Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
dawngreen · 03/03/2023 13:27

SHARED PATH IN UK

Top tips for cyclists
Whether you use them for a nice and safe family cycle ride in the great outdoors, or use them to commute from A to B avoiding busy roads, shared paths are really useful and fantastic for cyclists. Following our top tips for cyclists will ensure using shared paths is a positive experience for everyone.
Put a bell on your bike! Pedestrians welcome a polite warning of your approach. If you don’t have a bell, use a friendly greeting instead and always do this in plenty of time so you don’t surprise people or animals when approaching from behind.
Important: don’t ring your bell near horses, instead talk to the rider and check it is safe to pass.
Take care when passing other path users and ride at an appropriate speed. If necessary wait to pass until there is enough room.
Important: don’t ride fast when pedestrians are around.
Give way to pedestrians and wheelchair users, if you need to.
Be aware that pedestrians may have hearing impairments or be wearing in-ear headphones so might not hear your bell, so pass slowly and give as much space as possible.
When cycling on segregated shared paths, always keep to your side of any dividing lines.
Say a quick ‘thank you’ as you pass. Polite behaviour encourages others to share the space better.
Keep to the left when passing oncoming pedestrians or cyclists. Overtake on the right of any pedestrians and cyclists going the same way as you (like on the road). Again, do not ride too quickly. Think... if a pedestrian stepped into your path could you stop in time?
Be particularly careful at junctions, bends, entrances onto the path, or any other ‘blind spots’ where people or animals could appear without warning.
Groups of cyclists should ride in single file when approaching pedestrians on a shared pathway.
In dull and dark weather make sure you have bike lights on so you can be seen. It’s also a good idea to wear hi-visibility clothing too.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 13:26

ReformedWaywardTeen · 02/03/2023 15:55

I think it's disgusting and if the cyclist had of been a younger person nothing would have come of it and it would've been death by misadventure.
She had no helmet on and was cycling at speed on a pavement, with no apparent shared use or cycle path, she came at a woman who was partially sighted.
I think there should be an outcry, the cyclist was at fault, she was going to fast and swerved to avoid a pedestrian. If she had of had a helmet on she would've survived.

The justice system in this country never ceases to amaze me at how it's totally heavy handed in some cases and overly lenient in others.

Whether she had a helmet is completely irrelevant. Highly unlikely to make any difference if you are hit by 2 tonnes of metal traveling at speed.
It's just like saying a girl who was raped is at fault for wearing a skirt. There's no evidence it makes any difference. And even if it does, the onus is not on the victim of a violent and senseless attack.

Livingtothefull · 03/03/2023 12:51

I am sure that her disability and mitigating factors were taken into account in sentencing; but her actions led directly to the death of another person ie manslaughter. There is nothing 'bizarre' in sending her to prison.

The victim blamers and evident cyclist haters on here have made this thread a nauseating read in parts.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 12:50

Blossomtoes · 03/03/2023 12:39

The police and the local council did not know if it was a shared path so how the heck did the judge decide it was?

It’s always been a shared path, ever since it was built in 1975. Everyone who lives here knows it is.

What’s the reference to NSW? Are you quoting Australian law @dawngreen?

Yes, just like everyone in my area 'knows' that the main road has shared paths on both sides of it.

It hasn't.

If you're local could you tell me where there's a sign on that side of the road indicating a shared path?

Blossomtoes · 03/03/2023 12:39

The police and the local council did not know if it was a shared path so how the heck did the judge decide it was?

It’s always been a shared path, ever since it was built in 1975. Everyone who lives here knows it is.

What’s the reference to NSW? Are you quoting Australian law @dawngreen?

LadyWiddiothethird · 03/03/2023 12:32

Yes she should be in prison,clearly she thought her disability would excuse her behaviour.

dawngreen · 03/03/2023 12:25

The police and the local council did not know if it was a shared path so how the heck did the judge decide it was?

What is a shared path?
A shared path is an area open to the public that is designated for the use of both bicycle riders and pedestrians.
Shared paths can be identified by signs and/or pavement markings showing a pedestrian and a bike.
A shared path ends at the nearest of the following signs:
No bikes; Bikes Only; Shared path ends
Look out for each other
Shared paths are provided for the use of both bicycle riders and pedestrians (including riders of wheeled recreational devices and wheeled toys). There are some rules to follow and behaviours that will allow bicycle riders and pedestrians to stay safe and share the path.
Bicycle riders
When riding on a shared path, the road rules require bicycle riders to:
Keep to the left (unless it is impractical to do so)
Give way to pedestrians including wheeled recreational devices/toys. You should always slow down, stopping if necessary to avoid a collision
Keep to the left of any oncoming bicycle rider.
You can also make paths safer for everyone by:
Providing pedestrians with a metre of space when passing
Using your bell to warn others when you are approaching
If there is room, moving off the path to the left if you wish to stop riding
Being careful around young children and dogs, as they are often unpredictable in their movements, and older pedestrians who may be more vulnerable
Travelling at a safe speed so you can stop within a safe distance of pedestrians on the path.
Pedestrians
When walking on a shared path, to share the path safely, it is recommended that pedestrians:
Keep to the left
If there is room, move off to the path to the left if you wish to stop walking
Keep animals on short leads and under control
Be aware of bicycle riders sharing the path - to improve your safety we recommend riders use their bell to let you know they are approaching from the behind. We also recommend you focus on the path ahead when approaching corners.
Wheeled recreational devices
A person using a wheeled recreational device or wheeled toy on a shared path is required to:
Keep to the left (unless it is impractical to do so)
Give way to all other pedestrians. You should always slow down, stopping if necessary to avoid a collision.
More information
We commissioned research into different aspects of shared path safety in NSW. Our Shared paths document (PDF, 122Kb) Listen to this document has more information on the research findings and summarises the safety issues. For a copy of the full research reports, please use our Contact us form.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 12:16

I located the two 'shared use' signs someone posted on the other thread. They're both on the other side of the road, applying to that pavement only.

Where I live when they have a shared use path on one side of the road they don't have one on the other side. Maybe this area's different though.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 12:05

Not being sure of the status of the path is no reason to kill someone though. Even if it was pedestrian only path it does not give you the right to kill someone for cycling on it. You could report them to the police and that is your only recourse.

Of course it doesn’t give anyone the right to kill someone. (And cyclists on paths can kill someone too, and they don’t have the right to risk that either.) Nor did this woman intentionally ‘kill’ the poor woman cycling or think she had a ‘right to kill’ her.

The sentence is manslaughter not murder.

The council should mark cycle/pedestrian paths all along the path. The council are wrong here too imo.

lieselotte · 03/03/2023 11:42

All she seemed to do is say "get off the f-ing pavement" and gesture.
I thought it was illegal to ride on the pavement anyway

It is if the path is not shared, but as I keep saying, you take up more room next to your bike than you do on top of it. So in a lot of ways it makes more sense to ride slowly than it does to get off and push.

If they had both kept to the left on the path there would have been room for both of them.

If everyone reading this keeps left in future, and doesn't hog the entire path with their bikes/scooters/kids/dogs/other halves, the poor lady's death will have had some educational effect. Bikes are by no means the only hazard.

But as I said, I am not confident it will change anything.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 11:42

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:29

ReneBumsWombats · Today 11:20
Also why is the path not marked for cycles and pedestrians?

Apparently it is, but you don't see it in the section of street in the video footage.

So especially as she was partially sighted, there was nothing for her to see in the way of markings where she was, even if her eye-sight had been better.

Also, this reports says the police were not sure whether or not it was a shared cycle/pedestrian path.
Police inquiries failed to establish whether the pavement was a shared cycle-way or not (Hull Daily Mail)

So if the police did not know,
how would this person know- especially to the extent of warranting the judge to say “Surely you knew it was shared” to this particular woman?

Not being sure of the status of the path is no reason to kill someone though. Even if it was pedestrian only path it does not give you the right to kill someone for cycling on it. You could report them to the police and that is your only recourse.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 11:39

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:36

Ah ok, I looked for a discussion but couldn’t find it. Thanks.

Someone died but it was an accident. Pure and simple. Accidents do happen.

She pushed an elderly woman into the road where she got run over. Not seeing how that's an accident. Would you push someone under the wheels if a car for absolutely no reason other than that you were feeling aggressive that day?

ComtesseDeSpair · 03/03/2023 11:36

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:29

ReneBumsWombats · Today 11:20
Also why is the path not marked for cycles and pedestrians?

Apparently it is, but you don't see it in the section of street in the video footage.

So especially as she was partially sighted, there was nothing for her to see in the way of markings where she was, even if her eye-sight had been better.

Also, this reports says the police were not sure whether or not it was a shared cycle/pedestrian path.
Police inquiries failed to establish whether the pavement was a shared cycle-way or not (Hull Daily Mail)

So if the police did not know,
how would this person know- especially to the extent of warranting the judge to say “Surely you knew it was shared” to this particular woman?

The woman is, apparently, well known in her local area for behaving antisocially and aggressively towards both pedestrians and cyclists, including children, when she wants them to get out of her way and had previously been warned over it by the police. She therefore isn’t a poor helpless disabled woman fearful for her life.

whatsup00 · 03/03/2023 11:31

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 10:54

@whatsup00 I understand what you are saying particularly in regard to dug addiction related crimes. However prison is not just about rehabilitation, it's also to punish, to contain, to demonstrate to others. Justice is a wide ranging and without prison society would disintegrate. There must be consequences to aggressive actions and this was undoubtedly an aggressive action to an older woman in a vulnerable situation riding so close to the road. The disabled woman was not severely disabled, and I would say of the two an elderly woman on a bike near a busy road, as opposed to a tall powerful looking woman striding along the path, was not the vulnerable one.

Fair enough. I do see your point as well. Thanks for being able to have a discussion not an argument. I guess there does have to be some form of deterrant. It's just I have seen prison take people who were decent and made one mistake (gf of friend who did something v stupid when drunk, a genuinely nice, decent person) and turn her into... i don't even know how to describe it apart from hardened and not her. She also lost everything in there and came out with a few quid and homeless, i don't know if she ever got back on track (not in contact any more).

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:29

ReneBumsWombats · Today 11:20
Also why is the path not marked for cycles and pedestrians?

Apparently it is, but you don't see it in the section of street in the video footage.

So especially as she was partially sighted, there was nothing for her to see in the way of markings where she was, even if her eye-sight had been better.

Also, this reports says the police were not sure whether or not it was a shared cycle/pedestrian path.
Police inquiries failed to establish whether the pavement was a shared cycle-way or not (Hull Daily Mail)

So if the police did not know,
how would this person know- especially to the extent of warranting the judge to say “Surely you knew it was shared” to this particular woman?

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:20

“ReneBumsWombats “· Today 11:07
“Was it stated that she doesn't have mental capacity? I believe the judge stated that her disabilities didn't affect her understanding of right and wrong. They're purely physical.”

No they are not purely physical.

Police inquiries failed to establish whether the pavement was a shared cycle-way or not. Today Judge Sean Enright, passing sentence, said he acknowledged the partial blindness, cognitive and mobility issues and cerebral palsy that the "childlike" Ms Grey suffered from.

Despite this, he added: "It does not reduce your understanding of right or wrong. You have not expressed a word about remorse until today in the pre-sentencing notes. I accept the explanation from the counsel and that the difficulty you would face in custody and afterwards are considerable

That was from
www.hulldailymail.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/shocking-moment-disabled-woman-swears-8206731

There are judges who sometimes make ill informed judgements. They are not experts in complicated life long illnesses and impairments symptoms, including not only cognitive impairments but also possible autism (often undiagnosed in women).

ReneBumsWombats · 03/03/2023 11:20

Also why is the path not marked for cycles and pedestrians?

Apparently it is, but you don't see it in the section of street in the video footage.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:09

Something may well have gone wrong with her defence, maybe there was no expert witness about her condition, no expert witness about the city highways and their markings or lack there of.

Or the jury may have been prejudiced, because she didn’t behave like ‘normal’ people when she walked away. Her face may have looked blank and remorseless.

Also why is the path not marked for cycles and pedestrians? What about the city council’s responsibility? None of us go out and about expecting a cycle to come towards us on a footpath unexpectedly.

ReneBumsWombats · 03/03/2023 11:07

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:01

That's cold - anyway you look at it.

Why are you expecting her to react ‘normally’ when she does not have a normal person’s mental or physical capacity?

Was it stated that she doesn't have mental capacity? I believe the judge stated that her disabilities didn't affect her understanding of right and wrong. They're purely physical.

GrinAndVomit · 03/03/2023 11:05

Her actions caused the death of another person.
I’m comfortable with the result of the court case.
She’ll serve 18 months and then be on probation for a further 18 months.

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 11:02

@ScrollingLeaves I'm sure her mental capacity and intellectual ability would have been taken into account at trial as the charges were so serious? My DS has cerebral palsy and it's unreasonable to say CP affects all people in a way that makes them aggressive. It's also not an excuse. Plenty of people (we've all seen road rage drivers reacting aggressively) have issues with impulse control. It cannot be a defence in law that you behave in an aggressive manner. If she had been deemed incapable of making a rational choice as in the McNaughton rules, then the defence would have used this.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 11:01

That's cold - anyway you look at it.

Why are you expecting her to react ‘normally’ when she does not have a normal person’s mental or physical capacity?

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 11:01

The woman was sort of flapping her arms at the cyclist thinking she would be hit by the cycle. The cyclist must have veered out of the way, or at any rate not exactly been pushed.

She wasn't 'flapping'. She was making clear directional movement towards the road, at the same time as shouting 'get off the fucking pavement'. She then hesitates and extends her arm when the cyclist is alongside her.

If you watch the video slowly, as has been pointed out, the cyclists front wheel doesn't change direction until her back wheel is already in line with the pedestrian. Had she veered, it wouldn't have been straight up until that point, it would have been pointing towards the road as she passes.

MajorCarolDanvers · 03/03/2023 10:59

Lou670 · 03/03/2023 10:48

I think she got a lesser sentence than she would have done as cyclists are not supposed to be riding on the pavement anyway. So many ifs and buts and many mitigating circumstances. She should not have left the scene of the accident and find it hard to believe that someone could have done that.

cyclists are not supposed to be riding on the pavement anyway

It was shared cycleway. The victim had ever right to be cycling on the pavement and apportioning blame to the deceased is frankly victim blaming.

And lets not forget that after causing the death of Celia Ward - Auriol Gray left before emergency services arrived and went shopping.

That's cold - anyway you look at it.

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 10:54

@whatsup00 I understand what you are saying particularly in regard to dug addiction related crimes. However prison is not just about rehabilitation, it's also to punish, to contain, to demonstrate to others. Justice is a wide ranging and without prison society would disintegrate. There must be consequences to aggressive actions and this was undoubtedly an aggressive action to an older woman in a vulnerable situation riding so close to the road. The disabled woman was not severely disabled, and I would say of the two an elderly woman on a bike near a busy road, as opposed to a tall powerful looking woman striding along the path, was not the vulnerable one.