Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
HufflePuffllePuff · 03/03/2023 00:25

@NoBoatsOnSunday

Likewise the cyclist would have seen her coming towards her and being agitated. Most people would have stopped in that situation not carried on cycling until they were abreast of her (no, not victim blaming just seeing it from both sides) so wouldn't have lost their balance and fallen into the road.

It's reported the pedestrian had 'cognitive impairments' but the Judge said she doesn't have a learning disability. Potentially on the ASD spectrum then. That will maybe explain her reaction before and after the event, flapping and also lack of friends which PPs have said means she must be a nasty person. Also lack of diagnosis due to her age as it wouldn't have been picked up in the 1970s.

Obviously speculation but I still can't see anything to say she actually pushed the cyclist in the road. It's reported that she was asked if she'd touched her and and said it may have been a 'light touch' but that probably would have been after a lot of questioning which for someone with ASD would have been extremely difficult and confusing. My ASD DS would agree to anything to get people to shut up and leave him alone.

I stand by that this was a terrible accident and the pedestrian has been treated unjustly. I see there is a campaign already been started for her so plenty of others agree.

You can feel sadness and sympathy that someone lost their life at the same time as feeling that this was an unjust verdict.

This was a retrial as well. Does anyone know what the first verdict was and why?

Everyonesinvited · 03/03/2023 00:22

NoBoatsOnSunday · 03/03/2023 00:07

She obviously knew it was a bike and where the bike was in relation to her, based on her gestures.

I’m sure the extent of her visual impairment, and the consequences thereof, would have been properly considered at court. Do you have any basis for thinking otherwise?

Her perception of the threat posed to her may have been magnified by seeing it differently, her ability to process a constructive way to protect herself if believing herself in danger, her clear lumbering inability to step out of the way. All factors that mitigate that wouldn't mitigate with a 19 year old teenager sound in wind and limb. No legal basis but I think accomodations should always be made to allow for difference when it's present, rather than presuming.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 00:15

Court isn’t always fair. We know that.

She may have been poorly represented. She presents as someone unattractive especially in her anger. The judge may have been wrong about the shared cycle/pedestrian pavement. The other woman so tragically killed was older, more frail and appeared more likeable.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 03/03/2023 00:07

Everyonesinvited · 02/03/2023 23:49

You've missed my point completely! We don't know what that looked to her. It could have been a dark shape getting rapidly closer in a head on collision in her perception. She obviously knew it was a bike but it's not the same thing as a nimble young man stepping to one side.

She obviously knew it was a bike and where the bike was in relation to her, based on her gestures.

I’m sure the extent of her visual impairment, and the consequences thereof, would have been properly considered at court. Do you have any basis for thinking otherwise?

Everyonesinvited · 02/03/2023 23:49

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:45

She was certainly able to see the cyclist from at least a few metres away, given that she started swearing and gesticulating a good few seconds before the cyclist passed her.

You've missed my point completely! We don't know what that looked to her. It could have been a dark shape getting rapidly closer in a head on collision in her perception. She obviously knew it was a bike but it's not the same thing as a nimble young man stepping to one side.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:45

Everyonesinvited · 02/03/2023 23:34

I agree. She seems to be a victim of a system that doesn't accommodate disability. There is no knowing what she knew, or what a cyclist coming towards her looked like to her. At the same time, I don't think her behaviour was acceptable.

She was certainly able to see the cyclist from at least a few metres away, given that she started swearing and gesticulating a good few seconds before the cyclist passed her.

Everyonesinvited · 02/03/2023 23:37

MsJD · 02/03/2023 23:34

Shes lucky they didnt do her for murder. If she pushed the old lad into the path of an on coming car, then there is intent to cause serious harm or death. I.E. Murder. She could then have used here health issues to get diminished responsibility. She has got off light. Prosecution needs to appeal. 3 years is light

She didn't push anyone into the path of an oncoming car and there is not a shred of evidence for intent to commit murder. The car being right there was a variable she would have known about but couldn't guarantee in a planned murder.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:36

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:27

Just watched it again. It's definitely unclear whether she shoved her or not. It's literally off camera.

twitter.com/Cinister09/status/1631291726538104833/mediaViewer?currentTweet=1631291726538104833&currentTweetUser=Cinister09

this is a close up of the slighty longer version of the video.

You can see that:

the cyclist was going in a straight line until she was mostly passed the pedestrian;

just as the cyclist was passing, the pedestrian turns her upper body towards her and lifts her arm;

the cyclist’s bike then begins to suddenly tip to the right, then she swerves;

after the bike starts to tip, the pedestrian brings her arm back towards her body.

We cannot see the contact itself, because it is obscured by the pedestrian’s back, but we know that there was at least some contact (because she admitted as much).

Like I said, you can’t prove it was a push….but it looks a lot like one, particularly given the contact admission.

MsJD · 02/03/2023 23:34

Shes lucky they didnt do her for murder. If she pushed the old lad into the path of an on coming car, then there is intent to cause serious harm or death. I.E. Murder. She could then have used here health issues to get diminished responsibility. She has got off light. Prosecution needs to appeal. 3 years is light

Everyonesinvited · 02/03/2023 23:34

ScrollingLeaves · 02/03/2023 23:28

“A partially-sighted pedestrian with cerebral palsy has been has been found guilty of killing an elderly cyclist who had "angered" her by cycling on the pavement”.

She seemed to be almost flapping her arm at the cyclist. Her walk was a side-to-side kind. She does not look quite mentally or physically sound at all. The sentence seems wrong.

Apparently, according to the judge, the pavement was supposed to be shared by pedestrians and cyclists, and she ‘surely knew that’, but it certainly does not look wide enough for that to have been good traffic planning by the city council. Where are the standard pedestrian and cycle
markings?

How does the judge know she ‘knew’ that?

I agree. She seems to be a victim of a system that doesn't accommodate disability. There is no knowing what she knew, or what a cyclist coming towards her looked like to her. At the same time, I don't think her behaviour was acceptable.

ScrollingLeaves · 02/03/2023 23:28

“A partially-sighted pedestrian with cerebral palsy has been has been found guilty of killing an elderly cyclist who had "angered" her by cycling on the pavement”.

She seemed to be almost flapping her arm at the cyclist. Her walk was a side-to-side kind. She does not look quite mentally or physically sound at all. The sentence seems wrong.

Apparently, according to the judge, the pavement was supposed to be shared by pedestrians and cyclists, and she ‘surely knew that’, but it certainly does not look wide enough for that to have been good traffic planning by the city council. Where are the standard pedestrian and cycle
markings?

How does the judge know she ‘knew’ that?

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:27

Just watched it again. It's definitely unclear whether she shoved her or not. It's literally off camera.

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:23

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:11

I agree with the majority that, while not conclusive, the video (coupled with the pedestrian’s own statement that she made ‘light contact’) seems to show that the pedestrian deliberately pushed the cyclist into the road.

Even if she did not make meaningful contact, her aggressive shouting and gesturing was a criminal act that was directly and foreseeably responsible for causing the cyclist’s death.

Leaving the scene and the absence of remorse plunges her into irredeemable scumbag territory.

Yeah, I can't disagree she's a scumbag for just sauntering off. I took it that she shouted aggressively at the cyclist which startled her into swerving. Not a nice way to act and with terrible consequences but ultimately that she only meant to swear at her, which is perhaps more understandable given her cognitive issues and sight issues which likely means rash cyclists pose more of a threat to her than to most.

However, if she actually shoved her then that's entirely different.

MsJD · 02/03/2023 23:22

3 years is not enough IMO. She caused the death of a 77-year-old retired midwife. I hope the prosecution appeal against this unduly lenient sentence.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:20

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 02/03/2023 23:12

No, it's not clear. All you, can see is her turning as the video ends.

If you watch it properly it is clear. She shouts, swears and gesticulates. Then you can see her stop for a brief moment and move her arm out as soon as Celia comes alongside her (her hand passes in frame as it moves up). You can then see her arm coming back in towards her body as Celia left the pavement, at the angle that is correct to have pushed Celia's shoulder. You can even see her body weight shift backwards slightly because she was leaning towards Celia's bike on that step. Finally, even she said she made contact. So yes, it's plenty clear.

Yup. The cyclist was cycling in a straight line, with her front wheel straight, right until she was about 3/4ths of the way past the pedestrian.

At that point, you can see the pedestrian turn her body towards the cyclist and extend her arm
towards her.

The bike immediately begins to tip to the right, the the cyclist swerved into the road, and your can see the pedestrian bring her arm back towards her body.

You do not see the point of contact, but we know there was at least light contact as the pedestrian admitted it.

I appreciate it might not have been provable in court, but it looks a hell of a lot like a push.

In the end I suspect the police didn’t even want to get into whether there was a push or not, as manslaughter could be easily established on the incontrovertible facts.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 02/03/2023 23:13

OneTC · 02/03/2023 23:13

It's an unfortunate situation because someone had died, not because a woman has gone to prison for probably 18 months for being responsible for that death.

Absolutely

WhoSaidWhat123 · 02/03/2023 23:13

murasaki · 02/03/2023 15:59

Did the driver who hit the cyclist get charged? I couldn't see that anywhere.

Why would they? A car does not break instantly you know.

OneTC · 02/03/2023 23:13

It's an unfortunate situation because someone had died, not because a woman has gone to prison for probably 18 months for being responsible for that death.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 02/03/2023 23:12

No, it's not clear. All you, can see is her turning as the video ends.

If you watch it properly it is clear. She shouts, swears and gesticulates. Then you can see her stop for a brief moment and move her arm out as soon as Celia comes alongside her (her hand passes in frame as it moves up). You can then see her arm coming back in towards her body as Celia left the pavement, at the angle that is correct to have pushed Celia's shoulder. You can even see her body weight shift backwards slightly because she was leaning towards Celia's bike on that step. Finally, even she said she made contact. So yes, it's plenty clear.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:11

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:03

She shouted at her. I highly doubt the intention was physical harm, yet alone death. It's not even comparable to the 'one punch' cases where drunken youths have a scrap and kill each other with a single punch.

I agree with the majority that, while not conclusive, the video (coupled with the pedestrian’s own statement that she made ‘light contact’) seems to show that the pedestrian deliberately pushed the cyclist into the road.

Even if she did not make meaningful contact, her aggressive shouting and gesturing was a criminal act that was directly and foreseeably responsible for causing the cyclist’s death.

Leaving the scene and the absence of remorse plunges her into irredeemable scumbag territory.

WhoSaidWhat123 · 02/03/2023 23:10

ReformedWaywardTeen · 02/03/2023 15:55

I think it's disgusting and if the cyclist had of been a younger person nothing would have come of it and it would've been death by misadventure.
She had no helmet on and was cycling at speed on a pavement, with no apparent shared use or cycle path, she came at a woman who was partially sighted.
I think there should be an outcry, the cyclist was at fault, she was going to fast and swerved to avoid a pedestrian. If she had of had a helmet on she would've survived.

The justice system in this country never ceases to amaze me at how it's totally heavy handed in some cases and overly lenient in others.

Cycling at speed? Are you joking? The little bit of footage we do see shows the cyclist at a low speed. Which footage did you see to be adamant that the cyclist was going too fast and had to swerve? The pedestrian puts her arms out at the cyclist, the cyclist isn’t going towards the pedestrian at all.

ScrollingLeaves · 02/03/2023 23:10

What a tragedy.

'This was a shared path for cyclists and pedestrians, I am sure you knew cyclists used the path, and were not taken by surprise,' the judge said.

How can he be so sure she knew?
It was also reported the woman had cognitive issues.

To me three years in prison for someone like her seems excessive and useless.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 02/03/2023 23:04

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:01

Otherwise it would be a murder charge.

No, it wouldn't be murder if she didn't have the intent to kill her or cause gracious bodily harm. Manslaughter is correct because she was reckless to the danger her actions caused.

I don't think she was thinking 'let's shove this old lady into the road to kill her', and the prosecution would have had a really hard time proving that, so it wasn't murder. However I absolutely believe she didn't really think about the road or the traffic, just that she was justified in pushing the cyclist she didn't think should be there, out of the way.

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:03

NoBoatsOnSunday · 02/03/2023 23:00

Even if it was established, beyond all doubt, that the cyclist should not have been on that path, this sentence would still be lenient.

I am staggered that so many (albeit a minority) feel otherwise.

She shouted at her. I highly doubt the intention was physical harm, yet alone death. It's not even comparable to the 'one punch' cases where drunken youths have a scrap and kill each other with a single punch.

AllDayBreakfast92 · 02/03/2023 23:01

Otherwise it would be a murder charge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread