Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Moonicorn · 03/03/2023 14:47

Her MH problems are neither here nor there really, she didn’t plead insanity so shouldn’t have an impact on guilt or innocence.

CMO · 03/03/2023 14:47

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 10:53

This woman did not seem quite mentally or physically normal. Isn’t she partially sighted too?

Why would she react ‘normally’ if that is the case? If anything maybe she should be in a nursing home, not a prison.

All people with CP have problems with movement and posture. Many also have related conditions such as intellectual disability; seizures; problems with vision, hearing, or speech; changes in the spine (such as scoliosis); or joint problems (such as contractures).

Damage to the basal ganglia can cause issues with controlling anger and other emotions. Basal ganglia damage is often associated with athetoid cerebral palsy, but can affect other types of cerebral palsy

It is believed that 25% of all cerebral palsy patients have behavioral issues. Those most at risk include cerebral palsy patients with epilepsy, intellectual disabilities, and severe pain.
Some of the problem behaviors include:
Anger issues making conflict likely

Cognitive impairment

^Symptoms of CP in adults
Some forms of CP, such as spastic cerebral palsy, cause stiff muscles, exaggerated reflexes, and abnormal movements when walking or trying to move. CP can affect the entire body, but it may also only impact one side of it. Common symptoms of CP include: muscle weakness.24 Sept 2018^

Associated autism is also possible with cerebral palsy.

That the pavement was supposed to be a joint pedestrian and cycle path is ridiculous, especially without markings - if it was indeed a joint cycle and pedestrian path, then maybe the city council highways department should be partly liable for not maintaining it correctly with markings and signs.

The ‘surely you knew about the path being shared’ remark of the judge does not seem fair at all.

The woman was sort of flapping her arms at the cyclist thinking she would be hit by the cycle. The cyclist must have veered out of the way, or at any rate not exactly been pushed. Of course the accused should have just stepped out of the way, instead of swearing and flapping, but it didn’t look as though she was either nimble or quick witted.

I heard on the radio news there will be an appeal.

The clip you have seen doesn't show her pushing the cyclist. The video seen by the jury does, hence the guilty charge. It was a clear push with intent.

SnarkyBag · 03/03/2023 14:45

Just watched the footage nothing accidental about any of that. Even with cognitive issues if you know enough about whether a cyclist shouldn’t be on the pavement to the point you want act on it you know enough to know that forcing them off their bike into oncoming traffic can lead to a fatal collision

MichelleScarn · 03/03/2023 14:45

FingerPuppet · 03/03/2023 14:32

Setting a very dangerous precedent here.

As opposed to setting a precedent that it is perfectly fine to push cyclists into oncoming traffic?

Flabbergasted that posters are still justifying and minimising AGs actions that caused someone's death.

DesertRose64 · 03/03/2023 14:36

FingerPuppet · 03/03/2023 14:33

They’re inventing it to make AG a bigger victim that the deceased cyclist.

I’m pretty sure if Ms Grey was autistic her defense team would have made sure they had an official diagnosis for her at the time of her trial. And they didn’t so I think we can quite rightly put that argument to rest.

BishopRock · 03/03/2023 14:35

bellswithwhistles · 03/03/2023 14:23

100% the cyclists fault. I actually can't believe this went to court.

Cyclist would have seen the pedestrian up ahead. Could see that the pathway is too narrow for her to have passed and got off the bike and pushed it on that section.

To those saying she's a sociopath for going shopping rather than stopping - she clearly has special needs. When she left the house that morning, she was going shopping. Unless you have experience of autism and other conditions you won't realise this. Once their plan is in their head - that's what they're doing. Going shopping.

Setting a very dangerous precedent here.

The pathway is 2.4 metres wide, easily enough to accommodate both women, particularly when Celia's bike was one of those little, tiny-wheeled shopper types.

FingerPuppet · 03/03/2023 14:33

OneTC · 03/03/2023 14:25

Where are people reading about her autism?

They’re inventing it to make AG a bigger victim that the deceased cyclist.

FingerPuppet · 03/03/2023 14:32

Setting a very dangerous precedent here.

As opposed to setting a precedent that it is perfectly fine to push cyclists into oncoming traffic?

OneTC · 03/03/2023 14:25

Where are people reading about her autism?

bellswithwhistles · 03/03/2023 14:23

100% the cyclists fault. I actually can't believe this went to court.

Cyclist would have seen the pedestrian up ahead. Could see that the pathway is too narrow for her to have passed and got off the bike and pushed it on that section.

To those saying she's a sociopath for going shopping rather than stopping - she clearly has special needs. When she left the house that morning, she was going shopping. Unless you have experience of autism and other conditions you won't realise this. Once their plan is in their head - that's what they're doing. Going shopping.

Setting a very dangerous precedent here.

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 03/03/2023 14:17

Cycling on a pavement - technically breaking the law, but thousands do it every day.

Pushing somebody of their bike into the traffic - that's murder.

Donnashair · 03/03/2023 14:15

Nooyoiknooyoik · 03/03/2023 14:10

An eye for an eye eh?

Someone must pay. (Doesn’t matter who).

An eye for an eye?

AG is going to prison. She isn’t going to killed.

It does matter who. The person whose actions directly led to someone’s death.

jcyclops · 03/03/2023 14:14

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 12:50

Yes, just like everyone in my area 'knows' that the main road has shared paths on both sides of it.

It hasn't.

If you're local could you tell me where there's a sign on that side of the road indicating a shared path?

It's some distance from the crash site, but if you look at the George St/Walden Rd Junction (by the Wetherspoons) much further round the ring road, there is a proliferation of cycle way signs. The path on the RH side of St Johns Street - the ring road (opposite side of the road to the accident) is clearly a shared cycle way, and this is repeated all the way around the ring road to beyond the accident site.

Perhaps the most important sign is the one immediately outside the Wetherspoons, on the path on the LH side of St Johns Street (the side of the accident) which clearly indicates that this path is no longer a shared cycleway. As there are no further signs on this side of the road then the pavement where the accident happened is NOT A SHARED CYCLE WAY.

I would say the judge was factually wrong in his sentencing comments when he stated it was a shared cycle way, and I am surprised the police and council said they couldn't say for sure. Ironically, Huntingdon Police Station is on the ring road on the same side of the road as the accident and the path that is not a shared cycleway!

To think this woman should not be put in prison?
aSofaNearYou · 03/03/2023 14:13

Someone must pay. (Doesn’t matter who).

No, it does matter who - the person whose fault it was.

Nooyoiknooyoik · 03/03/2023 14:10

purpledalmation · 03/03/2023 10:35

@whatsup00 Well you can use that logic to a lot of people going to prison.

Don't you think the victim who died in a moment of fear as the car ploughed into her, and the driver, who will live with the guilt for an accident they had no control over, deserve justice?

Don' t you think the children, husband or family of the victim deserve justice?

It's not about the affect on the perpetrator that's the issue here. She committed a crime and now has to take the consequences of her actions. It's what we teach children.

An eye for an eye eh?

Someone must pay. (Doesn’t matter who).

OP posts:
BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 13:45

jcyclops · 03/03/2023 13:37

In this case the cyclist was travelling South East so she could have ridden on the road which is one-way in that direction. If she had been travelling North West, she could not have ridden on the road, as that would be travelling the wrong way down a one way street.

With a one-way road, road authorities often try to provide for cyclists travelling in the opposite direction. The main options are:
a) A cycle lane on the road
b) An unsegregated cycle path on the pavement
c) A segregated cycle path on the pavement (with a line to separate cycles and pedestrians

The signs for these are shown below.

In the case of the Huntingdon incident, the road is possibly too narrow for "a", and the pavement is too narrow for "c", so the only solution was "b".

Yes. On the pavement on the other side of the road.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 13:44

dawngreen · 03/03/2023 13:27

SHARED PATH IN UK

Top tips for cyclists
Whether you use them for a nice and safe family cycle ride in the great outdoors, or use them to commute from A to B avoiding busy roads, shared paths are really useful and fantastic for cyclists. Following our top tips for cyclists will ensure using shared paths is a positive experience for everyone.
Put a bell on your bike! Pedestrians welcome a polite warning of your approach. If you don’t have a bell, use a friendly greeting instead and always do this in plenty of time so you don’t surprise people or animals when approaching from behind.
Important: don’t ring your bell near horses, instead talk to the rider and check it is safe to pass.
Take care when passing other path users and ride at an appropriate speed. If necessary wait to pass until there is enough room.
Important: don’t ride fast when pedestrians are around.
Give way to pedestrians and wheelchair users, if you need to.
Be aware that pedestrians may have hearing impairments or be wearing in-ear headphones so might not hear your bell, so pass slowly and give as much space as possible.
When cycling on segregated shared paths, always keep to your side of any dividing lines.
Say a quick ‘thank you’ as you pass. Polite behaviour encourages others to share the space better.
Keep to the left when passing oncoming pedestrians or cyclists. Overtake on the right of any pedestrians and cyclists going the same way as you (like on the road). Again, do not ride too quickly. Think... if a pedestrian stepped into your path could you stop in time?
Be particularly careful at junctions, bends, entrances onto the path, or any other ‘blind spots’ where people or animals could appear without warning.
Groups of cyclists should ride in single file when approaching pedestrians on a shared pathway.
In dull and dark weather make sure you have bike lights on so you can be seen. It’s also a good idea to wear hi-visibility clothing too.

Seems strangely lacking in advice for what do to if verbally or physically abused by a pedestrian...

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 13:43

Blossomtoes · 03/03/2023 13:38

There are signs on the street furniture.

I've checked on Streetview and there don't seem to be any signs on that side of the road.

SnackSizeRaisin · 03/03/2023 13:41

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 12:05

Not being sure of the status of the path is no reason to kill someone though. Even if it was pedestrian only path it does not give you the right to kill someone for cycling on it. You could report them to the police and that is your only recourse.

Of course it doesn’t give anyone the right to kill someone. (And cyclists on paths can kill someone too, and they don’t have the right to risk that either.) Nor did this woman intentionally ‘kill’ the poor woman cycling or think she had a ‘right to kill’ her.

The sentence is manslaughter not murder.

The council should mark cycle/pedestrian paths all along the path. The council are wrong here too imo.

These type of shared paths are a nightmare for everyone. However whatever the status of the path, it doesn't excuse the attacker's behaviour. Seeing one person behaving illegally doesn't mean you can commit a more severe crime on them.

If you see someone shoplifting you don't hit them over the head with a shopping basket. If you see someone speeding you don't ram them off the road. The correct thing to do is to call the police. Perhaps you could video or photograph the person for evidence, or collect witness details, or call security. But you don't have the right to physically assault them. I don't understand how anyone thinks it's acceptable.

Blossomtoes · 03/03/2023 13:38

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 12:50

Yes, just like everyone in my area 'knows' that the main road has shared paths on both sides of it.

It hasn't.

If you're local could you tell me where there's a sign on that side of the road indicating a shared path?

There are signs on the street furniture.

jcyclops · 03/03/2023 13:37

In this case the cyclist was travelling South East so she could have ridden on the road which is one-way in that direction. If she had been travelling North West, she could not have ridden on the road, as that would be travelling the wrong way down a one way street.

With a one-way road, road authorities often try to provide for cyclists travelling in the opposite direction. The main options are:
a) A cycle lane on the road
b) An unsegregated cycle path on the pavement
c) A segregated cycle path on the pavement (with a line to separate cycles and pedestrians

The signs for these are shown below.

In the case of the Huntingdon incident, the road is possibly too narrow for "a", and the pavement is too narrow for "c", so the only solution was "b".

To think this woman should not be put in prison?
To think this woman should not be put in prison?
Hadjab · 03/03/2023 13:33

UnfinishedBusiness · 02/03/2023 15:44

There was nothing “accidental” about the way she harangued that elderly woman off the pavement into the path of an oncoming vehicle. There was also nothing accidental about her not giving enough shits to hang around to see if she would be ok. She just nipped off to the supermarket to do her weekly shop.

she didn’t actually harangue her though, did she? That suggests it was a sustained verbal attack - it wasn’t. Let’s not paint her to be any worse than she is.

dawngreen · 03/03/2023 13:31

I have a full motorcycle licence so I always plan for ppl doing dumb stuff.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 13:29

Keep to the left when passing oncoming pedestrians or cyclists

Think... if a pedestrian stepped into your path could you stop in time?
**
**

dawngreen · 03/03/2023 13:29

I also read that the shared path signs are on the opposite path to this one.