Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be thrilled to have an only child?

263 replies

iamloading · 02/03/2023 12:36

Ok so probably just getting this off my chest after reading yet another post saying "I feel sorry for only children." Obviously everyone is entitled to their opinion but I don't get the strange obsession on here that only children are to be pitied in some way.
We have one child by choice, and it is the right decision for us as a family. That's not a decision that's right for every family, and obviously there are huge potential benefits from sibling relationships.
However there are also massive benefits of being an only, and both my husband and I are also onlys so we know this from experience.
We are able to save an amount each month for DC, have far more financial freedom (we both work part time for instance,) have a lovely stress free life. We also moved to a house on a new build estate very near the school so every weekend it's a non stop procession of kids knocking on asking to play with our DC. In fact we are all ready for a break from all the friends at points!
I've never been asked in real life if I'm having another, nor has any pity for my DC ever been expressed. So it just seems to be an issue on here.
So AIBU to just not get the "pity." And ps if you are one child not by choice due to any reason then PLEASE don't feel guilty as in my opinion there is nothing at all to feel guilty for xx

OP posts:
kikisparks · 03/03/2023 08:18

Cornelious2011 · 02/03/2023 15:57

@Moonicorn
I think there is an important point there. A lot comes down to parenting styles. Some people may chose to have 2 or more because they don't like playing with their dc so want a playmate.

Dh and I always loved playing with dc and even though they're 11 now we've made a conscious effort to have a fun household. We don't mind being silly, jumping on trampoline, getting on scary rides, playing video games, , boardgames, Lego building, dancing around the kitchen, water fights etc etc. Dc has never wanted a playmate specifically at home. She has loads of friends and cousins she sees everyday and loves coming back to her quieter house.

As someone with a DD who is one year old and most likely won’t have siblings it’s really nice to hear about the lovely life of your older single child. We love playing with DD too and I think it’ll only get better as she gets older and her interests get more interesting than “that’s not my” books and stacking blocks 🤣 she most likely won’t have cousins either but hopefully lots of friends, we’ll do our best anyway to give her opportunities to socialise.

GotABeatForYouMama · 03/03/2023 08:16

then there is no other children around to fill the gap, and I guess sense of loss may feel greater.

I don't understand this view at all. Do you really think a parent who has lost a child will think "well at least I've got another one so it's not so bad"?

I am expecting my 3rd DD and I'm happy they will at least be able to play and grow up together and when they're older if something happens to me or their father at least they'll have each other.

I'm one of 3. Me and my siblings rarely played together as we all had different interests and friends. When my parents died it was left to me to sort everything out with no help from the other 2. We now have little contact with each other. Don't assume that because you have more than 1 child they will all get along famously. The relationship I had with my siblings was a primary reason as to why I am one and done.

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 08:12

stackhead · 02/03/2023 15:53

I think parents of onlies spend alot of time justifying it because there are many MANY people in society who judge people for only having one. There are examples of that all over this thread.

We currently have an only. She'll probably stay an only. I struggle immensely with guilt over not wanting to give her a sibling, but ultimately I don't want another child and I refuse to bring a child into the world who is not 100% wanted for them (rather than as an accessory to the first child).

I value the good parts of only having an only but being constantly told (both explicitly and implicitly) that only having 1 child is a "bad thing" is shit. And it happens all. the. time.

Sorry you experience this. But you are absolutely doing the right thing in not having a child that you don’t want just to “give” your existing child a sibling. Maybe she would be best friends with any sibling, maybe they’d be indifferent to each other, maybe they’d hate each other, most likely somewhere in between, who knows, but there would be no guarantee than any further child would be an asset to your existing child and it would be so unfair on them to be born purely to be a companion and playmate.

People telling you having one child is a bad thing are so rude- and perhaps may be projecting their own experiences onto you. There are loads and loads of positives both for the family (usually especially the woman) and the child of having a single child family. There can be benefits of having more than one child too. We all need to do what’s right for us and our families.

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 07:43

Vegrocks · 03/03/2023 07:40

I don’t get your point? You’re surprised that that’s a spectrum of responses and some contradict others? Is that a surprise?

My point is the first people are wrong- they’re saying why even post this as nobody cares about family size but then lots of people on the thread clearly do care as they’re making rude and negative comments about OP’s family size.

Vegrocks · 03/03/2023 07:40

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 07:34

People on this thread: YABU OP, literally nobody cares about your family size

Also people on this thread: YABU, I would never have an only, I don’t understand why anyone would, children need siblings, only children are aggressive and lack emotional awareness, siblings are needed to ensure one can relate to other children, what about when you’re dead etc etc etc etc

YANBU OP. Having one child is great and having warm, loving, engaged parents is infinitely more valuable than having a sibling.

I don’t get your point? You’re surprised that that’s a spectrum of responses and some contradict others? Is that a surprise?

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 07:34

People on this thread: YABU OP, literally nobody cares about your family size

Also people on this thread: YABU, I would never have an only, I don’t understand why anyone would, children need siblings, only children are aggressive and lack emotional awareness, siblings are needed to ensure one can relate to other children, what about when you’re dead etc etc etc etc

YANBU OP. Having one child is great and having warm, loving, engaged parents is infinitely more valuable than having a sibling.

beethecrackon24995 · 02/03/2023 23:39

I HATE posts like this and normally don't read them. I read a few of them though as i was bored and true to.form some smug MNer posts pointing out the bleeding obvious that basically if your child does you don't have another to fill the gap. Thanks for that. I tried for ten years to have another unsuccessfully going through all types of shit whilst you effortlessly knocked out three. Don't ever say that to someone in rl if they have one as they may have been ttc unsuccessfully. If you said that to me you'd have regretted it......

nanodyne · 02/03/2023 22:56

YANBU, it sounds like your family unit works perfectly for you.

I have lots of siblings but did consider only having one. However, because I'm so used to having so much family, once he started to really play at about 18 months I felt sad thinking of him not having a sibling - someone you have total ease with - to share all the things I had growing up. DS2 is so different to his brother already, it's fascinating to observe and I can't wait to see how they both are as they grow. In an ideal world I think I'd like a third but I can't bear the thought of being pregnant and having a newborn again, it's just not for me, I don't get how anyone can enjoy that stage.

I don't feel sorry for only children though, that's just how I feel about my family.

LarryandLeon · 02/03/2023 22:49

Mellymoon · 02/03/2023 21:33

Really strange way to see things. I highly doubt that having another child will fill the hole if your child dies..
children are individual and unique..
I doubt anyone who loses a child gets over it quicker because they have another.. wtf

I agree, I think it’s a very strange way of looking at things. Of all the things I worry about in terms of having one DC, the idea that if she died there would be some consolation in having more children makes no sense to me. I’ve seen it a few times on here- odd. It sticks in my mind a drama about a woman who lost her daughter in the London tube bombings- she had two other children & yet her grief for her daughter was so palpable. She became completely obsessed with the circumstances & actually became quite alienated from the rest of her family.

Darkdiamond · 02/03/2023 22:00

Mellymoon · 02/03/2023 21:33

Really strange way to see things. I highly doubt that having another child will fill the hole if your child dies..
children are individual and unique..
I doubt anyone who loses a child gets over it quicker because they have another.. wtf

I don't think it's strange.

I don't want to go too deeply into this as everything i have typed sounds so glib. But I don't think it's a strange way to see things at all.

Mellymoon · 02/03/2023 21:33

threeplusmum · 02/03/2023 13:54

My opinion differs, I think having one child is understandable but if something happens to that child - illness or tragedy (not saying it will) but there risk is there, then there is no other children around to fill the gap, and I guess sense of loss may feel greater. I am expecting my 3rd DD and I'm happy they will at least be able to play and grow up together and when they're older if something happens to me or their father at least they'll have each other.

Really strange way to see things. I highly doubt that having another child will fill the hole if your child dies..
children are individual and unique..
I doubt anyone who loses a child gets over it quicker because they have another.. wtf

kikisparks · 02/03/2023 21:09

Comedycook · 02/03/2023 14:49

Let's say two only children get married and have one child, once they're dead, their child will have zero family. Unless the choice has been take out of your hands, then I think it's very selfish. My parents died young. Thank heavens I have a sister.

Having any children at all is selfish. And that’s quite right, as children should be very wanted. Nobody should have a child just to gift their other child a sibling, a child doesn’t want to be born as a selfless act by parents who didn’t actually want them.

Misunderstoodagain · 02/03/2023 20:56

Oh I needed this thread so bad! I have one but have been flip flopping on another, mainly because I don't want him to be lonely etc. But I want a better lifestyle for our family and another would financially stretch us so have been feeling terribly guilty. So yes really needed to read all this!

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 20:50

bluelid · 02/03/2023 20:20

@BelindaBears

I mainly taught KS2, so most had siblings who were older than baby age (unless there was a bigger age gap). I guess it would take time to adapt to becoming a sibling, but some things change immediately. For example, bed time suddenly involves another person's schedule/ needs, mum/ dad has another person to carry/ cuddle/ get stuff for. Adult's tend to naturally accommodate the child... whereas other children are far less empathetic towards them and their desires!

In my experience, only children tend to prefer to do things on their own rather than with others, would often take a backseat in group work, would gravitate towards any adults in the room, wouldn't tend to stick up for themselves in a disagreement (i.e. about who was going to have the blue felt tip and who was going to have the red felt tip), would often be quite set about their ideas on things.

Thanks for replying! I definitely recognise some of your description (although many of those points also apply to my personality too so it’s hard to know what’s inherited and what’s the only child factor) I do consciously try to facilitate as many opportunities as possible for her to spend time with peers and her cousins who are close geographically and in age to help develop some of those skills she might not naturally get to learn at home.

PretzelBite · 02/03/2023 20:42

Interesting @bluelid
I teach secondary and have found eldest siblings and onlies generally more outgoing, confident and creative.

WorkerBee83 · 02/03/2023 20:31

Thank you OP. I have an only child and it’s staying that way but I’m sick of other people’s comments “she’ll be lonely, she’ll grow up selfish, I’m selfish for not having another” blah blah. I really only ever wanted one child and she’s a well rounded, happy little lady

Cornelious2011 · 02/03/2023 20:22

@Kpo58 perhaps that's correct in the early days, but from age 8 dc has a sleepover with friends/ family at least twice per month so dh and I get a day/ night to ourselves. We also reciprocate these sleepovers. Having 1 dc means we don't need to think about a second. Dc does a sport at a club level as does her bf (trains 4 times per week). We share lifts with the parents so we get another 2 evenings 'off' per week for 2.5 hours to binge watch yellow stone or other shit.

When dc goes on her school residential in a few months dh and I are off for 3 nights for a city break. We get lots of free time.

bluelid · 02/03/2023 20:20

@BelindaBears

I mainly taught KS2, so most had siblings who were older than baby age (unless there was a bigger age gap). I guess it would take time to adapt to becoming a sibling, but some things change immediately. For example, bed time suddenly involves another person's schedule/ needs, mum/ dad has another person to carry/ cuddle/ get stuff for. Adult's tend to naturally accommodate the child... whereas other children are far less empathetic towards them and their desires!

In my experience, only children tend to prefer to do things on their own rather than with others, would often take a backseat in group work, would gravitate towards any adults in the room, wouldn't tend to stick up for themselves in a disagreement (i.e. about who was going to have the blue felt tip and who was going to have the red felt tip), would often be quite set about their ideas on things.

Bamboux · 02/03/2023 20:06

Cherrysherbet · 02/03/2023 20:02

I was an only child, and feel I missed out.

I would have loved to have a sibling to grow up with. I spent a lot of time with only adults around me. They were loving and I was doted on, but it was a different kind of upbringing compared to my friends.

Now I am older, I feel sad that I don’t have a Brother or Sister to spend time with. My dh is also an only child, so we have no siblings and my kids have no cousins.

I lost my dear Dad a few years ago, and now my Mum is in a home. The responsibility is all on us to keep her looked after. It’s stressful at times, and would have been good to have another part of the family that cared as much as us for her. It’s lonely at times.

I have three children. I never wanted an only child.

I'm the eldest. I'm not on speaking terms with any of my siblings, for good reasons. My kids have never met their first cousins, and if I can help it, they never will.

I dread my parents dying not so much because of them dying, but because I will have to deal with my siblings.

I really, really, really wish my parents had stopped after me. Your idea of what it's like to have siblings is a rose-tinted view based on not having actually had any.

Cherrysherbet · 02/03/2023 20:02

I was an only child, and feel I missed out.

I would have loved to have a sibling to grow up with. I spent a lot of time with only adults around me. They were loving and I was doted on, but it was a different kind of upbringing compared to my friends.

Now I am older, I feel sad that I don’t have a Brother or Sister to spend time with. My dh is also an only child, so we have no siblings and my kids have no cousins.

I lost my dear Dad a few years ago, and now my Mum is in a home. The responsibility is all on us to keep her looked after. It’s stressful at times, and would have been good to have another part of the family that cared as much as us for her. It’s lonely at times.

I have three children. I never wanted an only child.

ellecf21 · 02/03/2023 19:51

Watching with interest. Had my first DD last June and already get asked if we are having another (which I find really annoying). To be honest we are really happy with one and aren't 100% whether we will have another. No pressure from DH as he would be really happy with one and we don't feel incomplete at all. The only thing that worries me is regretting not having more than one in the future. I always thought I'd have two in my minds eye but actually having one alters your perspective - DD is an absolute angel as well. Sleeps through, happy all the time and generally a joy. She will grow up with lots of lifelong friends through my friends children as well as cousins and second cousins in my family if we didn't have another. Will see if instinct prevails like it did with this one although can't afford another till DD is in free childcare anyway.

BelindaBears · 02/03/2023 19:47

bluelid · 02/03/2023 19:38

I'm an (ex) primary teacher.

I could identify an only child in a class of 30 within a day or two of knowing them (without actually knowing that they were). There is something about the way only children communicate/ relate to other children that it is quite unique, probably based on spending the majority of their time in adult company. It's not necessarily a good/ bad thing, but definitely distinctive.

Having said that, I would also have been able to tell you which children had older siblings (usually more mature in a 'streetwise' kind of way) and which ones were the 'babies' of the family. Again, without actually knowing their background.

My point is, family dynamics do tend to influence behaviour/ personality, whether parents want them to or not.

This is really interesting to read. I see so many of my personality traits in DD, but I’m in the middle of 4 siblings and she’s an only child. She definitely talks to adults in a different way to how I did though. What age did you teach? My DD is in reception and a lot of her peers have very young baby siblings. It’s difficult to see how having had a sibling for a few months could already have made that much difference to their behaviour/personality compared to an only child. Is it something you think kicks in later on?

ChaosAndCrumbs · 02/03/2023 19:45

Not unreasonable. It’s just horses for courses, isn’t it? People aren’t unreasonable for happily being single or polygamous or preferring to wear purple every day or disliking chocolate.

I didn’t want a single child, but I understand some people do and nobody’s less reasonable than the other person, it just suits them, their life, their family and the way they think. For me, it melts my heart when my two snuggle and the youngest calls her brother or the oldest shows her a new way to do something.

wideclosedspaces · 02/03/2023 19:44

Given the constant fighting of mine at the moment, I’m often bloody wishing I’d stopped at one!

IncessantNameChanger · 02/03/2023 19:40

People love to judge. The only to my face comments was from mil

Your selfish having none
Your selfish having one
2 no comments
3 was it a mistake?
4 practically did I hold a gun to dhs head to sexually assault him? I was a vile slut who tricked dh basically

So meh, as long you 3 are happy then it's the perfect number