) can decide not to comply with lawful police instructions.

speakingofart · 04/03/2023 06:11

You absolutely weren't being unreasonable - I would have got the non emergency number on the phone and sent a text to a friend with my location as well (though tricky at 2am). Highly highly dangerous situation in which you could easily have been raped and murdered so you absolutely were right not to trust as far as you could throw them. Fundamentally, if they want us to act otherwise, they need to stop committing these awful acts themselves.

Threee · 04/03/2023 05:36

They could have radioed and arranged for a female officer to undertake checks. I expect individual police officers will need to work hard to regain most women's trust now. This is a natural consequence

Justforthissnippet · 04/03/2023 00:28

explaining why it isn't realistic for you to remain in your car to perform a breathalyser test (some regional forces might do this from time to time, but its far from best practice and I suspect it only happens in cases where the officers involved are pretty much certain you aren't under the influence in any case)

What are you basing the statement that doing it in cars isn’t best practice on?

Also, if officers need reasonable reason to suspect drinking to administer a breath test, having spoken to the OP one could argue that they no longer had that anyway.

Yes, the risk is higher in this scenario that she would have been arrested for not agreeing to get out the car, than attacked if she did. But I do think this is less obvious in legal terms than some people are suggesting. In these cases, I think it’s problematic to say that people should comply because it’s easier as a general principle. Because often, it is challenge that highlights bad practice by the police, or where things can be improved.