Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill your pet if ordered to by the gov't?

638 replies

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 12:31

I read in the news this morning that at the beginning of the Covid crisis the gov't considered ordering the culling of all domestic cats in order to prevent the spread of Covid. This idea was later abandoned after it was proven that cats couldn't transmit Covid to humans.
AIBU to think that this would have caused a mass uprising? We are a nation of animal lovers, after all. Or would people have accepted it as they did some of the other draconian regulations (not visiting dying relatives, etc).

www.lbc.co.uk/news/govt-cat-cull-covid-pandemic/

OP posts:
WilmaFlintstone1 · 03/03/2023 09:52

I complied with the lockdown measures but would not have complied with this. My autistic son would have committed suicide if they’d removed his beloved cats from the home. We only have two but they are an important part of the family.

MarshaBradyo · 03/03/2023 08:59

GPTec1 · 03/03/2023 08:37

Different recollections, sure some shouting loud on SM but generally speaking, after 1st LD, it was more about timing then having more restrictions.

but i'm more rural, so i accept my experience around here is different then yours, we had very low infection rates.

I’m not really talking about rl as people mostly complied from what I saw although school closures probably got the most comments from other parents.

On mn though if anyone asks why and how was the Covid campaign so successful and why did so many accept extreme measures it’s a good place to look.

PolkaDotMankini · 03/03/2023 08:58

I would if it had been zombie apocalypse disease, Walking Dead style. Not for flu.

silverbubbles · 03/03/2023 08:41

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 19:16

Livestock, not pets.
There's a huge difference. Livestock is basically raised to be killed, so as long as the farmer is compensated he's ok.

You are clearly have no proper understanding of farming or the relationship that many farmers have with their livestock! Firstly to even think that for a farmer to watch all his healthy livestock shot and just burnt feels 'OK' because he has received some level of compensation is quite simply moronic and secondly many of the animal slaughtered were very precious breeding stock which will be their absolute pride and joy and in many cases generations of work and progress.

Murraydeservedit · 03/03/2023 08:39

theleafandnotthetree · 03/03/2023 08:29

Sweet Jesus, that is deranged....how are relations between you since? The kind of thing you can't unsee....

Thankfully we were just renting at that point, we moved a few months later.

But we were enemy number one for a while, because I had the worlds shittiest pregnancy so my midwife was round every two weeks and I was up and down to the hospital weekly - it made us unclean! Like I was going to bring back the plague from the maternity unit and infect the whole area. (I used to have a couple of nosey sods shouting out and asking why I was going out in the car again - “to the hospital, I’m pregnant and not very well” which is how they knew).

All that curtain twitching, people had nothing better to do than watch as I went in and out and wonder why we were getting a regular visitor to the door.

But that’s what fear can do. So many people were plunged into mental health crisis.

GPTec1 · 03/03/2023 08:37

Different recollections, sure some shouting loud on SM but generally speaking, after 1st LD, it was more about timing then having more restrictions.

but i'm more rural, so i accept my experience around here is different then yours, we had very low infection rates.

MarshaBradyo · 03/03/2023 08:34

GPTec1 · 03/03/2023 08:31

I think this is true of the weeks leading up to the March LD, i know on here and in my circle, people couldn't believe the UK was sooooo slow.

But i do not recall people wanting more LD restrictions, if anything, most not all didn't understand some of the stupid rules i.e not being allowed to sit on a bench when out of breath.

Its easy to be wise after the event but there was no vaccine and no effective treatments.

But by the 2nd and 3rd LD's people ignored them, roads around here were busy as before.

Mn cannot be a left wing echo chamber one minute but a good gauge of public opinion the next.

It’s a good record of the time but no it’s not all public opinion just some of it.

Yes there were loads of threads showing how people demanded further action. Many posters have said the same re what happened if you thought it a bad idea - it didn’t go down well.

So no not wise after the event. Many tried at the time.

GPTec1 · 03/03/2023 08:31

MarshaBradyo · 03/03/2023 08:25

Mn is a pretty good record of public opinion at the time. People demand further action.

I think this is true of the weeks leading up to the March LD, i know on here and in my circle, people couldn't believe the UK was sooooo slow.

But i do not recall people wanting more LD restrictions, if anything, most not all didn't understand some of the stupid rules i.e not being allowed to sit on a bench when out of breath.

Its easy to be wise after the event but there was no vaccine and no effective treatments.

But by the 2nd and 3rd LD's people ignored them, roads around here were busy as before.

Mn cannot be a left wing echo chamber one minute but a good gauge of public opinion the next.

theleafandnotthetree · 03/03/2023 08:29

Murraydeservedit · 03/03/2023 08:23

I was thinking about this thread when I couldn’t sleep last night.

I actually think a lot of people were so paralysed by fear of covid that they would have had their pets PTS, no matter how much they say they love them/they would rather die.

I also think that covid made some people so irrational that they would have killed their pets themselves or killed other peoples pets.

The language used by some on here was just unbelievable. Don’t forget, there were people who wanted the army on the streets. They were calling for martial law! There were threads asking if they should call the police on their neighbours.

The fear completely changed some people and it was bizarre and funny at best and horrifying at worst to see.

I posted upthread about my next door neighbour at the time, a solicitor, a professional, middle aged woman who had always been entirely sensible and quite lovely, who ripped a fence post out of the ground like the Hulk and started using it like a battering ram on my door while screaming that I would kill us all. This was because she had seen someone enter my house during lockdown. It was my midwife.

There was no calming her. And when the police arrived, who was questioned? Not the woman ramming my front door, damaging my property and screaming blue murder - it was me and the midwife! Absolutely crazy.

That woman had been driven crazy by the thought that covid would kill her if she didn’t stick to the rules. She had a dog that she doted on and treated like a child, but honestly, I think fear would have made her get rid of it in an instant.

Sweet Jesus, that is deranged....how are relations between you since? The kind of thing you can't unsee....

MarshaBradyo · 03/03/2023 08:25

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 03/03/2023 08:23

Yes, I don't agree with that poster's take in general but there's no getting round the fact that we wouldn't have had lockdowns had enough of the public not actively wanted them. Johnson didn't want to do it. That was abundantly obvious.

Mn is a pretty good record of public opinion at the time. People demand further action.

Murraydeservedit · 03/03/2023 08:23

I was thinking about this thread when I couldn’t sleep last night.

I actually think a lot of people were so paralysed by fear of covid that they would have had their pets PTS, no matter how much they say they love them/they would rather die.

I also think that covid made some people so irrational that they would have killed their pets themselves or killed other peoples pets.

The language used by some on here was just unbelievable. Don’t forget, there were people who wanted the army on the streets. They were calling for martial law! There were threads asking if they should call the police on their neighbours.

The fear completely changed some people and it was bizarre and funny at best and horrifying at worst to see.

I posted upthread about my next door neighbour at the time, a solicitor, a professional, middle aged woman who had always been entirely sensible and quite lovely, who ripped a fence post out of the ground like the Hulk and started using it like a battering ram on my door while screaming that I would kill us all. This was because she had seen someone enter my house during lockdown. It was my midwife.

There was no calming her. And when the police arrived, who was questioned? Not the woman ramming my front door, damaging my property and screaming blue murder - it was me and the midwife! Absolutely crazy.

That woman had been driven crazy by the thought that covid would kill her if she didn’t stick to the rules. She had a dog that she doted on and treated like a child, but honestly, I think fear would have made her get rid of it in an instant.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 03/03/2023 08:23

Yes, I don't agree with that poster's take in general but there's no getting round the fact that we wouldn't have had lockdowns had enough of the public not actively wanted them. Johnson didn't want to do it. That was abundantly obvious.

ImJustMadAboutSaffron · 03/03/2023 08:13

@Alexandra2001 Supporting the measures is not the same as having to go along with them because there was no option. I didn't meet friends, go shopping, go in pubs, bars, restaurants, theatres or to concerts or the cinema because they were closed. Not because I thought arses like Matt Hancock were right.

Alexandra2001 · 03/03/2023 08:08

Those who supported the lockdowns mostly would have, yes. Those who gave up all freedoms quicker than the PM's fart and supported the destruction of life and health that the lockdowns caused would have followed absolutely any instruction, without any questions whatsoever, same way as they did with supporting anything they were told to support

People had no choice, you do realise that the restrictions weren't optional?

We couldn't go to a funeral or visit a dying relative in hospital or go to the pub or have a meal out or go shopping.... these things were banned and shops pubs etc shut.

My partner went out for a cycle ride with a mate, they had a visit from the Police... whilst having a coffee nr Seaton.... or as Matt Hancock would say "Get the Police to go heavy with the Public" whilst he xxxxed his secretary.

How many people moaning now (in rose tinted hindsight) keep voting Tory? who gave us these draconian measures, whilst they fucking well ignored the rules.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 03/03/2023 07:56

ArcticSkewer · 03/03/2023 07:30

Huge numbers of psychological studies show that humans are basically prone to doing whatever someone in authority tells them to do.

What's being claimed here is that this would extend to people doing something that would cause pain to themselves and a loved one. Which actually is something quite different to the bog standard authority thing. It was an important part of the Stanford study that the participants didn't know each other. If you want to try and apply the lesson learned from that research here, actually what it would look like is people killing other people's cats.

A person claimed that there are similar studies where people electrocuted their own family members. That's a pretty huge deal and so I'd like to hear about them.

MarshaBradyo · 03/03/2023 07:50

fairywhale · 02/03/2023 21:31

Those who supported the lockdowns mostly would have, yes. Those who gave up all freedoms quicker than the PM's fart and supported the destruction of life and health that the lockdowns caused would have followed absolutely any instruction, without any questions whatsoever, same way as they did with supporting anything they were told to support.

Yes we pretty much went there anyway. Outrage at those not following mostly not at the extreme things in place.

Cornettoninja · 03/03/2023 07:49

ArcticSkewer · 03/03/2023 07:32

and that's exactly how the government would have phrased it ... and most people would have done it.

People are weak, really, and stupid, and credulous. Poor combination.

Ha! Pot meet kettle… would, could, all supposition created in the bias of your own mind and presented as a forgone conclusion.

But yes, it’s everyone else that’s the problem. Good job you’re about to shine a well informed light eh?

Cornettoninja · 03/03/2023 07:46

Jesus, is this thread still going?

It’s basically a digital version of arguing against yourself in the shower.

This didn’t happen. How people are drawing fictional conclusions from a scenario that didn’t happen, anywhere in the world, and allowing themselves to get so worked up over it is beyond me. There’s plenty of reality to get the blood pumping if you’re determined to get outraged over something.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 03/03/2023 07:38

maddiemookins16mum · 03/03/2023 07:24

I think part of the reason this thread has (understandably) become so emotive is the title. It’s as if we would have had to kill our cats with our bare hands.
If the title had said ‘take to the vet to be PTS to save thousands of lives’…….some of the responses MAY have been different.

My reaction would have been the same - they could fuck off. I would have kept my cat indoors if I had to but I would have hidden him rather than have him PTS. He has a cat proofed garden so doesn't roam but I'd have kept him in rather than risk the cat hating nutjobs getting him.

ArcticSkewer · 03/03/2023 07:32

maddiemookins16mum · 03/03/2023 07:24

I think part of the reason this thread has (understandably) become so emotive is the title. It’s as if we would have had to kill our cats with our bare hands.
If the title had said ‘take to the vet to be PTS to save thousands of lives’…….some of the responses MAY have been different.

and that's exactly how the government would have phrased it ... and most people would have done it.

People are weak, really, and stupid, and credulous. Poor combination.

ArcticSkewer · 03/03/2023 07:30

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 03/03/2023 07:10

It's been replicated with people's family being the loved ones? Where and when?

Huge numbers of psychological studies show that humans are basically prone to doing whatever someone in authority tells them to do.

maddiemookins16mum · 03/03/2023 07:24

I think part of the reason this thread has (understandably) become so emotive is the title. It’s as if we would have had to kill our cats with our bare hands.
If the title had said ‘take to the vet to be PTS to save thousands of lives’…….some of the responses MAY have been different.

BashirWithTheGoodBeard · 03/03/2023 07:10

TheOriginalEmu · 03/03/2023 00:12

It doesn’t necessarily need to be enforced for people to comply. A figure of authority tells people to do it, and they will. It’s been replicated in many different ways, with members of you own family being the electrocuted etc, people will still do it.

I just think there are a lot of people who say they wouldn’t, but in reality, they might well. Especially if there was a credible threat to their family’s or their own personal safety from the cat.

It's been replicated with people's family being the loved ones? Where and when?

XenoBitch · 03/03/2023 00:43

Spectre8 · 03/03/2023 00:37

Omg if its about cats I would absolutely loved it of the government chnahed the law at the time to say they are no longer allowed to roam and they had to be kept indoors to stop spreading covid. Then the law coikd of stayed in place and my garden would forever be free of cat poo!

what a missed opportunity

I don't think any cat owner would have an issue with that. They can cat proof their garden so their mogs cans still get outside.
A huge world away from being forced to have them PTS.

Spectre8 · 03/03/2023 00:37

Omg if its about cats I would absolutely loved it of the government chnahed the law at the time to say they are no longer allowed to roam and they had to be kept indoors to stop spreading covid. Then the law coikd of stayed in place and my garden would forever be free of cat poo!

what a missed opportunity

Swipe left for the next trending thread