Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this woman should not be put in prison?

960 replies

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:31

Bizarre and very unfair Link

OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 04/03/2023 08:42

milkyaqua · 04/03/2023 06:29

There was more footage, that was shown in court. AG also admitted in court that she made contact with the victim.

Regardless of what you think, she has been found guilty, by people with far more knowledge of the facts of the case than you. She will get out of prison in a very short amount of time and she will still be alive - and her victim will still be dead, and the motorist who ran her over will still be traumatised.

This. There cannot be no consequence for these actions.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 04/03/2023 08:41

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:20

It's probably fortunate that you're never likely to be in charge of the country then.

I am not sure what is problematic with my statement. Had I said that all people on the autistic spectrum or with mental health problems should have their liberty restricted, that would be unreasonable. No person NT, ND or with mental health issues who is a danger to others should have unrestricted liberty.

milkyaqua · 04/03/2023 06:29

Nooyoiknooyoik · 02/03/2023 15:40

Yes. It was an accident.

There was more footage, that was shown in court. AG also admitted in court that she made contact with the victim.

Regardless of what you think, she has been found guilty, by people with far more knowledge of the facts of the case than you. She will get out of prison in a very short amount of time and she will still be alive - and her victim will still be dead, and the motorist who ran her over will still be traumatised.

JackiePlace · 04/03/2023 05:00

Ok, In light of the updated video evidence and the admission of shoving, I have changed my mind and would say the sentence is justified.
I still don't think she'll go to prison though ... the appeal will be successful and she'll have had a good scare, for what it's worth.

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 01:42

It's not her fault how other people react to her either!

That's a bit circular for my liking.

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 01:30

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 01:13

As always with autism - it depends.

But generally no, I don't think you should judge.

I'm autistic, not an expert on autism. There are many experts on autism on MN who will no doubt be prepared to answer any questions on the subject. I'll just argue and tie us both up in knots. 🤣

Being judged for our actions and responses towards others is inevitable and ubiquitous though.

AG was shouty, aggressive with her gestures and sweary. This doesn’t engender warm social responses, our social reactions are instinctive and often protective.

you can’t be educated out of an instinctive social reaction although you may understand it better.

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 01:13

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 01:03

My own comparison of this woman's behaviour to my own autism is just an example of how people shouldn't be morally judged for 'disgusting behaviour' based on factors they have no absolute control over. Other autism experts on here can probably explain the issues better than I can. It's a bit close to home for me and I get emotional

Are you saying that if you are on the autism spectrum you have no control over your behaviour? And that if you’re triggered and swear and carry on people shouldn’t judge you?

Bearing in mind as well that AG is not on the autism spectrum?

As always with autism - it depends.

But generally no, I don't think you should judge.

I'm autistic, not an expert on autism. There are many experts on autism on MN who will no doubt be prepared to answer any questions on the subject. I'll just argue and tie us both up in knots. 🤣

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 01:03

My own comparison of this woman's behaviour to my own autism is just an example of how people shouldn't be morally judged for 'disgusting behaviour' based on factors they have no absolute control over. Other autism experts on here can probably explain the issues better than I can. It's a bit close to home for me and I get emotional

Are you saying that if you are on the autism spectrum you have no control over your behaviour? And that if you’re triggered and swear and carry on people shouldn’t judge you?

Bearing in mind as well that AG is not on the autism spectrum?

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:52

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:39

Well, I’m not quite clear what you’re defending over these two threads.

For a while it seemed you thought AG’s responses were understandable under the circumstances because you are ND, struggled with COvID and are triggered by perceived rule breaking.

Do you agree with the verdict and the sentencing?

I've said it clearly somewhere. From what I know I agree with the verdict.

The sentence is another matter, but I don't know the full details. The judge seems to have formed his opinion using spurious details like 'she should have known it's a shared path'. I'm not convinced it's a shared path at all, and even less convinced that she 'should' have know if it was, with no signs on it.

I'm not 100% convinced that's even relevant considering the circumstances but the judge obviously felt it relevant enough to mention it.

My own comparison of this woman's behaviour to my own autism is just an example of how people shouldn't be morally judged for 'disgusting behaviour' based on factors they have no absolute control over. Other autism experts on here can probably explain the issues better than I can. It's a bit close to home for me and I get emotional.

icountallthebeans · 04/03/2023 00:45

It's utterly tragic.

I don't know the town but from the video and photos, I'd say it looked an awful lot like a pavement. Cyclists shouldn't ride on pavements, and pedestrians who don't want cyclists on pavements are not "territorial" - they're legally right.

It should be easy to tell if something is a pavement or a shared cycleway. It's shocking that the police couldn't agree whether this was indeed a regular pavement or not - they had time to research this. The fact they couldn't decide shows there is something very wrong with the town planning, making this an entirely preventable accident. If the police with all their resources don't know after spending time on the matter, how is a visually impaired person supposed to tell from a quick glance?

It doesn't look to me like Grey actually pushed the deceased, just scared her into veering off, but the detective who interviewed Grey did say that there was more CCTV footage that had not been released. Maybe it's clearer from that. This whole thing has gone to court, so there must be details we don't know about that make this more clear-cut.

Without seeing those details, I can't say if I believe this should have been manslaughter. It could just have been an accident. It's abhorrent that Grey apparently didn't call 999 and show remorse, but is that in itself a crime? There's a crime for not stopping at the scene of an accident, I think, but isn't that in relation to drivers? Being unpleasant isn't in itself a crime.

I feel for the victim and her family, and for the driver, and to a lesser extent, for Grey. All three of them had the right to safely travel from A to B that day, and this set of circumstances should never have been possible. The town planners have a lot to answer for. I think they need to look at cycle options and signage urgently.

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:39

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:33

I don't think I've said that, or even suggested that the pedestrian in this case shouldn't have been found guilty?

Well, I’m not quite clear what you’re defending over these two threads.

For a while it seemed you thought AG’s responses were understandable under the circumstances because you are ND, struggled with COvID and are triggered by perceived rule breaking.

Do you agree with the verdict and the sentencing?

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:33

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:27

So if a person on the autism spectrum, who isn’t mentally unwell, is triggered, then they shouldn’t be held criminally responsible for whatever happens next?

I don't think I've said that, or even suggested that the pedestrian in this case shouldn't have been found guilty?

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:27

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:12

And if anyone is so triggered by day-to-day annoyances that they think they could also potentially force someone into busy traffic - by shouting, swearing, gesturing, touching - then, yes, I don’t think that person would present as mentally well.

Well you need to learn the difference between autism and mental illness then.

So if a person on the autism spectrum, who isn’t mentally unwell, is triggered, then they shouldn’t be held criminally responsible for whatever happens next?

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:20

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 04/03/2023 00:17

It doesn't matter if some one present as on the autistic spectrum or whether they are mentally ill. If they are a danger to others their liberty should be restricted.

It's probably fortunate that you're never likely to be in charge of the country then.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 04/03/2023 00:17

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:12

And if anyone is so triggered by day-to-day annoyances that they think they could also potentially force someone into busy traffic - by shouting, swearing, gesturing, touching - then, yes, I don’t think that person would present as mentally well.

Well you need to learn the difference between autism and mental illness then.

It doesn't matter if some one present as on the autistic spectrum or whether they are mentally ill. If they are a danger to others their liberty should be restricted.

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:12

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:02

Theres a gap between being annoyed with someone you perceive as breaking the rules and actually aggressively acting on it though.

Someone cycling on a pavement is aggravating and might be triggering, but if you aren’t mentally unwell to the extent that capacity is reduced, you’re still responsible for your reactions after that point.

And if anyone is so triggered by day-to-day annoyances that they think they could also potentially force someone into busy traffic - by shouting, swearing, gesturing, touching - then, yes, I don’t think that person would present as mentally well.

And if anyone is so triggered by day-to-day annoyances that they think they could also potentially force someone into busy traffic - by shouting, swearing, gesturing, touching - then, yes, I don’t think that person would present as mentally well.

Well you need to learn the difference between autism and mental illness then.

BrigitteBond · 04/03/2023 00:09

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:04

And what’s the alternative- do we just accept that if someone is triggered then anything that happens afterwards isn’t their responsibility?

No, it's not an excuse, it's an explanation.

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:04

And what’s the alternative- do we just accept that if someone is triggered then anything that happens afterwards isn’t their responsibility?

nolongersurprised · 04/03/2023 00:02

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 23:43

Umm yes. I'm ND and somebody breaking rules when it impacts me is a huge trigger for me. It's not 'right' but it's the way I am. So you have a problem with my disability?

Obviously I control myself as much as I can, but that will never be 100%. I've talked to twat cyclists worse than this woman did. I've been threatened and even had a knife pulled in me for daring to speak up.

I'm not excusing her actions at all, no more than I'd excuse mine at their extreme, but I certainly understand them, as far as I can, not having the same condition.

And 2020 was an absolute bastard stressful time for me. It

Theres a gap between being annoyed with someone you perceive as breaking the rules and actually aggressively acting on it though.

Someone cycling on a pavement is aggravating and might be triggering, but if you aren’t mentally unwell to the extent that capacity is reduced, you’re still responsible for your reactions after that point.

And if anyone is so triggered by day-to-day annoyances that they think they could also potentially force someone into busy traffic - by shouting, swearing, gesturing, touching - then, yes, I don’t think that person would present as mentally well.

Socrateswasrightaboutvoting · 04/03/2023 00:00

If an individual cannot navigate the world without being a danger to other people, their liberty should be restricted.

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 23:43

nolongersurprised · 03/03/2023 23:34

But you’re pretty much saying that you understand Grey’s reactions, or did I misinterpret that?

Umm yes. I'm ND and somebody breaking rules when it impacts me is a huge trigger for me. It's not 'right' but it's the way I am. So you have a problem with my disability?

Obviously I control myself as much as I can, but that will never be 100%. I've talked to twat cyclists worse than this woman did. I've been threatened and even had a knife pulled in me for daring to speak up.

I'm not excusing her actions at all, no more than I'd excuse mine at their extreme, but I certainly understand them, as far as I can, not having the same condition.

And 2020 was an absolute bastard stressful time for me. It

OneTC · 03/03/2023 23:36

@BrigitteBond I appreciate your input into this thread even if we're not in complete agreement. I do think the stress of the time is probably more relevant than most NT people might realise and it wasn't something I'd thought of until I read your post earlier.

nolongersurprised · 03/03/2023 23:36

That comment isn't necessarily the judge saying 'yes the defendant is childlike', so much as 'I acknowledge the evidence put forward about her disabilities and behaviour in making my judgement'

Youve articulated better than me.

The judge considered her “childlike” demeanour, as noticed by others, but it wasn’t sufficient to exonerate her

OneTC · 03/03/2023 23:34

Cos she won't do 3 years unless she's a complete terror

nolongersurprised · 03/03/2023 23:34

BrigitteBond · 03/03/2023 23:29

Thanks for your 'concern' but I'm a perfectly normal person with Autism. I'm completely 'mentally well'. Thanks for your concern.🙄

But you’re pretty much saying that you understand Grey’s reactions, or did I misinterpret that?