Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you kill your pet if ordered to by the gov't?

638 replies

JackiePlace · 02/03/2023 12:31

I read in the news this morning that at the beginning of the Covid crisis the gov't considered ordering the culling of all domestic cats in order to prevent the spread of Covid. This idea was later abandoned after it was proven that cats couldn't transmit Covid to humans.
AIBU to think that this would have caused a mass uprising? We are a nation of animal lovers, after all. Or would people have accepted it as they did some of the other draconian regulations (not visiting dying relatives, etc).

www.lbc.co.uk/news/govt-cat-cull-covid-pandemic/

OP posts:
ALongHardWinter · 05/03/2023 03:16

I have a cat,but she's an indoor cat, due to the fact that I live near a busy road,plus,my last cat went out one day and never returned. But....I could guarantee that someone in the vicinity of where I live would have dobbed me in for having a cat,even though she would have posed no threat to them. The Covid lockdowns turned so many people into curtain -twitching snitches.

ALongHardWinter · 05/03/2023 03:09

I must say I am reassured by the number of posters on here saying that they thought so many people over-reacted to Covid ('You sat down on a WALL?!'). As a previous poster said,huge numbers of psychological studies have proved that humans are basically prone to doing whatever someone in authority tells them to do.

XenoBitch · 05/03/2023 02:03

ALongHardWinter · 05/03/2023 02:00

When I first read this,I initially thought 'No way would the majority of cat owners take that lying down',but then I remembered how readily so many people accepted all the restrictions placed on their lives by the lockdowns and thought 'Maybe they WOULD have just accepted it'.

Not just accepted it.. but probably dobbed in any pet owning neighbours too.

ALongHardWinter · 05/03/2023 02:00

When I first read this,I initially thought 'No way would the majority of cat owners take that lying down',but then I remembered how readily so many people accepted all the restrictions placed on their lives by the lockdowns and thought 'Maybe they WOULD have just accepted it'.

Emotionalstorm · 05/03/2023 01:46

I wouldn't no but I wouldn't have any hard feelings against the government for calling it. They were in a very difficult position and did their best.

12345onceicaughtafishalive678910 · 05/03/2023 01:07

Given he pissed on my brand new pjs whilst they were outside the bathroom and I was having a bath before snuggling in to them I might kill him even if they don’t ask.

😂

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 05/03/2023 01:07

MarshaBradyo · 04/03/2023 20:01

Tbh I didn’t see the thread and thought it was the poster’s own baby which felt harsh. But then again given some of the posts on this thread in general keeping.

I’ve been on mn long enough to know some would save their dog over a stranger’s baby. No comment on that really. I don’t care enough about made up choices that hopefully don’t need to be made anyway.

There never is a baby.

Just goaty posters salivating over a made up drama and frothing themselves into indignation. It comes up every six months or so.

12345onceicaughtafishalive678910 · 05/03/2023 01:06

Some of these posts are completely crazy. Pets valued as much as your own children? Commit suicide if you had to have a pet PTS?

I love animals but that is utter madness.

Don't be so dismissive. It is only 'utter madness' to you. I would not swap my dogs for a million pounds..they have helped me through such darkness in my life, and their loyalty is top notch. I do love them almost as much as my children.

I grew up on a farm. I have not eaten meat for over 30 years. I realised from a very young age that animals are sentient beings and do feel pain. Just because they don't have as much 'power' doesn't mean they should be less valued, or should be treated less favourably.

Look how those who don't fit the mould are treated in society; they are not treated fairly. Whether that be unmarried mothers, gay people, non Caucasians, people with mental illnesses...you get my drift.

Pets have given lonely people something to focus on. This is so much the case for my dear mum, now that dad has sadly passed away. I do believe that her pet (as well as us) is what has kept her going. So, if this makes me sound like 'utter madness', I'll gladly accept the label.

catgirl1976 · 05/03/2023 00:39

Given he pissed on my brand new pjs whilst they were outside the bathroom and I was having a bath before snuggling in to them I might kill him even if they don’t ask.

XenoBitch · 05/03/2023 00:19

JackiePlace · 04/03/2023 23:01

Oh my, I wonder if Boris would have done Larry in with his bolt gun?!

Well, my google search history now has 'captive bolt gun cats' in it. They look too big to be used on cats, plus you would have to keep the cat still (hahahahha!) to make sure you get the right spot.

whumpthereitis · 05/03/2023 00:17

JanusTheFirst · 04/03/2023 09:02

This thread is reminding me of one a few years ago where a poster said she would run into a burning building to save her dog and leave a baby in there.

How can you begin to address that kind of insanity, other than feel very sorry for those so lacking in humanity? What sad lives they must have led.

‘Mumsnet poster in ‘would save her loved ones over a stranger!’ shocker’. Yeah, I would do the same. You are neither expected nor required to like it.

These threads always contain tedious weirdos who scramble to invent scenarios in which you’re expected to admit you’d leave a pet (or elderly relative, also a favourite to sacrifice) to die, or face opprobrium and the predictable ‘what a sad/pitiable life!’ opining. Oh well, by all means seethe about it.

ItWillWash · 05/03/2023 00:06

My cats are indoor cats so I would have been fairly confident that they did not have Covid. The most I would have done is confine them to one room if a member of the household got covid for their own wellbeing.

I can't imagine a situation in which I would leave or kill my pets. Re: the hypothetical baby, I cannot envision a situation where it would be safe to enter a building to rescue a stranger's baby but not safe to rescue my pets. I'd rescue them all, though I'd start with the baby as my animals are more capable of leaving a burning building of their own accord than a human baby.

ReadtheReviews · 05/03/2023 00:02

Fuck no. Reminiscent of that poor old lady who had two pet sheep that she kept in her house and garden and during foot and mouth, they bashed down her door and took them from her. I'd have shot them. The people. Not the sheep.

Figmentofmyimagination · 04/03/2023 23:36

Not for covid. But I could imagine doing this for something more deadly and dangerous or something hideously disfiguring. It perhaps depends on the seriousness of the disease and also how easily it is transmitted via the pet.

letthemalldoone · 04/03/2023 23:18

Everanewbie · 04/03/2023 22:08

I’ve had it twice. Mild cold both times. Everyone I know has had it, including my 90 year old grandma who is in a nursing home. Cold.

So millions died of something else then? There's wiser eating grass...!!!

JackiePlace · 04/03/2023 23:01

Oh my, I wonder if Boris would have done Larry in with his bolt gun?!

OP posts:
Everanewbie · 04/03/2023 22:08

I’ve had it twice. Mild cold both times. Everyone I know has had it, including my 90 year old grandma who is in a nursing home. Cold.

craycrayfish · 04/03/2023 20:13

If they had announced this, the Government would actually have been toppled and replaced by Larry the cat.

People always prefer the cat to the PM at any one time. I feel like this would have been the last straw for a nation of animal lovers.

MarshaBradyo · 04/03/2023 20:01

Tbh I didn’t see the thread and thought it was the poster’s own baby which felt harsh. But then again given some of the posts on this thread in general keeping.

I’ve been on mn long enough to know some would save their dog over a stranger’s baby. No comment on that really. I don’t care enough about made up choices that hopefully don’t need to be made anyway.

XenoBitch · 04/03/2023 19:55

ChardonnaysBeastlyCat · 04/03/2023 13:20

Yes, the Who Would You Save threads are utterly silly and goady.

Would you save your loved companion of many years or a hypothetical baby? No one knows how they will react in an extreme situation and the vast majority of people do the right thing, but faced with a goady thread they answer accordingly.

I hate those types of questions too, especially when someone then gets attacked for their answer. Why would my dog and a strange baby be in a building together with no one else? If you want to say "poor baby" because I would save my dog, then perhaps you should point the blame for the demise of the baby on it's parents.

SoShallINever · 04/03/2023 17:41

We have a knob of a neighbour who has her precious chickens out all the time, even though the government advice is that they spread bird flu and she lives a few meters away from a river where a huge number of wildfowl recently died. But hey, her chickens are special!

AnwenDolly · 04/03/2023 15:35

My experience was similar in a few ways to PinkSparkly and Marsha.

I was sufficiency scared in the first few weeks of the first lockdown that I was willingly compliant (although I never disinfected shopping or quarantined post).

We were given to believe - although the virus was it was mostly dangerous to elderly and vulnerable - that any one of us, including children - could die of it.

After a month or so, I no longer wanted to be compliant, but I was forced to be. Everything apart from "essential" shops and services were closed and we were led to believe that the police were patrolling every street corner and prosecuting anyone who strayed too far from home.

In order to meet up with people, you had to find others who were willing to break the law and expose your own willingness to people who might judge you negatively. No one I know admitted at the time that they would have or did break the law.

That is why I remained compliant pretty much to the end of restrictions. Not because I agreed with them, or that I was scared anymore, but because I feared the disapproval of others.

Fear of death and fear of the disapproval of others are powerful motivators and were used effective weapons against us during the lockdowns.

MarshaBradyo · 04/03/2023 15:06

Sir David Spiegelhalter was on the radio earlier and he also said it was amazing how much our behaviour changed.

I got caught up in the early stages too but once I realised how the headlines and daily numbers were so effective as a campaign it was much easier to step out of that cycle.

Once you did you could see the damage it was causing against the low risk to most. It was frustrating though as people post it’s ‘easy to be wise after the event’ - that’s not right many were saying it at the time they just got a load of abuse instead.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 04/03/2023 15:02

I got caught up in the hysteria a bit at the beginning but got past it pretty quickly. DH asked me if I thought it was safe to have a takeaway and I told him that I was having one but if he was worried he could cook himself something. I also told him that if he wanted to wash shopping he could crack on but not to expect any help from me. I may have been a bit unsympathetic...

AnwenDolly · 04/03/2023 14:54

JackiePlace · 04/03/2023 14:35

Don't forget, there were normally sane and rational people putting their post in quarantine and disinfecting their shopping. @AnwenDolly Haha... I'm still doing both of those things! … On the advice of my brother in law who is a biochemist. I haven't had Covid (touch wood) so maybe there is something in it?!

Ha! Ha! indeed, but if you really are doing those things (do you ever go out, meet friends or touch "things"?) it's rather sad, not funny that you haven't been able to move on like the rest of the world.

I suppose we could engage in a game of my (insert family member or friend) who is a (insert description of supposed "expert") says...

...but it would be fairly tedious and quite unhelpful. If quarantined post and disinfected shopping helps you sleep at night, go for it, but it might be more useful to get some help for your phobia.

As for your biochemist brother-in-law (if he exists), he really shouldn't be feeding your anxiety with his nonsense.