Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill your pet if ordered to by the gov't?

638 replies

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 12:31

I read in the news this morning that at the beginning of the Covid crisis the gov't considered ordering the culling of all domestic cats in order to prevent the spread of Covid. This idea was later abandoned after it was proven that cats couldn't transmit Covid to humans.
AIBU to think that this would have caused a mass uprising? We are a nation of animal lovers, after all. Or would people have accepted it as they did some of the other draconian regulations (not visiting dying relatives, etc).

www.lbc.co.uk/news/govt-cat-cull-covid-pandemic/

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2023 00:12

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 19:18

For that analogy to work though, since most people would be very upset about the deaths of their pets, they'd have to be giving themselves electric shocks.

I presume there could come a point when people felt sufficiently threatened by a disease that many of them would be willing to see their pets killed, but it doesn't follow that the early days of covid was it. Additionally, we don't actually have that much in the way of police and army in our society, so it would've been very hard to enforce. Those may well be amongst the reasons why the government realised it was a bad idea.

Practically speaking, I think if it ever did get bad enough that a good number of the population would consider this, we'd have a lot of vigilante pet killing and that might be a bigger deal than our rather small police and army trying to enforce it.

It doesn’t necessarily need to be enforced for people to comply. A figure of authority tells people to do it, and they will. It’s been replicated in many different ways, with members of you own family being the electrocuted etc, people will still do it.

I just think there are a lot of people who say they wouldn’t, but in reality, they might well. Especially if there was a credible threat to their family’s or their own personal safety from the cat.

whumpthereitis · 02/03/2023 23:57

ProbablyDogNappersHunX · 02/03/2023 23:34

Not remotely hypothetical

I knew a young man in his early 20s, at university, bright future ahead of him. He was diagnosed with cancer - a very treatable form with extremely high rates of survival. During first lockdown they delayed his treatment; he even went to the press about it as he was so scared. He died in autumn 2020.

At the same time I had a grandparent in their late 90s. We were very close, and I visited frequently despite living in another city. But - I have to be realistic - they had lived their life already (they've since died of sheer old age).

The country seemed perfectly willing to shut down to protect nonagenarians, but twenty-something cancer patients were thrown under the bus.

I really struggle with the idea that my grandparent's life was prioritised over the life of someone in their 20s.

not the same scenario as the hypothetical though, is it? Which was would you kill a loved one in order to save many? Which is an action, not a passive acceptance of risk and letting the cards fall where they may.

ProbablyDogNappersHunX · 02/03/2023 23:34

whumpthereitis · 02/03/2023 22:58

If you want to play hypotheticals, which loved ones of yours would you sacrifice to save thousands then?

Not remotely hypothetical

I knew a young man in his early 20s, at university, bright future ahead of him. He was diagnosed with cancer - a very treatable form with extremely high rates of survival. During first lockdown they delayed his treatment; he even went to the press about it as he was so scared. He died in autumn 2020.

At the same time I had a grandparent in their late 90s. We were very close, and I visited frequently despite living in another city. But - I have to be realistic - they had lived their life already (they've since died of sheer old age).

The country seemed perfectly willing to shut down to protect nonagenarians, but twenty-something cancer patients were thrown under the bus.

I really struggle with the idea that my grandparent's life was prioritised over the life of someone in their 20s.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 02/03/2023 23:14

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 02/03/2023 22:21

This whole thread is making me feel really distressed and should go. I've unfollowed but it's popping up again.

I lost count of friends screaming at me "that's the rules. That's the law. The police will come for you. Boris says so" when I voiced my opinion about the lockdown. One day I went out for a walk and a friend told me off because I sat down. "You sat down on a WALL?"

Amongst my friends there were those who wouldn't meet for walks outside, were terrified to drive anywhere in case the police got them and their mental health was stuffed. And "I can't come to your door so I'll leave this halfway up the garden" Amazon delivery drivers frisbeed packages from halfway down the street.

Another friend disinfected all her grocery shopping.

People went nuts.

Really? Nobody seemed to give a shit round my way. There was rule breaking everywhere you turn. But that's probably because a busy central London neighbourhood has great scope for anonymity.

whumpthereitis · 02/03/2023 22:58

Xol · 02/03/2023 22:53

But suppose it did? What then?

If you want to play hypotheticals, which loved ones of yours would you sacrifice to save thousands then?

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 22:55

Well then it wouldn't have been covid in 2020 when this possibility was discussed, for starters.

Xol · 02/03/2023 22:53

But suppose it did? What then?

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 02/03/2023 22:46

Xol · 02/03/2023 22:45

All the people saying absolutely not: would you say the same if presented with absolutely irrefutable evidence that the alternative would be the deaths of, potentially, hundreds or thousands of people?

Given the lunatic overreaction to covid, I can't imagine that would happen.

Xol · 02/03/2023 22:45

All the people saying absolutely not: would you say the same if presented with absolutely irrefutable evidence that the alternative would be the deaths of, potentially, hundreds or thousands of people?

EsmaCannonball · 02/03/2023 22:36

I'd turn into Wat Tyler, Guy Fawkes and William Wallace combined. The fuckers would rue the day.

I seriously think any government trying to do this would be making a very bad move.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 02/03/2023 22:21

This whole thread is making me feel really distressed and should go. I've unfollowed but it's popping up again.

I lost count of friends screaming at me "that's the rules. That's the law. The police will come for you. Boris says so" when I voiced my opinion about the lockdown. One day I went out for a walk and a friend told me off because I sat down. "You sat down on a WALL?"

Amongst my friends there were those who wouldn't meet for walks outside, were terrified to drive anywhere in case the police got them and their mental health was stuffed. And "I can't come to your door so I'll leave this halfway up the garden" Amazon delivery drivers frisbeed packages from halfway down the street.

Another friend disinfected all her grocery shopping.

People went nuts.

Tanktop · 02/03/2023 22:13

No no no. The very idea makes me feel ill. They would have to take me out first.

Verbena17 · 02/03/2023 21:54

Buzzinwithbez · 02/03/2023 20:42

And the fact that scarily the police were making their own law up for the first several weeks.
I would have assumed they'd have been carefully briefed on it, but no...
There was no law even in place for the first three days, so they were enforcing something that they hadn't seen and didn't yet exist.

Just because something is said to be law….doesn’t make it lawful 😉.
That was the case for the covid ‘laws’. One day people will realise just how much the wool was pulled over their eyes.

Verbena17 · 02/03/2023 21:52

fairywhale · 02/03/2023 21:31

Those who supported the lockdowns mostly would have, yes. Those who gave up all freedoms quicker than the PM's fart and supported the destruction of life and health that the lockdowns caused would have followed absolutely any instruction, without any questions whatsoever, same way as they did with supporting anything they were told to support.

🙌 yep.
Sadly most people just weren’t aware of what they so willingly gave up….and sadly still aren’t!

JudgeRudy · 02/03/2023 21:43

I don't think people would have needed to kill their cats, but they'd have had to keep them inside.
Tbh even if people didn't comply other people would. If I thought your cat would kill my kids I'd kill your cat. Pretty sure I wouldn't need to though because they'd be a queue of people ahead of me.
We all like to think we would be so different but would we? Look at the Nazis. Look at the Millgran Experiment.
When I was young if your cat/dog fell pregnant youd just drown the litter. Ordinary folk like you and me.
I suspect in years to come (not my lifetime) people will be studying history and saying ".....and then they took them out of their pens and ate them!!!"

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 21:39

fairywhale · 02/03/2023 21:31

Those who supported the lockdowns mostly would have, yes. Those who gave up all freedoms quicker than the PM's fart and supported the destruction of life and health that the lockdowns caused would have followed absolutely any instruction, without any questions whatsoever, same way as they did with supporting anything they were told to support.

This omits the aspect of ongoing restriction support that came from privilege. That is, people who weren't ever going to be the ones to bear the brunt of it not seeing the downsides. I don't believe that all the people whose support was based on I'm alright Jack with my nice house, decent income, online shopping and plenty of Internet would've been fine with culling their pets. It just isn't true that all lockdown supporters would've willingly embraced suffering for themselves.

fairywhale · 02/03/2023 21:31

Those who supported the lockdowns mostly would have, yes. Those who gave up all freedoms quicker than the PM's fart and supported the destruction of life and health that the lockdowns caused would have followed absolutely any instruction, without any questions whatsoever, same way as they did with supporting anything they were told to support.

Thesharkradar · 02/03/2023 21:27

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/03/2023 20:52

I would agree that most animals are considerably superior to many, many humans.

can you elaborate, in what sense are they superior?

Grumpybutfunny · 02/03/2023 21:20

catsnore · 02/03/2023 20:39

During the foot and mouth epidemic 20 years ago the government carried out the slaughter of millions of animals - some of whom were pets. Many millions of these animals had absolutely nothing wrong with them, but were unfortunate enough to be in the vicinity of another case. At the time the government did not actually have a legal basis for the slaughter - they had to have the permission of the owner and many tried to resist. A few years later the government passed an 'animal health bill' which gave them those legal powers. So actually they could order the slaughter of any animals they chose, if there was a disease involved. I doubt they'd come after dogs and cats though - guaranteed to lose the next election.

We murder around 80k animals a day, so killing them for a disease isn't as horrifying as killing pets. It should never have happened we should have refused to export to countries bothered about foot and mouth and used the meat internally. We need to go veggi as a country anyway, even COVID likely wouldn't have happened if we didn't have the meat trade!! It's like CJD most of us carry the prion without any effects you need to be genetically susceptible yet we slaughter thousands of animals!

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/03/2023 20:52

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 02/03/2023 16:32

@NewNovember You are right, animals are not equal to human life… ANIMALS ARE FAR, FAR, SUPERIOR TO ANY INDIVIDUAL OR GROUP OF HUMANS.

I would agree that most animals are considerably superior to many, many humans.

Museya15 · 02/03/2023 20:52

No way, I'd go on the run with my cat and my kids before I'd let anyone take her, she's 19 but still has lots of life in her.

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/03/2023 20:46

theleafandnotthetree · 02/03/2023 15:49

And they're right in the global sense. Pets carry a very very heavy carbon footprint and one could certainly envisage a future scenario where there are limits on the numbers you could keep.

People carry a heavier one - yet suggest that family size is limited and all hell breaks loose1

Buzzinwithbez · 02/03/2023 20:42

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 02/03/2023 20:21

I suppose one problem with lockdown is that it suddenly became law, so there was no reasonable way to respond that was 'within the law'.

Particularly given the dubiously lawful attempts to criminalise protest entirely.

And the fact that scarily the police were making their own law up for the first several weeks.
I would have assumed they'd have been carefully briefed on it, but no...
There was no law even in place for the first three days, so they were enforcing something that they hadn't seen and didn't yet exist.

Emotionalsupportviper · 02/03/2023 20:42

lieselotte · 02/03/2023 15:22

My mum has been adopted by a neighbour's cat. She tested positive for covid in 2020 but didn't have any symptoms. She spent her isolation gardening and the cat spent all his time with her. One of her friends said it was wrong because she could give the cat covid and he could give it to his actual owners.

So yes, I think people would have done in the covid madness.

However, it's true that having pets is bad for the environment but it doesn't stop people getting new ones.

Yes - I wonder how many people - particularly people who were otherwise totally isolated - only retained their sanity because of companion animals, especially cats and dogs.

catsnore · 02/03/2023 20:39

During the foot and mouth epidemic 20 years ago the government carried out the slaughter of millions of animals - some of whom were pets. Many millions of these animals had absolutely nothing wrong with them, but were unfortunate enough to be in the vicinity of another case. At the time the government did not actually have a legal basis for the slaughter - they had to have the permission of the owner and many tried to resist. A few years later the government passed an 'animal health bill' which gave them those legal powers. So actually they could order the slaughter of any animals they chose, if there was a disease involved. I doubt they'd come after dogs and cats though - guaranteed to lose the next election.