Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be thrilled to have an only child?

263 replies

iamloading · 02/03/2023 12:36

Ok so probably just getting this off my chest after reading yet another post saying "I feel sorry for only children." Obviously everyone is entitled to their opinion but I don't get the strange obsession on here that only children are to be pitied in some way.
We have one child by choice, and it is the right decision for us as a family. That's not a decision that's right for every family, and obviously there are huge potential benefits from sibling relationships.
However there are also massive benefits of being an only, and both my husband and I are also onlys so we know this from experience.
We are able to save an amount each month for DC, have far more financial freedom (we both work part time for instance,) have a lovely stress free life. We also moved to a house on a new build estate very near the school so every weekend it's a non stop procession of kids knocking on asking to play with our DC. In fact we are all ready for a break from all the friends at points!
I've never been asked in real life if I'm having another, nor has any pity for my DC ever been expressed. So it just seems to be an issue on here.
So AIBU to just not get the "pity." And ps if you are one child not by choice due to any reason then PLEASE don't feel guilty as in my opinion there is nothing at all to feel guilty for xx

OP posts:
Bamboux · 06/03/2023 11:50

Hillarious · 06/03/2023 10:43

You're quite right, and I apologise. I'm really sorry for assuming you may have anything other than a positive relationship with your siblings. But, I do wish you all the very best in your continued relationship with them, on whatever level that may be.

I don't have a continued relationship with them. I dread my parents dying because I'll have to deal with my siblings. After that I hope to never encounter them ever again. I wish I was an only child.

Thanks for the apology. Your comment was really out of line.

UWhatNow · 06/03/2023 10:52

daffodilday · 02/03/2023 16:21

It makes me chuckle when someone mentions my DC lack of siblings. I’m tempted to ask if they still feel sad for her knowing she just got back from a surfing holiday in Bali because we can afford such holidays due to her being an only .

That’s your perspective as a parent though.

We could only afford shitty out-of-season caravan holidays when our 3 were little but they still reminisce about the dances they made up, the time they raced each other on the beach in a rain storm, the time dad dropped his chips in McDonalds, the bits they bought with pocket money from the gift shop and the naff giant pen they are still fuming about because they weren’t allowed to buy it, and when Sam needed a poo on the beach and dad was mad because we’d just walked past the toilet block 10 minutes earlier etc.

They never talk about the later holidays abroad or activities we paid for such as scuba diving.

Laughing about the minutiae between siblings is what they remember.

Emptycrackedcup · 06/03/2023 10:44

Mumsnet is the only place I've ever seen comments about it!

Hillarious · 06/03/2023 10:43

Bamboux · 06/03/2023 10:25

I'm sorry, I don't understand what on earth makes you think you know better than I do about my own life?

You're quite right, and I apologise. I'm really sorry for assuming you may have anything other than a positive relationship with your siblings. But, I do wish you all the very best in your continued relationship with them, on whatever level that may be.

Bamboux · 06/03/2023 10:25

Hillarious · 06/03/2023 10:05

Of course you don't mean that!

I'm sorry, I don't understand what on earth makes you think you know better than I do about my own life?

Hillarious · 06/03/2023 10:05

Bamboux · 03/03/2023 18:30

Can i return my siblings and have the money instead please?

Of course you don't mean that!

LarryandLeon · 03/03/2023 18:51

Bamboux · 03/03/2023 18:30

Can i return my siblings and have the money instead please?

🤣

Bamboux · 03/03/2023 18:30

Hillarious · 03/03/2023 14:49

We had DC1 for the grandparents, DC2 to keep DC1 company and DC3 was for me and DH. Not really - DC2 and DC3 just arrived unannounced, with no forethought and all within three and a half years. No amount of additional finance in the household would make up for the unconditional friendship, love and support they give each other (all now in their early 20s), but no-one really cares about this except for me and DH (and the grandparents), so I'll keep my pity for the OP for what she's missing out on to myself.

Can i return my siblings and have the money instead please?

LarryandLeon · 03/03/2023 15:13

Hillarious · 03/03/2023 14:49

We had DC1 for the grandparents, DC2 to keep DC1 company and DC3 was for me and DH. Not really - DC2 and DC3 just arrived unannounced, with no forethought and all within three and a half years. No amount of additional finance in the household would make up for the unconditional friendship, love and support they give each other (all now in their early 20s), but no-one really cares about this except for me and DH (and the grandparents), so I'll keep my pity for the OP for what she's missing out on to myself.

WTF???!!!

labamba007 · 03/03/2023 15:10

BHRK · 02/03/2023 15:03

I couldn’t care less how many children people have, it’s a personal decision.
however I’m taking offence to all the people on here saying how awful and chaotic it is with 2/3 kids! We have 3 and absolutely love it. Just as you love your 1, I love my 3

This! I'm sticking with one. But we can't keep making out that our option is better. Have 10, have 1. Go anywhere in between. It doesn't matter and it's no one else's business, and if someone makes you feel crap for your choice ignore them. They aren't you.

BelindaBears · 03/03/2023 14:54

so I'll keep my pity for the OP for what she's missing out on to myself….by posting it on her thread.

Dense, or just smug?

Hillarious · 03/03/2023 14:49

We had DC1 for the grandparents, DC2 to keep DC1 company and DC3 was for me and DH. Not really - DC2 and DC3 just arrived unannounced, with no forethought and all within three and a half years. No amount of additional finance in the household would make up for the unconditional friendship, love and support they give each other (all now in their early 20s), but no-one really cares about this except for me and DH (and the grandparents), so I'll keep my pity for the OP for what she's missing out on to myself.

Bamboux · 03/03/2023 13:57

mastertomsmum · 03/03/2023 13:38

Speaking as one who had just one much older sibling, I loved the big gap. We always got on. My husband is one of 4 with the eldest being only 5.5 years older than the youngest. He’s in no doubt that that my experience of childhood sibling interaction was more positive than his. It can work for some relationships but definitely didn’t for theirs.

I'm one of three all born within four years of each other, and I agree with your husband. I left a gap of more than three years between my kids for that reason. (Think I was also lucky that they were different sexes - I am one of three girls. It was and is a nightmare.)

mastertomsmum · 03/03/2023 13:38

Speaking as one who had just one much older sibling, I loved the big gap. We always got on. My husband is one of 4 with the eldest being only 5.5 years older than the youngest. He’s in no doubt that that my experience of childhood sibling interaction was more positive than his. It can work for some relationships but definitely didn’t for theirs.

InvincibleInvisibility · 03/03/2023 11:08

I have 2 and an very happy with that. I'm glad others are very happy with 1.

However we have just moved overseas and I am so glad the DC have each other. A friend I met here has an only child (11). She says they have never wanted more, and neither has he, but she has also complained about how hard it is with just 1 in a new place. How hard it is to invite new friends over etc. (They're always busy with childhood friends and family....!)

You can't guarantee that your DC friends and cousins will live in the same place as you for their entire childhood.

afterdropshock · 03/03/2023 10:22

I think having more than one can be easier as others may have mentioned. They entertain each other, meaning you as an adult can get on with other things if you need or want to.

louise5754 · 03/03/2023 10:03

Clearly you have doubts as you wouldn't need to make a thread about it if you were that content?

defi · 03/03/2023 09:57

I love having just the one it's easy

derbylass81 · 03/03/2023 09:54

I agree it can be the best option for many families, for many reasons.

But I do feel that, on balance, it is a positive for a kid to have a sibling when young.

I have two and the laughing and giggling and in jokes that they have in the back of the car, or lounging on the couch, or lying in bed together, is amazing to hear. I have friends with only one and it can be a bit boring for their only at times.

I guess the flip side of that is getting more of the parents attention, no arguments about what to watch on tv etc.

So I do think that whilst the overall best option has to be what suits your own family for various reasons, there are huge benefits to having a constant playmate in childhood (albeit that doesn't often continue into adulthood).

pharmachameleon · 03/03/2023 09:44

@TempsPerdu rally, really well put.
I also marvel at the guilt that is placed upon mothers only in these threads and also in real life. My DH has never had one conversation in RL about why we have only one child whereas I have been asked by every single one of my female friends and good proportion of my female work colleagues. They stopped asking when it was obvious we weren't having any more mercifully-when DS was around 8.

BelindaBears · 03/03/2023 09:10

GotABeatForYouMama · 03/03/2023 08:16

then there is no other children around to fill the gap, and I guess sense of loss may feel greater.

I don't understand this view at all. Do you really think a parent who has lost a child will think "well at least I've got another one so it's not so bad"?

I am expecting my 3rd DD and I'm happy they will at least be able to play and grow up together and when they're older if something happens to me or their father at least they'll have each other.

I'm one of 3. Me and my siblings rarely played together as we all had different interests and friends. When my parents died it was left to me to sort everything out with no help from the other 2. We now have little contact with each other. Don't assume that because you have more than 1 child they will all get along famously. The relationship I had with my siblings was a primary reason as to why I am one and done.

Yep, I’m one of 4, my mum is terminally ill and I’m getting zero support and a lot of stress from my siblings. My support is coming from my husband and friends, the same as it would be if I were an only child. My DH has a brother who we will probably never see again once his mum dies, and thank fuck for that, he’s nothing but trouble. The The idea siblings provide a guaranteed positive relationship for life is naive.

ridemesideway · 03/03/2023 09:07

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 08:41

Thanks for sharing, it’s always nice hearing how single child families with an older child find it as I’m still at an early stage, it’s good to know that it has worked well for you.

It’s obvious to me that quite a lot of responses to this thread are from people with kids under 12. Its great having one.

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 09:04

TempsPerdu · 02/03/2023 19:03

So many of these only child threads, and they are very rarely edifying.

We have one, by choice. We don’t make a big thing of it, and I wouldn’t think to brag to anyone on here or irl about how brilliant our life with DD is, but it does get to me that some people seem determined not to allow one-child families to have anything nice. As in, you can list 20 different reasons why you stuck at one and insist until the cows come home that your only is perfectly happy/well-adjusted/good at sharing, and there’ll still be a contingent of posters who insist that you must be cruel/selfish, and that all only children must inevitably be dysfunctional, lonely and selfish.

Mothers who are already financially stretched, burnt out and temperamentally unsuited to parenting multiple DC should suck it up and pop out another one in order to provide a sibling. And whatever the reasons cited for being content with your one - better finances, less stress, more time and resources to invest in the child, parental temperament, or mental and physical wellbeing - they are dismissed as unimportant or superficial (‘selfish’, again). And it still seems weirdly acceptable to air these views, in a way that it wouldn’t be for any other family size or make-up.

I just wish people would accept that there are pros and cons to any situation in life, and agree to live and let live.

This! Very well put. Especially about mothers- so often in these “debates” people seem to disregard the point that women should have a choice about whether and when to have a child or children and family size is part of that.

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 08:41

EddieVeddersfoxymop · 02/03/2023 16:24

Same here. Medically, we had no choice really - my health was very poor through pregnancy. But, we probably wouldn't have had more anyway. 3 is the magic number for us, DD gets all our time which now as a teen is proving the best thing. We can save for her, allow her to undertake massively expensive hobbies that are her passion, she is well supported through her exams etc etc so it's all good here. Cannot imagine what life would look like with more kids now.

Thanks for sharing, it’s always nice hearing how single child families with an older child find it as I’m still at an early stage, it’s good to know that it has worked well for you.

kikisparks · 03/03/2023 08:26

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 02/03/2023 16:19

See you just said cousins- lots of cousins. So you clearly see the benefit of similar aged family- for most people that’s a sibling!

Cousins are very different than siblings, they don’t (usually) live with your child, you don’t have to be pregnant or give birth to them, or raise them, they don’t take any resources away from your child (apart from possibly grandparent inheritance) and generally friends are more important than cousins. Cousins or siblings who are friends with each other is nice but not much different IMO than non related friends. I see my friends a heck of a lot more than my cousins or even my sibling, I have a lot more in common with my friends and I find it quite awkward talking to my cousins as I don’t really know them. Cousins may sometimes be a benefit to a child but they’re not a necessity just like siblings aren’t.