Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill your pet if ordered to by the gov't?

638 replies

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 12:31

I read in the news this morning that at the beginning of the Covid crisis the gov't considered ordering the culling of all domestic cats in order to prevent the spread of Covid. This idea was later abandoned after it was proven that cats couldn't transmit Covid to humans.
AIBU to think that this would have caused a mass uprising? We are a nation of animal lovers, after all. Or would people have accepted it as they did some of the other draconian regulations (not visiting dying relatives, etc).

www.lbc.co.uk/news/govt-cat-cull-covid-pandemic/

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 02/03/2023 20:35

The World War 2 comparison is not a reasonable one as there was not noise or bombing with Covid 19.

I expect the consideration was only for a very brief period, and the attempt to give this story prominence is to detract from the criminal behaviour that some of the other leaked messages imply.

Perhaps it is where the phrase a 'dead cat story' to distract from another issue comes from.

Buzzinwithbez · 02/03/2023 20:33

There was no logic. There was we need to be seen to be doing something, this is something, so let's do it!

justasking111 · 02/03/2023 20:33

Neighbours would have reported that you had a cat back in the covid dobbing in days. Would that happen again

CrotchetyCrocheting · 02/03/2023 20:29

Mycatsgoldtooth · 02/03/2023 20:23

@CrotchetyCrocheting but this logic didn’t exist during covid. My husband was with my while I was at home in labour and for hours at the hospital but had to leave 40 Minutes after I’d given birth while I was in HDU. Because then he was a covid risk. Despite us both being tested and negative. The rules were never about logic. One woman on here had the police called and the warned her for sleeping in an outhouse on her property with her kids. It was never about risk most of the time just about compliance.

If you had a cat and they were to be culled it would not have mattered if your cat lived in the attic alone. The logic would have been ‘the rules are the rules - doesn’t matter if it makes sense or not - the cat has to die’

I'm not in the UK so am not really familiar with your logic or lack there of over there tbh.

Mycatsgoldtooth · 02/03/2023 20:23

@CrotchetyCrocheting but this logic didn’t exist during covid. My husband was with my while I was at home in labour and for hours at the hospital but had to leave 40 Minutes after I’d given birth while I was in HDU. Because then he was a covid risk. Despite us both being tested and negative. The rules were never about logic. One woman on here had the police called and the warned her for sleeping in an outhouse on her property with her kids. It was never about risk most of the time just about compliance.

If you had a cat and they were to be culled it would not have mattered if your cat lived in the attic alone. The logic would have been ‘the rules are the rules - doesn’t matter if it makes sense or not - the cat has to die’

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 20:21

I suppose one problem with lockdown is that it suddenly became law, so there was no reasonable way to respond that was 'within the law'.

Particularly given the dubiously lawful attempts to criminalise protest entirely.

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 20:18

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 19:44

Not for COVID, for a more deadly disease yes

A slight problem here is that it's hard to know how deadly something is in the very early stages, which is why even I complied with it all during the first lockdown

But then when it dragged on and pieces like the infamous SAGE report advocating "more emotive language" confirmed the manipulation taking place, I reverted to using some common sense and making more choices for myself

If it happened again I'm certain some would relish the opportunity to once more shriek that we're all murderers, etc, but I'm not convinced government could carry so many with them in future - and the more that keeps coming out the less likely it becomes

COVID is believed to have started in December 2019 by feb 2020 china was already publishing research that it was a disease of the elderly and infirm with 80% of cases mild. That was published on the 18th of feb we didn't lockdown until the 23rd of March when it was blatantly obvious the healthy weren't at risk in large numbers, hence Borris's let the bodies pile up comments he was being pushed down a road he didn't want to go.

He's mad a hatter but actually he was the one that had the best ideas out of all of them. Party gate was them actually following the science!!

tinkywinkysaysitsinconvenient · 02/03/2023 20:17

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 19:52

I think it was a weird kind of 'group think'. I don't understand what drives it, but it was similar with the death of Princess Diana. All of a sudden, everyone was expected to feel and do certain things, and anyone who didn't comply was vilified

It's a fair point, DieZensur, but then I've never been susceptible to "group think" and the mindless vilification which all too often goes with it.
Within the law I've always preferred to think for myself - listening to different points of view of course, but making (and taking responsibility for) my own choices

I suppose one problem with lockdown is that it suddenly became law, so there was no reasonable way to respond that was 'within the law'. Because it was all of a sudden illegal to think for oneself or to make one's own choices.

What a terrible business it was. I should really stay away from any threads to do with lockdown!

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 20:15

ChaToilLeam · 02/03/2023 20:06

No way would I do that. They’d have to get past me first.

Were you in favour of lockdown?

ChaToilLeam · 02/03/2023 20:06

No way would I do that. They’d have to get past me first.

BMW6 · 02/03/2023 20:02

I think if I'd been alive with my dog at the outbreak of WW2 I'd have had him PTS.

The bombing would have terrified him and there is the fear that I could be killed but he may be injured, buried alive or burned.

I completely understand why so many chose euthanasia for their beloved pets.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 19:52

I think it was a weird kind of 'group think'. I don't understand what drives it, but it was similar with the death of Princess Diana. All of a sudden, everyone was expected to feel and do certain things, and anyone who didn't comply was vilified

It's a fair point, DieZensur, but then I've never been susceptible to "group think" and the mindless vilification which all too often goes with it.
Within the law I've always preferred to think for myself - listening to different points of view of course, but making (and taking responsibility for) my own choices

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 19:51

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:43

It's a shame if it took people as long as Partygate to see sense, but if it has the long-term effect of preventing another lockdown, I'll go with that.

I didn't give a shit about Partygate as I may be annoying but I am not a hypocrite.

Speaking as a fellow early adopter of not locking down, it's only hypocritical to object to the Partygate gatherings if one was also trying to prevent other people from doing it. You aren't a hypocrite if you didn't observe lockdown and didn't try and make other people do it either.

CrotchetyCrocheting · 02/03/2023 19:44

My cats are inside cats so it would have made no sense. The only people they could have caught covid off is us and the only people they could have spread it to is us and we were on lockdown anyway.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 19:44

Not for COVID, for a more deadly disease yes

A slight problem here is that it's hard to know how deadly something is in the very early stages, which is why even I complied with it all during the first lockdown

But then when it dragged on and pieces like the infamous SAGE report advocating "more emotive language" confirmed the manipulation taking place, I reverted to using some common sense and making more choices for myself

If it happened again I'm certain some would relish the opportunity to once more shriek that we're all murderers, etc, but I'm not convinced government could carry so many with them in future - and the more that keeps coming out the less likely it becomes

Snooozername · 02/03/2023 19:43

If we were a nation of animal lovers, we'd all be vegan. We are clearly not anywhere close to being a nation of animal lovers.

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:43

It's a shame if it took people as long as Partygate to see sense, but if it has the long-term effect of preventing another lockdown, I'll go with that.

I didn't give a shit about Partygate as I may be annoying but I am not a hypocrite.

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:42

@BashirWithTheGoodBeard that's an interesting take on it - and yes, I agree that it's easier to imagine a situation in which you could hide your cat than it is to imagine a situation in which you would chain yourself to a hospital bed if your child was in it (which is what I would have been doing - someone would have literally had to have sedated me in order to remove me forcibly in that situation). But it is obviously a lot easier to respond to an imaginary scenario to which there would be some quite easy solutions.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 19:41

With the evidence piling up that this wasn't always the case, it's possible a change of attitude is happening and that some wouldn't be quite so quick to be fooled again

I think the collective experience of Partygate is probably impossible to control for here. It may be one of those things where the public attitude is never the same again.

DieZensur · 02/03/2023 19:39

It's a fair point, but back then there were still plenty who believed - or perhaps just wanted to believe - that government were genuinely doing their best for us all and that there was some hope of "everyone being in it together"

I disagree. I think it was a weird kind of 'group think'. I don't understand what drives it, but it was similar with the death of Princess Diana. All of a sudden, everyone was expected to feel and do certain things, and anyone who didn't comply was vilified. I just think there's a peculiar herd mentality that comes into play. My dad, who is a superbly clever man in many, many ways (taught Physics at Oxford) was completely taken in by Covid propaganda. He and I had to stop talking about it as we were so diametrically opposed. But he has always been a follower of crowds, whereas I've always run very fast in the opposite direction if I've seen a crowd walking somewhere.

MarshaBradyo · 02/03/2023 19:38

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/03/2023 19:33

When I think back to elderly isolated on care homes or people alone dying in hospital it makes me feel very sad and wonder where was everyone saying no chance and over my dead body as on this thread

It's a fair point, but back then there were still plenty who believed - or perhaps just wanted to believe - that government were genuinely doing their best for us all and that there was some hope of "everyone being in it together"

With the evidence piling up that this wasn't always the case, it's possible a change of attitude is happening and that some wouldn't be quite so quick to be fooled again

I hope so Puzzled. With Covid anyway.

Astrak · 02/03/2023 19:37

No way.

unrsnblyannoyd · 02/03/2023 19:37

Knowing what I know now I wouldn't kill the volume on my fucking stereo for these corrupt charlatans never mind a beloved family pet that frankly would have more sense than the arseholes apparently leading us

letthemalldoone · 02/03/2023 19:35

MarshaBradyo · 02/03/2023 19:27

Exactly. It’s so disconcerting if you said as much at the time

People were afraid. I think lockdown did save lives, and they were brought into being by countries worldwide. The death toll was colossal all the same.

I stuck by the rules but I'm not sure I would have been able to comply in the case of a dying parent or a sick child.

Plus cats could be confined, so the idea of culling them is beyond ridiculous! Humans weren't culled; they were asked to stay at home. Any risk could have been mitigated against.

DogInATent · 02/03/2023 19:35

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_cat_strategy