Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 10:53

This woman did not seem quite mentally or physically normal. Isn’t she partially sighted too?

Why would she react ‘normally’ if that is the case? If anything maybe she should be in a nursing home, not a prison.

All people with CP have problems with movement and posture. Many also have related conditions such as intellectual disability; seizures; problems with vision, hearing, or speech; changes in the spine (such as scoliosis); or joint problems (such as contractures).

Damage to the basal ganglia can cause issues with controlling anger and other emotions. Basal ganglia damage is often associated with athetoid cerebral palsy, but can affect other types of cerebral palsy

It is believed that 25% of all cerebral palsy patients have behavioral issues. Those most at risk include cerebral palsy patients with epilepsy, intellectual disabilities, and severe pain.
Some of the problem behaviors include:
Anger issues making conflict likely

Cognitive impairment

^Symptoms of CP in adults
Some forms of CP, such as spastic cerebral palsy, cause stiff muscles, exaggerated reflexes, and abnormal movements when walking or trying to move. CP can affect the entire body, but it may also only impact one side of it. Common symptoms of CP include: muscle weakness.24 Sept 2018^

Associated autism is also possible with cerebral palsy.

That the pavement was supposed to be a joint pedestrian and cycle path is ridiculous, especially without markings - if it was indeed a joint cycle and pedestrian path, then maybe the city council highways department should be partly liable for not maintaining it correctly with markings and signs.

The ‘surely you knew about the path being shared’ remark of the judge does not seem fair at all.

The woman was sort of flapping her arms at the cyclist thinking she would be hit by the cycle. The cyclist must have veered out of the way, or at any rate not exactly been pushed. Of course the accused should have just stepped out of the way, instead of swearing and flapping, but it didn’t look as though she was either nimble or quick witted.

I heard on the radio news there will be an appeal.

Lou670 · 03/03/2023 10:48

I think she got a lesser sentence than she would have done as cyclists are not supposed to be riding on the pavement anyway. So many ifs and buts and many mitigating circumstances. She should not have left the scene of the accident and find it hard to believe that someone could have done that.

whatsup00 · 03/03/2023 10:45

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 10:35

@whatsup00 Well you can use that logic to a lot of people going to prison.

Don't you think the victim who died in a moment of fear as the car ploughed into her, and the driver, who will live with the guilt for an accident they had no control over, deserve justice?

Don' t you think the children, husband or family of the victim deserve justice?

It's not about the affect on the perpetrator that's the issue here. She committed a crime and now has to take the consequences of her actions. It's what we teach children.

I think it's incredibly sad that Celia Ward died. It's horrible. And I see the impact it has on her family (although I don't think it should be a different punishment whether someone has zero friends vs having a family of 100 caring members).

I have only been able to watch the short video, not the longer one (the link is broken). From what I saw, she shouted and sort of jerked her arm (almost like flapping/repetitive movement). As someone else on this thread said, why didn't the cyclist just stop?

If there was any physical contact that's different (as it could have pushed her into the road or altered her course) but from the BBC article it's shouting get off the fucking pavement (which is not a crime as far as I'm aware, although it's rude) and flapping her arm at someone.

I also think had the pedestrian been tiny it may not have happened, as it looked like her body was quite wide and blocking the pavement which isn't her fault, it's just her stature.

Just my opinion - some cases aren't clear cut. I just didn't like all of this focus on going shopping. If something shocking happened to me, I would stick harder to my routine tbh, no matter how bad it was.

For me justice is a very odd concept anyway. I don't really see what use this woman going to prison serves. Prison seems to increase offending, maybe she ends up as a shoplifter after losing everything, we don't know. I have had people commit fairly serious crimes against me and I didn't actually want them to go to prison, I wanted whatever caused them to do it to be put right which I didn't think prison would achieve.

aSofaNearYou · 03/03/2023 10:41

But what on earth is prison going to do about this? Nothing I'd guess. Or make her situation worse (lose her home, etc).

Strange answer. That's the point of prison - to rehabilitate. Ending up in jail for acting like this should stop someone from being inclined to do it again.

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 10:37

The perpetrator admits she may have made slight contact. The force is not the issue, it was a threatening gesture which the victim reacted to. Threatening behaviour is also a criminal offence in itself. She put the cyclist in fear and her reaction had devastating consequences

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 10:35

@whatsup00 Well you can use that logic to a lot of people going to prison.

Don't you think the victim who died in a moment of fear as the car ploughed into her, and the driver, who will live with the guilt for an accident they had no control over, deserve justice?

Don' t you think the children, husband or family of the victim deserve justice?

It's not about the affect on the perpetrator that's the issue here. She committed a crime and now has to take the consequences of her actions. It's what we teach children.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 10:31

Rubbish the clips do not show her pushing her!! She hears the cyclist losing it because she has lost her balance on the manhole cover. So she turns to look.

What video are you watching?! Her arm moves up past her torso and retracts back in from being extended towards the cyclist, and she admits she made contact! Her weight shifts back because she leans in to push her, and I don't see a manhole cover where her front wheel veers off the pavement. She turns back to face the front when the cyclist is falling, she doesn't turn backwards to see what's happening.

whatsup00 · 03/03/2023 10:26

aSofaNearYou · 03/03/2023 08:08

To me three years in prison for someone like her seems excessive and useless.

I don't get the "what is the point of her going to prison" comments.

There are a lot of people who maintain that she had every right to do what she did and the cyclist was at fault purely for being there when she (maybe) was not supposed to be. The woman herself shows no remorse for what happened.

There is a very real possibility that left unchecked, she'd have done something like this again. She may not be deliberately murderous but her actions and the continued belief that they were correct, pose a threat to the public.

But what on earth is prison going to do about this? Nothing I'd guess. Or make her situation worse (lose her home, etc).

whatsup00 · 03/03/2023 10:23

I just want to say one thing. When my dad died, I went back into high school that day, I was messing around in class, laughing and smiling. It doesn't mean I wasn't devastated, in bits.

The fact she went to do her shopping means nothing at all, some people carry on as normal. Whether she went home and cried in her bedroom or went to the shops, that to me is completely irrelevant. The news article seems to focus on her going to the shops. I mean maybe she had no food in anyway.

All she seemed to do is say "get off the f-ing pavement" and gesture.
I thought it was illegal to ride on the pavement anyway.

Showing no remorse is a different matter.

dawngreen · 03/03/2023 10:12

Having seen the longer clip, I am in no doubt the pedestrian pushed the cyclist.
She may not have intended her to die, but she certainly intended to hurt her and didn't care what happened next.

Rubbish the clips do not show her pushing her!! She hears the cyclist losing it because she has lost her balance on the manhole cover. So she turns to look.

Everyonesinvited · 03/03/2023 09:34

NoBoatsOnSunday · 03/03/2023 00:49

But you’re just assuming all of these things in her favour without, I imagine, access to all relevant information from the trial (which I would fully expect to include medical evidence as to the extent and effect of AC’s disabilities in the context of the case).

Is it not possible, in your mind, that she purposefully assaulted the cyclist in anger?

Or if you accept that she purposefully assaulted the cyclist, are you confident that the extent of her disabilities mean that the guilty verdict and/or sentence cannot possibly be appropriate, regardless of the evidence that was before the court?

I'm saying these things should have been given due weight and they don't seem to have been. No assumptions.

Everyonesinvited · 03/03/2023 09:32

Grumpybutfunny · 03/03/2023 07:58

If she so disabled she doesn't know it's wrong to push someone off a bike (something we teach nursery age kids) then she needs to spend the rest of her life in prison!

You must mean an institution.

Donnashair · 03/03/2023 08:55

I simply can’t get my head round what argument people have, when they say she shouldn’t be in prison. Especially, when they say her disability is the reason she shouldn’t be.

Either she has capacity and acted knowing she was being intimidating and should have known her actions caused danger to another person, or she didn’t.

If she doesn’t have capacity and still thinks she is in the right and can not control her actions, she is a danger to the public. She will do it again. Perhaps next time to a victim (some) people feel is more deserving justice. What happens then? She is just allowed to carry on?

Her actions were extremely dangerous and led to someone’s death. It’s really that simple.

MajorCarolDanvers · 03/03/2023 08:11

Her bad behaviour caused a death - that's manslaughter.

Yes that deserves imprisonment.

aSofaNearYou · 03/03/2023 08:08

To me three years in prison for someone like her seems excessive and useless.

I don't get the "what is the point of her going to prison" comments.

There are a lot of people who maintain that she had every right to do what she did and the cyclist was at fault purely for being there when she (maybe) was not supposed to be. The woman herself shows no remorse for what happened.

There is a very real possibility that left unchecked, she'd have done something like this again. She may not be deliberately murderous but her actions and the continued belief that they were correct, pose a threat to the public.

Grumpybutfunny · 03/03/2023 07:58

If she so disabled she doesn't know it's wrong to push someone off a bike (something we teach nursery age kids) then she needs to spend the rest of her life in prison!

JackiePlace · 03/03/2023 07:11

@NoBoatsOnSunday link doesn't work. can you repost? (Thanks)

iloveeverykindofcat · 03/03/2023 06:48

People claiming she has cognitive impairment (no idea if this is true): the average IQ of the prison population is 13 points below the national average. Literacy rates are also well below average. If you think that's a mitigating factor, its part of a much bigger problem.

3 years is light. Her excessive aggression directly caused the death of another person. She then left the scene and continued with her day. She is dangerous.

steff13 · 03/03/2023 01:11

Everyonesinvited · 02/03/2023 23:34

I agree. She seems to be a victim of a system that doesn't accommodate disability. There is no knowing what she knew, or what a cyclist coming towards her looked like to her. At the same time, I don't think her behaviour was acceptable.

She was at the trial and had the opportunity to testify correct? Certainly she would have shared that information when she had the opportunity to do so.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 01:09

snitzelvoncrumb · 03/03/2023 01:07

If you watch the footage look at her legs. You can see her using a little force. She definitely pushed her.

I would suggest that you can't tell anything by looking at her leg movements. She suffers from Cerebral Palsy and has reduced mobility.

snitzelvoncrumb · 03/03/2023 01:07

If you watch the footage look at her legs. You can see her using a little force. She definitely pushed her.

snitzelvoncrumb · 03/03/2023 00:50

I just watched the footage. She pushed her onto the road. She may not have intended for the cyclist to be killed, but she is responsible for the death. I don’t know if prison is the right thing, maybe a care home.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 03/03/2023 00:49

Everyonesinvited · 03/03/2023 00:31

A good lawyer doesn't necessarily know how to secure accomodations for disability - it's quite specialised.

The fact you're judging her on a lack of remorse etc demonstrates the extent to which the court system is geared to favour NT, mentally able people who can process what the right thing to do is and rise to the level of circumstances, as it were. Some people simply can't.

But you’re just assuming all of these things in her favour without, I imagine, access to all relevant information from the trial (which I would fully expect to include medical evidence as to the extent and effect of AC’s disabilities in the context of the case).

Is it not possible, in your mind, that she purposefully assaulted the cyclist in anger?

Or if you accept that she purposefully assaulted the cyclist, are you confident that the extent of her disabilities mean that the guilty verdict and/or sentence cannot possibly be appropriate, regardless of the evidence that was before the court?

Everyonesinvited · 03/03/2023 00:31

NoBoatsOnSunday · 03/03/2023 00:27

Her lawyer is a very prominent, senior KC, with particular expertise in murder and manslaughter charges involving vulnerable people. I doubt that AC was poorly represented. You probably couldn’t ask for better legal counsel in the circumstances.

I’d also say that she was quite a sympathetic defendant, as can be seen from the media reaction to her sentencing.

And even if the judge was wrong about whether the pavement was shared or not, that does not excuse AC’s actions (most of which are absolutely plain from the video…save for that she’s probably gotten away with a deliberate push).

We also know that she left the scene, lied to the police and did not show a shred of remorse until sentencing.

It’s hard to see any reason for thinking she has been treated in an unduly harsh manner.

A good lawyer doesn't necessarily know how to secure accomodations for disability - it's quite specialised.

The fact you're judging her on a lack of remorse etc demonstrates the extent to which the court system is geared to favour NT, mentally able people who can process what the right thing to do is and rise to the level of circumstances, as it were. Some people simply can't.

NoBoatsOnSunday · 03/03/2023 00:27

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 00:15

Court isn’t always fair. We know that.

She may have been poorly represented. She presents as someone unattractive especially in her anger. The judge may have been wrong about the shared cycle/pedestrian pavement. The other woman so tragically killed was older, more frail and appeared more likeable.

Her lawyer is a very prominent, senior KC, with particular expertise in murder and manslaughter charges involving vulnerable people. I doubt that AC was poorly represented. You probably couldn’t ask for better legal counsel in the circumstances.

I’d also say that she was quite a sympathetic defendant, as can be seen from the media reaction to her sentencing.

And even if the judge was wrong about whether the pavement was shared or not, that does not excuse AC’s actions (most of which are absolutely plain from the video…save for that she’s probably gotten away with a deliberate push).

We also know that she left the scene, lied to the police and did not show a shred of remorse until sentencing.

It’s hard to see any reason for thinking she has been treated in an unduly harsh manner.