Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
romatheroamer · 02/03/2023 17:15

As GiveMushy explained so well, assault (a criminal offence and therefore a basis for manslaughter) doesn't have to involve physical contact with the victim.

DipperandMabel · 02/03/2023 17:15

I think the sentence is appropriate. She caused the death of a woman, verbally abusing her beforehand too then fucked off to the shops for a jolly!

Even if she had been startled, who would just leave a person lying on the road to die? That’s cruel and quite sickening. She didn’t even panic and go home to hide, she just carried on with her day as if nothing had happened.

Actions speak louder than words. I would have been more sympathetic towards her if she at least tried to help in some way.

TheGreatATuin · 02/03/2023 17:15

GoingOff · 02/03/2023 17:13

Pedestrians should always take priority. They can walk where they like! Crazy to think that fit and healthy cyclists should be able to force every other group off shared paths. Often there isn’t another route available.

The cyclist in this case wasn't forcing anyone off the path. The pedestrian forced the cyclist into the road. It was obviously an incredibly dangerous thing to do.

BrigitteBond · 02/03/2023 17:13

spelunky · 02/03/2023 17:08

It doesn't matter whether or not she pushed her. She still caused her death, hence it was manslaughter.

If she actually pushed the cyclist into busy traffic then one could argue it was murder.

I was commenting on the PP writing that the judge had seen the evidence and decided it was a push.

Unless I've missed it it's not been alleged that it was a push.

TheGreatATuin · 02/03/2023 17:13

I'm horrified by some of the reactions on this thread. Some spaces are shared by cyclists and pedestrians.
The result of this woman's actions were easily foreseeable. If you shout and swear and deliberately make physical contact with a cyclist who is close to a busy road, then it is very likely that they will fall into oncoming traffic.
At best, the cyclist would have had to swerve to avoid contact. It was an incredibly foolish and dangerous thing to do to her, and even worse, considering that there was no evidence that cycles weren't even allowed on the path.
I think a custodial sentence is essential tbh, based on this thread alone. No one has the right to endanger someone else like that. They just don't.
I'd hope that some of the posters on this thread take that on board.

GoingOff · 02/03/2023 17:13

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 02/03/2023 17:11

Pedestrians have a choice whether to use shared paths or not. If a pedestrian cannot is unwilling to stick to have of the shared path then they should walk somewhere else. If cyclists want to cycle more than one abreast, again a shared path is unsuitable and they need to go somewhere else. It’s basic stuff.

Pedestrians should always take priority. They can walk where they like! Crazy to think that fit and healthy cyclists should be able to force every other group off shared paths. Often there isn’t another route available.

dawngreen · 02/03/2023 17:13

She may have just thought the cyclist had hit the kerb badly and fallen. Then she got hit with the car. So she assumed it was sadly a accident nothing to do with her. And maybe she was in shock a bit. None of us know.

Plenanna · 02/03/2023 17:13

She was sentenced to three years imprisonment. Meanwhile in my town there is a hardened criminal who has undertaken a series of violent offences and death threats over the past year, including assaulting two police officers, possession of an offensive weapon and actual bodily harm. He has been sentenced to two years imprisonment. What the fuck is going on with the legal system?

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 02/03/2023 17:11

Pedestrians have a choice whether to use shared paths or not. If a pedestrian cannot is unwilling to stick to have of the shared path then they should walk somewhere else. If cyclists want to cycle more than one abreast, again a shared path is unsuitable and they need to go somewhere else. It’s basic stuff.

Patchworksack · 02/03/2023 17:10

Whoever decided the path was suitable for shared use should bear some responsibility. In the BBC footage a cyclist speeds past a reporter talking to camera in the spot it happened and is very near the edge of the pavement. www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-cambridgeshire-64824436

Blossomtoes · 02/03/2023 17:08

NewCarOldCar · 02/03/2023 17:00

She "literally" didn't "shove" her. She rightly told her off for being on the pavement

She wasn’t right. I live in the town. It’s a combined cycle path and pavement and clearly marked as such. The cyclist had as much right to be on it as the pedestrian.

spelunky · 02/03/2023 17:08

BrigitteBond · 02/03/2023 17:06

Yet as far as we know she was prosecuted for waving her arms and swearing, rather than for 'pushing'. That should tell you that there's no evidence she pushed the lady.

It doesn't matter whether or not she pushed her. She still caused her death, hence it was manslaughter.

If she actually pushed the cyclist into busy traffic then one could argue it was murder.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/03/2023 17:08

That's no indication the 77 lady was hurtling anywhere.

Are you saying then it was reasonable to try to topple the lady even if not into traffic?

The fact she a saw the accident she'd caused then tootle off to Sainsburys its frankly chilling

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 02/03/2023 17:08

Moonicorn · 02/03/2023 17:05

This needs to be balanced against the feeling of the deceased’s family.

Somebody who causes death by careless (not dangerous) driving may be full of remorse, no risk to the public and counterproductive to lock up, but that wouldn’t acknowledge the victim’s lost life.

It’s a tricky one.

So are you saying that if the deceased woman had no family, it would be OK not to jail the pedestrian?

OopsAnotherOne · 02/03/2023 17:07

I haven't seen all of the evidence, only what has been posted on the news sites, but although I can see both sides I think I am on the side of agreeing that the sentence is fair.

From the facts I can gather: on the one hand, there's the argument that a cyclist should be on the road rather than the pavement (which is subject to it's own fine) and the partially sighted lady was startled by the oncoming cyclist. The lady did not physically push the cyclist into the road, nor did she cause the cyclist to fall off or lose control of her bicycle, which was what led to the cyclist being hit by a car.

On the other hand, the pavement has not been confirmed as a "pavement" and it's contentious as to whether bicycles are allowed there or nor. The pavement was 8ft wide, wide enough for both users to allow each other to pass. The lady did not say "please may you cycle on the road rather than the pavement? The pavement is only for pedestrians, not cyclists", she waved her arms and swore which could have frightened the cyclist into feeling an imminent assault was oncoming. This may have meant the cyclist felt pressured and panicked into rejoining the road when it was unsafe for her to do so, leading to her falling off the bike. After the cyclist is hit by the car, the lady does not stop to enquire about her wellbeing, nor did she show any remorse until the day of the trial, she went on her way and bought some shopping.

Whether the cyclist should have been on the pavement or not, she shouldn't have died that day. Although she was responsible for her own re-entry to the road and was responsible for keeping control of her own bicycle, it's likely she would not have felt the need to rejoin the road at that moment and in that manner if she had not been sworn and gestured at by the lady. The lady's actions caused the cyclist to take measures which led to her death, which wouldn't have happened if the lady did not take those actions.

soleilblue · 02/03/2023 17:07

Whitewolf2 · 02/03/2023 17:06

I read there was no clear signage of it being a cycle path as well as pavement. The cyclist should have been in control and stopped when she saw this woman waving and swearing - who to me seems to have mental health issues.

The judge took into consideration all mitigating circumstances

BrigitteBond · 02/03/2023 17:06

Cantseethewoodforthetree · 02/03/2023 17:03

Luckily the judge who had full view of all of the evidence thought otherwise.

Yet as far as we know she was prosecuted for waving her arms and swearing, rather than for 'pushing'. That should tell you that there's no evidence she pushed the lady.

GoingOff · 02/03/2023 17:06

Exactly. Pedestrians can be blind, deaf, physically disabled, ND, elderly, children etc. There's no threshold of competence. The cyclist should have been pushing her bike.

This. Every single free person is allowed to walk the streets and they are not all going to have good awareness of the needs of cyclists for a whole host of reasons. I would bet that 9 times out of 10 it’s the disabled person who comes off worse. This seems to be a dangerous precedent. If you are cycling near pedestrians in a confined space then you need to exercise extreme caution.

Whitewolf2 · 02/03/2023 17:06

I read there was no clear signage of it being a cycle path as well as pavement. The cyclist should have been in control and stopped when she saw this woman waving and swearing - who to me seems to have mental health issues.

PuddlesPityParty · 02/03/2023 17:05

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:40

Yes. It was an accident.

She made contact (AKA pushed) her. It wasn’t an accident.

MichelleScarn · 02/03/2023 17:05

ClaraThePigeon · 02/03/2023 16:13

Her actions caused the victim to fall into the path of a car. She may not have intended to kill her, but she caused the accident.

There was a bit more to it than just a profanity. She made "light contact" Her language and gestures were aggressive and again we have not seen all the evidence that the jury did.

Exactly, is it because the victim was a cyclist there's so much sneeryness and blaming? If it had been a jogger AG had been aggressive towards and had admitted 'contact' resulting in their death with would that be different? The police themselves have NOT stated that the cyclist shouldn't have been on the pathway, and that it was unclear as whether this is shared for cyclists and pedestrians or not.

Moonicorn · 02/03/2023 17:05

Porpl · 02/03/2023 15:37

I agree, it's a tragedy but I don't think it benefits society her being jailed.

This needs to be balanced against the feeling of the deceased’s family.

Somebody who causes death by careless (not dangerous) driving may be full of remorse, no risk to the public and counterproductive to lock up, but that wouldn’t acknowledge the victim’s lost life.

It’s a tricky one.

soleilblue · 02/03/2023 17:04

SleepingStandingUp · 02/03/2023 17:03

But she did the thing that CAUSED Z the accident that killed a woman. That's manslaughter

Yeah I don't think people get that.

Manslaughter.

No one is saying she deliberately killed the cyclist.

givemushypeasachance · 02/03/2023 17:04

There's different types of manslaughter in the UK - a lot of people are probably thinking of the more typical sorts, which is where a crime is in effect murder, but due to the circumstances you "downgrade" it to manslaughter because of diminished responsibility or provocation. There's also gross negligence manslaughter, which is where you owe a duty of care to someone.

The third type which I believe this was is "unlawful and dangerous act manslaughter". So for that, you don't have to have intended any harm to the person that died. It's not like a murder case where you intended to give someone a bloody nose, but they hit their head and died, well tough you intended serious harm and that's bad enough. For unlawful and dangerous act manslaughter, if you commit any unlawful act and as a consequence someone dies, then there you go. If you commit a burglary and somehow someone died as a consequence, that's enough.

Aggressively shouting and waving at someone, in a way that can cause them to fear for their safety, is common assault. You don't have to have actually hit them - a raise fist and shouting is well established to amount to common assault. Most reasonable people could interpret that walking towards a 77 year old woman, waving your arm at her and shouting get off the fucking pavement, could make her afraid for her safety. As a result of that assault, the woman veered her bike into the road and died. That is sufficient to charge the offence, and the jury has convicted her.

spelunky · 02/03/2023 17:03

There seems to be a lot of confusion about the meaning of the word "manslaughter".

Nobody is saying that this woman intentionally killed the cyclist.

However, her actions undeniably caused the cyclists death.

This is why it is manslaughter and not murder.

You cannot go around aggressively gesticulating at cyclists on busy roads - it is incredibly dangerous and irresponsible behaviour.

She also just went off to the supermarket afterwards without even checking on the cyclist.

She deserves the sentence.