Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill your pet if ordered to by the gov't?

638 replies

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 12:31

I read in the news this morning that at the beginning of the Covid crisis the gov't considered ordering the culling of all domestic cats in order to prevent the spread of Covid. This idea was later abandoned after it was proven that cats couldn't transmit Covid to humans.
AIBU to think that this would have caused a mass uprising? We are a nation of animal lovers, after all. Or would people have accepted it as they did some of the other draconian regulations (not visiting dying relatives, etc).

www.lbc.co.uk/news/govt-cat-cull-covid-pandemic/

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 19:34

I don't have a cat myself, but I expect it makes a difference that people can easily envisage a mechanism whereby they wouldn't have to comply. You just hide your cat in your house. We don't have a national pet register or anything of that nature and clearly neither would we have had enough police or army to go house to house checking fast and efficiently enough, so it's quite obvious it wouldn't have worked and people could've evaded it (hindsight also helps here). Whereas I don't know how you manage to enforce your continued presence in a hospital. Not saying it couldn't happen, but it's harder than just unilaterally deciding not to let your pet out.

Fwiw me and mine opted out of lockdown fairly early, so I don't come at this from a position of respect for the authorities in that respect.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 19:33

When I think back to elderly isolated on care homes or people alone dying in hospital it makes me feel very sad and wonder where was everyone saying no chance and over my dead body as on this thread

It's a fair point, but back then there were still plenty who believed - or perhaps just wanted to believe - that government were genuinely doing their best for us all and that there was some hope of "everyone being in it together"

With the evidence piling up that this wasn't always the case, it's possible a change of attitude is happening and that some wouldn't be quite so quick to be fooled again

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 19:33

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:25

I also think if the government had even suggested this it would have been the straw that lost them all compliance with requirements

The straw that lost them all compliance should have been allowing family members to die alone and to have funerals with virtually nobody present. It should have been refusing to allow parents of young children to be with them in hospital. How could an animal be 'the final straw' compared to the stuff that actually happened? What the fuck was wrong with people?

A lot are closer to pets than elderly family members. Yes I would have gone in to see elderly family as we were working with the virus so lost interest in it quite quickly, my mother who was scarred of catching it more than likely wouldn't. Not sure I would have wanted her to go in either as she older so was safer and happy staying at home.

If you tried to take the dog (or cat) she had in the house with her that had no chance of catching it, not a chance would she have let you. She would literally have been more likely to lock down to save the dog than an elderly family member!

@NeverDropYourMooncup I'm tired foot and mouth disease 😉 to be fair I think it was the point we should have defended animals and just out lawed meat eating.

NomiMacaroni · 02/03/2023 19:32

Not for COVID, for a more deadly disease yes

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:31

If someone had told me that I could avoid lockdown and all that went with it, if I killed my cat, I would have been saying goodbye kitty. And I am fond of my cat.

MarshaBradyo · 02/03/2023 19:27

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:25

I also think if the government had even suggested this it would have been the straw that lost them all compliance with requirements

The straw that lost them all compliance should have been allowing family members to die alone and to have funerals with virtually nobody present. It should have been refusing to allow parents of young children to be with them in hospital. How could an animal be 'the final straw' compared to the stuff that actually happened? What the fuck was wrong with people?

Exactly. It’s so disconcerting if you said as much at the time

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/03/2023 19:26

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 19:22

Nope not a chance I would have sent them into hiding first. I also think if the government had even suggested this it would have been the straw that lost them all compliance with requirements. Moderate scientists were already shouting that we didn't need restrictions like they wanted, just look at Matt Hancock keeping kids off school when it wasn't needed!!!

Also hand foot and mouth was an economic decision not a scientific one, most adult animals recover from hand foot and mouth. That's another government scandal!!!

Foot and Mouth and Hand, Foot and Mouth Disease are two completely separate things.

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:25

I also think if the government had even suggested this it would have been the straw that lost them all compliance with requirements

The straw that lost them all compliance should have been allowing family members to die alone and to have funerals with virtually nobody present. It should have been refusing to allow parents of young children to be with them in hospital. How could an animal be 'the final straw' compared to the stuff that actually happened? What the fuck was wrong with people?

MarshaBradyo · 02/03/2023 19:25

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:22

This sort of comment is interesting, given that so many people went along with lockdown and all the restrictions. I said at the time if one of my (adult) children were dying in hospital, someone would actually have to kill me to stop me getting to them. Yet people on this thread are keener to defend their pets than they were to refuse to go along with the "rules".

If only they had spoken up, we might have been spared lockdown.

I'm not seeing this through retrospective eyes. I disagreed with lockdown right from the start, and carried on seeing my friends, allowed my teenagers to have 'gatherings' here, smuggled them to friends' houses, went shopping every day for inessential items etc, etc. Indeed, I started a MN thread to ask if anyone else was refusing to comply (under another name) and it was deleted (ie censored) by HQ for not toeing the party line.

So I'm surprised that so many people would defend their cat, but were not prepared to defend their own rights and those of their loved ones.

I agree with you. When I think back to elderly isolated on care homes or people alone dying in hospital it makes me feel very sad and wonder where was everyone saying no chance and over my dead body as on this thread.

justasking111 · 02/03/2023 19:23

forums.pigeonwatch.co.uk/forums/topic/355587-1969-rabies-outbreak-containment-what-would-happen-today/

Rabies outbreak what would happen today. The comments are priceless and pre covid

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 19:22

Nope not a chance I would have sent them into hiding first. I also think if the government had even suggested this it would have been the straw that lost them all compliance with requirements. Moderate scientists were already shouting that we didn't need restrictions like they wanted, just look at Matt Hancock keeping kids off school when it wasn't needed!!!

Also hand foot and mouth was an economic decision not a scientific one, most adult animals recover from hand foot and mouth. That's another government scandal!!!

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:22

UserID59272626 · 02/03/2023 17:16

This

This sort of comment is interesting, given that so many people went along with lockdown and all the restrictions. I said at the time if one of my (adult) children were dying in hospital, someone would actually have to kill me to stop me getting to them. Yet people on this thread are keener to defend their pets than they were to refuse to go along with the "rules".

If only they had spoken up, we might have been spared lockdown.

I'm not seeing this through retrospective eyes. I disagreed with lockdown right from the start, and carried on seeing my friends, allowed my teenagers to have 'gatherings' here, smuggled them to friends' houses, went shopping every day for inessential items etc, etc. Indeed, I started a MN thread to ask if anyone else was refusing to comply (under another name) and it was deleted (ie censored) by HQ for not toeing the party line.

So I'm surprised that so many people would defend their cat, but were not prepared to defend their own rights and those of their loved ones.

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 19:19

User473831 · 02/03/2023 17:00

Do I have to do with with my bare hands?

it would also depend on which pet, chickens yes, cat probably, ponies maybe, dog, no way,

I believe the last time this happened pet owners were directed to purchase a bolt gun.

OP posts:
BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 19:18

TheOriginalEmu · 02/03/2023 19:10

It’s a pointless question. People will say ‘of course not’ because it’s a not a real scenario and we are at a point where covid is not the threat it was, but at the beginning of the pandemic I’m sure it would have been a different story.
This is just Milgram’s experiment by a different method. That experiment (for those unaware, people were asked to give other people electric shocks if they incorrectly answered a question: most did. Even when the shock was marked ‘may cause death’ and there was screaming) was meant to prove that there was something deficient in the German people that caused the deaths of the Jews. There wasn’t. People are just very susceptible to being told what to do by authority figures.

For that analogy to work though, since most people would be very upset about the deaths of their pets, they'd have to be giving themselves electric shocks.

I presume there could come a point when people felt sufficiently threatened by a disease that many of them would be willing to see their pets killed, but it doesn't follow that the early days of covid was it. Additionally, we don't actually have that much in the way of police and army in our society, so it would've been very hard to enforce. Those may well be amongst the reasons why the government realised it was a bad idea.

Practically speaking, I think if it ever did get bad enough that a good number of the population would consider this, we'd have a lot of vigilante pet killing and that might be a bigger deal than our rather small police and army trying to enforce it.

justasking111 · 02/03/2023 19:16

api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1969/nov/11/rabies

November 1969 how the government handled a rabies scare. BADLY!!! Worth a read

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 19:16

silverbubbles · 02/03/2023 16:39

The farmers had to kill thousands of their animals during foot and mouth in 2001 under government orders....

Livestock, not pets.
There's a huge difference. Livestock is basically raised to be killed, so as long as the farmer is compensated he's ok.

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 02/03/2023 19:10

It’s a pointless question. People will say ‘of course not’ because it’s a not a real scenario and we are at a point where covid is not the threat it was, but at the beginning of the pandemic I’m sure it would have been a different story.
This is just Milgram’s experiment by a different method. That experiment (for those unaware, people were asked to give other people electric shocks if they incorrectly answered a question: most did. Even when the shock was marked ‘may cause death’ and there was screaming) was meant to prove that there was something deficient in the German people that caused the deaths of the Jews. There wasn’t. People are just very susceptible to being told what to do by authority figures.

Eeiliethya · 02/03/2023 19:04

Nope. She'd be stashed in the loft like Anne Frank.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 18:57

Imagine being sat in your living room today, knowing you had killed your beloved pet. To be reading the messages that horrific little man Hancock sent.
Knowing that you killed your pet based on political point scoring and hitting targets

Imagination isn't always necessary; there are still countless people who were forced to stay away from their sick loved ones, unable even to hold their hands as they died or attend the funeral afterwards, and they too will no doubt have views about Hancock's messages

And now, in a supreme irony, this person has described the leaks as "a betrayal"

TheOriginalEmu · 02/03/2023 18:38

KimberleyClark · 02/03/2023 12:34

I think some vets might have objected to such a plan.

I read that as ‘pets’ and was imagining a gang of cats barricading themselves into a school.

Prescottdanni123 · 02/03/2023 18:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

bozzabollix · 02/03/2023 18:36

Absolutely zero way. And if the bastards try to cull the badgers on our land that’s not happening either.

Interesting to see how much it’d damage the government though, but wouldn’t be worth the cost to the animals abd I don’t think most would comply now. WW2 were different times.

XenoBitch · 02/03/2023 18:35

Hell no. My dog is my family, and I would never hand her over to have her killed. They would have to deal with me first.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/03/2023 18:31

Oreosareawful · 02/03/2023 12:35

My cats are valued as much as my children, there's absolutely no way I could have done it. I'd risk prison to protect them.

See I do understand why people say no, of course. But if we weren't talking covid. If there was genuinely a Cat Flu or Mad Cat Disease etc. and it was clear that transmitted to humans it was highly fatal, esp on children, are you honestly saying you couldn't pick your kids over your cat?

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 02/03/2023 18:05

There’s a brilliant film about a baby elephant hidden in a terraced house in Belfast during the war.
it’s a very sad but beautiful film, it’s called zoo.
it’s fantastic.