Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 20:56

WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 20:24

and what about your beak then?!

Natural curiosity, fine. But you’re arguing with someone who knows the area by looking up street view as your defence.

Shared use or not, still doesn’t give the right to act in such am aggressive manner does it? I mean, how many e-scooters are zooming around in areas they’re not supposed to? Many have passed close to DD and I just make sure to hold her hand and move out the way, I don’t act aggressive in any way, neither does anyone else.

And before you mention her disability, it was proven in court that she didn’t have any learning disabilities, they don’t take these things lightly you know and there’s a whole process.

No. I was looking at Streetview because I wanted to know the facts after somebody posted pictures of 'shared user' signs on the road yesterday. The other poster then told me there were signs in a place I'd already looked at on Streetview, so I checked again and there are no signs, meaning they've been put up in the last 5 months, probably in response to this accident. I informed the other poster of this. The other poster then posted on a different thread implying (as she had previously) that these signs had been there for a long time.

I can't be bothered addressing your other points again but I will state again that I fully support a conviction and disability isn't an excuse but it can be a reason. My main comments today have been against invented scenarios that don't seem to have even been brought up in court, never mind proved.

OneTC · 03/03/2023 20:43

Not all defence barristers are equal.

Yeah most aren't as good as hers that's true.

and despite this she got sentenced to 3 years, if that's as much mitigation as your defense can actually offer that should tell you something

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 20:40

Not all defence barristers are equal. The law is almost like a game of rhetoric.

I don't disagree with your comments about the differences in judges, but she wasn't poorly represented. Her defence barrister was a highly experienced KC with particular expertise in defending vulnerable witnesses in murder and manslaughter trials.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 20:31

I honestly am baffled with those who are investigating street view etc. and those who are against the judge’s and jury’s decision. Like all things mentioned on this thread haven’t been considered in court!

Not everyone is unquestioning of court decisions. The law does its best but there are plenty of mistakes made too.

It was reported that the police were not sure if it was a shared pavement so why shouldn’t someone here in this discussion look for markings?

It was reported too that the culprit had cognitive difficulties. The judge himself said she was childlike. Why shouldn’t people wonder if she didn’t have quite a few mental difficulties, which do not mean she is innocent, but do mean prison is not the best place for her, but that the judge was over ’black and white’ in his views. Judges do have different tendencies.

I remember a judge in the past said that a father, or stepfather, who raped an 8 year old little girl when his wife, her mother was pregnant, was “just a normal red-blooded man”. Another accused a raped hitchhiker of contributory negligence. Judges do sometimes misunderstand aspects of life.

Not all defence barristers are equal. The law is almost like a game of rhetoric.

WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 20:24

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 20:09

Natural curiosity. The council and the police apparently don't know the status of the path, so how is a random disabled woman meant to know?

But what business is it if yours what I show an interest in? And what are you doing here when the thread's got no more to do with you than it has to do with me?

Keep your beak out.

and what about your beak then?!

Natural curiosity, fine. But you’re arguing with someone who knows the area by looking up street view as your defence.

Shared use or not, still doesn’t give the right to act in such am aggressive manner does it? I mean, how many e-scooters are zooming around in areas they’re not supposed to? Many have passed close to DD and I just make sure to hold her hand and move out the way, I don’t act aggressive in any way, neither does anyone else.

And before you mention her disability, it was proven in court that she didn’t have any learning disabilities, they don’t take these things lightly you know and there’s a whole process.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 20:09

WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 19:57

@BrigitteBond why are you even taking the time to look at street view? Don’t you think the legal teams looked at all the evidence and put it forward to the judge? Who are you to investigate this crime?

Natural curiosity. The council and the police apparently don't know the status of the path, so how is a random disabled woman meant to know?

But what business is it if yours what I show an interest in? And what are you doing here when the thread's got no more to do with you than it has to do with me?

Keep your beak out.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 20:05

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 20:00

If this pavement on the edge of a busy road is supposed to be shared I think it is very dangerous. It may be 2 1/2 metres of that is true but even if that sounds wide looking here it really isn’t at all especially as the lamppost takes up some of the space at the point a second before the accident.

When two people pass each other here, one on a bicycle and one on foot, one of them is going to be on the kerb.

Try looking at it head on, as the perspective is deceiving from this footage due to the angle - there's plenty of images available or the street from the direction Celia was cycling from. There's enough space for three people walking abreast (even with the post), or two and an oncoming cyclist without touching or knocking into each other, albeit a touch snug.

The judges comments said it is 2.4m, so unless someone can prove otherwise, I'd say it's fair to say it's true.

I don't think anyone disagrees it isn't a massive space, but there's plenty for two people to pass side by side.

WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 20:03

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 19:37

Did she veere towards her? I looked for that and couldn't see it. She actually seemed to move away to give more space at the end.

The cyclist was coming up over a dropped kerb and may have altered course. We can't really tell.

If following the 'rules' of shared paths the cyclist should have passed on the other side of the pedestrian anyway, and should have been prepared to stop and give way instantly if obstructed.

No, we can’t really tell. However the clips from
different angles that have been shown in court to the judge and jury did show more, clearly.

WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 20:01

BishopRock · 03/03/2023 19:22

What part are posters missing about learning difficulties?

Jailing Grey, of Huntingdon, Judge Sean Enright said her actions ‘are not explained by disability’.

He said she had no mental disorder or learning difficulties and he said the pavement was 2.4 metres wide at the relevant point, describing it as a ‘shared path on the ring road’.

The judge described her as being ‘territorial about the pavement’, adding: ‘You resented the presence of an oncoming cyclist.’

Don’t waste your time. The judge clearly doesn’t know anything and all this information is a complete fabrication by the legal teams clearly 🙄

I honestly am baffled with those who are investigating street view etc. and those who are against the judge’s and jury’s decision. Like all things mentioned on this thread haven’t been considered in court!

ScrollingLeaves · 03/03/2023 20:00

If this pavement on the edge of a busy road is supposed to be shared I think it is very dangerous. It may be 2 1/2 metres of that is true but even if that sounds wide looking here it really isn’t at all especially as the lamppost takes up some of the space at the point a second before the accident.

When two people pass each other here, one on a bicycle and one on foot, one of them is going to be on the kerb.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?
WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 19:57

Blossomtoes · 03/03/2023 16:32

So, there are two signs on that stretch of road. One at the junction with Cowper Road and another at the junction with Priory Road. Just to make it easy for you.

@BrigitteBond why are you even taking the time to look at street view? Don’t you think the legal teams looked at all the evidence and put it forward to the judge? Who are you to investigate this crime?

OneTC · 03/03/2023 19:55

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 19:37

Did she veere towards her? I looked for that and couldn't see it. She actually seemed to move away to give more space at the end.

The cyclist was coming up over a dropped kerb and may have altered course. We can't really tell.

If following the 'rules' of shared paths the cyclist should have passed on the other side of the pedestrian anyway, and should have been prepared to stop and give way instantly if obstructed.

She probably wasn't anticipating being attacked, I know I don't ride round expecting to be assaulted, even though it's happened before

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 19:51

It's a shame this isn't being framed from the perspective of the victim.

Celia Ward, a 77 year old retired midwife was cycling on her shopper bike along the outer part of a 2.4 metre wide pavement, leaving space for the approaching pedestrian who veered towards her, shouted, "get off the fucking pavement" before making physical contact with Celia who then toppled into the road and was run over and killed.

You are, of course, completely correct.

WhoSaidWhat123 · 03/03/2023 19:43

whatsup00 · 03/03/2023 10:26

But what on earth is prison going to do about this? Nothing I'd guess. Or make her situation worse (lose her home, etc).

It’s about setting an example. If you commit a crime, you get punished, regardless of disability I’m afraid. She acted in an aggressive way, period. This aggressiveness unfortunately resulted in someones death which is why she has been charged with manslaughter.

No one should be above the law. No one should be given special treatment when a crime has been committed, especially one that resulted in someones death. Even those who committed a murder with diminished responsibility still get charged with something, usually manslaughter instead of murder.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 19:37

Did she veere towards her? I looked for that and couldn't see it. She actually seemed to move away to give more space at the end.

The cyclist was coming up over a dropped kerb and may have altered course. We can't really tell.

If following the 'rules' of shared paths the cyclist should have passed on the other side of the pedestrian anyway, and should have been prepared to stop and give way instantly if obstructed.

dawngreen · 03/03/2023 19:36

What constitutes a common assault?

Assault: Physical contact does not have to occur for an assault to take place. If the defendant causes another person to fear violence, this is enough to be classed as assault, for example if the defendant raises their fist to the victim.

What does the prosecution have to prove to establish common assault?
The prosecution must be able to prove that the defendant intended to cause the victim to feel that violence will be used against them. Without this proof, there is no grounds for assault, unless the defendant has behaved in such a reckless and thoughtless way that the victim was apprehensive of a violent act occurring.
What is the definition of recklessness?
If a person is aware that there is a possibility that their act could cause another person to apprehend immediate violence, and they still take the risk and proceed with the action, this is recklessness.
Will I go to prison for common assault?
If you’re convicted of common assault, you could be looking at a maximum prison sentence of six months, and/or a fine or a community service order.
Remember: prison sentences are usually handed down for cases where serious injury was caused, or in the case of repeat offenders. If the attack was made towards a disabled person, or was racially motivated, the chance of going to prison is higher

BishopRock · 03/03/2023 19:32

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 19:23

She apparently caused the death by gesticulating and shouting

She absolutely caused Celia Ward's death by acting disproportionately and recklessly and assaulting her, causing her to fall into the road.

It's a shame this isn't being framed from the perspective of the victim.

Celia Ward, a 77 year old retired midwife was cycling on her shopper bike along the outer part of a 2.4 metre wide pavement, leaving space for the approaching pedestrian who veered towards her, shouted, "get off the fucking pavement" before making physical contact with Celia who then toppled into the road and was run over and killed.

BreastedBoobilyToTheStairs · 03/03/2023 19:23

She apparently caused the death by gesticulating and shouting

She absolutely caused Celia Ward's death by acting disproportionately and recklessly and assaulting her, causing her to fall into the road.

BishopRock · 03/03/2023 19:22

EvenleyWitch · 03/03/2023 19:12

You did get the part about her having learning difficulties, didnt you? Not that that excuses her actions, but it makes them a easier to understand why she just left the scene the way she did.
Partially sighted as well, it could be considered whether she knew it had actually happened.

What part are posters missing about learning difficulties?

Jailing Grey, of Huntingdon, Judge Sean Enright said her actions ‘are not explained by disability’.

He said she had no mental disorder or learning difficulties and he said the pavement was 2.4 metres wide at the relevant point, describing it as a ‘shared path on the ring road’.

The judge described her as being ‘territorial about the pavement’, adding: ‘You resented the presence of an oncoming cyclist.’

SamanthaCaine · 03/03/2023 19:22

Antigonads · 03/03/2023 19:20

After you.

Nah, I'm ok. Basically because I understand the case in hand.

ReneBumsWombats · 03/03/2023 19:21

Antigonads · 03/03/2023 19:18

She apparently caused the death by gesticulating and shouting 🙄

She admitted to making contact with the cyclist.

Gesticulating and shouting from ten feet away won't have the same consequences as gesticulating, shouting and making contact with a cyclist right next to a busy road. If you don't know that, stop gesticulating and shouting at all. You could kill someone.

Antigonads · 03/03/2023 19:20

After you.

SamanthaCaine · 03/03/2023 19:19

Antigonads · 03/03/2023 18:27

I am genuinely shocked by this sentence.

I knew someone who reversed out of a drive and killed a motorcyclist and was done for driving without due care and attention.

If shouting and gesticulating is a criminal offence now then I’m doomed.

I just wish they'd lock up stupid people too.

ReneBumsWombats · 03/03/2023 19:18

EvenleyWitch · 03/03/2023 19:12

You did get the part about her having learning difficulties, didnt you? Not that that excuses her actions, but it makes them a easier to understand why she just left the scene the way she did.
Partially sighted as well, it could be considered whether she knew it had actually happened.

There's no way she wouldn't have heard it. She was right there. There's nothing to suggest she literally didn't know the cyclist was hit by the car.

Antigonads · 03/03/2023 19:18

She apparently caused the death by gesticulating and shouting 🙄