Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be thrilled to have an only child?

263 replies

iamloading · 02/03/2023 12:36

Ok so probably just getting this off my chest after reading yet another post saying "I feel sorry for only children." Obviously everyone is entitled to their opinion but I don't get the strange obsession on here that only children are to be pitied in some way.
We have one child by choice, and it is the right decision for us as a family. That's not a decision that's right for every family, and obviously there are huge potential benefits from sibling relationships.
However there are also massive benefits of being an only, and both my husband and I are also onlys so we know this from experience.
We are able to save an amount each month for DC, have far more financial freedom (we both work part time for instance,) have a lovely stress free life. We also moved to a house on a new build estate very near the school so every weekend it's a non stop procession of kids knocking on asking to play with our DC. In fact we are all ready for a break from all the friends at points!
I've never been asked in real life if I'm having another, nor has any pity for my DC ever been expressed. So it just seems to be an issue on here.
So AIBU to just not get the "pity." And ps if you are one child not by choice due to any reason then PLEASE don't feel guilty as in my opinion there is nothing at all to feel guilty for xx

OP posts:
Meem321 · 02/03/2023 19:39

Tiredmum100 · 02/03/2023 19:35

My friends brother died. I think this is one of her fears, when her parents are older/ill/die it will be all her responsibility to sort everything out. It is a lot for one person, and I am sorry you are going through this.

Thank you @Tiredmum100 that's kind of you to say x

bluelid · 02/03/2023 19:38

I'm an (ex) primary teacher.

I could identify an only child in a class of 30 within a day or two of knowing them (without actually knowing that they were). There is something about the way only children communicate/ relate to other children that it is quite unique, probably based on spending the majority of their time in adult company. It's not necessarily a good/ bad thing, but definitely distinctive.

Having said that, I would also have been able to tell you which children had older siblings (usually more mature in a 'streetwise' kind of way) and which ones were the 'babies' of the family. Again, without actually knowing their background.

My point is, family dynamics do tend to influence behaviour/ personality, whether parents want them to or not.

endoftheworldniteclub · 02/03/2023 19:38

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:32

Sorry you read it that way. I know people who have made it clear that part of their motivation in having a second child was wanting a do-over of the experience of having their first.

My motivation for having one child was not wanting to have another child, because the one we have makes our family complete. This isn’t a “nasty barb”. You read all the time that people didn’t feel their family was complete, that the arrival of their last child “made them a family”, “made them parents”, “made them complete”, when having their first child did not.

Those statements don’t apply to me. She is enough.

Ok, that’s a better explanation for how you feel.

Kpo58 · 02/03/2023 19:35

I don't understand why people think that they get more time to themselves if they have an only. In reality they need more time spent on them as there is no-one else for them to play with. The only reason you would get more time to yourself is if you ignore the child and they have given up as they know that you will never play with them.

Tiredmum100 · 02/03/2023 19:35

Meem321 · 02/03/2023 14:31

I am an only child. Never minded growing up. But am now feeling the loneliness in dealing with terminally ill parent on my own. Wish I had siblings to share the grief with.

My friends brother died. I think this is one of her fears, when her parents are older/ill/die it will be all her responsibility to sort everything out. It is a lot for one person, and I am sorry you are going through this.

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:33

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:32

Sorry you read it that way. I know people who have made it clear that part of their motivation in having a second child was wanting a do-over of the experience of having their first.

My motivation for having one child was not wanting to have another child, because the one we have makes our family complete. This isn’t a “nasty barb”. You read all the time that people didn’t feel their family was complete, that the arrival of their last child “made them a family”, “made them parents”, “made them complete”, when having their first child did not.

Those statements don’t apply to me. She is enough.

Fair enough, thank you for explaining that. I read it as derogatory.

laddersandsnakes12 · 02/03/2023 19:33

Christ almighty, the sniping and bickering on this thread! Can't we all just accept that we make decisions that we feel work best for ourselves and our families, or circumstances dictate a certain amount of children?
We have 1, and are very happy. We make time to play games, build Lego, read books etc with him so he doesn't feel lonely, as well as make sure he sees other kids all the time. When we go on holiday we often go with friends who have kids of a similar age so the kids all play together constantly - they are like siblings in many ways. Some of our friends have 2 or more kids and are very happy, some have 2 kids and they are miserable. Some have 1 child and want more but can't. We ummmed and ahhhed for a few years about having a second, but my mental health forced our hand and for the sake of my MH we have the 1 child. I'd much rather have 1 child that I am happy to be around and mentally well for than 2 who I may be seriously unwell for, and not be as good a mother as I want to be. That's the decision we came to, and we are a happy family of 3. People should just make their decisions based on what is right for them, and stop judging others for what they have chosen to do.

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:32

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:27

But your motivation for only having one was you don't want a do-over which was a really nasty barb at those who have more than one child. No child is a do-over, what a horrible thing to say.

Sorry you read it that way. I know people who have made it clear that part of their motivation in having a second child was wanting a do-over of the experience of having their first.

My motivation for having one child was not wanting to have another child, because the one we have makes our family complete. This isn’t a “nasty barb”. You read all the time that people didn’t feel their family was complete, that the arrival of their last child “made them a family”, “made them parents”, “made them complete”, when having their first child did not.

Those statements don’t apply to me. She is enough.

Tiredmum100 · 02/03/2023 19:31

Camilliatile · 02/03/2023 13:23

Only children are the best life hack of all time. All the love and benefits of DC while maintaining sleep, money, low stress life, time for yourself, time for your partner and friends, career etc. Pressure on women to have two accounts for a lot of second children, they think you're meant to have two and the option of having one just doesn't occur to them.

To be honest I have all of the above and two children. It's not necessarily all doom and gloom having more than one. My life and career is the best It's ever been.

RuthW · 02/03/2023 19:28

I have an adult only. I'm an only. Can't imagine having more than one.

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:27

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:24

I have no idea of my parents motivations for having more than one child so I don’t know.

But your motivation for only having one was you don't want a do-over which was a really nasty barb at those who have more than one child. No child is a do-over, what a horrible thing to say.

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:24

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:21

That makes it even worse!!!! Were your siblings do-overs?

I have no idea of my parents motivations for having more than one child so I don’t know.

Thepurplelantern · 02/03/2023 19:23

Camilliatile · 02/03/2023 13:23

Only children are the best life hack of all time. All the love and benefits of DC while maintaining sleep, money, low stress life, time for yourself, time for your partner and friends, career etc. Pressure on women to have two accounts for a lot of second children, they think you're meant to have two and the option of having one just doesn't occur to them.

Absolutely makes sense to me. I totally get this.

I have 3 and absolutely love it because we have very limited extended family but I genuinely don’t get where the angst over having one comes from (usually from people with more than one too). My best friend has one and they have an absolutely lovely set up.

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:23

So let me get this right - we have to suck up all the ‘lonely only’ comments and listen to people waxing lyrical about how they’re ‘so glad we gave DS/DD the gift of a sibling’, but we’re not allowed to state what we consider to be the positives of only having one?

Yes, infertility is the only permitted reason to have one child.

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:21

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:19

Yeah, must be because I’m one of 4.

That makes it even worse!!!! Were your siblings do-overs?

TempsPerdu · 02/03/2023 19:19

People don't have an issue with one child families. It's only when they start sounding smug and all the reasons they give are really for the parent's benefit rather than the child that it gets annoying

So let me get this right - we have to suck up all the ‘lonely only’ comments and listen to people waxing lyrical about how they’re ‘so glad we gave DS/DD the gift of a sibling’, but we’re not allowed to state what we consider to be the positives of only having one?

We need to get over the whole ‘anything that’s done for the benefit of the parent is cruel’ mindset. We could have had another child, but we didn’t want one. As well as all the ‘superficial’ reasons like time and resources etc (which are pretty bloody sensible considerations IMO), having a second child would have likely wrecked my body (I have large fibroids so any further pregnancy would have been risky), didn’t want to roll the dice again because we are older parents who know several similar families where the 2nd child has profound special needs, and are both temperamentally unsuited to the chaos, noise and reduced focus of multiple DC. Are all of those reasons ‘selfish’ because they benefit mainly us as parents?

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:19

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:18

I am still laughing at the do-over comment. Batshit!

Yeah, must be because I’m one of 4.

Pigletnotatwiglet · 02/03/2023 19:18

I am still laughing at the do-over comment. Batshit!

reddwarfgeek · 02/03/2023 19:12

Love these threads. It's so interesting to see different points of view.
I have an only, through 50/50 choice/circumstances . She's 5. She's really sociable, seems happy and after a year of asking me on and off for a sibling, she says she doesn't want one and wants a playroom in the house for her and her friends instead! 🤣
It depends on many factors though. My father is an only but my grandma was the type who didn't play and never allowed other children in the house. I have one brother but my parents used to avoid all child friendly activities and take us on very boring walking holidays...no sleepovers or friends for tea allowed etc.
With my DD I'm always happy to try and make friends with other parents and arrange playdates. I'm pretty sure DD isn't lonely at all. Obviously this might change, but I love just having 1.
It's interesting to see people who say 2 is easier than 1 as they play together so the parents get peace and quiet.
Playing with DD has never been an issue. I've lots of energy and like a big kid myself so am happy to play and dance with her. The part I didn't want to go through again was pregnancy, post partum psychosis and loosing myself for 3 years.
Each to their own.

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:12

StrawHatOnTheParcelShelf · 02/03/2023 18:51

God I hope you don't speak to her like that, she'll grow up to be insufferable.

Telling a child they’re enough? My child knows she’s loved, she’s enough and that I think she’s wonderful. If your children don’t know that you feel that way about them, I feel sorry for them.

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:11

NowAAT · 02/03/2023 18:39

WTF???? You really thought that statement was appropriate?

Yes. I know more than one person who, for whatever reason, wanted another go at the experience of pregnancy, or childbirth, or breastfeeding, or the newborn days, or whatever after it had not gone well the first time - and that was a factor in their decision to have a second/third/more child.

Kpo58 · 02/03/2023 19:08

People don't have an issue with one child families. It's only when they start sounding smug and all the reasons they give is really for the parent's benefit rather than the child that it gets annoying.

Like when they say that they can have loads of great holidays to random destinations but for the child, there isn't anyone else their age they can talk to or if they do make friends they will never see them again or that the entire itinerary of the trip is stuff that the parents rather than the child wants to do, then the child may rather stay at home seeing friends than being dragged around all these places.

RumandSpinach · 02/03/2023 19:06

I have an only, and after an ectopic and two miscarriages I'm starting to accept he will stay an only.

I worry and I'm grieving. I wish people wouldn't be so judgemental.

TempsPerdu · 02/03/2023 19:03

So many of these only child threads, and they are very rarely edifying.

We have one, by choice. We don’t make a big thing of it, and I wouldn’t think to brag to anyone on here or irl about how brilliant our life with DD is, but it does get to me that some people seem determined not to allow one-child families to have anything nice. As in, you can list 20 different reasons why you stuck at one and insist until the cows come home that your only is perfectly happy/well-adjusted/good at sharing, and there’ll still be a contingent of posters who insist that you must be cruel/selfish, and that all only children must inevitably be dysfunctional, lonely and selfish.

Mothers who are already financially stretched, burnt out and temperamentally unsuited to parenting multiple DC should suck it up and pop out another one in order to provide a sibling. And whatever the reasons cited for being content with your one - better finances, less stress, more time and resources to invest in the child, parental temperament, or mental and physical wellbeing - they are dismissed as unimportant or superficial (‘selfish’, again). And it still seems weirdly acceptable to air these views, in a way that it wouldn’t be for any other family size or make-up.

I just wish people would accept that there are pros and cons to any situation in life, and agree to live and let live.

EarthlyNightshade · 02/03/2023 18:57

endoftheworldniteclub · 02/03/2023 18:47

I’m thinking of getting a second cat.

I hear ya.
I fear my cat might also be a do-over.